Diagnostic performance of the three-dimensional fast spin echo-Cube sequence in comparison with a conventional imaging protocol in evaluation of the lachrymal drainage system

Dacryocystography: From theory to current practice

PURPOSE

To provide a review and an update on dacryocystography (DCG) and its relevance in the current era.

METHODS

The authors performed a PubMed search of all articles published in English on DCG, digital subtraction-DCG (DS-DCG), computed tomographic DCG (CT-DCG) and magnetic resonance-DCG (MR-DCG). Data analyzed include the indications, techniques, interpretations, complication and limitations.

RESULTS

Dacryocystography has been used for illustrating the morphological and functional aspects of the lacrimal drainage system (LDS). Subtraction DCG provides the precise location of the alterations and acceptably delineates stenosis or an obstruction. Transit time for contrast into the nose varies widely across the studies. Low osmolality iodinated contrast media are tolerated well for DS-DCG and CT-DCG. However, normal saline either mixed with lidocaine or alone provided similar image quality as obtained with gadolinium for MR-DCG. CT-DCG provides useful information in complex orbitofacial trauma and lacrimal tumors. MR-DCG allows better 3D visualization of the LDS and dynamic functional evaluation. Sensitivity of CT-DCG and MR-DCG are mostly similar in identifying an LDS obstruction.

CONCLUSION

Various forms of DCGs can provide additional information to evaluate patients with maxillo-facial trauma, functional epiphora, suspected lacrimal sac diverticula, partial nasolacrimal duct obstruction, and lacrimal drainage tumors. Canaliculi and the membranous part of the nasolacrimal duct are not yet visualized in detail and further focused studies with advanced techniques are required.

Combined application of isotropic three-dimensional fast spin echo (3D-FSE-Cube) with 2-point Dixon fat/water separation (FLEX) and 3D-FSE-cube in MR dacryocystography

Objective:

To evaluate the image quality of magnetic resonance dacryocystography (MRD) using three-dimesional fast spin-echo -Cube (3D-FSE-Cube) and 3D-FSE-Cube-Flex sequences to examine the lacrimal drainage system (LDS).

Methods:

21 healthy volunteers underwent 3D-FSE-Cube and 3D-FSE-Cube-Flex MRD after topical administration of compound sodium chloride eye drops. Two radiologists assessed LDS images in a blinded fashion. The signal-to-noise ratio of fluid-filling and the contrast-to-noise ratio of fluid-turbinate were compared between the two sequences. Overall image quality, sharpness, artefacts, visualization of anatomical structures, and visibility of LDS segments were also compared.

Results:

Overall image quality, visualization of anatomic structures, and artefact were significantly better on 3D-FSE-Cube-Flex MRD (p < 0.001, respectively). when compared to 3D-FSE-Cube. 3D-FSE-Cube showed lower fluid-filling signal-to-noise ratio and fluid-inferior turbinate CNR (all p < 0.001). In comparison with 3D-FSE-Cube-Flex, 3D-FSE-Cube produced superior visibility of the upper drainage segments (superior canaliculi, p = 0.003; common canaliculus, p = 0.033; inferior canaliculi, p < 0.001), but inferior in lower-LDS visibility (lacrimal sac, p = 0.001; nasolacrimal duct, p < 0.001). There was no difference in the total number of segments visualized per LDS between the two sequences (p = 0.068).

Conclusions:

3D-FSE-Cube-Flex demonstrated superior image quality and visibility of the lower LDS segments. 3D-FSE-Cube showed an advantage in visualizing the upper LDS segments. The combination of these sequences can improve LDS visibility.

Advances in knowledge:

3D-FSE-Cube-Flex provides robust water & fat separation and mitigates lower LDS-associated inhomogeneity artefacts. 3D-FSE-Cube shows optimal upper LDS visualization. The combined application of these sequences is a non-invasive and effective method for assessing LDS disease.