The current profile of persistent cloaca and cloacal exstrophy in Japan: the results of a nationwide survey in 2014 and a review of the literature

Qualitative inductive analysis of the lives of women with persistent cloaca based on their narratives

PURPOSE

The study aimed to explore and describe the lives of patients with persistent cloaca (PC) from childhood to adulthood.

METHODS

Semistructured interviews were conducted with nine adult patients with PC. Their experiences and thoughts regarding this disease were analyzed qualitatively and inductively.

RESULTS

After classifying the experiences and thoughts of patients with PC, 13 categories were extracted. The following five themes emerged from these categories. (1) Difficulties with excretion and vaginal management because of the disease. (2) The degree of understanding of those around them and society has a huge effect on their way of life. (3) The inferiority of a woman who is not a "normal woman." (4) A "never-ending disease" in which problems continue even after the transition period. (5) Differences in the central point of the narrative depending on the age group.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, qualitative and inductive analyses of data from semistructured interviews with patients with PC revealed their experiences and thoughts. The results will provide a guide for young patients and the medical professionals who treat them. Accordingly, monitoring their lives until adulthood is necessary.

Posterior sagittal anorecto-urethro-vagino-plasty in the late period was associated with the long-term bowel function in patients with persistent cloaca: results of a nationwide survey in Japan

PURPOSE

After conducting a nationwide survey of persistent cloaca (PC), we assessed whether or not the timing of definitive anorectoplasty affects the long-term bowel function of patients with PC.

METHODS

Patient information was obtained via questionnaire, and a total of 169 PC patients who underwent posterior sagittal anorectourethrovaginoplasty (PSARUVP) were enrolled in this study. Patients were classified into 2 groups based on their operative period, which was analyzed by the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve: the early group (EG) underwent anorectoplasty at ≤ 18 months old (n = 106), and the late group (LG) underwent anorectoplasty at > 18 months old (n = 63). The bowel function was evaluated using the evacuation score of the Japan Society of Anorectal Malformation Study Group. We also examined the postoperative results of vaginoplasty.

RESULTS

The total evacuation score was significantly higher in the EG than in the LG (5.2 ± 1.7 vs. 4.2 ± 1.8, p = 0.003). The frequency of bowel movement and the constipation scores were significantly higher in the EG than in the LG (1.4 ± 0.6 vs. 1.2 ± 0.7, p < 0.05, 2.4 ± 1.0 vs. 2.1 ± 1.0, p < 0.05, respectively). Postoperative vaginal stenosis was observed in 18 cases (10.7%), of which 16 could be reconstructed transperineally.

CONCLUSION

PSARUVP should be performed in early infancy and facilitate vaginal reconstruction.

The clinical features of patients who underwent bladder augmentation of cloacal exstrophy and their functional outcomes: the results of a nationwide survey in Japan

PURPOSE

Cloacal exstrophy (CE) patients may need bladder reconstruction after initially undergoing surgery to obtain continence and improve their quality of life. This study attempts to clarify the clinical features of CE patients who underwent bladder augmentation (BA) and their urinary functional outcomes based on a nationwide survey in Japan.

METHODS

A questionnaire survey was conducted, and 150 CE patients were enrolled. Their clinical characteristics and urinary outcomes were reviewed.

RESULTS

BA was performed in 52 patients (34.7%). Most cases underwent early bladder closure at initial surgery in neonate period. The age at the BA was performed 6.4 [6-9.0] years. Among them, the most used organ for BA was ileum (n = 30, 57.7%). Regarding the outcomes, the age when the renal function was evaluated was 14.0 [10.0-20.5] years and the serum creatinine level was 0.44 [0.36-0.60] (mg/dl). Clean intermittent catheterization was required in 37 (71.2%) patients. On the other hand, no dialysis or kidney transplantation was necessary in any of these patients.

CONCLUSION

The renal function and conditions of patients who underwent BA were relatively well preserved. Individualized management with a stepwise surgical approach for CE patients should thus be considered in the future.

Clinical features of patients who underwent anoplasty for cloacal exstrophy and their functional outcomes: the results of a nationwide survey in Japan

PURPOSE

This study was performed to clarify the clinical features of cloacal exstrophy (CE) patients who underwent anoplasty and their functional outcomes based on a nationwide survey in Japan.

METHODS

A questionnaire survey was conducted and data were obtained from 229 CE patients. After the exclusion of non-surviving patients and unknown data, 195 patients were enrolled. We compared the patient characteristics of the no anoplasty group (NAP group) to the anoplasty group (AP group). The defecation function of patients who underwent anoplasty was evaluated.

RESULTS

The AP group had significantly lower rates of omphalocele (p = 0.045) and spinal defects (p = 0.003) than the NAP group. Of the 195 patients enrolled in this study, only 17 (8.7%) underwent anoplasty. Of the 17 patients who underwent anoplasty, 7 (41.1%) eventually had a permanent stoma after anoplasty [after ileostomy: n = 3 (60.0%), after colostomy: n = 4 (44.4%)]. Regarding soiling, 4 patients (66.7%) showed the absence of soiling, 2 (33.3%) showed accidental soiling, and no patients showed frequent soiling.

CONCLUSION

In our study, spinal defects may have affected the determination of anoplasty. Anoplasty may improve the quality of life, because defecation can be kept clean, but indications, including colon function, may be carefully considered.

Analysis of the potential risk factors for defecation problems and their bowel management based on the long-term bowel function in patients with persistent cloaca: results of a nationwide survey in Japan

AIM OF THE STUDY

We conducted a nationwide survey of persistent cloaca (PC) to determine its current status in Japan. This study clarifies the potential risk factors for defecation problems in patients with PC.

METHODS

Patient information was obtained via questionnaire, and a total of 213 PC patients who responded to a questionnaire on defecation problems and their bowel functions were enrolled in this study. We evaluated the constipation, incontinence, and soiling as bowel functions. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed using a logistic regression analysis to clarify the risk factors for defecation problems.

RESULTS

Of 213 patients with PC, 55 (25.8%) had defecation problems. A multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that sacral agenesis, as an associated anomaly, was significantly associated with defecation problems (odds ratio [OR] 3.19, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.11-9.16, p = 0.03). The other multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that the PC patients who underwent antegrade continence enema and regularly took laxatives after anorectoplasty had defecation problems (OR 12.4, 95% CI 2.35-65.6, p = 0.003, OR 2.84, 95% CI 1.24-6.55, p = 0.01).

CONCLUSION

Sacral agenesis is the potential risk factor of defecation problems in the patients with PC who underwent anorectoplasty. Those patients require vigorous defecation management.

Risk factor analysis of irreversible renal dysfunction based on fetal ultrasonographic findings in patients with persistent cloaca: Results from a nationwide survey in Japan

AIM OF THE STUDY

We conducted a nationwide survey of persistent cloaca (PC) to determine its current status in Japan. We focused on the relationship between fetal ultrasonographic findings and irreversible renal dysfunction in PC.

METHOD

Patient information was obtained via questionnaire, and 466 PC patients were ultimately enrolled in this study. Fifteen patients (3.2%) who required dialysis or kidney transplantation were compared to those who were able to survive with their native kidney. Univariable and multivariable analyses were performed using a logistic regression analysis to clarify the relationship between irreversible renal dysfunction and fetal ultrasonographic findings.

RESULTS

A multivariable logistic analysis showed that fetal ultrasonic findings of oligohydramnios independently increased the risk of irreversible renal dysfunction (adjusted odds ratio [OR] 5.8, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.7-20, p = 0.005). A regression analysis showed that fetal ultrasonographic findings of hydroureteronephrosis (crude OR 5.6, 95% CI 0.9-24, p = 0.03) tended to be associated with irreversible renal dysfunction. In the PC patients with oligohydramnios, however, the ultrasonographic findings and associated anomalies did not affect the renal prognosis. The 15 renal dysfunction patients were treated as follows: hemodialysis (n = 4), peritoneal dialysis (n = 3), living donor renal transplantation (n = 8), and cadaveric renal transplantation (n = 1).

CONCLUSION

Fetal ultrasonographic findings of oligohydramnios increase the risk of irreversible renal dysfunction. Such findings suggest we consider the need for earlier therapeutic intervention, such as fetal and postnatal treatment, to prevent the progression of renal dysfunction.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III (Study of diagnostic test, study of nonconsecutive patients and/or without a universally applied "gold" standard).

Long-term Kidney Outcomes in Exstrophy-Epispadias Complex: How Patients Present as Adults

OBJECTIVE

To characterize kidney function in patients with exstrophy-epispadias complex (EEC) at time of presentation for adult urologic care.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This was a retrospective analysis of 23 patients (ages 18-57) with EEC who presented to a single tertiary care center from 2001-2020. Kidney function was evaluated based on calculated eGFR and presence of hydronephrosis on imaging. UDS data was used to evaluate the bladder.

RESULTS

Patients had undergone a variety of different surgical techniques for exstrophy or epispadias repair prior to presentation to an adult urologist. We found that 10 of the 23 patients had evidence of CKD Stage II or higher at the time of presentation and 7 patients had evidence of hydronephrosis on imaging. There was urodynamics data available for 14 patients, of which 8 patients showed poor (≤15 ml/cmH₂O) or intermediate (15-20 ml/cmH₂O) bladder compliance.

CONCLUSION

In conclusion, some patients with EEC have evidence of kidney dysfunction at time of presentation to an adult urologist. It is important to consider this when caring for patients with EEC as adults.

Challenges in the Prenatal Diagnosis of Cloaca

Background:

Cloaca is a common excretory channel for the genital, urinary, and gastrointestinal tracts. It is considered a severe anorectal malformation caused by failed partitioning of the genital, rectal, and urinary tracts.

Methods:

We report 5 infants with cloaca at birth who were identified prenatally by one or more of the following on prenatal ultrasound (US): ambiguous genitalia, a cystic pelvic/abdominal mass, hydronephrosis, ascites, a single umbilical artery, and oligohydramnios.

Results:

A cystic pelvic/abdominal mass and ambiguous genitalia were each observed in 3 cases by prenatal US. Ambiguous genitalia was observed in all 5 neonates at birth. There were 2 twin pregnancies (dichorionic/diamniotic and monochorionic/monoamniotic), with only 1 twin in a set affected with cloaca.

Conclusion:

Pediatricians should be alert to the prenatal US findings that may raise suspicion of a persistent cloaca to improve both prenatal counseling and family preparation.

Cloacal Malformation in Female Children: Outcome of Initial Management

Objective:

To document our experience of initial management of Cloacal malformation in female patients.

Methods:

A descriptive retrospective study was conducted in the Department of Pediatric Surgery of the National Institute of Child Health Karachi from January 2010 to September 2018. Female patients with diagnosis of Cloacal malformation were included in this study. Data regarding the age at presentation, mode of presentation, clinical features, presence of hydrocolpos, and associated anomalies were noted. Surgical procedures performed in these patients and the outcomes were also documented. Data was analyzed on SPSS Version 20.

Results:

Sixty females were included in the study. Age ranged from birth to three years with a median of four days. Patients admitted through emergency were 44 (73.33%) while 16 (26.66%) were admitted through outpatient clinic. Hydrocolpos was found in 15 (25.00%) patients. Five (8.33%) patients had massive abdominal distention and were presented with severe respiratory distress. Among them three had massive hydrocolpos, one patient had pneumoperitoneum secondary to Meckel’s perforation and one patient was having massive colonic dilatation. Hydronephrosis and hydroureter were found in 14 (23.33%) patients, while dilated bladder was found in three (5.00%) patients. After optimization of patients, bowel diversion was done as transverse colostomy in 39 (65.00%) patients, high sigmoid colostomy in 17(28.33%) patients while ileostomy was done in three (5.00%) patients. All patients with hydrocolpos had tube vaginostomy. None of the patients required bladder diversion and urinary tract dilatations were gradually subsided in nine patients in the post-operative period. Associated anomalies were found in 22(36.66%) of cases predominantly of sacral origin. Operative complications were found in 18(30.00%) patients, including stoma site in infection in 12(20.00%) patients, vaginal tube dislodgement in two patients, wrong placement of tube in one patient and vaginostomy stenosis in one case. While bowel stoma retraction occurred in four patients, prolapsed was found in three patients. Renal failure occurred in one patient. In total, 37(61.00%) patients had smooth recovery, 18(30.00%) patients had some complications, while Five (8.33%) patients were expired due to sepsis.

Conclusions:

Majority of cloacal malformations present in neonatal life. Initial management is an important step in dealing with these patients. Care must be taken during the abdominal exploration regarding drainage of hydrocolpos and appropriate placement of bowel stoma.

Measuring the common canal of a persistent cloaca: can MRI replace conventional imaging?

AIM

To evaluate the role of MRI in preoperative assessments of patients with a persistent cloaca and compare magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) versus fluoroscopy contrast study in the accuracy of common canal measurement and classification prediction.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty-one patients with a persistent cloaca were diagnosed and treated at Guangzhou Women and Children's Medical Center between March 2011 and December 2017. The length of the common canal was measured using MRI and fluoroscopy contrast study. Classification results based on measurements were compared with cystoscopy and intraoperative findings. The accuracy in predicting the classification by measuring the common canal length was compared.

RESULT

Among 31 patients, 24 had MRI, 24 underwent fluoroscopy contrast study, and 25 underwent cystoscopy. In 20 patients, MRI-based categorisations were in accordance with cystoscopy or surgery findings, whereas in four patients there was discordance. In 17 patients, categorisations based on fluoroscopy contrast study were in accordance with cystoscopy or surgery findings, and in seven patients there was discordance; the difference was not statistically significant (p>0.05).

CONCLUSION

MRI may accurately demonstrate genitourinary anomalies and the length of the common canal in patients with persistent cloaca. Categorisation based on MRI measurements of the common canal was accordant with the results from cystoscopy and findings from surgery. The use of this method may help surgeons to develop appropriate reconstruction plans before sending their patients to the operating room.

Clinical and risk factor analysis of cloacal defects in the National Birth Defects Prevention Study

Cloacal exstrophy (CE) and persistent cloaca (PC) (alternatively termed urorectal septum malformation sequence [URSMS]), represent two major cloacal defects (CDs). Clinical characteristics and risk factors often are studied for both defects combined, rather than exploring if these defects have different etiologies. We enumerated clinical features for 47 CE and 54 PC (inclusive of URSMS) cases from the National Birth Defects Prevention Study. Thirty-three CE cases were classified as isolated and 14 as multiple (presence of unassociated major defects); respective totals for PC cases were 26 and 28. We compared selected child and maternal characteristics between 11,829 non-malformed controls and CE and PC cases using chi-square or Fisher's exact tests. Compared to controls, CE and PC cases were statistically more likely (p < 0.05) to be preterm; CE cases were more likely to be multiple births. We conducted logistic regression analysis to estimate odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals for any CD, CE, and PC with selected self-reported maternal prepregnancy and periconceptional (one month prior to 3 months following conception) exposures. In crude and adjusted analyses, we observed significant positive associations for any CD, CE, and PC with use of any fertility medication or assisted reproductive technology procedure. Significant positive associations observed only in crude analyses were any CD with maternal obesity or use of progesterone, any CD and CE with any x-ray, and any CD and PC with use of folate antagonist medications. Our findings provide some of the first insights into potential differing etiologies for CE and PC.