Comparison of the diagnostic performance of 2D and 3D MR elastography in staging liver fibrosis

Acquisition Efficiency and Technical Repeatability of Dual-Frequency 3D Vector MR Elastography of the Liver

BACKGROUND

MR elastography (MRE) at 60 Hz is widely used for staging liver fibrosis. MRE with lower frequencies may provide inflammation biomarkers.

PURPOSE

To establish a practical simultaneous dual-frequency liver MRE protocol at both 30 Hz and 60 Hz during a single examination and validate the occurrence of second harmonic waves at 30 Hz.

STUDY TYPE

Retrospective.

SUBJECTS

One hundred six patients (48 females, age: 50.0 ± 13.4 years) were divided as follows: Cohort One (15 patients with chronic liver disease [CLD] and 25 healthy volunteers) with simultaneous dual-frequency MRE. Cohort Two (66 patients with CLD) with second harmonic MRE.

FIELD STRENGTH/SEQUENCE

3-T, single- or dual-frequency MRE at 30 Hz and 60 Hz.

ASSESSMENT

Liver stiffness (LS) in both cohorts was evaluated with manually placed volumetric ROIs by two independent analyzers. Image quality was assessed by three independent readers on a 4-point scale (0-3: none/failed, fair, moderate, excellent) based on the depth of wave propagation with 1/3 incremental penetration. The success rate was derived from the percentage of nonzero quality scores.

STATISTICAL TESTS

Measurement agreement, bias, and repeatability of LS were assessed using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs), Bland-Altman plots, and repeatability coefficient (RC). Mann-Whitney U tests were used to evaluate the differences in image quality between different methods. A P-value <0.05 was considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

Success rate was 97.5% in Cohort One and 91% success rate for the second harmonic MRE in Cohort Two. The second harmonic and conventional MRE showed excellent agreement in LS (all ICCs >0.90). The quality scores for the second harmonic wave images were lower than those from the conventional MRE (Z = -4.523).

DATA CONCLUSION

Compared with conventional and second harmonic methods, simultaneous dual-frequency had better image quality, high success rate and the advantage of intrinsic co-registration, while the second harmonic method can be an alternative if custom waveform is not available.

EVIDENCE LEVEL

3 TECHNICAL EFFICACY: Stage 1.

MR and Ultrasound Elastography for Fibrosis Assessment in Children: Practical Implementation and Supporting Evidence-AJR Expert Panel Narrative Review

Quantitative MRI and ultrasound biomarkers of liver fibrosis have become important tools in the diagnosis and clinical management of children with chronic liver disease (CLD). In particular, MR elastography is now routinely performed in clinical practice to evaluate the liver for fibrosis. Ultrasound shear-wave elastography has also become widely performed for this purpose, especially in young children. These noninvasive methods are increasingly used to replace liver biopsy for the diagnosis, quantitative staging, and treatment monitoring of patients with CLD. Although ultrasound has the advantages of portability and lower equipment cost than MRI, available evidence indicates that MRI may have greater reliability and accuracy in liver fibrosis evaluation. In this AJR Expert Panel Narrative Review, we describe how, why, and when to use MRI- and ultrasound-based elastography methods for liver fibrosis assessment in children. Practical approaches are discussed for adapting and optimizing these methods in children, with consideration of clinical indications, patient preparation, equipment requirements, and acquisition technique, as well as pitfalls and confounding factors. Guidance is provided for interpretation and reporting, and representative case examples are presented.

3D vector MR elastography applications in small organs

BACKGROUND

Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is a rapidly developing medical imaging technique that allows for quantitative assessment of the biomechanical properties of the tissue. MRE is now regarded as the most accurate noninvasive test for detecting and staging liver fibrosis. A two-dimensional (2D MRE) acquisition version is currently deployed at >2000 locations worldwide. 2D MRE allows for the evaluation of the magnitude of the complex shear modulus, also referred to as stiffness. The development of 3D vector MRE has enabled researchers to assess the biomechanical properties of small organs where wave propagation cannot be adequately analyzed with the 2D MRE imaging approach used in the liver. In 3D vector MRE, the shear waves are imaged and processed throughout a 3D volume and processed with an algorithm that accounts for wave propagation in any direction. Additionally, the motion is also imaged in x, y, and z directions at each voxel, allowing for more advanced processing to be applied.

PURPOSE

This review describes the technical principles of 3D vector MRE, surveys its clinical applications in small organs, and discusses potential clinical significance of 3D vector MRE.

CONCLUSION

3D vector MRE is a promising tool for characterizing the biomechanical properties of small organs such as the uterus, pancreas, thyroid, prostate, and salivary glands. However, its potential has not yet been fully explored.

A Versatile MR Elastography Research Tool with a Modified Motion Signal-to-noise Ratio Approach

PURPOSE

This study aimed to facilitate research progress in MR elastography (MRE) by providing a versatile and convenient application for MRE reconstruction, namely the MRE research tool (MRE-rTool). It can be used for a series of MRE image analyses, including phase unwrapping, arbitrary bandpass and directional filtering, noise assessment of the wave propagation image (motion SNR), and reconstruction of the elastogram in both 2D and 3D MRE acquisitions. To reinforce the versatility of MRE-rTool, the conventional method of motion SNR was modified into a new method that reflects the effects of image filtering.

METHODS

MRE tests of the phantom and liver were performed using different estimation algorithms for stiffness value (algebraic inversion of the differential equation [AIDE], local frequency estimation [LFE] in MRE-rTool, and multimodel direct inversion [MMDI] in clinical reconstruction) and acquiring dimensions (2D and 3D acquisitions). This study also tested the accuracy of masking low SNR regions using modified and conventional motion SNR under various mechanical vibration powers.

RESULTS

The stiffness values estimated using AIDE/LFE in MRE-rTool were comparable to that of MMDI (phantom, 3.71 ± 0.74, 3.60 ± 0.32, and 3.60 ± 0.54 kPa in AIDE, LFE, and MMDI; liver, 2.26 ± 0.31, 2.74 ± 0.16, and 2.21 ± 0.26 kPa in AIDE, LFE, and MMDI). The stiffness value in 3D acquisition was independent of the direction of the motion-encoding gradient and was more accurate than that of 2D acquisition. The masking of low SNR regions using the modified motion SNR worked better than that in the conventional motion SNR for each vibration power, especially when using a directional filter.

CONCLUSION

The performance of MRE-rTool on test data reached the level required in clinical MRE studies. MRE-rTool has the potential to facilitate MRE research, contribute to the future development of MRE, and has been freely released online.

Fast abdominal magnetic resonance elastography with simultaneous encoding of three-dimensional displacements

Three-dimensional (3D) magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is more accurate than two-dimensional (2D) MRE; however, it requires long-term acquisition. This study aimed to reduce the acquisition time of abdominal 3D MRE using a new sample interval modulation (short-SLIM) approach that can acquire all three motions faster while reducing the prolongation of echo time and flow compensation. To this end, two types of phantom studies and an in vivo test of the liver in three healthy volunteers were performed to compare the performances of conventional spin-echo echo-planar (SE-EPI) MRE, conventional SLIM and short-SLIM. One phantom study measured the mean amplitude and shear modulus within the overall region of a homogeneous phantom by changing the mechanical vibration power to assess the robustness to the lowered phase-to-noise ratio in short-SLIM. The other measured the mean shear modulus in the stiff and background materials of a phantom with an embedded stiffer rod to assess the performance of short-SLIM for complex wave patterns with wave interference. The Spearman's rank correlation coefficient was used to assess similarity of elastograms in the rod-embedded phantom and liver between methods. The results of the phantom study changing the vibration power indicated that there was little difference between conventional MRE and short-SLIM. Moreover, the elastogram pattern and the mean shear modulus in the rod-embedded phantom in conventional SLIM and short-SLIM did not change for conventional MRE; the liver test also showed a small difference between the acquisition techniques. This study demonstrates that short-SLIM can provide MRE results comparable to those of conventional MRE. Short-SLIM can reduce the total acquisition time by a factor of 2.25 compared to conventional 3D MRE time, leading to an improvement in the accuracy of shear modulus estimation by suppressing the patient movements.

Interpretation, Reporting, and Clinical Applications of Liver MR Elastography

Chronic liver disease is highly prevalent and often leads to fibrosis or cirrhosis and complications such as liver failure and hepatocellular carcinoma. The diagnosis and staging of liver fibrosis is crucial to determine management and mitigate complications. Liver biopsy for histologic assessment has limitations such as sampling bias and high interreader variability that reduce precision, which is particularly challenging in longitudinal monitoring. MR elastography (MRE) is considered the most accurate noninvasive technique for diagnosing and staging liver fibrosis. In MRE, low-frequency vibrations are applied to the abdomen, and the propagation of shear waves through the liver is analyzed to measure liver stiffness, a biomarker for the detection and staging of liver fibrosis. As MRE has become more widely used in clinical care and research, different contexts of use have emerged. This review focuses on the latest developments in the use of MRE for the assessment of liver fibrosis; provides guidance for image acquisition and interpretation; summarizes diagnostic performance, along with thresholds for diagnosis and staging of liver fibrosis; discusses current and emerging clinical applications; and describes the latest technical developments.

Magnetic resonance elastography for noninvasive detection of liver fibrosis: is there an added value of 3D acquisition?

PURPOSE

(1) Assess the diagnostic performance of liver 3D magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) parameters (including stiffness, storage/loss modulus and damping ratio) compared to liver stiffness measured with 2D MRE for noninvasive detection of advanced liver fibrosis (F3-F4) and cirrhosis (F4) in patients with chronic liver disease. (2) Assess the value of serum markers (FIB-4) in detecting advanced liver fibrosis and cirrhosis in the same patients.

METHODS

This was a single center, prospective IRB-approved cross-sectional study that included 49 patients (M/F: 23/26, mean age 50.8 y) with chronic liver disease and concomitant liver biopsy. MRE was acquired at 1.5T using a spin echo-EPI sequence. The following parameters were measured: liver stiffness using 2D MRE (LS-2D) and 3D MRE parameters (LS-3D, liver storage, loss modulus and damping ratio). The Mann-Whitney U test, ROC curve analysis, Spearman correlation and logistic regression were performed to evaluate diagnostic performance of MRE parameters and FIB-4.

RESULTS

LS-2D and LS-3D had similar diagnostic performance for diagnosis of F3-F4, with AUCs of 0.87 and 0.88, sensitivity of 0.71 and 0.81, specificity of 0.89 for both. For diagnosis of F4, LS-2D and LS-3D had similar performance with AUCs of 0.81 for both, sensitivity of 0.75 and 0.83, and specificity of 0.84 and 0.73, respectively. Additional 3D parameters (storage modulus, loss modulus, damping ratio) had variable performance, with AUC range of 0.59-0.78 for F3-F4; and 0.52-0.70 for F4. FIB-4 had lower diagnostic performance, with AUCs of 0.66 for F3-F4, and 0.68 for F4.

CONCLUSION

Our study shows no added value of 3D MRE compared to 2D MRE for detection of advanced fibrosis and cirrhosis, while FIB-4 had lower diagnostic performance.

Advances in application of novel magnetic resonance imaging technologies in liver disease diagnosis

Liver disease is a major health concern globally, with high morbidity and mor-tality rates. Precise diagnosis and assessment are vital for guiding treatment approaches, predicting outcomes, and improving patient prognosis. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a non-invasive diagnostic technique that has been widely used for detecting liver disease. Recent advancements in MRI technology, such as diffusion weighted imaging, intravoxel incoherent motion, magnetic resonance elastography, chemical exchange saturation transfer, magnetic resonance spectroscopy, hyperpolarized MR, contrast-enhanced MRI, and ra-diomics, have significantly improved the accuracy and effectiveness of liver disease diagnosis. This review aims to discuss the progress in new MRI technologies for liver diagnosis. By summarizing current research findings, we aim to provide a comprehensive reference for researchers and clinicians to optimize the use of MRI in liver disease diagnosis and improve patient prognosis.

Conventional and artificial intelligence-based computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging quantitative techniques for non-invasive liver fibrosis staging

Chronic liver disease (CLD) ultimately develops into liver fibrosis and cirrhosis and is a major public health problem globally. The assessment of liver fibrosis is important for patients with CLD for prognostication, treatment decisions, and surveillance. Liver biopsies are traditionally performed to determine the stage of liver fibrosis. However, the risks of complications and technical limitations restrict their application to screening and sequential monitoring in clinical practice. CT and MRI are essential for evaluating cirrhosis-associated complications in patients with CLD, and several non-invasive methods based on them have been proposed. Artificial intelligence (AI) techniques have also been applied to stage liver fibrosis. This review aimed to explore the values of conventional and AI-based CT and MRI quantitative techniques for non-invasive liver fibrosis staging and summarized their diagnostic performance, advantages, and limitations.

Multimodal fusion of tomographic sequences of medical images: MRE spatially enhanced by MRI

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

In biomedical fields, image analysis is often necessary for an accurate diagnosis. In order to obtain all the information needed to form an in-depth clinical picture, it may be useful to combine the contents of images taken under different diagnostic modes. Multimodal medical image fusion techniques enable complementary information acquired by different imaging devices to be automatically combined into a unique image.

METHODS

In this paper, multimodal medical images fusion method based on multiresolution analysis (MRA) is proposed, with the aim to combine the high geometric content of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and the elasticity information of magnetic resonance elastography (MRE), simultaneously acquired on the same organs of a patient. First, the slices of MRE are volumetrically interpolated to exactly overlap, each with a slice of MRI. Then, the spatial details of MRI are extracted by means of MRA and injected into the corresponding slices of MRE. Due to the intrinsic dissimilarity between corresponding slices of MRE and MRI, the spatial details of MRI are modulated by local or global matching functions.

RESULTS

The performance of the proposed method is quantitatively assessed considering radiometric and geometric consistency of the fused images with respect to their originals, in a comparison with two popular methods from the literature. For a qualitative evaluation, a visual inspection is carried out.

CONCLUSIONS

The results show that the proposed method enables an effective MRI-MRE fusion that allows the elasticity information and geometric details of the examined organs to be evaluated in a single image.