The influence of delay in closure of the abdominal wall on outcome in gastroschisis

Management of Gastroschisis: Timing of Delivery, Antibiotic Usage, and Closure Considerations (A Systematic Review From the American Pediatric Surgical Association Outcomes & Evidence Based Practice Committee)

BACKGROUND

No consensus exists for the initial management of infants with gastroschisis.

METHODS

The American Pediatric Surgical Association (APSA) Outcomes and Evidenced-based Practice Committee (OEBPC) developed three a priori questions about gastroschisis for a qualitative systematic review. We reviewed English-language publications between January 1, 1970, and December 31, 2019. This project describes the findings of a systematic review of the three questions regarding: 1) optimal delivery timing, 2) antibiotic use, and 3) closure considerations.

RESULTS

1339 articles were screened for eligibility; 92 manuscripts were selected and reviewed. The included studies had a Level of Evidence that ranged from 2 to 4 and recommendation Grades B-D. Twenty-eight addressed optimal timing of delivery, 5 pertained to antibiotic use, and 59 discussed closure considerations (Figure 1). Delivery after 37 weeks post-conceptual age is considered optimal. Prophylactic antibiotics covering skin flora are adequate to reduce infection risk until definitive closure. Studies support primary fascial repair, without staged silo reduction, when abdominal domain and hemodynamics permit. A sutureless repair is safe, effective, and does not delay feeding or extend length of stay. Sedation and intubation are not routinely required for a sutureless closure.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the large number of studies addressing the above-mentioned facets of gastroschisis management, the data quality is poor. A wide variation in gastroschisis management was documented, indicating a need for high quality RCTs to provide an evidence-based approach when caring for these infants.

TYPE OF STUDY

Qualitative systematic review of Level 1-4 studies.

Functional outcome at school age of children born with gastroschisis

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to determine motor, cognitive and behavioural outcomes of school aged children born with gastroschisis compared to matched controls.

STUDY DESIGN

We compared outcomes of 16 children born with gastroschisis treated at the University Medical Center Groningen, the Netherlands, between 1999 and 2006 with 32 controls matched for gender, gestational age, birth weight, and corrected for small for gestational age (SGA) and parental socioeconomic status (SES). Intelligence, auditory-verbal memory, attention, response inhibition, visual perception, motor skills, visuomotor integration, problem behaviour and executive functioning were evaluated.

RESULTS

Median verbal intelligence quotient and global executive functioning scores of children born with gastroschisis were poorer than of controls (95 (inter quartile range (IQR) 88-100) vs. 104 (IQR 98-113), P=0.001, and 29 (IQR 6.8-63.8) vs. 5.0 (IQR 2.8-19.8), P=0.03, respectively). Children with gastroschisis were more often classified as borderline or abnormal than controls regarding response inhibition (odds ratio (OR) 20.4; 95%-confidence interval (95%-CI); 2.4-171.5), selective visual attention (OR 40.4; 95%-CI 5.9-275.4), sustained auditory attention (OR 88.1; 95%-CI 5.8-1342.8), and fine motor skills (50% vs. 0%). Grade retention was more prevalent in gastroschisis children (OR 6.07; 95%-CI 1.42-25.9). These associations persisted after adjustment for SGA and SES. The auditory-verbal memory, visuomotor integration and behavioural problems did not significantly differ from the controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Gastroschisis is associated with poorer verbal intelligence, and with an increased risk for poor performance on several aspects of attention, response inhibition and fine motor skills at school age. The follow-up of children born with gastroschisis deserves attention regarding these specific domains, to improve their functional outcomes.

Timing of elective delivery in gastroschisis: a decision and cost-effectiveness analysis

OBJECTIVE

To determine the most cost-effective timing of delivery in pregnancies complicated by gastroschisis, using a decision-analytic model.

METHODS

We created a decision-analytic model to compare planned delivery at 35, 36, 37, 38 and 39 weeks' gestation. Outcomes considered were stillbirth, death within 1 year of birth and respiratory distress syndrome (RDS). Probability estimates of events (stillbirth, complex gastroschisis and RDS for each gestational age at delivery and risk of death with simple and complex gastroschisis), utilities and costs assigned to the outcomes were obtained from the published literature. Cost analysis was assessed from a societal perspective, using a willingness-to-pay threshold of $100,000 per surviving infant. Outcomes and costs were considered throughout 1 year of postnatal life. Multiway sensitivity analysis was performed to address uncertainties in baseline assumptions.

RESULTS

In the base-case analysis, delivery at 38 weeks' gestation was the most cost-effective strategy. Planned delivery at 35 weeks was associated with the fewest stillbirths and deaths within 1 year of delivery, owing largely to a lower ongoing risk of stillbirth. In Monte Carlo simulation when every variable was varied over its entire range, delivery at 38 weeks was cost-effective compared to delivery at 39 weeks in 76% of trials and delivery at 37 weeks was cost-effective in 69% of trials. Delivery at 38 weeks resulted in three additional cases of RDS for every 100 stillbirths or deaths within 1 year that were prevented.

CONCLUSIONS

For pregnancies complicated by gastroschisis, the most cost-effective timing of delivery is at 38 weeks. Few additional cases of RDS are caused for every one stillbirth or death within 1 year that was prevented with delivery at 37-38 weeks compared with at 39 weeks.

Delayed exstrophy repair (DER) does not compromise initial bladder development

OBJECTIVE

Delayed exstrophy repair (DER) represents an alternative to early neonatal bladder closure. This study aims to define the consequence of DER on bladder growth in bladder exstrophy patients who underwent routine DER, compared with those who underwent immediate postnatal reconstruction.

METHODS

Between 2000 and 2005, classic bladder exstrophy patients referred to the authors' institution underwent early neonatal bladder closure (group 1). Subsequently, classic bladder exstrophy patients referred to the authors' institution were treated with an elective DER (group 2). Bladder capacity was assessed between the age of 1 and 4 years with an unconscious cystogram. When dilating VUR was present, the volume of the contrast migrated into the ureter was calculated and subtracted.

RESULTS

Sixty patients were treated between 2000 and 2012. Complete follow-up data were available for 45 patients and they were included in the study: 21 in group 1 (11 males) and 24 in group 2 (14 males). The mean (SD) bladder volumes were 72.85 (28.5) ml in group 1 and 72.87 (34.9) in group 2 (p = 0.99).

CONCLUSION

In the authors' experience, DER does not reduce the subsequent bladder capacities compared with neonatal exstrophy closure.

Monitoring intravesical pressure during gastroschisis closure. Does it help to decide between delayed primary or staged closure?

INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVE

Correction of gastroschisis may be accomplished by either primary or staged closure or even delayed primary closure after the use of a preformed silo. However, there is neither a consensus on the best approach nor established criteria to favor one method over the other. The aim of this paper was to investigate the role of intravesical pressure (IVP) as a tool to prevent abdominal compartment syndrome in newborns undergoing correction of abdominal wall defects.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed 45 newborns with gastroschisis in whom trans-operative intravesical pressure was used to choose between primary or staged closure. A threshold of 20 cm H(2)O was used and the outcomes between the two methods were compared.

RESULTS

In 24 children delayed primary closure was achieved while the remaining 21 underwent staged reduction and closure. There was no difference in the frequency of complications, time to begin oral feeding, length of parenteral nutrition or length of hospital stay between the children of the two groups. The incidence of temporary oliguria or anuria, averaged 33% and it was similar in both groups of children.

CONCLUSION

The data here presented suggests that monitoring intraoperative IVP during correction of gastroschisis may help to select children in whom staged closure is necessary, keeping their complication rate and overall outcome similar to that of children undergoing delayed primary closure. Further prospective studies should investigate more deeply the correlation between type of closure and the development of a compartment syndrome.

Infectious complications in the management of gastroschisis

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Neonates with gastroschisis make up an increasing proportion of prolonged surgical NICU admissions. While infectious complications are known to increase patient morbidity, it is unclear whether they vary according to abdominal closure method, or can be predicted by initial patient assessment.

METHODS

A national, prospective, disease-specific database was evaluated for episodes of wound infection (WI) and catheter-related infection (CRI). Antibiotic use and timing, as well as method and location of abdominal closure were studied. The gastroschisis prognostic score (GPS) was calculated and evaluated as a predictor of infectious complications.

RESULTS

Of 395 patients, 48 (12.6%) had a documented abdominal WI, and 59 patients (14.9%) had at least one episode of CRI-most commonly coagulase negative staphylococcus. Most abdominal closures took place within 6 h of admission (194 = 51.3%), while 132 (34.9%) were delayed greater than 24 h. The WI rate was greater in the delayed group (21.2 vs. 8.2%, p = 0.0006). The GPS was found to predict development of an infectious complication (WI + CRI, p = 0.04).

CONCLUSION

Infectious complications remain an important consideration in the management of gastroschisis. GPS correlates with the development of infectious complications. Prophylaxis for skin flora and early closure, when feasible, may reduce WI rates.

Perinatal predictors of outcome in gastroschisis

OBJECTIVE

To identify perinatal risk variables predictive of outcome in gastroschisis.

STUDY DESIGN

Gastroschisis cases were collected over a 3-year period from a national database. Risk variables evaluated included gestational age (GA), birth weight, time of birth, admission illness severity (score for neonatal acute physiology-II, SNAP-II) score, and abdominal closure type. Mortality and survival outcomes were analyzed. Multivariate analyses were performed.

RESULT

In all, 239 infants were survived (96%). SNAP-II score predicted mortality (relative risk (RR)=1.07, 95% confidence interval (CI)=1.0 to 1.1). Length of hospital stay (LOS) and ventilation days were predicted by GA and by SNAP-II score. SNAP-II score predicted total parenteral nutrition (TPN) days (P=0.006). Severe cholestasis (conjugated bilirubin of >10 mg per 100 ml) was inversely related to GA (RR=0.77, 95% CI=0.61 to 0.97) and directly to categorical SNAP-II score (RR=3.4, 95% CI=1.2 to 10.1). Urgent closure predicted fewer TPN days (P=0.003) and shorter LOS (P=0.0002).

CONCLUSION

SNAP-II scores significantly predict mortality and survival outcomes. Urgent closure favors fewer TPN days and shorter LOS. Our data refute routine preterm delivery in gastroschisis.

Risk stratification in gastroschisis: can prenatal evaluation or early postnatal factors predict outcome?

PURPOSE

The prenatal or postnatal factors that predict complex gastroschisis in patients (atresia, volvulus, necrotic bowel and bowel perforation) remain controversial. We evaluated the prognostic value of prenatal ultrasonographic parameters and early postnatal factors in predicting clinical outcomes.

METHODS

We analyzed maternal and neonatal records of 46 gastroschisis patients treated from 1998 to 2007. Information regarding demographics, prenatal ultrasound data when available, intrapartum and postnatal course was abstracted from medical records. Outcome variables included survival, ventilator days, TPN days, time to full enteral feeds, complications and length of stay. Univariate or multivariate analysis was used, with P < 0.05 considered as significant.

RESULT

A total of 75% of complex patients were categorized within 1 week of life. Interestingly, prenatal bowel dilation (>17 mm) and thickness (>3 mm) did not correlate with outcome or risk stratification into simple versus complex (P < 0.05). Complex patients had increased morbidity compared to simple patients (sepsis 58 versus 18%; P = 0.021, NEC 42 versus 9%; P = 0.020, short bowel syndrome 58 versus 3%; P = 0.0001, ventilator days 24 versus 10; P = 0.021; TPN days 178 versus 38; P = 0.0001 and days to full feeds 171 versus 31; P = 0.0001; and length of stay 90 versus 39 days, P = 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Prenatal bowel wall dilation and/or thickness did not predict complex patients or adverse outcome. Complex gastroschisis patients can be identified postnatally and have substantial morbidity.

Contemporary postnatal surgical management strategies for congenital abdominal wall defects

Early definitive closure of abdominal wall defects is possible in most cases. Staged reduction does offer distinct advantages, and mortality and morbidity may be better. Risk stratification may produce outcome and tailor management of difficult cases in the form of a clinical pathway. Stem cell technology may, in the future, offer the ideal allogenic prosthesis in complex cases.

Anesthetic management of gastrochisis--a review of our practice over the past 5 years

BACKGROUND

Surgical closure of gastrochisis has traditionally been performed under general anesthesia followed by admission to intensive care and postoperative ventilation. We reviewed the management of these neonates in our hospital over the past 5 years to identify changes in practice and possible factors which affect the perioperative course.

METHODS

We retrospectively identified cases of gastrochisis undergoing repair from June 2002 to May 2007. Details of the demographic data, preoperative factors, intraoperative anesthetic and surgical management and postoperative care were collected from the anesthetic chart, operative record and patient notes.

RESULTS

Forty-eight self-ventilating neonates underwent operative repair in theatre. A neuraxial local anesthetic block was performed as part of the anesthetic technique in 22 patients. There was a significant difference in the need for postoperative ventilation in this group (23%) when compared with a traditional opioid-based method of providing analgesia (88%, P < 0.05). This difference was seen in both term and preterm babies.

CONCLUSION

Conclusions are difficult when analyzing retrospective data in patients with a variety of factors. The results suggest that anesthesia which includes a regional technique is a valid method in these cases. Traditional opioid analgesia when compared to regional techniques may be associated with increased need for postoperative ventilation.

The female condom as a temporary silo: a simple and inexpensive tool in the initial management of the newborn with gastroschisis

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study is to report the use of a female condom as a non-surgical silon pouch in the early management of newborns with gastroschisis with large visceroabdominal disproportion.

METHODS

Pre-washed, sterile female condoms without spermicide were used as an early approach to treat gastroschisis in 20 newborns with large defects and in whom staged correction was anticipated. The condom was placed in the neonatal intensive care unit using sterile technique, with no anesthesia, and it was removed only at the time of the surgical procedure for gastroschisis correction.

RESULTS

There were no complications associated with the use of a female condom as a temporary silo for gastroschisis. It protected the exposed organs and also allowed a careful evaluation of the bowel and a better pre-operative planning without the need for emergency procedures.

CONCLUSION

The use of a female condom as a silon pouch is a low-cost and simple alternative in the initial management of newborns with gastroschisis in whom primary correction is considered non-feasible.

Scheduled preterm delivery for gastroschisis improves postoperative outcome

There are some evidence to suggest that careful antenatal monitoring, scheduled preterm delivery and immediate abdominal wall closure may reduce gastroschisis morbidity. We hypothesised that the advantages of a scheduled preterm delivery balance possible complications related to prematurity. A retrospective study was performed including all cases of gastroschisis born between 1990 and 2004 (n = 69). Cases were categorised in two groups. Group 1 contained gastroschisis cases born between 1990 and 1997. Group 2 contained cases occurring since 1997, when a new management pathway for gastroschisis was established: weekly evaluation of the foetal gut by ultrasound (>28 weeks), corticosteroids, and delivery by scheduled caesarean section at 35 weeks (before if evidence of bowel compromise was present). The primary endpoints of this study were the initiation of oral feeding and the number of re-operation for intestinal obstruction. There was a significantly faster initiation of oral feeding (P < 0.0001), however, duration of parenteral nutrition (34 vs. 38 days) and hospital discharge (53 vs. 58.5 days) was not reduced. There was no complication due to prematurity in group 2. Postoperative outcome was improved with less need for muscular stretching or prosthetic patch and less re-operation for intestinal obstruction (P < 0.05). Scheduled and elective preterm delivery facilitates surgical procedure and shortens the time to first feeding. A delivery at 35 weeks (preferring vaginal delivery) seems to be a good compromise between risks related to prematurity and complications related to intestinal peel.

Anaesthetic management of gastroschisis - a review of our practice over the past 5 years

BACKGROUND

Surgical closure of gastrochisis has traditionally been performed under general anesthesia followed by admission to intensive care and postoperative ventilation. We reviewed the management of these neonates in our hospital over the past 5 years to identify the changes in practice and possible factors which affect the peri-operative course.

METHODS

We retrospectively identified cases of gastrochisis undergoing repair from June 2002 to May 2007. Details of the demographic data, preoperative factors, intra-operative anesthetic and surgical management, and postoperative care were collected from the anesthetic chart, operative record, and patient notes.

RESULTS

Forty-eight self-ventilating neonates underwent operative repair in theatre. A neuraxial local anesthetic block was performed as part of the anesthetic technique in 22 patients. There was a significant difference in the need for postoperative ventilation in this group (23%) when compared with a traditional opioid-based method of providing analgesia (88%, P < 0.05). This difference was seen in both term and preterm babies.

CONCLUSION

Conclusions are difficult to make when analyzing retrospective data in patients with a heterogeneous variety of factors. The results suggest that anesthesia which includes a regional technique is a valid method in these cases. Traditional opioid analgesia when compared with regional techniques may be associated with increased need for postoperative ventilation.

Canadian Pediatric Surgical Network: a population-based pediatric surgery network and database for analyzing surgical birth defects. The first 100 cases of gastroschisis

PURPOSE

Outcomes studies for gastroschisis are constrained by small numbers, prolonged accrual, and nonstandardized data collection. The aim of this study is to create a national pediatric surgical network and database for gastroschisis (GS) that tracks cases from diagnosis to hospital discharge.

METHODS

The 16-center network serves a population of 32 million. Gastroschisis cases are ascertained at prenatal diagnosis. Perinatal data include maternal risk and fetal ultrasound variables, delivery plan and outcome, a postnatal bowel injury score, intended and actual surgical treatment, and neonatal outcomes. Institutional review board-approved data collection conforms to regional privacy legislation. Deidentified data are centralized and accessible for research through the network steering committee.

RESULTS

To date, 114 cases of pre- and/or postnatal gastroschisis have been uploaded. Of 106 live-born infants (40 [38%] by cesarean delivery), 100 had complete records, and overall survival to discharge was 96%, with a mean survivor length of stay (LOS) of 46 days. Infants treated with attempted urgent closure (61%) had significantly shorter LOS (42 vs 57 days; P = .048) but comparable LOS compared with those treated with silos and delayed closure. Fetal bowel dilation 18 mm or greater did not predict a difference in outcome.

CONCLUSION

Population-based databases allow rapid case accrual and enable studies that should aid in the identification of optimal perinatal treatment.

Benefit of preformed silos in the management of gastroschisis

Gastroschisis is traditionally managed by primary closure (PC) or delayed closure after surgical silo placement. Bedside insertion of preformed silos (PFS) and delayed closure has become more widespread, although its benefits remain unclear. To identify differences in outcome of infants managed with PFS compared with traditional closure (TC) techniques. Single-centre retrospective review of 53 consecutive neonates admitted between February 2000 and January 2006. Data expressed as median (range). Non-parametric statistical analysis used with P < 0.05 regarded as significant. Forty infants underwent TC and 13 had PFS and delayed closure. Median ventilation time in both groups was 4 days (P = 0.19) however this was achieved with higher mean airway pressures (MAPs) (day 0, 10 (5-16) versus 8 (5-10) cmH(2)O; P = 0.02) and inspired oxygen (40 (21-100) versus 30 (21-60)%; P = 0.03) in TC group. Urine output on day-1 of life was significantly higher in PFS group (1.1 (0.16-3.07) versus 0.45 (0-2.8) ml/kg/h; P = 0.02). Inotrope support was required in 17/40 (43%) of TC versus 0/13 (0%) in PFS (P < 0.01). After exclusion of infants with short bowel syndrome and/or intestinal atresia (n = 9), there was a shorter time to full enteral feeds in the TC group (22 (12-36) versus 27 (17-45); P = 0.07), although there was no difference in the period of parenteral nutrition (PN) (P = 0.1) or overall hospital stay (P = 0.34). No deaths or episodes of necrotizing enterocolitis occurred. The use of PFS for gastroschisis closure is associated with a reduction in pulmonary barotrauma, better tissue perfusion and improved early renal function, consistent with a reduction in abdominal compartment syndrome.

Perinatal management of gastroschisis: analysis of a newly established clinical pathway

PURPOSE

The authors developed a clinical pathway for optimal management after antenatal diagnosis of gastroschisis. This is the outcomes analysis of our first 30 consecutive patients.

METHOD

Antenatal counseling was provided for all families with in-utero diagnosis of gastroschisis. Bowel dilatation, thickness, motility, amniotic fluid volume, and fetal development were followed by ultrasonography every 4 weeks. Babies were delivered by cesarean section between 36 and 38 weeks gestation if the lungs were mature or earlier for bowel complications. Gastroschisis repair was scheduled 90 minutes after birth. Primary repair was attempted in all through the abdominal wall defect without an additional incision, resulting in an umbilicus with no abdominal scar.

RESULTS

Primary repair was achieved in 83%. Babies needed assisted ventilation for 3 days, reached full feeds by 19 days, and were discharged by 24 days (all medians). There were 3 (10%) deaths, all after staged repair.

CONCLUSIONS

Our new protocol of both scheduled elective cesarean section and early gastroschisis repair resulted in a higher proportion of primary repair, shorter duration of mechanical ventilation, earlier full feeds, and shorter length of stay. There was no increase in mortality or morbidity. The primary-repair babies had no mortality and had excellent cosmesis.

Congenital Abdominal Wall Defects: An Update

OBJECTIVE

To review published peer-reviewed literature regarding abdominal wall defects including gastroschisis and omphalocele.

METHODS

Review of published peer-reviewed literature using Med Line 1985-2003 and textbooks.

RESULTS

Gastroschisis and omphalocele literature is reviewed using pathology, incidence and epidemiology, prenatal evaluation, pregnancy and delivery management, postnatal outcome and fetal therapy.

CONCLUSION

Gastroschisis and omphalocele are common abdominal wall defects and have significant morbidity and mortality.

Gastroschisis: etiology, diagnosis, delivery options, and care

Gastroschisis, one of the more common congenital abdominal wall defects, results in herniation of fetal abdominal viscera into the amniotic cavity. This article discusses theories about gastroschisis etiology, in utero diagnostic tools, delivery options, and postdelivery care. Included are detailed considerations regarding immediate interventions after delivery to support the infant's thermal and fluid management needs and to protect the exposed bowel. Surgical options and postoperative care issues and complications are reviewed, as are respiratory distress and vena cava compression from increased abdominal pressure, nutritional support, and interventions related to the prevention of infection. Giving birth to an infant with gastroschisis is an upsetting experience for parents. Evidence suggests, however, that with today's advances in neonatal care and nutrition and with meticulous attention, the survival rate for infants born with gastroschisis can be excellent.

Abdominal wall defects

Survival for newborns with congenital abdominal wall defects (primarily omphalocele and gastroschisis) has improved, but controversy remains regarding etiology, anatomy and embryology, the role of prenatal diagnosis and mode of delivery, and initial management. A number of recent studies have added to our knowledge and understanding of several of these topics, while several others have raised questions regarding traditional initial management of these infants. Continued improvement in the survival of these infants can be anticipated with further understanding of the in utero and antepartum diagnosis and management of infants with these common congenital abnormalities.