Secondary surgery in germ cell tumors--when and how extensively should it be performed?

Therapeutic supine robotic retroperitoneal lymph node dissection for post-chemotherapy residual masses in testicular cancer: technique and outcome analysis of initial experience

Retroperitoneal lymph node dissection (RPLND) is a therapeutic standard of care for post-chemotherapy residual masses in testicular cancer. While a robotic approach to this procedure has the potential of decreasing the morbidity associated with this major endeavour, it is often criticised for its inability to provide a bilateral complete template resection without redocking and repositioning the patient. Herein, we present the technique and initial outcomes of a supine approach to Robotic RPLND (R-RPLND) using the da Vinci Xi^® system, which obviates the need for repositioning or redocking for a bilateral full template resection. Three patients (age 21-36) with nonseminomatous germ cell tumours of the testis underwent R-RPLND for post-chemotherapy residual retroperitoneal masses with normalised tumor markers. Salient steps of the procedure were as follows: port placement in supine Trendelenburg position, docking of the da Vinci Xi^® system from one side, exposure of retroperitoneum, dissection of paracaval, retrocaval, interaortocaval, paraaortic and bilateral common iliac templates, and excision of gonadal vein. Mean console time and estimated blood loss were 257 (190-305) minutes and 333 (300-400) ml, respectively. Mean lymph node yield was 52 (29-94). One patient had a common iliac vein injury which was managed robotically without further consequence. No drains were placed in all three. There were no postoperative complications and all of them were advanced to a normal diet within 24 h and discharged on the second postoperative day. Histopathology reports were suggestive of necrosis and mature teratoma without any viable tumour. There have been no recurrences in these patients at a mean follow-up of 14 (1-22) months. R-RPLND in the supine position is practical, safe and feasible in the post-chemotherapy setting of testicular cancer. It eliminates the need for repositioning the patient or redocking the robot to achieve a complete resection with adequate lymph node yields, while preserving the benefits of a minimally invasive surgical approach.

Role of post-chemotherapy surgery in germ cell tumors

Surgery after systemic chemotherapy for advanced testicular cancer has maintained its role in staging and therapeutic management. The clinical outcome is strongly influenced by patient selection and extent of extirpative surgery. Although extensive predictive modeling has attempted to define appropriate post-chemotherapy surgical candidates based on various clinical and pathologic parameters, the accuracy of these models remains controversial. Complete removal of all post-chemotherapy residual masses in nonseminomatous germ cell tumors remains the standard of care and allows for improved prognostication of the long-term oncologic and functional outcome.

Late Relapse of Testis Cancer

Most relapses of germ-cell tumors occur within 2 years of initial treatment. In 2% to 4% of patients, relapse may occur later. The retroperitoneum is the primary site of late relapse, and alpha-fetoprotein is the predominant marker. These tumors are highly resistant to chemotherapy. Surgical resection is the preferred treatment. If the recurrent disease is inoperable, chemotherapy may be instituted, followed by resection of residual masses. Patients successfully managed for testis cancer need lifelong surveillance.

Two cycles of cisplatin-based chemotherapy for low-volume retroperitoneal stage II nonseminomatous germ cell tumours

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the oncological efficacy of reducing cisplatin-based chemotherapy to two cycles in patients with low-volume retroperitoneal stage II nonseminomatous germ cell tumours (NSGCTs).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From October 1988 until January 2004, two cycles of cisplatin-based chemotherapy were administered in 59 patients with low-volume retroperitoneal clinical stage II NSGCT (retroperitoneal mass of <5 cm in diameter). Regardless of remission detected on computed tomography, 6 weeks after chemotherapy the patients had a retroperitoneal lymph node dissection (RPLND) to assess residual active tumour or mature teratoma (open modified bilateral RPLND until 1992, then laparoscopic unilateral template RPLND).

RESULTS

The chemotherapy was effective, as no active tumour was found in any of RPLND specimens. Mature teratoma was present in lymphatic tissue in 23 of 59 patients (39%). In one patient there was a pulmonary recurrence, successfully treated with cisplatin-based salvage chemotherapy. One patient died from an accident but with no evidence of tumour, and 56 patients remained free of disease at a mean follow-up of 98.6 months. No patient died from disease. All patients had antegrade ejaculation after laparoscopic RPLND, as did 89% after open RPLND.

CONCLUSION

In this pilot study, the oncological efficacy of two cycles of cisplatin-based chemotherapy was favourable, but this approach still cannot be recommended as a standard treatment for patients with low-volume retroperitoneal stage II disease. RPLND after chemotherapy has diagnostic (detecting active tumour) and therapeutic (removing mature teratoma) value and can be done laparoscopically. Based on the present results a prospective randomized trial seems reasonable.

Distribution of nodal metastases after chemotherapy in nonseminomatous testis cancer: a possible indication for limited dissection

OBJECTIVE

To assess the clinical and pathological findings of patients treated by bilateral retroperitoneal lymph node dissection (RPLND) after chemotherapy, to identify a subset for whom modified template nodal resection might be contemplated, as bilateral RPLND is the treatment of choice in patients with residual retroperitoneal disease after chemotherapy for nonseminomatous germ-cell tumour (GCT).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The medical records were reviewed of 50 consecutive patients who had RPLND after chemotherapy between 1996 and 2005. Bilateral template RPLND was performed uniformly. Extracted lymph nodes were surgically stratified into three distinct anatomical zones by two sagittal planes running in front of the aorta and the inferior vena cava. The pathological findings were correlated with the side of the primary lesion and the extent of metastatic disease before chemotherapy.

RESULTS

Pathological assessment of the resected lymph nodes revealed teratoma in 28 patients (56%), viable carcinoma in three (6%), and necrosis or fibrosis in 19 (38%). All clinical stage Is, IIA and IIB left-sided primary tumours followed a predictable pattern of spread constricted to a modified left-sided template. Patients with clinical stage IIC and III, or right-sided primary tumour, had a less predictable metastatic pattern, having crossover metastases to the contralateral template.

CONCLUSION

Bilateral RPLND should be considered as the reference standard in patients with metastatic GCT and residual retroperitoneal mass after completing chemotherapy. However, the present data suggest that a modified template dissection might be considered even after chemotherapy in patients with left-sided primary tumours and limited nodal involvement at presentation.