Problems with 'focal segmental glomerulosclerosis'

Variations of type IV collagen-encoding genes in patients with histological diagnosis of focal segmental glomerulosclerosis

Focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS), an important cause of end-stage kidney disease (ESKD), covers a spectrum of clinicopathological syndromes sharing a common glomerular lesion, based on an injury of podocytes caused by diverse insults to glomeruli. Although it is well expressed in many reports that the term FSGS is not useful and applicable to a single disease, particularly in genetic studies, FSGS continues to be used as a single clinical diagnosis. Distinguishing genetic forms of FSGS is important for the treatment and overall prognosis because secondary forms of FSGS, produced by rare pathogenic variations in podocyte genes, are not good candidates for immunosuppressive treatment. Over the past decade, several next generation sequencing (NGS) methods have been used to investigate the patients with steroid resistance nephrotic syndrome (SRNS) or FSGS. Pathogenic variants in COL4A3, COL4A4, or COL4A5 genes have been frequently identified in patients with histologic diagnosis of FSGS. The contribution of these mostly heterozygous genetic variations in FSGS pathogenesis and the clinical course of patients with these variations have not been well characterized. This review emphasizes the importance of appropriate approach in selection and diagnosis of cases and interpretation of the genetic data in these studies and suggests a detailed review of existing clinical variant databases using newly available population genetic data.

Genetic studies of focal segmental glomerulosclerosis: a waste of scientific time?

Many genetic causes of focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) have been described. A paradox is that the science in the molecular biology, which generally appears of high quality, is not mirrored by a similarly critical analysis of the renal pathology. FSGS has been applied to such a wide range of conditions that it can reasonably be said to have no useful meaning. Attempts to refine the term have been largely ignored. Study of 252 papers on genetic causes of FSGS found various clinical features. Many papers took the reported diagnosis without question. Few papers reported a pathological review, almost half reported FSGS and up to six other conditions caused by any particular gene, some reported FSGS with recognisable glomerular disorders, over 80% did not apply the Columbia classification, and in nearly all with photomicrographs, the images were not useful for refinement of FSGS. Some workers commented on a lack of genotype-phenotype correlation. One reason is a disregard of the principle that scientific investigation requires an unambiguous definition of the condition studied, to allow others to replicate or refute the findings. Genetic studies of FSGS should use a similarly rigorous approach to renal pathology to that used in molecular biology.

Classification Systems in Renal Pathology: Promises and Problems

Kidney diseases are morphologically heterogeneous. Pathologic classifications of renal disease permit standardization of diagnosis and may identify clinical-pathologic subgroups with different outcomes and/or responses to treatment. To date, classifications have been proposed for lupus nephritis, allograft rejection, IgA nephropathy, focal segmental glomerulosclerosis, antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody -related glomerulonephritis, and diabetic glomerulosclerosis. These classifications share several limitations related to lack of specificity, reproducibility, validation, and relevance to clinical practice. They offer a standardized approach to diagnosis, however, which should facilitate communication and clinical research.

Exome analysis resolves differential diagnosis of familial kidney disease and uncovers a potential confounding variant

A girl aged 6 presented with haematuria and her sister (aged 5) presented with haematuria and proteinuria. Family history showed multiple individuals suffering from end stage renal failure from the paternal side of the pedigree. Following kidney biopsy in the father and paternal grandmother, the pathological diagnosis was of focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS). Exome sequencing was undertaken in the proband's sister and grandmother. Genetic variants shared by both affected individuals were interrogated to identify the genetic cause of disease. Candidate variants were then sequenced in all the family members to determine segregation with the disease. A mutation of COL4A5 known to cause Alport syndrome segregated with disease from the paternal side of the pedigree and a variant in NPHS1 was present in both paediatric cases and inherited from their mother. This study highlights the advantages of exome sequencing over single gene testing; disease presentation can be heterogeneous with several genes representing plausible candidates; candidate gene(s) may be unavailable as a diagnostic test; consecutive, single gene testing typically concludes once a single causal mutation is identified. In this family, we were able to confirm a diagnosis of Alport syndrome, which will facilitate testing in other family members.

The podocyte's response to stress: the enigma of foot process effacement

Progressive loss of podocytes is the most frequent cause accounting for end-stage renal failure. Podocytes are complex, terminally differentiated cells incapable of replicating. Thus lost podocytes cannot be replaced by proliferation of neighboring undamaged cells. Moreover, podocytes occupy a unique position as epithelial cells, adhering to the glomerular basement membrane (GBM) only by their processes, whereas their cell bodies float within the filtrate in Bowman's space. This exposes podocytes to the danger of being lost by detachment as viable cells from the GBM. Indeed, podocytes are continually excreted as viable cells in the urine, and the rate of excretion dramatically increases in glomerular diseases. Given this situation, it is likely that evolution has developed particular mechanisms whereby podocytes resist cell detachment. Podocytes respond to stress and injury by undergoing tremendous changes in shape. Foot process effacement is the most prominent and, yet in some ways, the most enigmatic of those changes. This review summarizes the various structural responses of podocytes to injury, focusing on foot process effacement and detachment. We raise the hypothesis that foot process effacement represents a protective response of podocytes to escape detachment from the GBM.

Genetic testing in renal disease

A revolution is happening in genetics! The decoding of the first genome in 2003 was a large international collaborative effort that took about 13 years at a cost of around $2.7 billion. Now, only a few years later, new technology allows the sequencing of an entire genome within a few weeks--and at a cost of less than $10,000. The vaunted $1000 genome is within reach. These extraordinary advances will undoubtedly transform the way we practice medicine. But, like any new technology, it carries risks, as well as benefits. As physicians, we need to understand the implications in order to best utilise these advances for our patients and to provide informed advice. In this review, our aim is to explain these new technologies, to separate the hype from the reality and to address some of the resulting questions and implications. The practical objective is to provide a simple overview of the available technologies and of purpose to which they are best suited.

Target organ damage in African American hypertension: role of APOL1

Apolipoprotein L1 (APOL1) gene association studies and results of the African American Study of Kidney Disease and Hypertension are disproving the longstanding concept that mild to moderate essential hypertension contributes substantially to end-stage renal disease susceptibility in African Americans. APOL1 coding variants underlie a spectrum of kidney diseases, including that attributed to hypertension (labeled arteriolar or hypertensive nephrosclerosis), focal segmental glomerulosclerosis, and HIV-associated nephropathy. APOL1 nephropathy risk variants persist because of protection afforded from the parasite that causes African sleeping sickness. This breakthrough will lead to novel treatments for hypertensive African Americans with low-level proteinuria, for whom effective therapies are lacking. Furthermore, APOL1 nephropathy risk variants contribute to racially variable allograft survival rates after kidney transplantation and assist in detecting nondiabetic forms of nephropathy in African Americans with diabetes. Discovery of APOL1-associated nephropathy was a major success of the genetics revolution, demonstrating that secondary hypertension is typically present in nondiabetic African Americans with nephropathy.