HIDA scan ejection fraction does not predict sphincter of Oddi hypertension or clinical outcome in patients with suspected chronic acalculous cholecystitis

Cholescintigraphy may have a role in selecting patients with biliary dyskinesia for cholecystectomy: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Patients with typical biliary pain, no gallstones on ultrasound and low gallbladder ejection fraction (GBEF) on cholescintigraphy (gallbladder dyskinesia) may be considered for a laparoscopic cholecystectomy. However, some studies have suggested that symptoms alone are an adequate indication for laparoscopic cholecystectomy. The aim was to determine the role of cholescintigraphy in predicting outcomes of cholecystectomy in patients with typical and atypical biliary symptoms and normal biliary ultrasound.

METHODS

Meta-analysis using Preferred Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) guidelines of published literature using several electronic databases.

RESULTS

Twenty-four articles were selected with a total of 1710 patients. The majority (n = 1633, 94.4%) of patients had typical biliary symptoms. A total of 1047 patients with typical symptoms and a reduced GBEF had a cholecystectomy with 852 (81.4%) having complete resolution of symptoms. A total of 148 with typical symptoms and normal GBEF had a cholecystectomy with 103 (69.5%) having complete resolution, which was significantly less than those with a reduced GBEF (odds ratio 1.65, confidence interval 1.08-2.05, P = 0.01). Forty-five patients with atypical symptoms and a reduced GBEF had a cholecystectomy with 31 (68.9%) having complete resolution of symptoms, which is significantly lower than those with typical symptoms (odds ratio 1.97, confidence interval 0.95-3.90, P = 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Cholescintigraphy improved the predication of outcome of cholecystectomy in biliary dyskinesia by 10%. However, the presence of typical symptoms does predict an effective response in 70% of patients. Atypical symptoms predict a poorer response.

Systematic review with meta-analysis: cholecystectomy for biliary dyskinesia-what can the gallbladder ejection fraction tell us?

BACKGROUND

Gallbladder dyskinesia (gallbladder spasm, biliary dyskinesia or chronic acalculous cholecystitis) is a poorly defined entity which presents as biliary-type pain without any identifiable organic pathology. Abnormal gallbladder ejection fraction (GBEF) is used by some to select those likely to benefit from cholecystectomy. The validity of this approach has been questioned.

AIM

To systematically review the literature and summarise the evidence surrounding the practice of cholecystectomy based on GBEF for gallbladder dyskinesia.

METHODS

We conducted a systematic search of PubMed/MEDLINE and SCOPUS from 1980 to 2016 to identify the relevant literature.

RESULTS

Twenty-nine studies including 2891 patients were included in the final analysis. In comparing cholecystectomy with medical management, patients with a normal GBEF did not benefit from cholecystectomy; whereas those with low GBEF had a higher chance (RR, relative risk = 2.37) of symptomatic improvement following surgery. When those classified as "low" and "normal" GBEF were compared in terms of outcome following cholecystectomy, the rate of improvement following surgery was similar in the two groups (RR 1.09) which suggests a placebo effect of surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

While a low GBEF may provide some guidance in identifying those with gallbladder dyskinesia who may benefit from cholecystectomy, the available data are inconsistent and based on studies of poor quality which are often subject to bias and the impact of confounding factors. For these reasons, we conclude that the role of scintigraphy and cholecystectomy in the definition and management of this disorder remain unclear pending definitive study.

Biliary Dyskinesia in Children: A Systematic Review

Cholecystectomy rates for biliary dyskinesia in children are rising in the United States, but not in other countries. Biliary dyskinesia is a validated functional gallbladder disorder in adults, requiring biliary colic in the diagnosis. In contrast, most studies in children require upper abdominal pain, absent gallstones on ultrasound, and an abnormal gallbladder ejection fraction (GBEF) on cholecystokinin-stimulated cholescintigraphy for diagnosis. We aimed to systematically review existing literature in biliary dyskinesia in children, determine the validity and reliability of diagnostic criteria, GBEF, and to assess outcomes following cholecystectomy. We performed a systematic review following the PRISMA checklist and searched 7 databases including PubMed, Scopus, Embase, Ovid, MEDLINE, ProQuest, Web of Science, and the Cochrane library. Bibliographies of articles were screened for additional studies. Our search terms yielded 916 articles of which 28 were included. Three articles were manually added from searched references. We reviewed 31 peer-reviewed publications, all retrospective chart reviews. There was heterogeneity in diagnostic criteria and GBEF values. Outcomes after laparoscopic cholecystectomy varied from 34% to 100% success, and there was no consensus concerning factors influencing outcomes. The observational, retrospective study designs that comprised our review limited interpretation of safety and efficacy of the investigations and treatment in biliary dyskinesia in children. Symptoms of biliary dyskinesia overlapped with functional dyspepsia. There is a need for consensus on symptoms defining biliary dyskinesia, validation of testing required for diagnosis of biliary dyskinesia, and randomized controlled trials comparing medical versus surgical management in children with upper abdominal pain.

Cholecystectomy for biliary dyskinesia: how did we get there?

BACKGROUND

The focus of biliary dyskinesia (BD) shifted within the last 30 years, moving from symptoms after cholecystectomy (CCY) to symptoms with morphological normal gallbladder, but low gallbladder ejection fraction.

METHODS

We searched the pubmed database to systematically review studies focusing on the diagnosis and treatment of gallbladder dysfunction.

RESULTS

Impaired gallbladder contraction can be found in about 20% of healthy controls and an even higher number of patients with various other disorders. Surgery for BD increased after introduction of laparoscopic CCY, with BD now accounting for >20% of CCY in adults and up to 60% in pediatric patients. The majority of cases reported were operated in the USA, which differs from surgical series for cholelithiasis. Postoperative outcomes do not differ between groups with abnormal or normal gallbladder function.

CONCLUSION

Functional gallbladder testing should not be seen as an indicator of relevant biliary tract disease or prognostic marker to identify patients who may benefit from operative intervention. Instead biliary dyskinesia should be considered as a part of a spectrum of functional disorders, which are generally managed conservatively. Small proof of concept studies have demonstrated effects of medical therapy on biliary dysfunction and should thus be never tested in appropriately designed trials.

Diagnostic stringency and healthcare needs in patients with biliary dyskinesia

AIM

We have recently shown an increase in cholecystectomies for biliary dyskinesia. Based on these results, we hypothesized that diagnostic criteria are less stringently applied which may contribute to ongoing resource utilization.

METHODS

Using billing codes, patients seen for biliary dyskinesia were identified and data were extracted from the electronic medical record to confirm the diagnosis, obtain demographic and clinical data and assess resource utilization 1 year prior to and after cholecystectomy.

RESULTS

A total of 972 patients were identified, with 894 undergoing cholecystectomy. In 259 patients, symptoms had started <3 months prior to evaluation. Functional gallbladder imaging revealed a mean gallbladder ejection fraction of 23.1 ± 0.7 %; of the patients undergoing surgery, 116 had a normal gallbladder ejection fraction. Sufficient up data for pre- and post-operative assessment of resource utilization was available for 368 patients. Emergency room (ER) visits decreased from 0.86 ± 0.07 to 0.69 ± 0.03 (P < 0.05), while hospitalization rates remained unchanged after surgery. Patients not meeting consensus criteria for the diagnosis of biliary dyskinesia were more likely to use opioids and have ER visits prior to and after cholecystectomy. Using multiple logistic regression benzodiazepine use, migraine history and prior ER visits independently predicted postoperative resource utilization.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data demonstrate that a significant number of patients undergo cholecystectomy for biliary dyskinesia, even though they do not meet currently accepted diagnostic criteria. While healthcare resource utilization drops within the first year after surgery, ER visits and hospitalizations remain common, suggesting a more limited benefit of surgical approaches in these patients.

The rising tide of cholecystectomy for biliary dyskinesia

BACKGROUND

Expert consensus defines biliary dyskinesia as a rare disorder of the gall-bladder characterised by pain and impaired gall-bladder function.

AIM

To determine trends in cholecystectomy rates for biliary dyskinesia in the United States.

METHODS

As biliary dyskinesia does not have a distinct diagnosis code, the narrative diagnoses for patients were reviewed and abstracted for 200 patients treated for the most commonly used diagnosis codes for biliary dyskinesia (validation sample). Time trends in cholecystectomies and hospitalisations for biliary diseases were assessed using the Nationwide Inpatient Sample (Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality) based on codes for cholecystectomy and diagnosis codes for different biliary disorders.

RESULTS

In the validation sample, biliary dyskinesia accounted for 81% of the patients with ICD-9 code 575.8 (gall-bladder disease not elsewhere specified). Between 1997 and 2010, admissions for acute cholecystitis and complications of gallstone disease decreased slightly, whereas admissions with the primary diagnosis code ICD-9 575.8 tripled. This rise was most pronounced in the paediatric population (700% increase), with biliary dyskinesia accounting for more than 10% of cholecystectomies. Compared with acute biliary diseases, significantly more of the elective hospitalisations were covered by private insurances.

CONCLUSIONS

Practice patterns differ from expert opinion, with biliary dyskinesia accounting for an increasing fraction of cholecystectomies. The rise in these elective interventions is associated with a shift to a younger, low risk and predominantly privately insured population. Considering the benign nature of biliary dyskinesia, it is time to reassess the need for operative interventions, which have never been compared with active conservative therapy.

Normokinetic biliary dyskinesia: a novel diagnosis

BACKGROUND

Biliary dyskinesia diagnosed with CCK-HIDA scan and ejection fraction less than 35 % has been successfully treated by laparoscopic cholecystectomy. However, a population of patients with symptomatic biliary pain and a normal CCK-HIDA scan never receive a diagnosis, and thus no definitive treatment. Some of these patients report a reproducible pain during their CCK-HIDA scan. It is hypothesized that these patients have a novel diagnosis, normokinetic biliary dyskinesia, and may have resolution of pain when treated with cholecystectomy.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review was completed looking for patients with biliary pain in accordance with the ROME III criteria. Additional inclusion criteria were (1) greater than age 18 years, (2) reproducible biliary symptoms during the CCK-HIDA scan, and (3) an ejection fraction greater than 35 %. Treatment modality was laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Descriptive statistics were preformed, and data were reported as mean ± standard deviation and range.

RESULTS

Nineteen patients met the inclusion criteria for this study from August 2008 to July 2011. There were 15 women and 4 men with a mean age of 48.4 ± 13.0 years. The mean ejection fraction was 75.1 ± 19.4 %. The average duration of preoperative symptoms was 6.8 ± 5.9 months and postoperative follow-up was 21.8 ± 10.6 months. Seventeen patients had complete resolution of symptoms, one had partial resolution, and one had no change. There was a complete resolution rate of 89.5 % and an improvement rate of 94.7 %.

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest that patients who present with biliary pain, a normal CCK-HIDA scan with an ejection fraction greater than 35 %, and with reproducible symptoms on infusion of CCK could have a novel diagnosis: normokinetic biliary dyskinesia. Currently, these patients are excluded from the diagnosis of biliary dyskinesia and thus treatment. We hypothesize a potential new diagnosis, suggest cholecystectomy as treatment, and recommend a prospective study design for further evaluation.

The cholecystokin provocation HIDA test: recreation of symptoms is superior to ejection fraction in predicting medium-term outcomes

BACKGROUND

The (99m) technetium labelled hepato imino diacetic acid (HIDA) scan is widely used in the investigation of patients with typical biliary pain but whose trans-abdominal ultrasound scan (US) is normal. Although the standard measure by which the HIDA scan is deemed positive is the presence of an ejection fraction (EF) of <35% following provocation with cholecystokinin (CCK), there still remains debate as to the usefulness of this measure. The aim of this study was to compare the roles of EF and symptom provocation following CCK infusion in relation to the outcome following laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC). More specifically, we aimed to review the resolution of symptoms for our significant population of patients with normal HIDA scan EFs for whom surgery has traditionally been deemed inappropriate.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

All patients undergoing LC for a presumed diagnosis of biliary dyskinesia were identified from a prospectively maintained database. Data were collected regarding pre-operative symptoms, EF and symptom provocation during the CCK HIDA scan, histological findings, early symptomatic outcome, and medium-term follow-up.

RESULTS

During the period from March 2006 to October 2009, 42 patients with biliary symptoms but a negative US were referred for assessment by a single surgeon. There were 31 women and 11 men with a mean age of 39.0 ± 12.6 years. All underwent a CCK HIDA scan of which 17 were positive with an EF <35% and the remaining 25 were negative. All patients reported recreation of symptoms following administration of CCK. All gallbladders were delivered intact for histological assessment and all but one showed evidence of chronic cholecystitis. At each postoperative visit, approximately 2 weeks following the procedure, all patients reported resolution of symptoms. After a mean of 18.7 ± 12.1 months symptom recurrence had been noted in only one of 42 (2.4%).

CONCLUSIONS

The CCK HIDA scan is a useful study in the investigation of acalcalous cholecystitis; however, we would suggest that recreation of symptoms following CCK provocation is superior to EF for the identification of underlying chronic cholecystitis. Indeed, a normal gallbladder ejection fraction does not necessarily rule out a biliary aetiology of symptoms for this patient population.

Biliary dyskinesia

Functional disorders of the biliary tract include gallbladder dyskinesia (GBD) and sphincter of Oddi dysfunction (SOD). The diagnosis of GBD is made if the gallbladder ejection fraction is less than 35% to 40% using cholecystokinin cholescintigraphy. Despite slightly inferior outcomes compared with calculous disease, patients who have GBD should be treated with cholecystectomy. SOD is most often noted in the postcholecystectomy patient and symptoms can be biliary or pancreatic in nature. The gold standard for diagnosis remains manometry, with basal biliary or pancreatic sphincter pressures measuring greater than 40 mm Hg. Patients who have increased pressures may benefit from endoscopic sphincterotomy.

Evaluation of surgical outcomes and gallbladder characteristics in patients with biliary dyskinesia

INTRODUCTION

This study was designed to compare symptomatic outcomes following cholecystectomy in patients with biliary dyskinesia.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

From 1999 to 2006 at New York University Medical Center, 197 adults underwent hepatobiliary scintigraphy with cholecystokinin administration to evaluate gallbladder ejection fraction (GBEF). Biliary dyskinesia was demonstrated in 120 patients based on decreased GBEF of </=35%. Forty-four patients underwent cholecystectomy, and data from chart review and telephone questionnaires were available for 42 patients. Patients reported symptomatic improvement whether gallstones were present (25/27, 92.6%) or absent (13/15, 86.7%) prior to cholecystectomy (p = 0.90). The most common pathologic findings were chronic cholecystitis and cholesterolosis, regardless of the presence of gallstones. Additional data from 101 of the 120 patients with decreased GBEF demonstrated 74/101 (73.2%) patients were diagnosed with gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), and 59/101 (58.4%) patients were diagnosed with gastritis.

RESULTS

The results of this study suggest that biliary dyskinesia should be considered as part of the spectrum of symptomatic gallbladder disease that can be successfully treated with cholecystectomy and that biliary dyskinesia is associated with GERD and gastritis.

Reproduction of Postprandial Symptoms with Cholecystokinin Injection: An Indication for Cholecystectomy without the Presence of Gallstones or an Abnormal Ejection Fraction on Quantitative Cholescintigraphy?

Quantitative cholescintigraphy with cholecystokinin injection is commonly used to assess patients without evidence of cholelithiasis but with functional biliary pain. However, normal results may not always exclude the possibility of pathologic biliary disease. Retrospective review of prospectively collected data on eight patients with biliary colic, no evidence of cholelithiasis, a normal quantitative cholescintigraphy ejection fraction but with reproduction of their specific symptoms on cholecystokinin injection was performed. The mean ejection fraction was 66.2 per cent. All of these patients underwent cholecystectomy with complete resolution of their symptoms. Pathology was abnormal in all cases. Patients with symptoms suggestive of biliary disease with reproduction of these symptoms on cholecystokinin injection may benefit from cholecystectomy even in the absence of abnormally low ejection fraction on quantitative cholescintigraphy.