Endoscopic removal of tracheobronchial foreign bodies: results on a series of 51 pediatric patients

Flexible versus Rigid Bronchoscopy for Tracheobronchial Foreign Body Removal in Children: A Comparative Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

The removal of foreign bodies (FBs) from the airways of children is a critical procedure that can avert serious complications. While both flexible and rigid bronchoscopy techniques are employed for this purpose, their comparative efficacy and safety remain subjects of debate. Therefore, we conducted this investigation to compare between both procedures. Studies comparing flexible to rigid bronchoscopy (n = 14) were identified by searching PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Cochrane Library, and Google Scholar. We performed comparative meta-analyses of reported presentation characteristics and clinical outcomes, using fixed- and random-effects models. A diverse range of FB types and locations were identified. No difference was observed in the success rate of FB removal between flexible and rigid bronchoscopy (logOR = 0.27; 95%CI: -1.91:2.45). The rate of negative first bronchoscopy was higher in the flexible compared to the rigid group (logOR = 2.68; 95%CI: 1.68:3.67). Conversion rates to the alternative method were higher in the flexible bronchoscopy group. The overall complication rates were similar between both methods; however, the risk of desaturation was significantly lower with flexible bronchoscopy (logOR = -2.22; 95%CI: -3.36:-1.08). Flexible bronchoscopy was associated with a shorter length of hospital stay. The choice of bronchoscopy technique should be tailored to individual case characteristics.

Clinical analysis of special types of tracheobronchial foreign bodies in children

Objectives

To explore the clinical diagnosis and treatment of special types of tracheobronchial foreign bodies in children and provide a reference for clinicians to formulate treatment plans.

Methods

Clinical data of 29 children with special types of tracheobronchial foreign bodies who were treated at The Second Affiliated Hospital and Yuying Children's Hospital of Wenzhou Medical University between June 2017 and June 2022 were collected and analyzed, and their diagnosis and treatment processes were reviewed.

Results

All 29 special types of foreign bodies were successfully removed using rigid bronchoscopy under general anesthesia, with no surgical complications.

Conclusions and significance

For the treatment of special types of tracheobronchial foreign bodies, clinicians should make detailed surgical plans and select appropriate instruments according to different conditions to improve the surgical success rate and reduce the occurrence of complications.

Flexible bronchoscopy for foreign body aspiration in children: A single-centre experience

BACKGROUND

The technological evolution of bronchoscopy has led to the widespread adoption of flexible techniques and their use for both diagnostic and therapeutic purposes. Currently, there is an active debate regarding the comparative efficacy and safety of rigid vs flexible bronchoscopy in the treatment of foreign body aspiration.

AIM

To evaluate our experience with tracheobronchial foreign body extraction using flexible bronchoscopy and provide a literature overview.

METHODS

This was a single-centre retrospective study. Twenty-four patients were enrolled between January 2017 and January 2023. Medical records of patients aged below 18 years who were admitted to authors' affiliated institution with a suspected diagnosis of foreign body aspiration were collected from hospital's database to Microsoft Excel 2019. Data were analysed using MedCalc Statistical Software.

RESULTS

Patient ages varied from 9 months to 11 years. The median age was 23.5 months, 95% confidence interval (CI) 19.49-44.77. We observed age clustering in children with foreign body aspiration at our institution with three age subgroups: (1) 0-25 months; (2) 40-60 months; and (3) 120-140 months. We expectancy of an organic tracheobronchial foreign body was significantly higher in 0-25 months subgroup than that in older ones when subgroups 40-60 and 120-140 months were combined together (odds ratio = 10.0, 95%CI: 1.44-29.26, P = 0.0197). Successful foreign body extraction was performed in all cases. Conversion to a rigid bronchoscope was not required in any of the cases. No major complications (massive bleeding, tracheobronchial tree perforation, or asphyxia) were observed.

CONCLUSION

Flexible bronchoscopy is an effective and safe method for tracheobronchial foreign body extraction in children.

Three different surgical methods of the special tracheobronchial foreign body (pen cap) in children: Case series

We present three novel cases of tracheobronchial foreign bodies (TFBs) in children caused by pen caps. One was removed by the rigid bronchoscopy successfully, the second was removed by rigid bronchoscopy combined with tracheotomy, and the last one was treated by bronchotomy from an external thoracic approach. Rigid bronchoscopy is the most widely used for treating TFBs in clinics, especially treating large and special foreign bodies, because rigid bronchoscopy can provide a good view for observation and operation. Successful removal of a foreign body under rigid bronchoscopy (an experienced doctor, suitable instruments, etc.) can obviate tracheotomy/tracheostomy or thoracotomy/bronchotomy.

Comparison of rigid bronchoscopy and flexible bronchoscopy for the management of foreign body aspiration in children

OBJECTIVE

To compare clinical outcomes of flexible and rigid bronchoscopies for the management of foreign body aspiration (FBA) in different airway locations, especially in unilateral main bronchus, in children, so as to provide some suggestions to assist clinical decisions.

METHODS

The medical records of children diagnosed with FBA in Qingdao Women and Children's Hospital Affiliated to Qingdao University from January 2020 to June 2022 were retrospectively reviewed. The following information was collected: demographics, radiological findings, endoscopic findings, foreign body locations, duration of operation, operation cost, and intraoperative and postoperative complications.

RESULTS

182 children were included in the study with the median age of 1.3 years (interquatile range, 1.0-1.8). Among whom, 124 cases (68.1 %) were male and 58 cases (31.9 %) were female. 11 cases (6.0 %) had the foreign bodies located in the trachea (larynx to carina), 3 cases (1.6 %) located in the trachea and lower bronchus, 1 case (0.5 %) located in bilateral main bronchus, 135 cases (74.2 %) located in unilateral main bronchus, 4 cases (2.2 %) located in main and lobar bronchus, and 28 cases (15.4 %) located in the lobar or segmental bronchus. Among all the included children, 84 cases (46.2 %) received rigid bronchoscopy (RB) and 98 cases (53.8 %) received flexible bronchoscopy (FB). 131 cases with the foreign bodies located in unilateral main bronchus received one type of bronchoscopy (RB or FB). They were divided into two groups according to the location of foreign body relative to the midpoint of main bronchus, the proximal bronchus group and the distal bronchus group. In the proximal bronchus group, duration of operation using RB and FB was 15 (12.5-27.5) min and 15 (14.5-30.0) min, respectively (Z = 0.000, P = 1.000). The intraoperative and postoperative complication rate using RB and FB was 15.4 % and 9.1 %, respectively (χ2 = 0.008, P = 0.927). Operation cost of FB was significantly higher than that of RB (t = -13.396, P = 0.000). In the distal bronchus group, duration of operation using RB was 20 (13.5-25.0) min, which was drastically shorter than that of FB (25 (20.0-35.0) min) (Z = -2.947, P=0.003). Operation cost of FB was still found to be significantly higher than RB (t = -20.456, P=0.000). No significant difference was found in complication rate of RB (14.3%) compared to FB (8.3%) (χ2=0.251, P=0.616).

CONCLUSIONS

When foreign bodies are lodged in unilateral main bronchus, RB could be chosen as the first-choice procedure with advantages in duration of operation and operation cost, especially for patients in China. Regardless of duration of operation and operation cost, FB is also a safe and efficient therapeutic procedure to remove inhaled foreign bodies in children, except for those located in the trachea and asphyxiating foreign bodies.

The Transition of Pediatric Tracheobronchial Foreign Body Cases in the Past 36 Years: A Retrospective Single-Center Study in Japan

Tracheobronchial foreign bodies (TFBs) are pediatric airway emergencies frequently seen. We aimed to examine the changes in the clinical characteristics of pediatric TFB patients in a single institution within the past 36 years. We retrospectively reviewed the data of 85 patients aged 0-10 years with TFBs lodged in the trachea or bronchus admitted at the Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery at Tohoku University Hospital between 1986 and 2021. We also compared the characteristics, diagnostic methods, and treatments of the previous 64 cases (1986-2005) with those of the recent 21 cases (2006-2021). The number of TFB patients decreased later in this study (3.2 vs. 1.3 patients per year). The proportion of TFB patients aged > 3 years was significantly higher in the later period (6.3% vs. 23.8%, p = 0.038). Peanut was the most common cause of TFBs in both periods, and the overall incidence of peanut aspiration significantly decreased in the later period (68.8% vs. 38.1%, p = 0.019). No patient had an undetected TFB for more than 1 month after the onset of symptoms in the later period. Foreign body extraction using rigid bronchoscopy was performed in all patients earlier, whereas flexible bronchoscopy was used in 14.3% later. Our study revealed a recent trend in the clinical characteristics of pediatric TFB patients in a single institution in Northeast Japan. The prevention and treatment of pediatric TFBs should be considered following the recent trends.

Foreign body aspiration in children - being safe and flexible

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Anesthesia for foreign body removal in children can be quite challenging. Even though rigid bronchoscopy is considered the gold standard for foreign body removal, there is increasing evidence for successful foreign body removal using flexible bronchoscopy. This review discusses the recent implications for flexible bronchoscopy for the purpose of foreign body removal and will compare these findings to rigid bronchoscopy.

RECENT FINDINGS

During the last few years, several observational studies on foreign body removal by flexible bronchoscopy have been published, with promising results.

SUMMARY

Flexible bronchoscopy is a feasible and safe method for removing aspirated foreign bodies in children. In order to improve patient safety during the procedure, it is necessary for a pediatric anesthetist and a pediatric pulmonologist to work closely together. The anesthetist can take care of the administration of the anesthetic and maintenance of the vital functions, and the pulmonologist can carry out a safe and fast bronchoscopy. In the case of foreign body removal by flexible bronchoscopy, the anesthesiological procedure of choice should be general anesthesia with controlled ventilation via a laryngeal mask.

Research on removing characteristics of tracheal foreign bodies based on the baskets

BACKGROUND

Foreign body aspiration is a prevalent respiratory disease in life. There is a lack of relevant research on removing foreign bodies. The process that foreign bodies are removing with baskets is very complicated and the relevant theoretical research is immature.

METHODS

The characteristics of the basket to remove foreign bodies in the trachea were analyzed. According to the geometric and force relationship between the basket, the foreign body and the trachea, the geometric relationship model and mechanical model are established, and validated by finite element analysis and experiments.

FINDINGS

The simulation results and experimental results show that the simulation curves of the contact force between the baskets and the foreign bodies, and the simulation curves of the contact force between the basket and the trachea are the same as the theoretical curve. Therefore, the geometric relationship model and mechanical model have reference values.

INTERPRETATION

These results can not only improve the quality of the operation, and shorten the operation time, but also provide a theoretical basis for automatic removal of foreign bodies.

Complication rates in rigid vs. flexible endoscopic foreign body removal in children

While foreign body aspiration remains a frequent and preventable cause of morbidity and mortality in children, recommendations on the appropriate removal technique do often not match the lived practice and expertise of the performing examiners. As there is a scarcity of data regarding success and complication rates of the procedure, the aim of this study was to set up a classification system for procedure-related complications, prospectively record and analyze them. Specialists in the field of foreign body removal contributed cases anonymously. Information regarding procedural details of the bronchoscopy, type, and severity of complications as well as patient characteristics were classified and recorded. Correlations were calculated using Pearson's Chi Square test. A total of 314 rigid and 178 flexible bronchoscopies were compared. Complications were categorized and their severity was defined by the anesthesiologist's assessment of whether to interrupt or terminate the procedure. The overall complication rate was similar in rigid vs. flexible bronchoscopy (19.1% vs. 24.2%, p = 0.232), while respiratory complications occurred significantly less frequent during rigid bronchoscopy (9.2% vs. 16.3%, p = 0.025). This is the largest pediatric case collection recording and comparing complications between rigid and flexible foreign body removal. The higher rate of respiratory complications in flexible bronchoscopy has been shown for the first time and validates some of the concerns about its use for foreign body removal. Flexible bronchoscopy is a safe procedure when extended respiratory monitoring and the possibility of an immediate switch to a secured airway are assured.

Title-Optical Forceps: The Real Boon for Surgeon, Residents and Patients with Foreign Body Aspiration

Management of aspirated foreign bodies in children becomes very challenging in absence of most appropriate instruments. Rigid bronchoscopy has evolved in the long course of history. The advent of Hopkins rod telescope and optical forceps has enhanced the efficacy as well as the safety of removing tracheobronchial foreign bodies. Total 36 children of age less than 16 year with confirmed diagnosis of airway F.B. were included in the study. Two types of forceps were used: (1)Optical forceps combined with Hopkins rod lens telescope[n = 25] (2)Standard forceps [n = 11]. Most common age group was 1-5 year [n = 26] with male preponderance [n = 20]. Most common site was right bronchus in 13 cases (RMB-11, RBI-1, RLLB-1) followed by Left main bronchus in 11 cases, trachea in 10 cases, bilateral bronchus and sub-glottis each in 1 case. Vegetative F.B. were found in majority of cases [n = 26]. Mean grasping attempt, Mean bronchoscopic insertion and Mean time taken from insertion of forceps to removal of F.B. were less in optical forceps as compared to standard forceps with significant p-value. Optical forceps have advantage of high resolution & magnified view of airway, spring action in handle and better tactile sensation. These helps in correctly identifying the type, size and site of tracheobronchial foreign body. Precise grasping attempts with optical forceps reduces the chances of complications. Optical forceps have given the new dimension to the Rigid Bronchoscopy and proved to be the real boon for surgeons, residents and patients with F.B. aspiration.

Foreign body aspirations in dental clinics: a narrative review

Foreign body aspiration can produce a medical emergency. Obstruction of the airways can be life-threatening, and complications may develop in less-severe cases if it is left untreated. Although it is more prevalent in children by approximately three times, adults can still experience it, and it is more frequently related to healthcare in adults. Objects used in dental treatment are usually placed in the oral cavity and can be ingested or inhaled by accident. Dental treatment has been identified as an important cause of the misplacement of foreign bodies in the airway. However, few reports have been published on dentistry-related foreign body aspiration. This paper discusses the disease course, management, and clinical outcomes of foreign body aspiration, especially those associated with dentistry. The patient must be examined for respiratory distress. If the patient is unstable, urgent airway management and the maneuvers for removal should be performed. Radiographs and computed tomography can help identify and locate the object. The treatment of choice is often bronchoscopy, and both flexible and rigid endoscopes can be used depending on the situation. Preventive measures need to be implemented to avoid inhalation accidents given the potential consequences. Though the incidence is rare, healthcare levels need to be enhanced to avert morbidity and mortality. Radiological evaluation and bronchoscopy are vital for management.

Clinical presentation, diagnosis and management of aerodigestive tract foreign bodies in the paediatric population: Part 2

Children, especially toddlers, because of their behaviour, physiology and anatomical characteristics such as oral exploration of their surroundings, have a tendency to place objects in their mouth. Therefore, ingestion or aspiration of foreign bodies (FBs) in children is a potentially life-threatening and common problem seen across the world. In this second part of our pictorial review on ingested and aspirated FBs, we focus on the paediatric population, reviewing the current literature and examining the epidemiology, clinical presentation, anatomic considerations, appropriate imaging modalities, key imaging characteristics associated with clinically relevant FBs in the emergency department (ED) and current management protocols.