C1q nephropathy in two young sisters

C1q nephropathy in adults is a form of focal segmental glomerulosclerosis in terms of clinical characteristics

Although C1q nephropathy (C1qN) was introduced three decades ago, the clinical significance and renal outcomes of C1qN remain unclear. This study aimed to evaluate the clinical characteristics of C1qN, including renal outcomes, by performing a matched comparison within a multicenter cohort. We enrolled 6,413 adult patients who underwent kidney biopsy between January 2000 and January 2018 at three tertiary hospitals in Korea. We compared the clinical characteristics of 23 patients with C1qN with those of patients with focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) or minimal change disease (MCD) who were matched by age, sex, diabetic status, and a period of biopsy. Histological and clinical parameters in patients with C1qN were also evaluated according to the different pathological phenotypes. For a mean follow-up period of 92 months, 4 patients with C1qN (17.4%) developed end-stage renal disease (ESRD). None of the matched patients with MCD had ESRD, but 7 (30.4%) of patients with FSGS progressed to ESRD, which was not different from that of C1qN patients (p = 0.491). Laboratory and pathological findings, except segmental glomerulosclerosis, were not notably different between FSGS and C1qN. The presence of segmental glomerulosclerosis, mesangial hypercellularity, and podocyte effacement did not affect both the short- and long-term renal outcomes in patients with C1qN. Our study showed that the renal outcomes of C1qN are comparable with those of FSGS, and not with MCD. Specific pathological findings, including segmental glomerulosclerosis in C1qN, were not associated with renal outcomes, which may suggest homogeneity in the clinical features of C1qN.

C1q nephropathy in the pediatric population: pathology and pathogenesis

C1q nephropathy was originally described nearly 25 years ago by Jennette and Hipp. Since that time there have been a limited number of publications on C1q nephropathy, most of them in the pediatric literature. Despite reported incidences as high as 16% in some pediatric biopsy series, a consensus definition on the diagnosis of C1q nephropathy is lacking and its existence as a distinct clinical disease entity remains controversial. The purpose of this review is to discuss the biology of C1q in the context of mechanisms of C1q deposition, and to provide a detailed analysis of the published pediatric case series with a focus on the pathological criteria used to establish the diagnosis of C1q nephropathy as well as long-term outcomes in children.

Current status and issues of C1q nephropathy

C1q nephropathy, first proposed by Jennette and Hipp [Am J Clin Pathol 83:415-420, 1985; Am J Kidney Dis 6:103-110, 1985], was described as a distinct glomerular disease entity characterized by extensive mesangial deposition of C1q, with associated mesangial immune complexes, and the absence of any clinical and laboratory evidence of systemic lupus erythematosus. Now, 20 years since the first report, the disease entity is gradually attaining recognition, particularly in the field of pediatrics. C1q is the subcomponent of C1 in the classical pathway of complement activation. Generally, C1q deposition is caused by the activation of C1 by immunoglobulin G (IgG) and IgM; therefore, C1q nephropathy is considered as an immune complex glomerulonephritis. However, in C1q nephropathy, it remains unclear whether the deposition of C1q in the glomeruli is in response to the deposition of immunoglobulin or immune complex, or whether deposition is non-specific trapping that accompanies increased glomerular protein trafficking associated with proteinuria. Since not only the pathogenesis of C1q deposition in glomeruli but also its significance are still uncertain, it has not yet been established as an independent disease. From recent publications of the clinical and pathological characterizations, C1q nephropathy has been thought to be a subgroup of primary focal segmental glomerular sclerosis. However, many reports describe different symptoms, histopathologies, therapeutic responses and prognoses, suggesting that C1q nephropathy is not a single disease entity, but that it may be a combination of several disease groups. There are many uncertain areas requiring further investigation, though it is hoped that a detailed examination of future cases will clarify the subgroups making up C1q nephropathy and their clinicopathological characteristics, and will lead to the establishment of C1q nephropathy as an independent disease entity.

C1q nephropathy and minimal change nephrotic syndrome

C1q nephropathy (C1qN) is an uncommon disorder seen in children and adults with nephrotic syndrome and non-specific urinary findings. It has been described with minimal change nephrotic syndrome (MCNS), focal segmental glomerulonephritis and isolated mesangial proliferative glomerulonephritis. We describe nine children with MCNS and mesangial C1q deposition. These children had a median age of 2.7 years at diagnosis (range 1.3-15 years), 56% were male and 78% were Hispanic. We compared these children to concurrent patients with nephrotic syndrome and biopsy-proven MCNS. We found that the C1qN patients were more likely than MCNS children to require chronic immunosuppression with calcineurin inhibitors or mycophenolate mofetil to maintain remission. However, all children were able to achieve and sustain clinical remission of nephrotic syndrome. Children with C1qN and minimal change histology have an increased frequency of frequently relapsing and steroid-unresponsive disease, but they can attain prolonged remission and stable renal function with calcineurin inhibitor or mycophenolate mofetil therapy.