Sternotomy for substernal goiter: retrospective study of 52 operations

Surgical Resection of Retrosternal Goitre: The Four-Finger Technique

Retrosternal goitre (RSG) is a thyroid gland with more than 50% of its mass located below the thoracic inlet. Pre-operative Computed Tomography can visualise the anatomical relations between the RSG and each mediastinal component, and the level of extension. Most cases of RSG can be resected via the cervical approach, as the thoracic approach carries a greater risk of complications. We describe a four finger technique for total thyroidectomy in five cases of RSG through a neck incision, without the need for a sternotomy. The recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) was identified early in the Baehr's triangle. The thyroid was mobilised in the neck by ligation of the feeding vessels and separated from the tracheal attachments. The retrosternal portion was then delivered into the neck by blunt dissection, keeping two fingers of each hand close to the thyroid gland. The RLN and parathyroids were identified early in the surgery to avoid the complications of hoarseness and hypoalcemia, respectively.

Retrosternal Goitre: Anatomical Aspects and Technical Notes

Background and Objectives: surgery for substernal goitre is still debated in the literature, due to the wide range of surgical options. This article outlines the findings of our extensive experiences, which include 264 cases of patients with “goitre plongeant“, and compares postoperative complications, despite surgical approaches. Material and Methods: preoperative planning and anatomical landmarks are described to determine the potential need of a combined approach. The surgical procedure is described, along with some stratagems, to ensure that the operation is completed safely. A statistical analysis of complications and the length of stay, with a comparison of cervicotomy and combined access, was performed using the Pearson chi-square significance test. Results: 264 patients underwent thyroid surgery for substernal goitre. The Kocher incision was the surgical approach chosen in 256 patients (96.6%), while an accessory incision was performed in 8 patients (3.4%). The necessity to use a two-fold surgical access was linked to a higher rate of postoperative complications (p-value < 0.01). The average length of stay (LOS) for cervicotomy was 2 days (1−3 days), while the average LOS was 5 days (4−7 days) (p-value = n.s.) for combined access. Conclusions: cervicotomy should be the gold standard technique for exploring intrathoracic goitre with a digital dissection, which, in almost all cases, enables the externalization of the mediastinal portion associated. Sternotomy is related to a higher rate of complications, so it should be performed only in selected cases. Management in large-volume centres may be more appropriate.

Case Report: Modified Thoracoscopic-Assisted Cervical Resection for Retrosternal Goiter

Introduction: The treatment of choice for retrosternal goiters (RSG) is surgical resection to relieve symptoms and rule out malignancy. Although the majority of RSG can be removed by a cervical approach only, an extracervical approach (e.g., sternotomy, thoracotomy or thoracoscopy) may be required. Herein, we describe a refined thoracoscopic-assisted cervical two-team RSG resection without thoracoscopic mediastinal dissection.

Technique: A 57-year-old man presented with a large RSG with posterior mediastinal extension (PME) and extensive peritumoral vascularization. Due to its extension below the aortic arch and its small connection with the right thyroid lobe, a combined cervical and thoracoscopic approach was intended. The endocrine surgery unit performed the cervical mobilization of the right thyroid lobe, while the thoracic surgery unit gently pushed the mediastinal tumor through the thoracic inlet without performing mediastinal dissection. This allowed a safe visualization of the inserting vessels by the endocrine surgery team at the neck, followed by a stepwise division of the vessels and resection of the retrosternal nodule through the cervical access.

Comment: The described approach is indicated for RSG with posterior mediastinal extension, anteroposterior dimension smaller than the thoracic inlet and inaccessibility from a cervical approach only. This minimally invasive approach is associated with a faster recovery, decreased morbidity and postoperative pain, shorter hospital stay and better cosmetic results.

Combined cervicosternotomy and cervicotomy for true retrosternal goiters: a surgical cohort study

Objective

Intrathoracic goiters are a heterogeneous group characterized by limited or extensive substernal extension. Whereas the former can be treated through cervicotomy, the latter sometimes requires a cervicosternotomy. Whether cervicosternotomy leads to more morbidity remains unclear.

This study aimed to compare intra- and postoperative morbidity in patients treated by cervicotomy or cervicosternotomy for intrathoracic goiters and standard thyroidectomy.

Methods

In a prospectively gathered cohort undergoing thyroid surgery (2010–2019) intra- and postoperative morbidity of cervicotomy (N = 80) and cervicosternotomy (N = 15) for intrathoracic goiters was compared to each other and to a ‘standard’ thyroidectomy (N = 1500).

Results

An intrathoracic extension prior to surgery was found in 95 (6%) of all thyroidectomies. Eighty patients (84%) were operated by cervicotomy and 15 (16%) by cervicosternotomy. The risk of temporary recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy was much higher in the cervicosternotomy group (21%) compared to cervicotomy (4%) and standard thyroidectomy (3%). The risk of temporary hypocalcemia after cervicotomy (28%) was comparable to a standard thyroidectomy (32%) but higher after cervicosternotomy (20%). No cases of permanent hypocalcemia or laryngeal nerve palsy were observed in both groups with substernal extension. The need for surgical reintervention was significantly higher in the cervicotomy group (6%) compared to cervicosternotomy (0%) and standard thyroidectomy (3%).

Conclusion

In patients undergoing thyroid surgery for an intrathoracic goiter, cervicosternotomy was associated with more temporary laryngeal nerve palsy, but none of the interventions resulted in higher risks of permanent nerve damage, permanent hypocalcemia, or reintervention for bleeding. Reintervention was even more common after cervicotomy compared to cervicosternotomy.

Level of evidence

IV

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13304-021-01027-1.

Retrosternal goiter in thoracic surgical practice

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate and optimize surgical approaches to the management of retrosternal goiter.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A cohort retrospective single-center study included 56 patients aged 68.3±9.8 years with retrosternal goiter who underwent surgery between 2004 and 2019. Right-sided goiter was diagnosed in 16 cases, left-sided goiter in 21 patients, bilateral goiter in 19 patients. Palpable neck mass was found in 17 (30.4%), stridor in 16 (28.6%), thyrotoxicosis in 4 (7.1%) and recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy in 2 (3.6%) cases. X-ray signs of tracheal compression were detected in 43 (76.8%) patients, deviation in 26 (46.4%) patients. Resection through cervical collar incision was performed in 40 (71.4%) patients. Additional sternotomy was required in 11 (19.6%) patients, 1 (1.8%) patient required collar incision and right anterior mediastinotomy. Right-sided posterolateral thoracotomy without collar incision was performed in 1 (1.8%) patient with a suspected mediastinal teratoma. Three patients underwent median sternotomy only because of preoperative diagnosis of teratoma in one and thymoma in two patients.

RESULTS

There was no perioperative mortality. Transient vocal changes occurred in 3 (5.4%) patients, recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy in 3 (5.4%), atrial fibrillation in 2 (3.6%), wound complications in 2 (3.6%), left phrenic nerve palsy in 1 (1.8%), transient hypocalcaemia in 1 (1.8%) and persistent hypothyroidism in 1 (1.8%) patient. Hospital-stay ranged from 2 to 12 (5.5±2.0) days. Multinodular goiter was found in 53 (94.6%) patients, diffuse goiter in 1 (1.8%), ectopic thyroid in 1 (1.8%) and oncocytic tumor in 1 (1.8%) patient. One (1.8%) patient underwent simultaneous resection of RSG via a collar incision and right-sided VATS upper lobectomy for primary lung cancer. One (1.8%) patient also underwent simultaneous resection of RSG via collar incision and right-sided VATS subcarinal lymph node biopsy for coexistent lymphoma. Mean vertical length of goiter in the collar incision group was 7.6 cm compared to 10.6 cm in the sternotomy group. Mean weight of specimens was 162.3 g in patients with collar incisions and 312.5 g in the sternotomy group. Sternotomy was required in 14 (25%) patients.

CONCLUSION

Resection of retrosternal goiter is more commonly performed via cervical collar incision with mandatory availability of sternotomy. Radiological measurement of craniocaudal length may predict the need for sternotomy. Surgical outcomes are not affected by surgical approach. Simultaneous thoracic interventions for a coexistent pathology in patients with RSG may be considered. Further research of minimally invasive interventions for RSG resection is required.

Substernal Goiter: a case to remember

Goiter is a localized or generalized thyroid hypertrophy. It can remain within the cervical region or grow down until it invades the mediastinum. The signs and symptoms depend on the size and location of the goiter. Although drugs and radioactive iodine are often used to treat thyroid disease, the presence of symptomatic substernal goiter is a clear indication for surgery. Death or postoperative complications rarely occur. We present a case of a 71-year-old man with recurrent thyroid pathology in the form of substernal goiter and hyperthyroidism even after partial thyroidectomy. The importance of this relates to the clinical evolution, volume, and location of the goiter as well as the surgical and pharmacological approach.

Ultrasound-Guided Percutaneous Microwave Ablation for Substernal Goiter: Initial Experience

OBJECTIVES

To preliminarily evaluate the safety, effectiveness, and feasibility of microwave ablation (MWA) for substernal goiter (SSG) in select patients and to provide a relevant treatment reference for further studies.

METHODS

From April 2017 to December 2017, 10 patients with SSG were treated by MWA. All patients were followed for at least 3 months to observe the therapeutic effects and complications. Therapeutic effects were assessed at follow-up for the relief of patients' symptoms, resolution of the cosmetic grade, and volume reduction rate (VRR) of SSG. Possibly related factors for the 3-month VRR of the nodules were analyzed.

RESULTS

The study included 9 female patients and 1 male patient with a mean age ± SD of 56.8 ± 10.1 years (range, 34-70 years). The mean volume of the nodules was 52.9 ± 27.9 mL (range, 23.7-122.6 mL). The nodule volume was significantly reduced at the 3-month follow-up (17.5 ± 9.5 mL; P < .05). The mean 3-month VRR of the index nodule was 66.7% ± 7.1%. A higher ablated portion-to-nodule ratio 1 day after MWA predicted a higher 3-month VRR (Spearman r = 0.646; P = .044). The mean symptom score (from 4.5 ± 1.7 to 1.5 ± 1.0; P = .005) and cosmetic grade (from 3.3 ± 0.5 to 2.2 ± 0.4; P = .004) declined significantly 3 months after the procedure. No complications or unexpected side effects were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Our preliminary results support the effectiveness and safety of MWA for local control of SSG. This technology can be applied in select patients with SSG who are ineligible for surgery.

A Large Substernal Goiter that Extended to Both Sides of the Thorax

Most substernal goiters can be managed through the transcervical approach, but a sternotomy is required in some cases. This report is about a large substernal goiter, which was resected via a transcervical and full sternotomy approach. The patient was a 57-year-old female, who visited our hospital for surgical treatment for a large substernal goiter. Computed tomography of the neck and chest revealed that the substernal goiter extended to both sides of the thorax and had compressed the trachea. We performed total thyroidectomy safely via a transcervical and full sternotomy approach. No postoperative complications occurred, except transient hypocalcemia. A histopathological examination did not reveal any malignancy, and the lesion was diagnosed as an adenomatous goiter. Most substernal goiters can be managed through the transcervical approach, but a full sternotomy is required when a substernal goiter extends to both sides of the thorax and/or has a larger diameter than the thoracic inlet or airway constriction is revealed. A full sternotomy provides excellent exposure and can help reduce the risk of complications, such as recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy and injuries to major blood vessels.

Substernal Goiter: Correlation between Grade and Surgical Approach

Substernal goiter is defined as a thyroid growth beyond the thoracic inlet. Using the cross-section imaging CT system, it can be classified into three grades. The aim of the study was to validate the surgical approach and the occurrence of postoperative complications with substernal goiter extension in our patient population. From a total of 1145 patients who underwent thyroid surgery at our institution in a 15-year period, 60 patients with substernal goiter were included. Clinical features and demographics, degree of extension, surgical details, and complications were analyzed. Mean ± SD age of the patients was 58 ± 14.7 years and 88 per cent were females. According to the cross-section imaging CT system 61.7 per cent were grade I,23.3 per cent grade II, and 15 per cent grade III. Total thyroidectomy was performed in 78.3 per cent of the patients, subtotal thyroidectomy in 18.3 per cent, and lobectomy in 3.3 per cent. The cervical approach was sufficient to perform 96.7 per cent of the thyroidectomies, requiring partial sternotomy in only two patients with grade III substernal goiter. Patients with grade III substernal goiter had a higher risk for postoperative dysphonia (OR = 14.29, IC95% 1.14-178.9, P = 0.03), which occurred in three patients (two transient and one permanent). Transitory hypoparathyroidism was present in 20 patients (33.3%) and did not correlate with goiter extension. Most substernal goiters can be resected through a cervical approach, with relatively low morbidity. Postoperative dysphonia was directly related to the extension of the goiter. Few cases with grade III goiters require a partial sternotomy.

Surgical Treatment of Retrosternal Goitre

This study aims to evaluate surgical approaches to the management of retrosternal goitre. Between 2004 and 2014, 35 patients (eight males; mean age 67.4 ± 10.9 years) with retrosternal goitre (mainly right-sided in 9, left-sided in 14 and bilateral in 12) underwent surgery. A palpable neck mass was found in 11 (31.4%), stridor in 10 (28.6%) and thyrotoxicosis in 4 (11.4%) cases. 4 (11.4%) patients were asymptomatic. Tracheal compression was detected radiologically in 27 (77.2%) patients with deviation in 18 (51.4%). A collar incision was performed in 34 patients, 6 (17.1%) of whom required additional sternotomy, 1 (2.9%) was assisted by an anterior mediastinotomy. 1 (2.9%) had a right lateral thoracotomy. There was no operative mortality. Transient vocal changes occurred in 3 (8.6%) patients, recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy in 3, atrial fibrillation in 2, and wound complications in 2 (5.7%). Hospital stay ranged from 2 to 12 days (5.5 ± 2.0). Multinodular goitre was found in 33 patients, diffuse goitre in 1 and ectopic thyroid in 1. The average vertical length of goitres in the collar incision group was 7.6 cm compared to 10.6 cm in the sternotomy group. The average weight of specimens was 156.3 g in patients with collar incisions and 307.5 g in the sternotomy group. Removal of retrosternal goitre is more commonly performed via a cervical collar incision with mandatory availability of sternotomy. Radiological measurement of craniocaudal length may predict the risk of sternotomy. Surgical outcomes are not affected by surgical approach.

Assessment and management of cervico-mediastinal goiter

Cervico-mediastinal goiter is a particular entity from the point of view of thyroid surgery. Its volume, hardness and intrathoracic extension require the surgeon to adapt technique and perform a painstaking preoperative work-up, so as to draw up fully-fledged plan. CT is now indispensable, to anticipate risks and determine whether sternotomy is needed. Surgery seems to induce more postoperative complications than in conventional surgery, although they can be reduced by retrograde dissection of the inferior laryngeal nerve and downward dissection of the posterior side of the lobe to optimize control of adjacent structures. This surgery requires optimal teamwork between all of the specialties involved in patient management: medical, radiological, anesthesiological and surgical.

Retrosternal Goiter

Objective

Retrosternal goiters pose a significant challenge in determining the indications and appropriate approach for surgical removal while limiting postoperative morbidity and mortality. The objective of this study is to use the National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP) database to compare outcomes of transcervical and transthoracic approaches for retrosternal goiter removal and to review the literature regarding the varying indications for the 2 surgical approaches.

Study Design

Administrative database analysis.

Setting

NSQIP database.

Subjects and Methods

The NSQIP database was queried for all cases of retrosternal thyroid: 2716 patients were included, which represents one of the largest data reviews of patients with retrosternal thyroid pathology who underwent surgery. Data were analyzed to examine morbidity and mortality of the cervical and transthoracic approaches.

Results

Patient demographics and preoperative comorbidities were similar between groups. Patients undergoing a transthoracic approach experienced increased rates of unplanned intubations and need for transfusion and length of stay postoperatively.

Conclusions

A transthoracic approach is associated with increased rates of several critical postoperative morbidities, and the data indicate the potential of increased overall mortality. Given equivalent retrosternal extension, a transcervical approach should be attempted whenever anatomically possible, regardless of pathology.

Demographics, disparities, and outcomes in substernal goiters in the United States

BACKGROUND

Disparities distinguishing patients with substernal goiters from nonsubsternal goiters have not been thoroughly described.

METHODS

The National Inpatient Sample database was used to compare patients who underwent substernal thyroidectomy years 2000 to 2010 with those who underwent thyroidectomy for nonsubsternal goiter.

RESULTS

A total of 110,889 patients underwent thyroidectomy for goiter (5,525 substernal and 105,364 nonsubsternal). Substernal thyroidectomy patients were older, more likely to be Black or Hispanic and to have Medicare insurance. They had a higher comorbidity index, were more likely to be admitted emergently and to have postoperative complications such as hemorrhage/hematoma, pneumothorax, pulmonary embolism, and hypocalcemia/hypoparathyroidism. Furthermore, substernal thyroidectomy patients had 73% increased odds of death during admission than nonsubsternal thyroidectomy patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Substernal goiters present a distinct type of goiter with identifiable patient-level characteristics and an increased risk of postoperative complications and death. Earlier identification and treatment of goiters may allow earlier interventions at a stage when risks are reduced.