Pressure-induced end-plate fracture in the porcine spine: Is the annulus fibrosus susceptible to damage?

The effect of intervertebral disc damage on the mechanical strength of the annulus fibrosus in the adjacent segment

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

A herniated intervertebral disc (IVD) is a common injury in the human population. Despite the injury being isolated to a singular IVD in the spine, it is important to look at the biomechanical effects that a damaged IVD has on the entire spine, specifically the IVD adjacent to the injury.

PURPOSE

This study examined the effects of a damaged IVD on the mechanical properties of the annulus fibrosus (AF) in the adjacent cranial IVD.

STUDY DESIGN

Basic science study using an in-vitro porcine model.

METHODS

Sixteen porcine cervical spines were used; specifically spinal levels C3/4/5 were assigned to one of two experimental groups: 1) a control group that was not subjected any injuries (n=8); 2) an experimental group that experienced an injury to the anterolateral part of the disc, reaching the nucleus pulposus but without affecting the posterior portion of the AF in the C4/5 functional spine unit (FSU) (n=8). Each specimen underwent a previously published precondition compression protocol of 300 N of compression for 15 minutes followed by a cyclical compression protocol of compression protocol of 0.5 Hz sinusoidal waveform at 300 to 1200 N for 2 hours (3600 cycles). Post compression, the C3/4 AF was dissected to obtain two multilayer samples (one anterior and one posterior) as well as a peel sample (from the posterolateral region). A tensile strength test was conducted to examine the strength of the interlamellar matrix (peel sample) and the overall strength of the AF (multilayer samples).

RESULTS

Significant results were found in the peel test samples. Specifically, experimental specimens were less stiff compared than control specimens (p<.01). In addition, experimental specimens also had a lower average strength then control specimens (p<.01). This reduction in both interlamellar strength and stiffness increases the risk of delamination in the experimental samples. In contrast, there were no differences found between the two groups when examining the AF as a whole through the multilayer tests (p>.05).

CONCLUSIONS

It appears that a damaged IVD impacts the biomechanics of the spine and specifically the mechanical properties of the adjacent IVD. Specifically, the observed weakening of the interlamellar matrix in these adjacent IVDs may predispose it to delamination and subsequently degeneration or herniation.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

These findings may help clinicians when treating patients who have experienced a disc herniation or severe degeneration, as they may potentially experience accelerated adjacent disc degeneration.

In-vitro models of disc degeneration - A review of methods and clinical relevance

The intervertebral disc (IVD) provides flexibility, acts as a shock absorber, and transmits load. Degeneration of the IVD includes alterations in the biomechanics, extracellular matrix (ECM), and cellular activity. These changes are not always perceived, however, IVD degeneration can lead to severe health problems including long-term disability. To understand the pathogenesis of IVD degeneration and suitable testing methods for emerging treatments and therapies, this review documents in-vitro models of IVD degeneration including physical disruption, hyperphysiological loading, ECM degradation by enzyme digestion, or a combination of these methods. This paper reviews and critically analyses the models of degeneration published since the year 2000 in either in human or animal specimens. The results are categorised in terms of the IVD biomechanics, physical attributes, ECM composition, tissue damage and cellularity to evaluate the models with respect to natural human degeneration, and to provide recommendations for clinically relevant models for the various stages of degeneration. There is no one model that replicates the wide range of degenerative changes that occur as part of normal degeneration. However, cyclic overloading replicates many aspects of degeneration, with the advantage of a dose-response allowing the tuning of damage initiated. Models of severe degeneration are currently lacking, but there is potential that combining cyclic overloading and enzymatic digestion will provide model that closely resembles human IVD degeneration. This will provide an effective way to investigate the effects of severe degeneration, and the evaluation of treatments for the IVD, which would generally be indicated at this advanced stage of degeneration.

Delamination of the Annulus Fibrosus of the Intervertebral Disc: Using a Bovine Tail Model to Examine Effect of Separation Rate

The intervertebral disc (IVD) is a complex structure, and recent evidence suggests that separations or delamination between layers of the annulus may contribute to degeneration development, a common cause of low back pain The purpose of the present experiment was to quantify the mechanical response of the layer-adjoining interlamellar matrix at different rates of separation. Understanding the rate-dependency of the interlamellar matrix, or the adhesion between adjacent layers of the disc, is important as the spine experiences various loading velocities during activities of daily living. Twelve discs were dissected from four bovine tails (three extracts per tail). Two multi-layered annulus samples were collected from each IVD (total = 24, mean bond width = 3.82 ± 0.96 mm) and randomly assigned to a 180° peel test at one of three delamination rates; 0.05 mm/s, 0.5 mm/s, or 5 mm/s. Annulus extracts were found to have similar maximal adhesion strengths (p = 0.39) and stiffness (p = 0.97) across all rate conditions. However, a significant difference in lamellar adhesion strength variability was observed between the 5 mm/s condition (0.96 N/mm ± 0.31) when compared to the 0.5 mm/s (0.50 N/mm ± 0.19) and 0.05 mm/s (0.37 N/mm ± 0.13) conditions (p < 0.05). Increased variability may be indicative of non-uniform strength due to inconsistent adhesion throughout the interlamellar matrix, which is exacerbated by increased rates of loading. The observed non-uniform strength could possibly lead to a scenario more favourable to the development of microtrauma, and eventual delamination.

A Novel Testing Method to Quantify Mechanical Properties of the Intact Annulus Fibrosus Ring From Rat-Tail Intervertebral Discs

The annulus fibrosus is the ring-like exterior of the intervertebral disc which is composed of concentrically organized layers of collagen fibre bundles. The mechanical properties of the annulus have been studied extensively; however, tests are typically performed on extracted fragments or multilayered samples of the annulus and not on the annulus as a whole. The purpose of this study was two-fold: 1) to develop a novel testing technique to measure the mechanical properties of the intact, isolated annulus; and 2) to perform a preliminary analysis of the rate-dependency of these mechanical properties. Twenty-nine whole annulus ring samples were dissected from 11 skeletally mature Sprague Dawley rat tails and underwent a tensile failure test at either 2%/s (n=16) or 20%/s (n=13). Force and displacement were sampled at 100Hz and were subsequently normalized to stress and strain. Various mechanical properties were derived from the stress-strain curves and statistically compared between the rates. All mechanical variables, with the exception of initial failure stress, were found to be unaffected by rate. Interestingly, initial failure stress was higher for samples tested at the slower rate compared to the higher rate which is atypical for viscoelastic tissues. Although in general rate did not appear to impact the annulus ring response to tensile loading, this novel, intact annular ring testing technique provides an alternative way to quantify mechanical properties of the annulus.

Porcine Functional Spine Unit in orthopedic research, a systematic scoping review of the methodology

Purpose

The aim of this study was to conduct a systematic scoping review of previous in vitro spine studies that used pig functional spinal units (FSU) as a model to gain an understanding of how different experimental methods are presented in the literature. Research guidelines are often used to achieve high quality in methods, results, and reports, but no research guidelines are available regarding in vitro biomechanical spinal studies.

Methods

A systematic scoping review approach and protocol was used for the study with a systematic search in several data bases combined with an extra author search. The articles were examined in multiple stages by two different authors in a blinded manner. Data was extracted from the included articles and inserted into a previously crafted matrix with multiple variables. The data was analyzed to evaluate study methods and quality and included 70 studies.

Results

The results display that there is a lack of consensus regarding how the material, methods and results are presented. Load type, duration and magnitude were heterogeneous among the studies, but sixty-seven studies (96%) did include compressive load or tension in the testing protocol.

Conclusions

This study concludes that an improvement of reported data in the present field of research is needed. A protocol, modified from the ARRIVE guidelines, regarding enhanced report-structure, that would enable comparison between studies and improve the method quality is presented in the current study. There is also a clear need for a validated quality-assessment template for experimental animal studies.

Examining the protective role of the posterior elements of the spine against endplate fractures in a porcine model

Previous studies have shown that the posterior elements/facet joints provide strength to the overall functional spine unit (FSU) by taking 3-25% of vertical compressive load off the intervertebral disc (IVD). However, little is known regarding whether this offloading has a protective effect against endplate fracture. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to investigate if the posterior elements provide a protective role to the endplate in porcine cervical spines under fracture-inducing conditions. Twenty-two cervical porcine FSUs (C5/6 level) were randomized into two groups: 1) a control group which had their posterior elements left intact (n = 11); 2) an experimental group which had the posterior elements removed (n = 11). Each FSU underwent a previously reported rapid IVD pressurization protocol in order to create endplate fractures. Briefly, hydraulic fluid was rapidly injected into the IVD via a standard inflation needle inserted through the anterior annulus which was connected to a hydraulic pump and pressure transducer. Post pressurization, each FSU was dissected to determine the presence and size of endplate fracture. Peak pressurization and rate of pressurization were not found to differ between intact and cut specimens (p = 0.313 and 0.101, respectively). In contrast, significantly, more cut FSUs sustained an endplate fracture (11/11) compared to intact FSUs (5/11); p = 0.012. Further, cut FSUs resulted in a fracture area 1.91 times greater in size compared to the fractures seen in the intact FSUs (p = 0.011). Therefore, posterior elements appear to decrease the risk and severity of endplate fracture.

The effect of compressive loading rate on annulus fibrosus strength following endplate fracture

Intervertebral disc degeneration poses a considerable healthcare challenge, although the process is not well understood. Endplate fracture marks severe biomechanical compromise in a segment and may be correlated with degeneration of the disc. The purpose of this experiment was to investigate the relationship between endplate fracture velocity and damage to the annulus fibrosus. Following overnight-thawing, 27 frozen porcine cervical spines were dissected into motion segments (vertebra-disc-vertebra) and compressed until fracture at one of three loading rates (fast=15 mm/s, medium=1.5 mm/s, and slow=0.15 mm/s), or remained unfractured (control). Two annular samples were extracted and mechanically tested from each segment: 1) Bilayer samples underwent uniaxial tension to a stretch-ratio of 1.5; 2) Multilayer samples were delaminated with a 180° peel test configuration. All three rates of compression resulted in specimen fracture observed in the endplate and/or vertebra with varying degree of severity. Significant differences were detected in compressive strength and stiffness of motion segments when loaded at different rates of compression; interestingly these differences were not observed in the mechanical properties of the annulus fibrosus suggesting that at slow rates of loading, fracture of the endplate precedes destruction of the annulus fibrosus. In corroboration of these findings, gross and histological analysis reported no signs of annular disruption, strengthening assertions that annular damage did not occur.

The Influence of Axial Compression on the Cellular and Mechanical Function of Spinal Tissues; Emphasis on the Nucleus Pulposus and Annulus Fibrosus: A Review

In light of the correlation between chronic back pain and intervertebral disc (IVD) degeneration, this literature review seeks to illustrate the importance of the hydraulic response across the nucleus pulposus (NP)-annulus fibrosus (AF) interface, by synthesizing current information regarding injurious biomechanics of the spine, stemming from axial compression. Damage to vertebrae, endplates (EPs), the NP, and the AF, can all arise from axial compression, depending on the segment's posture, the manner in which it is loaded, and the physiological state of tissue. Therefore, this movement pattern was selected to illustrate the importance of the bracing effect of a pressurized NP on the AF, and how injuries interrupting support to the AF may contribute to IVD degeneration.

Rapid increase in intradiscal pressure in porcine cervical spine units negatively impacts annulus fibrosus strength

Vertebral endplate fracture is generally accepted to occur as a result of excessive, typically rapid, pressure developed within the intervertebral disc. Clinical evidence of disc disorders later in life following endplate fracture suggests that the disc is also impacted by the fracture event. There is an abundance of evidence to indicate that loss of disc pressure at the time of fracture alters annulus fibrosus loading which could impact disc health long-term. However, little is known regarding the isolated impact of the rapid disc pressurization during the fracture event. This study sought to determine if rapid disc pressurization impacts mechanical properties of the annulus. Intervertebral discs of porcine cervical functional spine units (FSU) were pressurized via rapid injection of hydraulic fluid (standard motor oil). FSUs were subsequently grouped according to whether the pressurization resulted in endplate fracture ('fracture'; n = 9) or not ('non-fracture'; n = 13). Annular tensile properties and lamellar adhesion strength were quantified for both fractured and non-fractured samples. A third group was also examined in which FSUs did not undergo the pressurization protocol ('control'; n = 10). Annular tensile properties were not found to be statistically different between the three conditions (p > 0.05). Lamellar adhesion strength, in contrast, was found to be, on average, 53% lower in specimens which were pressurized compared to control, non-pressurized samples (p = 0.03). Further, no statistical differences in adhesion strength was found between fractured and non-fractured pressurized samples (p = 0.990) indicating that rapid pressurization , and not the presence of an endplate fracture, impacted the mechanical properties of the annulus. Decreased lamellar adhesion strength increases the potential of delamination, which can lead to disc disorders.