Comparison of refractive outcomes in three corneal transplantation techniques for keratoconus

Postoperative Astigmatism after Keratoplasty: A Systematic Review Meta-Analysis Based on PRISMA

Background: The number of corneal transplants is rising, with the aim to treat a spectrum of diseases ranging from dystrophies to corneal opacities caused by trauma or chemical burns. Refractive outcomes after this procedure are often impossible to predict and associated with high levels of astigmatism. However, there are many techniques that affect the reduction of astigmatism and improve the quality of life of patients. Objectives: The aim was to compare the improvement in postoperative visual acuity (logMAR) and amount of corneal astigmatism (Diopters) after corneal keratoplasty in patients who additionally underwent a surgical procedure, which affects the reduction in postoperative astigmatism, and to determine the most effective method. Search Methods and Selection Criteria: A thorough search was carried out across online electronic databases including PubMed, Embrase, Ovid MEDLINE, Scopus, and Web of Science, using combinations containing the following phrases: postoperative astigmatism, post-keratoplasty astigmatism, anterior lamellar keratoplasty (ALK), deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK), posterior lamellar keratoplasty, endothelial keratoplasty (EK), penetrating keratoplasty (PK), corneal transplant, keratoplasty, refractive surgery, kerato-refractive surgery, laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK), and femtosecond LASIK. This was to determine all English-language publications that discuss refractive operations for postoperative or post-keratoplasty astigmatism. These bibliographies were searched for English-language publications published between 2010 and 2023. We proceeded to review each detected record's reference list. Data Extraction: Study characteristics such as study design, sample size, participant information, operations performed, and clinical outcomes were all extracted. Data Statistical Analyses: The Comprehensive Meta-Analysis software (version 3.3.070, 2014) was used to perform the analysis. The threshold of 0.05 for p-values was considered statistically significant. All effect sizes are reported as standardized differences (Std diff) in means with a 95% confidence interval (CI) and visualized graphically as forest plots. Publication bias is presented as a funnel plot of standard error by Std diff in means. Four methods were used to evaluate the heterogeneity among the studies: Q-value, I2, chi-square (χ2), and tau-squared. Main Results: We included 21 studies that randomized 1539 eyes that underwent corneal transplantation surgery either by PKP, DALK, or DSEAK techniques. The results showed the most significant improvement in the visual acuity and significant decrease in the corneal astigmatism after laser surgery procedures, like femtosecond-assisted keratotomy after DALK and PKP and LASIK after DSEAK.

Long-term outcomes of deep anterior lamellar versus penetrating keratoplasty for keratoconus

AIMS

To compare the long-term outcomes of deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK) with penetrating keratoplasty (PK) in keratoconus.

METHODS

Retrospective comparative case series (228 DALKs and 274 PKs). A biphasic linear model was used to describe the postoperative outcome of the endothelial cell density (ECD). Visual acuity, specular microscopy, corneal topography and optical coherence tomography findings were recorded.

RESULTS

Graft survival of the 502 keratoconus eyes was 96.7 at 10 years and 95.6% at 20 years. Visual acuity improved from 20/378±5.1 lines preoperatively to 20/32±2.1 lines at 30 months. The corneal ECD decreased from 2494±382 cells/mm2 to 1521±659 cells/mm2 at 10 years. The mean simulated keratometry increased from 44.88±2.54 D at 1 year to 46.60±3.0 D at 3 years. The mean follow-up was 103.4 months for DALKs and 106.1 months for PKs. The cumulated incidence of postoperative ocular hypertension requiring treatment was significantly higher in PKs than in DALKs. The early- and late-phase rates of ECD loss were significantly lower in DALKs than in PKs. These figures in DALKs were 50% of those observed in PKs. The simulated mean keratometry was significantly higher in DALKs than in PKs in the mid but not in the long term. No significant differences in visual acuity were observed between both groups. Manual dissection-DALK featured slower visual recovery than PK and big bubble-DALK, whereas big bubble-DALK and PK featured similar visual recovery.

CONCLUSIONS

DALK featuring higher endothelial survival and lower risk of postoperative ocular hypertension may be superior to PK when indicated for keratoconus.

Penetrating Keratoplasty versus Deep Anterior Lamellar Keratoplasty for Keratoconus: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Keratoconus is the most common form of primary corneal thinning. Different methods have been suggested to deal with the condition, including glasses, contact lenses, and surgical interventions, like penetrating keratoplasty (PKP) and deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK), well-known methods of the latter. This study was conducted to compare the outcomes and side effects of the two mentioned keratoplasty techniques. First, we systematically reviewed all original articles studies on PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and Embase. Then, the extracted data were pooled and meta-analyzed on each of the intended outcomes. A total of 30 studies were included in which PKP was more commonly performed compared to DALK. We found that adverse outcomes consisting of cataracts, graft rejection, graft failure, High-IOP, and corneal infection, were all more common findings in the PKP groups compared to the DALK groups. However, only for the high-IOP, cataracts, and graft rejection, the analysis of the extracted results demonstrated statistical significance. Overall, the DALK groups demonstrated significantly better results when considering the improvement levels by measuring the Endothelial Cell Count (ECC) and Spherical Equivalent (SE). In addition, though statistically insignificant, the Central Corneal Thickness(CCT), Best Corrected Visual Acuity(BCVA), Topographic Cylinder(TC), Refractive Cylinder values were greater in the PKP groups. Based on our study and with its limitations in mind, we can conclude that DALK can be a relatively safer and more effective procedure. Though, a larger number of high-standard randomized clinical trials still need to be conveyed for more definite conclusions.

Comparison of deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty and corneal cross-linking in patients with advanced keratoconus

PURPOSE

To compare outcomes of deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK) and corneal cross-linking (CXL) in patients with advanced keratoconus, with the primary aim of assessing CXL as a potential therapeutic alternative.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective, multi-center, comparative study.

METHODS

Patients with advanced keratoconus (maximum keratometry reading (K-max) > 58D, best spectacle-corrected visual acuity worse than 0.52logMAR), undergoing either DALK or CXL treatment at four tertiary ophthalmic centers in Wenzhou, Hangzhou, Nanjing and Wuhan were included. Visual acuity, refractive error, corneal topography and complications were evaluated at baseline and at least 2 year postoperatively.

RESULTS

75 eyes of 72 patients were included, of which 37 eyes underwent DALK and 38 eyes, CXL. A larger reduction in Kmax was observed in the DALK group (-18.18 ± 9.44 D versus -1.10 ± 2.70D, p < 0.001). Seven eyes (18%) in the CXL group showed progression of keratoconus. No disease progression was observed in the DALK group. Greater improvements in best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (logMAR) were observed in the DALK group (-0.59 ± 0.25 versus -0.24 ± 0.44, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to CXL, DALK leads to larger reductions in Kmax and better improvement in visual acuity in advanced keratoconus.

Malapposition of graft-host interface after penetrating keratoplasty (PK) and deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK): an optical coherence tomography study

Backgroud

Previous studies of internal graft-host malappositions have not dealt with the precise ways in which each malapposition affected post-penetrating keratoplasty (post-PK) visual outcomes. In this study, we reviewed our post-PK and post-deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (post-DALK) keratoconic patients and used anterior segment optical coherence tomography (AS-OCT) to evaluate the associations between graft-host interface (GHI) characteristics and visual outcomes.

Methods

Novel GHI metrics included: mean graft-host touch (GHT), total prevalence of malapposition proportion (Pm), frequency of apposition (F), size of malapposition (Sm), junctional graft thickness (Tg), junctional host thickness (Th) and the absolute value of difference between Tg and Th (|Tg-Th|). We connected the external and internal junction points of GHI (GHT) and drew a straight line through the central point, perpendicular to both sides of the cornea. Tg and Th were the thicknesses at cross-points 1 mm away from the meeting point on the external side of the graft and host, respectively. Linear regression analysis was used to describe associations between GHI metrics and postsurgical visual outcomes [logarithm of minimum angle of resolution best-corrected visual acuity (logMAR BCVA), spherical equivalent diopter (SE), diopter of spherical power (DS), diopter of cylindrical power (DC) and keratometric astigmatism (Astig value)].

Results

We enrolled 22 post-PK and 23 post-DALK keratoconic patients. Compared with the regular-apposition results, GHT was decreased in step and gape patterns, and increased in hill and tag patterns. SE increased averagely by 6.851, 5.428 and 5.164 diopter per 1% increase in: F (step) [β = 6.851; 95% Confidence interval (CI) = 2.975–10.727; P = 0.001]; F (graft step) [β = 5.428; 95% CI = 1.685–9.171; P = 0.005]; and Pm [β = 5.164; 95%CI = 0.913–9.146; P = 0.018], respectively. SE increased averagely by 0.31 diopter per 10-μm increment in |Tg-Th| [β = 0.031; 95% CI = 0.009–0.054; P = 0.007]. LogMAR BCVA increased (on average) by 0.01 per 10-μm increment in both GHT [β = 0.001; 95% CI = 0–0.002; P = 0.030]. and Tg [β = 0.001; 95% CI = 0.001–0.002; P = 0.001]. Astig value increased on average by 0.17 diopter per 10-μm increment in Sm [β = 0.017; 95% CI = 0–0.033; P = 0.047].

Conclusion

This investigation of GHI characteristics suggests explanations for varied ametropia in keratoconic eyes and has potential significance as a reference for promoting pre-surgical planning and technology for corneal transplantation.

Stepwise Decreasing of Vitreous Pressure by Anterior Vitrectomy: A Novel Method for Preventing Positive Vitreous Pressure During Penetrating Keratoplasty

BACKGROUND

This study evaluates the clinical effects of the stepwise anterior vitrectomy on the prevention of positive vitreous pressure (PVP) during penetrating keratoplasty (PKP).

METHODS

PKP in conjunction with stepwise anterior vitrectomy was performed on 15 eyes of 15 patients under retrobulbar anesthesia. A preset vitrectomy trocar-cannula was inserted into the vitreous cavity before PKP. During the opening of the anterior chamber, intermittent vitrectomy and corneal incision expansion were performed alternately to keep the lens or artificial intraocular lens (IOL) and iris flat until the entirety of the pathological cornea had been dissected. The main outcome measures include visual acuity, crystalline lens rise (CLR), corneal curvature and diopter, and corneal endothelial cell loss.

RESULTS

All surgical procedures were performed successfully without any PVP-related intraoperative complications. The mean time of the stepwise vitrectomies was 3.1 ± 0.7 s, the duration of each vitrectomy was 8.1 ± 5.3 s, and the duration of the total surgery was 60.5 ± 5.3 min. The anterior segment reaction was mild and the shape of the pupil remained normal 1 day after surgery. The mean preoperative and mean 3-month postoperative CLR values were 0.48 ± 0.09 mm and - 0.16 ± 0.04 mm, respectively (p < 0.0001). The mean preoperative endothelial cell density in donor buttons was 2570 ± 171 cells/mm², and the mean 6- and 12-month postoperative endothelial cell density in donor buttons was 2207 ± 127 cells/mm² and 2000 ± 198 cells/mm², respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The novel and stabilized PKP procedure, performed in conjunction with the stepwise anterior vitrectomy, effectively avoided the PVP during open-sky surgery.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Chinese Clinical Trial Registry, ChiCTR1900021227.

Long-term safety of laser in situ keratomileusis in eyes with thin corneas: 5-year follow-up

AIM

To investigate the long term (≥5y) efficacy, predictability, and safety of laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) in eyes with thin corneas [central corneal thickness (CCT) <500 µm].

METHODS

A total of 339 patients met the criteria of this study. Finally, 175 eyes of 89 patients who had thin corneas and underwent LASIK≥5y ago returned to our clinic and included in this study. Preoperative parameters recorded included uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA), corrected distance visual acuity (CDVA), manifest refraction, CCT and corneal topography. At returning visits, in addition to visual acuity and manifest refraction, ultrasound CCT and corneal topography were performed. Optical coherence tomography was used to measure the CCT, LASIK flap thickness, and residual stromal bed thickness (RSBT). Safety index, efficacy index, percentage of eyes within ±0.5 D and ±1.0 D of refraction, percent tissue altered (PTA), and percentage stromal bed thickness (PSBT) were calculated.

RESULTS

The safety index was 1.09 and efficacy index was 0.99. The percentages of eyes within ±0.5 D and ±1.0 D were 71.2% and 87.7%, respectively. The mean PTA was 40%±6% (range 20% to 55%); 76 eyes (43.4%) had PTA <40% and 99 eyes (56.6%) had PTA≥40%. The mean RSBT was 303±27 µm (range 240 to 390 µm), and 2 eyes had RSBT<250 µm. The mean PSBT was 61%±9% (range 51% to 85%). No eyes developed ectasia.

CONCLUSION

In this cohort with the PSBT of 50% or more, LASIK is safe with follow-up for at least 5y.

Vitreous cavity length in keratoconus: implications for keratoplasty

PurposeTo compare axial length (AL) with vitreous cavity length (VCL) in patients with keratoconus and to ascertain whether graft size can be tailored to reduce myopic refractive error in patients with keratoconus undergoing penetrating keratoplasty (PK).Patients and methodsThe AL and VCL were measured prospectively in patients with keratoconus not undergoing PK (Group 1) and in normal phakic, emmetropic individuals (Group 2). A retrospective analysis of these measurements in patients with keratoconus who had undergone PK (Group 3) was also performed. The postoperative spherical equivalent (SE) was then correlated to size of donor buttons.ResultsKeratoconus patients tended to have a longer mean VCL than emmetropic normal individuals. The mean VCL of these patients (Group 1) was 16.49 mm±SD 1.13 compared to the mean VCL of 15.94 mm±SD 0.56 in normals (Group 2, P<0.0001). Patients with keratoconus who had an undersized graft showed reduced myopic refractive error compared to those with same size or oversized grafts.ConclusionVCL measurement is more accurate than AL measurement in deciding upon graft-host size disparity for corneal graft in patients with keratoconus. In patients with increased VCL, undersizing the donor button helps in reducing postoperative myopia. We recommend VCL measurement as part of the routine workup in all keratoconus patients undergoing corneal transplants.

Comparison of visual and topographic outcomes of deep-anterior lamellar keratoplasty and penetrating keratoplasty in keratoconus

AIM

To compare visual, surgical and topographic outcomes of deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK) and penetrating keratoplasty (PK) for keratoconus (KC).

METHODS

In this multicenter, prospective, randomized clinical trial 76 eyes of 71 KC patients operated between January 2011 and July 2014 in 2 tertiary referral hospitals were included. Consecutive patients were alternately selected to receive one of the two surgical methods. Thirty eight eyes underwent DALK with the big-bubble technique and 38 eyes underwent PK.

RESULTS

Mean best spectacle corrected visual acuity (BSCVA) at the first postoperative week (P=0.012) and the first postoperative month (P<0.001) was statistically significantly higher in DALK group. The mean BSCVA at 12mo was not significantly different for DALK (0.30±1.99 logMAR) versus PK (0.40±0.33 logMAR) (P=0.104). The 76.3% of the eyes had a BSCVA over 0.5 in DALK and 47.4% in PK group (P=0.009). The 7.9% of the eyes had a BSCVA of 1.0 in DALK and 5.3% in PK group (P=0.644). Mean spherical equivalent was -2.94 D in DALK and -3.09 D in PK group. Mean topographic astigmatism was 4.62 D and 4.18 D respectively. Regular topographic patterns were observed in 31 (81.6%) of DALK and 29 (76.3%) of PK (P=0.574). The most frequent topographic pattern was oblate asymmetric bow tie, seen in 39.5% in DALK and 23.7% in PK.

CONCLUSION

Big bubble DALK provides an earlier visual improvement compare to PK. However, visual and topographic outcomes are similar to those in PK at 1y. Postoperative complications including rejection and intraocular pressure elevation are more frequent in PK. DALK is a safer alternative to PK for KC. However, intraoperative perforation of the Descemet's membrane is a significant complication.

Clinical application of TICL implantation for ametropia following deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty for keratoconus: A CONSORT-compliant article

BACKGROUND

This study aimed to investigate the clinical application of phakic toric intraocular collamer lens (TICL) implantation in treating ametropia following deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty (DALK) for patients with keratoconus, especially the effectiveness and safety of high astigmatism and indications of TICL implantation after corneal transplantation.

METHODS

Using the self-controlled case series observation approach, 9 patients with ametropia (9 eyes) who underwent DALK surgery for keratoconus 1.5 years ago with stitches removed 3 months ago were kept under observation from May 2013 to April 2014 in Ophthalmic Center of Nanjing Drum Tower Hospital affiliated to Nanjing Medical University. TICL implantation was performed in all patients. The uncorrected visual acuity (UCVA) and best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) were examined before surgery and 1 week, 6 months, 1 year, and 2 years after surgery. Corneal astigmatism, corneal thickness, anterior chamber depth, corneal endothelial cell density (ECD), and preoperative and postoperative intraocular pressures at different time points were measured. Intraoperative or postoperative complications of TICL implantation were observed, and the safety of the operation was evaluated.

RESULTS

The UCVA and BCVA in all operated eyes were better 6 months after surgery than before surgery. The spherical diopter and cylindrical diopter decreased to different degrees after surgery. Six months after surgery, the deviation of TICL axis in all operated eyes was less than 10 degrees, tending to be stable. No severe intraoperative or postoperative complication occurred.

CONCLUSION

TICL implantation was an optional choice for ametropia correction after DALK surgery, especially in patients with high astigmatism.

Refractive outcomes of penetrating keratoplasty and deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty in fellow eyes for keratoconus

PURPOSE

To compare the refractive outcomes following penetrating keratoplasty and deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty in fellow eyes in patients with keratoconus.

METHODS

This is an observational retrospective review of consecutive patients with keratoconus first managed with penetrating keratoplasty in one eye and then with lamellar keratoplasty in the fellow eye, between 2002 and 2007. Data collection was based on patients' hospital records. Information related to assessment before surgery and at 1, 3, 6, 12, 24, and 48 months after keratoplasty were retrieved and considered in the analysis. Clinical evaluations included patients' medical histories and diagnosis of keratoconus, uncorrected and best corrected visual acuity, spherical equivalent, refractive cylinder, topographic cylinder, and high-order aberrations, complications, and adverse reactions. Data on contrast sensitivity, central corneal thickness, and central residual bed thickness (only for lamellar keratoplasty) were retrieved from anterior segment optical coherence tomography observation performed at 48 months.

RESULTS

Sixteen patients (32 eyes), 7 males and 9 females, were included in the analyses. After 4 years from transplantation, at the end of follow-up, no statistically significant differences were found in visual acuity and refractive measures between the two keratoplasties. Perforating keratoplasty showed significant differences for contrast sensitivity at 6 cpd with maximum glare (p = 0.026) and without glare (p = 0.015). Deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty showed a negative correlation between central residual bed thickness and best corrected visual acuity (R = -0.414, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

The manual pre-descemetic deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty used in this study showed refractive and visual results comparable to those obtained with penetrating keratoplasty. Such results indicated that leaving healthy stroma attached to Descemet's membrane does not compromise the clinical outcome in the short and long term after surgery.