Laparoscopic management of impalpable testes: comparison of different techniques

Comparison between staged laparoscopic technique in children with high intra-abdominal undescended testis: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Background

This study performed a systematic review and meta-analysis to compare the outcomes of the staged laparoscopic Fowler-Stephens Laparoscopic Orchiopexy (FSLO) and Staged Laparoscopic Traction Orchiopexy (SLTO) in patients with intra-abdominal testes (IAT).

Methods

This study reviewed literature published from 2016 to 2024. A systematic literature search was conducted on three databases: PubMed, ScienceDirect, and Google Scholar, using keywords (High intra abdominal testis) AND (("Fowler Stephens laparoscopic orchiopexy" OR (FSLO)) OR (Staged Laparoscopic traction orchiopexy OR (SLTO)). Non-randomized trials and observational studies comparing staged laparoscopic FSLO and SLTO, without any time range restriction are included. Studies without FLSO orchidopexy as a control, case reports, case studies, duplicate publication, no full text and non-English studies are excluded. This study used the PRISMA protocol, the Jadad Scale, and the Newcastle Ottawa Scale (NOS) to evaluate the included studies. To analyze statistical data, the Review Manager (RevMan) software was used. The Chi-squared test was used to calculate statistical heterogeneity in the meta-analysis.

Results

There were 240 patients from 5 studies (109 in the SLTO group and 131 FSLO in group). The primary outcome of this study is testicular descent and atrophy. There were no significant differences in testicular descent (RR:1.08[0.96 - 1.23],p<0.20,I 2:0%) and atrophy rate (RR:0.45[0.19 - 1.09],p<0.08,I 2:0%). Secondary outcomes are the duration of operation in both the first and second stages. Statistical analysis reveals a significantly lower first-stage operation time in the FSLO group (MD:9.31[7.08,11.55], p<0.05;I 2:94%). At the same time, lower second-stage operation times are significantly reported in the SLTO group (MD:-4.05[-7.99,-0.12],p<0.05; I 2:60%).

Conclusions

In terms of testicular descent and testicular atrophy the SLTO technique yields similar results to the FSLO technique. Both techniques have advantages and disadvantages, and we recommend SLTO as the first choice in children with a high IAT of <4 cm.

PROSPERO registration

CRD42023412407.

Laparoscopic staged management of high intrabdominal testis: A prospective randomized study

OBJECTIVE

To prospectively compare outcomes and complications of both staged laparoscopic techniques used in management of high intrabdominal testis (IAT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty five patients were included in the study in whom unilateral high IAT were identified and were subjected to two-stage laparoscopic orchiopexy. Patients were prospectively randomized into two groups according to laparoscopic technique in use; either two stage Fowler-Stephens laparoscopic orchiopexy (FSLO) or staged laparoscopic traction orchiopexy (SLTO). Intraoperative evaluation for the distance of the testis from the internal ring, state of the internal ring (closed or open), operative time (min), intraoperative and early postoperative complications were recorded after first stage. Surgical outcomes of both techniques included operative time, intraoperative complications, success rate, final scrotal site position, testicular size and vascularity, and these were recorded within 48h of the second stage procedure and at 6 month follow-up.

RESULTS

Staged FSLO was performed on 25 testes. Four cases were lost during follow up. Out of these 21 cases, one child had an atrophic testis before the second stage based on previously recorded operative size. SLTO was done on 20 testes. We had 2 cases of fixation suture slippage rendering a total of 18 patients who underwent second stage operation. No patients converted from laparoscopic to open surgery. At 6 month follow-up visits, 27 testes were found on examination to have a low scrotal position, (14 in the FSLO group and 13 in the SLTO group), 9 testes in high scrotal position (5 in the FSLO group and 4 in the SLTO group). Testicular ascent occurred in one patient in each group. Testicular atrophy was identified in 3 cases among the FS group, while no case of testicular atrophy occurred in the traction group of patients (p = 0.048).

CONCLUSIONS

Both staged laparoscopic techniques had comparable success rates as regard final scrotal position for high undescended IAT in children, and were associated with no intra or post operative complications. SLTO had a better outcome as it was not associated with any testicular atrophy compared to FSLO at 6 months follow up.

Surgical exploration for impalpable testis: Which should be first, inguinal exploration or laparoscopic abdominal exploration?

PURPOSE

To discuss an optimal surgical approach for impalpable testis in children, our own treatment results and those reported in the literature were reviewed.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seventy-two impalpable testes were diagnosed in 68 patients: unilateral in 64 patients and bilateral in 4 patients. All patients underwent surgical exploration at the ages of 6 to 140months (median, 15months). The inguinal canal was initially explored, and abdominal exploration was performed with laparoscopy when an extra-abdominal testis was not identified. In addition, articles regarding surgical exploration for impalpable testis, published over the last 20years, were retrieved and the results were examined.

RESULTS

Testes were detected by inguinal exploration in 28 of 72 (39%) impalpable testes: intracanalicular in 22 testes and at the internal inguinal ring (peeping or low abdominal testis) in 6 testes. All these testes were treated by conventional inguinal orchidopexy. Laparoscopic exploration was performed in 44 (61%) impalpable testes, and 4 (5.6%) high abdominal testes were detected and treated by two-stage Fowler-Stephens orchidopexy. Vanishing or absent testis was the final diagnosis in the remaining 40 testes (55.6%). The literature review showed that the ratios of intra- and extra-abdominal testes were lower in the articles that reported the results of inguinal or scrotal exploration than in those of laparoscopic exploration, although the difference was not significant.

CONCLUSIONS

Considering the relatively low incidence of high abdominal testis, we recommend to start with inguinal exploration for impalpable testis. When an extra-abdominal testis is not detected, transinguinal laparoscopic exploration should be indicated.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Treatment study, Level IV.

Staged laparoscopic traction orchiopexy for intra-abdominal testis: Is it always feasible?

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Laparoscopic orchiopexy for intra-abdominal testis is a well-known and commonly practiced technique. The traction technique is based on elongation of the testicular vessels without cutting them, in contrast with the two-stage Fowler-Stephens technique in which the testicular vessels are divided. The current study evaluated the feasibility of the traction technique according to the type of intra-abdominal testis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The study included 20 boys with 22 intra-abdominal testes and who underwent staged laparoscopic traction orchiopexy between October 2013 and October 2015. Eighteen testes were proximal to the internal ring by <2 cm (type III), while the remaining four were high and away from the internal ring by >2 cm (type IVa). The patients' ages ranged between 6 months and 5 years (mean 2.2 years; median 2 years). Patients were followed up for 1 year for testicular atrophy and satisfactory scrotal site relocation.

RESULTS

This study did not detect any cases of testicular atrophy among the participants (0/22), while failure to achieve satisfactory scrotal site was found in two out of the four cases with type IVa intra-abdominal testes.

DISCUSSION

Traction techniques for elongating the testicular vessels were employed years ago, but this was revisited by Shehata in 2008. It has the advantage of preserving the main testicular blood supply, which can be reflected by the decreasing rate of testicular atrophy when compared with the Fowler-Stephens orchiopexy. The results of the traction technique may be less satisfactory regarding the testicular location for higher types of intra-abdominal testes (type IVa).

CONCLUSION

Staged laparoscopic traction orchiopexy was a feasible technique for intra-abdominal testes (within 2 cm of the internal ring), but the results were less satisfactory when applied for higher intra-abdominal testes (type IVa).

Presence of viable germ cells in testicular regression syndrome remnants: Is routine excision indicated? A systematic review

There is no consensus in the literature about the necessity for excision of testicular remnants in the context of surgery for an impalpable testis and testicular regression syndrome (TRS). The incidence of germ cells (GCs) within these nubbins varies between 0 and 16% in previously published series. There is a hypothetical potential future malignancy risk, although there has been only one previously described isolated report of intratubular germ-cell neoplasia. Our aim was to ascertain an accurate incidence of GCs and seminiferous tubules (SNTs) within excised nubbins and hence guide evidence-based practice. The systematic review protocol was designed according to the PRISMA guidelines, and subsequently published by the PROSPERO database after review (CRD42013006034). The primary outcome measure was the incidence of GCs and the secondary outcome was the incidence of SNTs. The comprehensive systematic review included articles published between 1980 and 2016 in all the relevant databases using specific search parameters and terms. Strict inclusion and exclusion criteria were ultilised to identify articles relevant to the review questions. Twenty-nine paediatric studies with a total of 1455 specimens were included in the systematic review. The mean age of the patients undergoing nubbin resection was 33 months and the TRS specimen was more commonly excised from the left (68%). The incidence of SNTs was 10.7% (156/1455) and the incidence of GCs, 5.3% (77/1455). Histological analysis excluding the presence of either SNTs or GCs was consistent with TRS, fibrosis, calcification or haemosiderin deposits. There is limited evidence on subset analysis that GCs and SNTs may persist with increasing patient age. This systematic review has identified that 1 in 20 of resected testicular remnants has viable GCs and 1 in 10 has SNTs present. There is insufficiently strong evidence for the persistence of GCs and SNTs with time or future malignant potential. Intra-abdominal TRS specimens may contain more elements and, therefore, require excision, although this is based on limited evidence. However, there is no available strong evidence to determine that a TRS specimen requires routine excision in an inguinal or scrotal position.

Treatment of impalpable testis - one clinic's experience

Introduction

Undescended testes are recognised in 1% to 2% of boys during the first year of life, and about 20% of them are impalpable. Ultrasonography (US) may establish the localisation of the testis but the final diagnosis is usually determined laparoscopically.

Aim

To evaluate long-term results of laparoscopic treatment of boys with impalpable testes and sensitivity of preoperative ultrasound.

Material and methods

Between 2011 and 2015, we operated on 545 boys with undescended testes. Sixty-two of them with 65 impalpable testes were treated laparoscopically – the study group. Mean age was 3.5 years. The study group was divided into 5 groups according to type of treatment. The volume and position of the operated gonad were assessed manually and by ultrasound.

Results

In group 1 testicular agenesis was observed in 19 patients. In group 2 revision of the inguinal canal revealed testicular agenesis in 7 and atrophy in 4 patients. In group 3 conversion to classic orchiopexy was performed in 10 patients. In group 4 one-stage orchiopexy was performed in 9 patients on 12 testes. In group 5 a two-stage F-S procedure was performed in 13 patients. Ten testes in group 4 had a volume in the normal range (84%) and also 10 testes in group 5 (77%).

Conclusions

Laparoscopy in impalpable testes is the procedure of choice and allows definitive management, even when conversion to open procedure is necessary. Sensitivity of preoperative ultrasound is generally about 60% for true intra-abdominal testes, so diagnostic laparoscopy is necessary.

Laparoscopic one-stage Fowler-Stephens orchiopexy preserving gubernaculum

OBJECTIVE

To assess gubernaculum-sparing laparoscopic one-stage Fowler-Stephens orchiopexy (FSO), in the management of high intrapelvic testis.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Medical reports of boys who underwent laparoscopic one-stage FSO were retrospectively reviewed. High intrapelvic testis was defined as testis ≥3 cm away from ipsilateral internal ring. Testes were evaluated on physical examination at 3^rd, 6^th and 18^th months after surgery. Children were evaluated as for their demographic data, operative findings, interventional details and outcomes.

RESULTS

Seven patients met inclusion criteria of the study. Six of 7 testis were small and had abnormal appearance, compared with the contralateral testis. Average distance of the testes from the internal ring was 4.2±1.1 cm (3 to 6). Average age at surgery was 6.1±4.2 years (2 to 12). Average follow-up period was 14±5.8 months (8 to 20), and 5 testis (71.4%) were considered to be normal in volume and scrotal location. Two testes were relatively atrophic and underwent orchiectomy.

CONCLUSION

Our preliminary results shows a good testicular survival rate for one-stage laparoscopic FSO. Sparing collateral vasculature of the gubernaculum is important.

Staged Fowler-Stephens and Single-stage Laparoscopic Orchiopexy for Intra-abdominal Testes: Is There a Difference? A Single Institution Experience

OBJECTIVE

To compare single-stage laparoscopic orchiopexy (SSLO) and staged Fowler-Stephens (SFS) procedures in the management of intra-abdominal undescended testes, and to analyze postoperative atrophy and malpositioning as end points.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective chart review identified laparoscopic orchiopexy patients with intra-abdominal testes between November 2006 and November 2014. Of 167 patients who had laparoscopic orchiopexy, 73 (85 testes) were identified as having laparoscopic orchiopexy. Baseline characteristics, as well as testicular scrotal position and size at follow-up, were recorded. Regression analysis was performed to compare outcomes between patients who underwent SFS and SSLO.

RESULTS

Of the 85 laparoscopic orchiopexies, 35 underwent SFS and 50 had SSLO. Patient demographics were comparable in both groups. The median age at surgery was 12 months (5-151 months), and the average follow-up was 17.3 months. On follow-up, there were 0 recorded cases of SFS patients with abnormally positioned testes postoperatively, whereas there were 10 (20.0%) SSLO patients who had abnormally positioned testes (odds ratio: 0.05, 95% confidence interval: 0.01-0.44). Differences in atrophy rates were not significant.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that there may be no difference between the 2 approaches in terms of postoperative atrophy. However, the SFS appears to be more successful in securing a favorable scrotal position. Atrophy does not seem to be associated with other patient factors. Prospective, randomized studies are indicated to further explore outcome differences between the 2 approaches.

Laparoscopic treatment of nonpalpable testicle. Factors predictive for diminished size

PURPOSE

The purposes of this study were to demonstrate the usefulness of laparoscopy in intraabdominal testicle (IAT) and to determine factors associated with diminished size during the final outcome after laparoscopic orchidopexy.

METHODS

This is a retrospective analysis of consecutive patients from 1999 to 2013 with a minimum follow-up of 1year. Patient and testicular factors were related to diminished size.

RESULTS

Sixty one patients, and 92 testicles were included. Median age at operation was 42months. Initially we found 66 normal sized testes (71.7%), 22 hypotrophic (23.9%) and four atrophic (4.3%). Eighty seven testes were brought down laparoscopically, 50 in one surgical stage and 37 in two stages. Mean follow-up was 40.2months and the final outcome was success: 73.5% and diminished size: 26.5%. Variables associated with diminished size were hypotrophy during initial evaluation, short spermatic vessels, section of spermatic vessels, two-stage surgery and tension to reach contralateral inguinal ring. Multivariate analysis showed that initial hypotrophy (odds ratio [OR] 4.96, confidence interval 95% [CI] 1.36-18.10) and tension to reach contralateral ring (OR 4.11, 95% CI 1.18-14.34) were associated with diminished size.

CONCLUSIONS

Laparoscopy is useful in treating IAT. Initial size and tension to reach contralateral ring are factors associated with diminished size.

Use of laparoscopy as the initial surgical approach of impalpable testes: 10-year experience

AIM: To review the experience in the management of impalpable testes using laparoscopy as the initial approach and the need for inguinal exploration.

METHODS: From January 2004 to June 2014, 339 patients with undescended testes underwent operation in our institute. Fifty patients (15%) had impalpable testes. All children with impalpable testes underwent initial laparoscopy. A retrospective review was conducted on this group of patients and the outcome was analyzed.

RESULTS: Forty children had unilateral impalpable testis. Ten children had bilateral impalpable testes. Thirty-one children (78%) in the unilateral group underwent subsequent inguinal exploration while 4 children (40%) in the bilateral group underwent inguinal exploration (P < 0.05). Orchidopexy was performed in 16 children (40%) in the unilateral group and 9 children (90%) in the bilateral group (P < 0.05). Regarding the 24 children with unilateral impalpable testis and underwent orchidectomy for testicular nubbin (n = 19) or atrophic testes (n = 2) or has vanishing testes (n = 3); contralateral testicular hypertrophy was noticed in 10 (41%). No intra-operative complication was encountered. Two children after staged Fowler-Stephens procedure and 1 child after inguinal orchidopexy had atrophic testes.

CONCLUSION: The use of laparoscopy in children with impalpable testes is a safe procedure and can guide the need for subsequent inguinal exploration. Children with unilateral impalpable testis were associated with an increased need for inguinal exploration after laparoscopy. Orchidopexies could be performed successfully in 90% of children with bilateral impalpable testes.

What is the ideal surgical approach for intra-abdominal testes? A systematic review

There is controversy regarding the ideal surgical management of intra-abdominal testes (IAT) to preserve fertility; we conducted a systematic review to address this problem. We performed a comprehensive electronic search of CENTRAL, MEDLINE, EMBASE, and CINAHL from 2008 to September 2014 (the date range was limited due to an abundance of literature), as well as reference lists of included studies. Two researchers screened all studies for inclusion, and quality assessed each relevant study using AMSTAR for systematic reviews (SRs), Cochrane 'Risk of bias' tool for randomized controlled trials (RCTs), and MINORS for non-randomized studies. We identified two relevant SRs and 29 non-randomized studies. Due to the heterogeneity of the data, meta-analysis was not possible. Ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging are insufficient for identification or localization of IAT; laparoscopic or surgical exploration is necessary. Primary orchiopexy is effective for low IAT, and Fowler-Stephens orchiopexy (FSO) is effective for high IAT. There is no clear benefit of one- vs. two-stage FSO, or of open vs. laparoscopic technique. Several alternative or modified techniques also show promise. RCTs are needed to confirm the validity of these findings, and to assess long-term outcomes.