Validation of a semiautomated volumetric approach for fetal neurosonography using 5DCNS+ in clinical data from > 1100 consecutive pregnancies

A Clinical Approach to Semiautomated Three-Dimensional Fetal Brain Biometry-Comparing the Strengths and Weaknesses of Two Diagnostic Tools: 5DCNS+TM and SonoCNSTM

(1) Objective: We aimed to evaluate the accuracy and efficacy of AI-assisted biometric measurements of the fetal central nervous system (CNS) by comparing two semiautomatic postprocessing tools. We further aimed to discuss the additional value of semiautomatically generated sagittal and coronal planes of the CNS. (2) Methods: Three-dimensional (3D) volumes were analyzed with two semiautomatic software tools, 5DCNS+™ and SonoCNS™. The application of 5DCNS+™ results in nine planes (axial, coronal and sagittal) displayed in a single template; SonoCNS™ depicts three axial cutting sections. The tools were compared regarding automatic biometric measurement accuracy. (3) Results: A total of 129 fetuses were included for final analysis. Our data indicate that, in terms of the biometric quantification of head circumference (HC), biparietal diameter (BPD), transcerebellar diameter (TCD) and cisterna magna (CM), the accuracy of SonoCNS™ was higher with respect to the manual measurement of an experienced examiner compared to 5DCNS+™, whereas it was the other way around regarding the diameter of the posterior horn of the lateral ventricle (Vp). The inclusion of four orthogonal coronal views in 5DCNS+™ gives valuable information regarding spatial arrangements, particularly of midline structures. (4) Conclusions: Both tools were able to ease assessment of the intracranial anatomy, highlighting the additional value of automated algorithms in clinical use. SonoCNS™ showed a superior accuracy of plane reconstruction and biometry, but volume reconstruction using 5DCNS+™ provided more detailed information, which is needed for an entire neurosonogram as suggested by international guidelines.

Computational methods for the analysis of early-pregnancy brain ultrasonography: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Early screening of the brain is becoming routine clinical practice. Currently, this screening is performed by manual measurements and visual analysis, which is time-consuming and prone to errors. Computational methods may support this screening. Hence, the aim of this systematic review is to gain insight into future research directions needed to bring automated early-pregnancy ultrasound analysis of the human brain to clinical practice.

METHODS

We searched PubMed (Medline ALL Ovid), EMBASE, Web of Science Core Collection, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, and Google Scholar, from inception until June 2022. This study is registered in PROSPERO at CRD42020189888. Studies about computational methods for the analysis of human brain ultrasonography acquired before the 20th week of pregnancy were included. The key reported attributes were: level of automation, learning-based or not, the usage of clinical routine data depicting normal and abnormal brain development, public sharing of program source code and data, and analysis of the confounding factors.

FINDINGS

Our search identified 2575 studies, of which 55 were included. 76% used an automatic method, 62% a learning-based method, 45% used clinical routine data and in addition, for 13% the data depicted abnormal development. None of the studies shared publicly the program source code and only two studies shared the data. Finally, 35% did not analyse the influence of confounding factors.

INTERPRETATION

Our review showed an interest in automatic, learning-based methods. To bring these methods to clinical practice we recommend that studies: use routine clinical data depicting both normal and abnormal development, make their dataset and program source code publicly available, and be attentive to the influence of confounding factors. Introduction of automated computational methods for early-pregnancy brain ultrasonography will save valuable time during screening, and ultimately lead to better detection, treatment and prevention of neuro-developmental disorders.

FUNDING

The Erasmus MC Medical Research Advisor Committee (grant number: FB 379283).

Applicability of a semiautomated volumetric approach (5D CNS+™) for detailed antenatal reconstruction of abnormal fetal CNS anatomy

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy and reliability of a semiautomated volumetric approach (5D CNS+™) when examining fetuses with an apparent abnormal anatomy of the central nervous system (CNS).

METHODS

Stored 3D volumes extracted from a cohort of > 1.400 consecutive 2nd and 3rd trimester pregnancies (range 15-36 gestational weeks) were analyzed using the semiautomatic software tool 5D CNS+™, enabling detailed reconstruction of nine diagnostic planes of the fetal brain. All 3D data sets were examined and judged for plane accuracy, the need for manual adjustment, and fetal CNS anomalies affecting successful plane reconstruction.

RESULTS

Based on our data of 91 fetuses with structural cerebral anomalies, we were able to reveal details of a wide range of CNS anomalies with application of the 5D CNS+™ technique. The corresponding anatomical features and consecutive changes of neighboring structures could be clearly demonstrated. Thus, a profound assessment of the entire altered CNS anatomy could be achieved in nearly all cases. The comparison with matched controls showed a significant difference in volume acquisition (p < 0.001) and in need for manual adjustment (p < 0.001) but not in the drop-out rates (p = 0.677) of both groups.

CONCLUSION

5D CNS+™ is applicable in the majority of cases with brain lesions and constitutes a reliable tool even if the integrity of the fetal CNS is compromised by structural anomalies. Using volume data that were acquired in identical cutting sections needed for conventional biometry allows for detailed anatomic surveys grossly independent of the examiner's experience.

The Use of Artificial Intelligence in Automation in the Fields of Gynaecology and Obstetrics - an Assessment of the State of Play

The long-awaited progress in digitalisation is generating huge amounts of medical data every day, and manual analysis and targeted, patient-oriented evaluation of this data is becoming increasingly difficult or even infeasible. This state of affairs and the associated, increasingly complex requirements for individualised precision medicine underline the need for modern software solutions and algorithms across the entire healthcare system. The utilisation of state-of-the-art equipment and techniques in almost all areas of medicine over the past few years has now indeed enabled automation processes to enter - at least in part - into routine clinical practice. Such systems utilise a wide variety of artificial intelligence (AI) techniques, the majority of which have been developed to optimise medical image reconstruction, noise reduction, quality assurance, triage, segmentation, computer-aided detection and classification and, as an emerging field of research, radiogenomics. Tasks handled by AI are completed significantly faster and more precisely, clearly demonstrated by now in the annual findings of the ImageNet Large-Scale Visual Recognition Challenge (ILSVCR), first conducted in 2015, with error rates well below those of humans. This review article will discuss the potential capabilities and currently available applications of AI in gynaecological-obstetric diagnostics. The article will focus, in particular, on automated techniques in prenatal sonographic diagnostics.