Near-infrared autofluorescence-based parathyroid glands identification in the thyroidectomy or parathyroidectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Intraoperative Adjuncts in Thyroid Surgery

Thyroidectomy is relatively safe and often can be done as a minimally invasive procedure. Although they may be associated with a learning curve, thoughtful use of intraoperative adjuncts such as energy devices, recurrent laryngeal nerve monitoring, and parathyroid autofluorescence have the potential to make incremental improvements in the safety and efficiency of thyroid surgery. Perhaps many of these adjuncts may be of greatest benefit when used routinely by less experienced surgeons or selectively in higher-risk operations, although their adoption in practice continues to increase overall.

Raman spectroscopy with an improved support vector machine for discrimination of thyroid and parathyroid tissues

The objective of this study was to discriminate thyroid and parathyroid tissues using Raman spectroscopy combined with an improved support vector machine (SVM) algorithm. In thyroid surgery, there is a risk of inadvertently removing the parathyroid glands. At present, there is a lack of research on using Raman spectroscopy to discriminate parathyroid and thyroid tissues. In this article, samples were obtained from 43 individuals with thyroid and parathyroid tissues for Raman spectroscopy analysis. This study employed partial least squares (PLS) to reduce dimensions of data, and three optimization algorithms are used to improve the classification accuracy of SVM algorithm model in spectral analysis. The results show that PLS-GA-SVM algorithm has higher diagnostic accuracy and better reliability. The sensitivity of this algorithm is 94.67% and the accuracy is 94.44%. It can be concluded that Raman spectroscopy combined with the PLS-GA-SVM diagnostic algorithm has significant potential for discriminating thyroid and parathyroid tissues.

Autofluorescence-guided hemithyroidectomy in a low-volume thyroid institution with no experience in parathyroid surgery: randomized clinical trial

BACKGROUND

Recent studies suggest that low-volume surgeons with no experience in parathyroid surgery are at increased risk of causing parathyroid gland damage during thyroid surgery. The aim of this RCT was to evaluate the impact of using autofluorescence in hemithyroidectomy on parathyroid gland identification and preservation in a low-volume institution with no experience in parathyroid surgery.

METHODS

Patients referred for hemithyroidectomy were randomized 1 : 1 to either autofluorescence-guided hemithyroidectomy (the near-infrared autofluorescence group) or conventional hemithyroidectomy (the control group). The primary outcome was parathyroid gland identification rate. Secondary outcomes were the rate of parathyroid gland autotransplantation and the rate of inadvertent parathyroid gland excision.

RESULTS

A total of 170 patients were randomized to either autofluorescence-guided hemithyroidectomy (84 patients) or conventional hemithyroidectomy (86 patients). In the near-infrared autofluorescence group, 81.0% of parathyroid glands were identified, compared with 57.0% in the control group (P < 0.001). Autofluorescence enabled parathyroid gland visualization before the naked eye in 46.3% of cases. Surgeons had lower confidence in the parathyroid gland identification process in the control group than in the near-infrared autofluorescence group (59.1% versus 87.5% respectively; P < 0.001). In the near-infrared autofluorescence group, the parathyroid gland autotransplantation rate was initially high, but declined over time. There was no difference in the rate of inadvertent parathyroid gland excision.

CONCLUSION

Autofluorescence guidance significantly improved the parathyroid gland identification rate in hemithyroidectomy in a low-volume institution with no experience in parathyroid surgery and provided an increase in surgical confidence. The pattern of parathyroid gland autotransplantation in autofluorescence-guided surgery indicates the presence of a learning curve.

REGISTRATION NUMBER

NCT05044351 (http://www.clinicaltrials.gov).

The application of autofluorescence system contributes to the preservation of parathyroid function during thyroid surgery

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to investigate the impact of autofluorescence technology on postoperative parathyroid function and short-term outcomes in patients undergoing thyroid surgery.

METHODS

A total of 546 patients were included in the study, with 287 in the conventional treatment group and 259 in the autofluorescence group. Both groups underwent central lymph node dissection, which is known to affect parathyroid function. Short-term outcomes, including rates of postoperative hypocalcemia and parathyroid dysfunction, serum calcium and PTH levels on the first postoperative day, as well as the need for calcium supplementation, were analyzed. A multivariable analysis was also conducted to assess the impact of autofluorescence on postoperative parathyroid dysfunction, considering factors such as age, BMI, and preoperative calcium levels.

RESULTS

The autofluorescence group demonstrated significantly lower rates of postoperative hypocalcemia and parathyroid dysfunction compared to the conventional treatment group. The autofluorescence group also had better serum calcium and PTH levels on the first postoperative day, and a reduced need for calcium supplementation. Surprisingly, the use of autofluorescence technology did not prolong surgical time; instead, it led to a shorter hospitalization duration. The multivariable analysis showed that autofluorescence significantly reduced the risk of postoperative parathyroid dysfunction, while factors such as age, BMI, and preoperative calcium levels did not show a significant correlation.

CONCLUSION

This study provides evidence that autofluorescence technology can improve the preservation of parathyroid function during thyroid surgery, leading to better short-term outcomes and reduced postoperative complications. The findings highlight the potential of autofluorescence as a valuable tool in the management of parathyroid hypofunction. Further research and validation are needed to establish the routine use of autofluorescence technology in the thyroid.

Autofluorescence of Parathyroid Glands: A Review of Methods of Parathyroid Gland Identification and Parathyroid Vascular Assessment

Postoperative hypoparathyroidism may cause significant patient morbidity and even mortality. Emerging technologies centered on autofluorescent properties of parathyroid glands when exposed to near-infrared light hold promise to improve surgical parathyroid gland identification and preservation. Two systems (probe-based and camera-based) are commercially available currently; however, neither system alone provides indication of vascular viability or postoperative parathyroid gland function. The administration of indocyanine green, when combined with near-infrared fluorescence imaging, enables subjective assessment of parathyroid gland perfusion. Additional technologies to assess parathyroid gland perfusion are being developed. The impact of these nascent technologies on relevant clinical outcomes is an area of active investigation.

Future Directions in the Treatment of Thyroid and Parathyroid Disease

The surgical management of thyroid and parathyroid disease has evolved considerably since the era of Theodor Kocher. We review the current trends in thyroid and parathyroid surgery concerning robotic surgery for remote access, the use of parathyroid autofluorescence detection technology to aid in the prevention of hypocalcemia as well as the use of thermal ablation to target thyroid nodules in a minimally invasive way. We also discuss how artificial intelligence is being used to improve the workflow and diagnostics preoperatively as well as for intraoperative decision-making. We also discuss potential areas where future research may enhance outcomes.

The utility of parathyroid autofluorescence as an adjunct in thyroid and parathyroid surgery 2023

Thyroid and parathyroid surgery requires careful dissection around the vascular pedicle of the parathyroid glands to avoid excessive manipulation of the tissues. If the blood supply to the parathyroid glands is disrupted, or the glands are inadvertently removed, temporary and/or permanent hypocalcemia can occur, requiring post-operative exogenous calcium and vitamin D analogues to maintain stable levels. This can have a significant impact on the quality of life of patients, particularly if it results in permanent hypocalcemia. For over a decade, parathyroid tissue has been noted to have unique intrinsic properties known as "fluorophores," which fluoresce when excited by an external light source. As a result, parathyroid autofluorescence has emerged as an intra-operative technique to help with identification of parathyroid glands and to supplement direct visualization during thyroidectomy and parathyroidectomy. Due to the growing body of literature surrounding Near Infrared Autofluorescence (NIRAF), we sought to review the value of using autofluorescence technology for parathyroid detection during thyroid and parathyroid surgery. A literature review of parathyroid autofluorescence was performed using PubMED. Based on the reviewed literature and expert surgeons' opinions who have used this technology, recommendations were made. We discuss the current available technologies (image vs. probe approach) as well as their limitations. We also capture the opinions and recommendations of international high-volume endocrine surgeons and whether this technology is of value as an intraoperative adjunct. The utility and value of this technology seems promising and needs to be further defined in different scenarios involving surgeon experience and different patient populations and conditions.

Distribution of inadvertently excised parathyroid glands during thyroid surgery and the link with post-surgical hypoparathyroidism

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the incidence of inadvertent parathyroidectomy, identify risk factors, determine the location of inadvertently excised glands, review pathology reporting in inadvertent parathyroidectomy, and explore relationships between inadvertent parathyroidectomy and post-surgical hypoparathyroidism or hypocalcaemia.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study of 899 thyroidectomies between 2015 and 2020 was performed. Histopathology slides of patients who had an inadvertent parathyroidectomy and a random sample of patients without a reported inadvertent parathyroidectomy were reviewed.

RESULTS

Inadvertent parathyroidectomy occurred in 18.5 per cent of thyroidectomy patients. Central neck dissection was an independent risk factor (inadvertent parathyroidectomy = 49.4 per cent with central neck dissection, 12.0 per cent without central neck dissection, p < 0.001). Most excised parathyroid glands were extracapsular (53.3 per cent), followed by subcapsular (29.1 per cent) and intrathyroidal (10.9 per cent). Parathyroid tissue was found in 10.2 per cent of specimens where no inadvertent parathyroidectomy was reported. Inadvertent parathyroidectomy was associated with a higher incidence of six-month post-surgical hypoparathyroidism or hypocalcaemia (19.8 per cent who had an inadvertent parathyroidectomy, 7.7 per cent without inadvertent parathyroidectomy).

CONCLUSION

Inadvertent parathyroidectomy increases the risk of post-surgical hypoparathyroidism or hypocalcaemia. The proportion of extracapsular glands contributing to inadvertent parathyroidectomy highlights the need for preventative measures.

Intraoperative Identification of Thyroid and Parathyroid Tissues During Human Endocrine Surgery Using the MasSpec Pen

Importance

Intraoperative identification of tissues through gross inspection during thyroid and parathyroid surgery is challenging yet essential for preserving healthy tissue and improving outcomes for patients.

Objective

To evaluate the performance and clinical applicability of the MasSpec Pen (MSPen) technology for discriminating thyroid, parathyroid, and lymph node tissues intraoperatively.

Design, Setting, and Participants

In this diagnostic/prognostic study, the MSPen was used to analyze 184 fresh-frozen thyroid, parathyroid, and lymph node tissues in the laboratory and translated to the operating room to enable in vivo and ex vivo tissue analysis by endocrine surgeons in 102 patients undergoing thyroidectomy and parathyroidectomy procedures. This diagnostic study was conducted between August 2017 and March 2020. Fresh-frozen tissues were analyzed in a laboratory. Clinical analyses occurred in an operating room at an academic medical center. Of the analyses performed on 184 fresh-frozen tissues, 131 were included based on sufficient signal and postanalysis pathologic diagnosis. From clinical tests, 102 patients undergoing surgery were included. A total of 1015 intraoperative analyses were performed, with 269 analyses subject to statistical classification. Statistical classifiers for discriminating thyroid, parathyroid, and lymph node tissues were generated using training sets comprising both laboratory and intraoperative data and evaluated on an independent test set of intraoperative data. Data were analyzed from July to December 2022.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Accuracy for each tissue type was measured for classification models discriminating thyroid, parathyroid, and lymph node tissues using MSPen data compared to gross analysis and final pathology results.

Results

Of the 102 patients in the intraoperative study, 80 were female (78%) and the median (IQR) age was 52 (42-66) years. For discriminating thyroid and parathyroid tissues, an overall accuracy, defined as agreement with pathology, of 92.4% (95% CI, 87.7-95.4) was achieved using MSPen data, with 82.6% (95% CI, 76.5-87.4) accuracy achieved for the independent test set. For distinguishing thyroid from lymph node and parathyroid from lymph node, overall training set accuracies of 97.5% (95% CI, 92.8-99.1) and 96.1% (95% CI, 91.2-98.3), respectively, were achieved.

Conclusions and Relevance

In this study, the MSPen showed high performance for discriminating thyroid, parathyroid, and lymph node tissues intraoperatively, suggesting this technology may be useful for providing near real-time feedback on tissue type to aid in surgical decision-making.

Modern Surgical Techniques of Thyroidectomy and Advances in the Prevention and Treatment of Perioperative Complications

Thyroid cancer is the most common cancer of the endocrine system, and, in recent years, there has been a phenomenon of overdiagnosis followed by subsequent overtreatment. This results in an increasing number of thyroidectomy complications being faced in clinical practice. In this paper, we present the current state of knowledge and the latest findings in the fields of modern surgical techniques, thermal ablation, the identification and assessment of parathyroid function, recurrent laryngeal nerve monitoring and treatment and perioperative bleeding. We reviewed 485 papers, from which we selected 125 papers that are the most relevant. The main merit of this article is its comprehensive view of the subject under discussion-both general, concerning the selection of the appropriate method of surgery, and particular, concerning the selection of the appropriate method of prevention or treatment of selected perioperative complications.

Emerging Imaging Technologies for Parathyroid Gland Identification and Vascular Assessment in Thyroid Surgery: A Review From the American Head and Neck Society Endocrine Surgery Section

Importance

Identification and preservation of parathyroid glands (PGs) remain challenging despite advances in surgical techniques. Considerable morbidity and even mortality result from hypoparathyroidism caused by devascularization or inadvertent removal of PGs. Emerging imaging technologies hold promise to improve identification and preservation of PGs during thyroid surgery.

Observation

This narrative review (1) comprehensively reviews PG identification and vascular assessment using near-infrared autofluorescence (NIRAF)-both label free and in combination with indocyanine green-based on a comprehensive literature review and (2) offers a manual for possible implementation these emerging technologies in thyroid surgery.

Conclusions and Relevance

Emerging technologies hold promise to improve PG identification and preservation during thyroidectomy. Future research should address variables affecting the degree of fluorescence in NIRAF, standardization of signal quantification, definitions and standardization of parameters of indocyanine green injection that correlate with postoperative PG function, the financial effect of these emerging technologies on near-term and longer-term costs, the adoption learning curve and effect on surgical training, and long-term outcomes of key quality metrics in adequately powered randomized clinical trials evaluating PG preservation.

Parathyroid Autofluorescence in Pediatric Thyroid Surgery: Experience With False Positive and False Negative Results

Devices for near-infrared light stimulation of autofluorescence (NIRAF) allow for intraoperative identification of parathyroid glands with high sensitivity in adults. However, their performance in the pediatric population is unknown. In this case series with chart review at a tertiary academic children's hospital, we investigated pediatric patients undergoing thyroid surgery and concurrent use of a probe-based NIRAF device. Thirteen patients (ages 6-18 years) underwent thyroid and/or neck dissection procedures, and 2 patients had revision procedures for a total of 15 cases with the NIRAF device. Eight cases had NIRAF values that matched surgeon opinion of parathyroid tissue or histology when available. Six cases had false positive NIRAF readings (40.0%) and 1 case had false negative readings (6.7%). Compared with surgeon opinion or histology, the NIRAF device confirmed 26 of 34 parathyroid gland candidates (76.5%). These devices need further investigation in pediatric patients, whose tissues may have different autofluorescence characteristics.

Prevention of hypoparathyroidism: A step-by-step near-infrared autofluorescence parathyroid identification method

BACKGROUND

Hypoparathyroidism is an important factor that seriously affects the quality of life of patients after thyroidectomy. This study aimed to optimize the surgical procedure for parathyroid identification using near-infrared autofluorescence (NIRAF) during thyroidectomy.

METHODS

This was a prospective controlled study that included 100 patients with primary papillary thyroid carcinoma diagnosed in Beijing Tongren Hospital between June 2021 and April 2022 who were awaiting total thyroidectomy and bilateral neck dissection. The patients were randomly divided into an experimental group in whom step-by-step NIRAF imaging was used to identify parathyroid glands, and a control group in whom NIRAF was not used.

RESULTS

The number of parathyroid glands identified in the NIRAF group was higher than that in the control group (195 vs. 161, p=0.000, Z=-5.186). The proportion of patients with parathyroid glands inadvertently removed in the NIRAF group was lower than that in the control group (2.0% vs. 18.0%, respectively; p=0.008, χ^{2 =} 7.111). In the NIRAF group, we found that more than 95% of the superior parathyroid glands and more than 85% of the inferior parathyroid glands were identified before the dangerous phase, which was much higher than that in the control group. The incidences of temporary hypoparathyroidism, hypocalcemia, and symptomatic hypocalcemia were higher in the control group than those in the NIRAF group. On the first postoperative day, the average parathyroid hormone (PTH) level in the NIRAF group decreased to 38.1% of the preoperative level and that in the control group decreased to 20.0% of the preoperative level (p=0.000, Z=-3.547). On the third postoperative day, the PTH level in 74% of the patients in the NIRAF group recovered to normal levels, whereas it recovered in only 38% of the patients in the control group (p=0.000, χ^{2 =} 13.149). The PTH levels in all patients in the NIRAF group had recovered within 30 days after surgery, whereas one patient in the control group failed to return to the normal level 6 months after surgery and was diagnosed with permanent parathyroidism.

CONCLUSIONS

The step-by-step NIRAF parathyroid identification method can effectively locate the parathyroid gland and protect its function.

Heterogeneity in Utilization of Optical Imaging Guided Surgery for Identifying or Preserving the Parathyroid Glands—A Meta-Narrative Review

Background: Postoperative hypoparathyroidism is the most common complication after total thyroidectomy. Over the past years, optical imaging techniques, such as parathyroid autofluorescence, indocyanine green (ICG) angiography, and laser speckle contrast imaging (LSCI) have been employed to save parathyroid glands during thyroid surgery. This study provides an overview of the utilized methods of the optical imaging techniques during total thyroidectomy for parathyroid gland identification and preservation. Methods: PUBMED, EMBASE and Web of Science were searched for studies written in the English language utilizing parathyroid autofluorescence, ICG-angiography, or LSCI during total thyroidectomy to support parathyroid gland identification or preservation. Case reports, reviews, meta-analyses, animal studies, and post-mortem studies were excluded after the title and abstract screening. The data of the studies were analyzed qualitatively, with a focus on the methodologies employed. Results: In total, 59 articles were included with a total of 6190 patients. Overall, 38 studies reported using parathyroid autofluorescence, 24 using ICG-angiography, and 2 using LSCI. The heterogeneity between the utilized methodology in the studies was large, and in particular, regarding study protocols, imaging techniques, and the standardization of the imaging protocol. Conclusion: The diverse application of optical imaging techniques and a lack of standardization and quantification leads to heterogeneous conclusions regarding their clinical value. Worldwide consensus on imaging protocols is needed to establish the clinical utility of these techniques for parathyroid gland identification and preservation.

The Year in Surgical Thyroidology: Recent Technological Developments and Future Challenges

Background: The field of surgical and interventional thyroidology is rapidly evolving. In the past few years, we have seen the introduction and establishment of many novel surgical adjuncts, techniques, and disruptive ablative technologies that have impacted the field. Methods: We identified the most influential articles on technological developments in surgical and interventional thyroidology that were published from September 1, 2020, to August 1, 2021. We searched three electronic databases and consulted experts. Results: Major findings are summarized. Continuous intraoperative nerve monitoring (cIONM) lowered the risk of early postoperative vocal cord palsy 1.8-fold and permanent palsy 29 · 4-fold compared with intermittent intraoperative nerve monitoring. Parathyroid autofluorescence yielded a diagnostic odds ratio (OR) of 228.9 for detection of parathyroid glands over visualization, with 96% sensitivity and 92% specificity. There was no significant difference in the incidence of major complications between the transoral endoscopic thyroidectomy vestibular approach (TOETVA) and transcervical thyroidectomy (1.5% vs. 2.1%, p = 0.75), and a higher body mass index did not lead to a significant increase in the odds of cumulative complication with TOETVA for the overweight (OR = 0.52 [95% confidence interval {CI} 0.17-1.58]) and obese groups (OR = 1.69 [CI 0.74-3.88]). Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) for benign thyroid nodules typically resulted in a 50-85% volume reduction with faster recovery times, less pain levels, and higher social and psychological well-being compared with conventional thyroidectomy at 15 months post-treatment, although physical well-being levels were higher in the conventional thyroidectomy group at this time. RFA for papillary thyroid microcarcinoma showed no significant difference in local tumor progression (1.8% vs. 3.3%, p = 0.209), lymph node metastasis (0.6% vs. 0.6%, p = 1.000), recurrence (1.2% vs. 2.4%, p = 0.244), and 4-year recurrence-free survival rates (98.2% vs. 97.0%, p = 0.223) when compared with transcervical lobectomy. Conclusions: cIONM, parathyroid autofluorescence, transoral vestibular approach thyroid surgery, and RFA for benign and malignant thyroid nodules are some of the latest additions to the surgeon's and interventionalist's armamentarium to manage thyroid disease. These technological advancements demonstrate promise to improve outcomes, decrease complications, and enhance a patient's quality of life, but further rigorous studies are needed to define their utility and value.