Feasibility and acceptability of hypnosis-derived communication administered by trained nurses to improve patient well-being during outpatient chemotherapy: a pilot-controlled trial

Cultivating Comfort: Examining Participant Satisfaction with Hypnotic Communication Training in Pain Management

Context

One in four Canadians experiences chronic pain, yet insufficient services and restrictions surrounding prevailing treatments result in inadequate management and significant negative consequences for these individuals. Previous work indicates that hypnotic communication represents a promising complementary treatment; however, training protocols for healthcare professionals are underdeveloped and understudied.

Aim

To evaluate the level of satisfaction for a training program on hypnotic communication in pain management clinics.

Design

Qualitative study.

Methods

Six health professionals who first completed the hypnotic communication training participated in 30 minutes virtual semi-structured interviews. These testimonials allowed them to elaborate on their user experience and potential areas for improvement. Thematic analysis using qualitative data management software NVIVO was conducted on the interview data.

Results

Two themes emerged from the interviews. 1) Satisfaction: Participants expressed satisfaction on various structural aspects of the training, including the provided materials, atmosphere, training structure, presentation modalities, practical workshops, acquired knowledge, trainer quality, and training duration. 2) Areas for Improvement: Five main improvement suggestions were identified (providing more material; more practical workshops, more concrete and adapted; testimonials from former patients; follow-up training meeting; and continuing education).

Implications for the Profession and/or Patient Care and Conclusion

The results improved the training program to help minimized inherent biases related to this technique, cut associated costs, and identify reasons that would explain its underutilization among medical professionals in Quebec. Our work highlights that healthcare professionals in chronic pain management clinics (eg, respiratory therapists, nurses) can incorporate this simple hypnotic communication technique into their usual care and contribute to the well-being of patients.

Impact

This study aimed to address the lack of training protocols for healthcare professionals, that are underdeveloped and understudied. The main findings on participant' satisfaction and the areas of improvement for the training will help the refinement of the training to better suit healthcare professional's needs in hospitals and chronic pain facilities.

Do All Patients Benefit From the Soothing Properties of a Conversational Nursing Intervention to Reduce Symptom Burden During Outpatient Chemotherapy?: A Multimethod Secondary Analysis

BACKGROUND

Soothing conversation (SC) is particularly promising for symptom management during outpatient chemotherapy. However, we know little about the profile of patients who are most likely to benefit from this intervention.

OBJECTIVE

To gain a better understanding of the profile of patients most likely to benefit from SC to reduce symptom burden during outpatient chemotherapy.

METHODS

We performed a multimethod secondary analysis of 2 data sets: the first gathered during a quantitative pilot trial investigating the impact of SC on patients' symptom fluctuations during chemotherapy perfusion (n = 24); the second derived from qualitative interviews about nurses' experiences with SC in this context (n = 6).

RESULTS

Secondary quantitative analysis suggests that symptom control with SC is more effective in older patients, reporting lower education, widowed status, work incapacity, advanced cancer, and undergoing chemotherapy perfusion for less than 1 hour. According to nurses' interviews, SC could best benefit patients (1) prone to anxiety and fear, (2) with unalleviated pain, (3) who are unaccompanied during treatment, and contrary to what was shown with quantitative data, (4) undergoing longer perfusion duration.

CONCLUSION

Although this study provides valuable insights, much work remains to be done to fully understand the factors that predispose patients to respond positively to SC during outpatient chemotherapy.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

This study extends previous research on the effectiveness of SC for symptom management during outpatient chemotherapy by comparing nurses' experience with the intervention to patients' results. Results could be used to inform the assignment and delivery of supportive communication-based interventions during chemotherapy protocols.

Hypnotherapy and therapeutic suggestion: bridging the gap between evidence and utility

The use of hypnotherapy in psychiatry has been controversial. However, evidence presented by Chan and colleagues shows that it is beneficial to the promotion of good mental health and well-being, specifically being applicable in the management of mental disorders. But what does this mean for practice? This commentary looks at what we agree and disagree with, what we opine is missing from the article and what now needs to happen. Patients should be able to access hypnotherapy or hypnosis routinely on the National Health Service. Since it works, who may it work for and how may we make this available to those who could benefit from it?

Nurses' perception of integrating an innovative clinical hypnosis-derived intervention into outpatient chemotherapy treatments

Introduction

Conversational hypnosis (CH) is known to optimize the management of symptoms resulting from antineoplastic treatment. However, the perception of nurses who have been called upon to integrate this practice into their care has yet to be documented.

Goal

Describe how nurses perceive the integration of CH into chemotherapy-related care.

Methods

Individual interviews and an iterative analysis were conducted with six nurses who had previous experience in CH in an outpatient oncology clinic.

Findings

Six themes emerged: 1) the outpatient oncology clinic, a saturated care setting; 2) the key elements supporting the integration of CH into care; 3) an added value for patients; 4) a positive and rewarding experience for nurses; 5) collateral benefits; and 6) CH, an approach that warrants consideration amid the pandemic.

Conclusion

These findings shed light on nurses' unique point of view regarding the challenges and benefits of integrating CH into oncology care.

La perception des infirmières quant à l’intégration d’une intervention novatrice inspirée de l’hypnose clinique aux traitements de chimiothérapie à la clinique externe d’oncologie

Introduction

L’hypnose conversationnelle (HC) est connue pour optimiser la gestion des symptômes liés aux traitements antinéoplasiques. Toutefois, la perception des infirmières qui ont dû intégrer cette pratique dans leurs soins n’a encore jamais été documentée.

But

Décrire la perception des infirmières quant à l’intégration de l’HC aux soins entourant la chimiothérapie.

Méthodes

Des entrevues individuelles et une analyse itérative ont été réalisées auprès de 6 infirmières possédant une expérience préalable de l’HC à la clinique externe d’oncologie.

Résultats

6 thèmes ont émergé : 1) la clinique externe d’oncologie, un contexte de soins saturé; 2) les clés de voûte qui soutiennent l’intégration de l’HC dans les soins; 3) une valeur ajoutée pour les patients; 4) une expérience positive et valorisante pour les infirmières; 5) des bénéfices collatéraux; et 6) l’HC, une approche à considérer pendant la pandémie.

Conclusions

Ces résultats révèlent le point de vue unique des infirmières sur les défis et avantages de l’intégration de l’HC aux soins en oncologie.

How Fast Can Nurses Learn Therapeutic Communication Skills? A Pilot Study on Brief Hypnotic Communication Training Conducted with Oncology Nurses

Objective: This project aimed to train nurses on an oncology unit in hypnotic communication to reduce treatment-related pain and anxiety in their patients. A pilot study was conducted to assess changes in hypnotic communication behaviors associated with the training.

Methods: Nurses were recruited and their interactions during a simulated patient admission for treatment (before and after training) were recorded. Hypnotic communication skills were assessed by independent reviewers using a training checklist listing different hypnotic communication techniques and a validated assessment scale (Sainte-Justine Hypnotic Communication Assessment Scale, SJ-HCAS).

Results: Seven nurses were evaluated. Wilcoxon paired-sample tests (pre–post) reported significant improvement with large effect sizes in the total score of the training grid (P = 0.034, r = 0.832) and significant improvement with large effect sizes in the relational (P = 0.018, r = 0.930) and total (P = 0.021, r = 0.903) scores of the SJ-HCAS.

Conclusion: This pilot study shows promising results regarding the effectiveness of hypnotic communication training for nurses. These acquired skills could translate into improved treatment experience with patients and could be transferred to other professionals and settings in the health care system.