Short isthmic versus long trans-isthmic C2 screw: anatomical and biomechanical evaluation

Biomechanical Comparison of Facet Versus Laminar C2 Screws

BACKGROUND

Transpedicular or transisthmic screws for C2 instrumentation represent the gold standard; however, the anatomy is not always compatible (hypoplastic pedicles, procidentia of the vertebral artery). Laminar screws (LS) have been proposed as a rescue technique and recently, bicortical facet screws (FS). To date, the biomechanical property of FS remains unknown.

OBJECTIVE

To compare the pull-out resistance of bicortical facet (FS) vs laminar (LS) C2 screws.

METHODS

Thirty-two human cadaveric C2 vertebrae were screened by CT scan imaging and dual x-ray absorptiometry before receiving both techniques and were randomized according to side and sequence (FS or LS first). Screw positioning was validated using 2-dimensional x-rays. Sixty-four mechanical tests were performed using pure tensile loading along the axis of the screws until pull-out. Mean pull-out strengths were compared using paired tests, multivariate and survival analysis (Kaplan-Meier curves).

RESULTS

The morphometric data were consistent with previous studies. Over 64 tests, the mean pull-out strength of LS (707 ± 467 N) was significantly higher than that of FS (390 ± 230 N) ( P = .0004). Bone mineral density was weakly correlated with pull-out strength (r = 0.42 for FS and r = 0.3 for LS). Both techniques were mechanically equivalent for vertebrae in which intralaminar cortical grip was not achievable for LS. The mean pull-out strength for LS with laminar cortical grip (1071 ± 395 N) was significantly higher than that of LS without (423 ± 291 N) ( P < .0001).

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that bicortical FS of C2 offer less mechanical resistance than LS.

Bicortical Short C2 Pars Screw Fixation for High-Riding Vertebral Artery Provided Sufficient Biomechanical Stability: A Finite Element Study

STUDY DESIGN

Finite element analysis.

OBJECTIVE

To determine and compare the biomechanical stability of the bicortical short C2 pars screw fixation for high-riding vertebral artery (HRVA) with the C2 pedicle screw and C2 translaminar screw fixation in finite element models.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Fixation of C2 is technically demanding in the case of HRVA. However, there is no consensus on the alternative technique for the C2 screw fixation for HRVA in the literature.

METHODS

A finite element model of the upper cervical spine (C0-C2) with HRVA had been developed. C1 pedicle screw was applied at C1 by using notching technique. Bicortical short C2 pars screws, C2 pedicle screws, and C2 translaminar screws were used in each model. Then a vertical load of 50 N and a 1.5 Nm torque were applied to the C0 to simulate flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation respectively.

RESULTS

Compared with C2 pedicle screw fixation, the bicortical short C2 pars screw fixation increased the range of motion by -1.45%, 2.13%, 62.0%, and 22.0% under flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation, respectively. However, the C2 translaminar screw fixation increased the range of motion by 43.6%, 17.8%, 423.4%, and 19.9%, respectively. In terms of the peak von Mises stress, compared with C2 pedicle screw fixation, bicortical short C2 pars screw decreased 46.1%, 41.6%, 71.3%, and -12.5% under flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation, respectively; C2 translaminar screw decreased -2.66%, -4.87%, 73.0%, and -10.1%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

For a patient with HRVA, bicortical short C2 pars screw fixation provides sufficient stability and exhibited a smaller von Mises distribution on the screw-rod construct, indicating it could be an effective C2 internal fixation method for HRVA to promote C1-C2 stability and avoid the vertebral artery injury.Level of Evidence: N/A.

C1 fracture: Analysis of consolidation and complications rates in a prospective multicenter series

INTRODUCTION

Three types of C1 fracture have been described, according to location: type 1 (anterior or posterior arc), type 2 (Jefferson: anterior and posterior arc), and type 3 (lateral mass). Stability depends on transverse ligament integrity. The main aim of the present study was to analyze complications and consolidation rates according to fracture type, age and treatment.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The French Society of Spinal Surgery (SFCR) performed a multicenter prospective study on C1-C2 trauma. All patients with recent fracture diagnosed on CT were included. Consolidation on CT was studied at 3 months and 1 year. Medical, neurologic, infectious and mechanical complications were inventoried using the KEOPS data-base.

RESULTS

Sixty-three of the 417 patients (15.1%) had C1 fracture: type 1 (33.3%), type 2 (38.1%), or type 3 (28.6%). The transverse ligament was intact in 53.9% of cases. Treatment was non-operative in 63.5% of cases, surgical in 27.0%, and surgical after failure of non-operative treatment in 9.5%. There were 8 medical complications, more frequently in patients aged >70 years, following surgery (p<0.0001). The consolidation rate was 84.2% with non-operative treatment, 100% for primary surgery, and 33.3% for secondary surgery (p=0.002). There were 10 cases of non-union, in 4.8% of type 1, 13.6% of type 2 and 33.3% of type 3 fractures (p=0.001).

CONCLUSION

Medical complications showed association with age and with type of treatment. Non-operative treatment was suited to types 1, 2 and 3 with minimal displacement and intact transverse ligament. C1-C2 fusion was suited to displaced unstable type 2 fracture. Displaced type 3 fracture incurred risk of non-union. Early surgery may be recommended.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Bicortical facet screws as a new option for posterior C2 fixation: anatomical study and clinical experience

PURPOSE

C2 fixation is a demanding procedure, particularly in patients with variants of C1-C2 anatomy. The inferior articular process (IAP) of the axis can be an alternative for screw placement. We report the results of a CT study of C2 IAP anatomy and we present the clinical experience of 28 patients operated with this technique.

METHODS

Anatomical study: 50 CT angiographies of the vertebral arteries (VA) were used for this study and, therefore, 100 IAPs were considered. We measured on the axial and sagittal planes the length, height and width of the facet, the distance between the anterior cortex and the VA and the distance between the screw entry point and the VA. We also measured the angle between the sagittal plane and the external tangent line of the VA.

CLINICAL REPORT

28 patients were treated with C2 IAP screws at the Spine Surgery Department of the University Hospital in Lyon, France, from January 2014 to January 2016.

RESULTS

Anatomical study: the mean length of C2 IAP was 12 ± 2 mm, the mean distance between the anterior cortical layer and the VA was 5.2 ± 1.4 mm, and the mean angle we found was 0.2° ± 5.3°.

CLINICAL REPORT

16 of the 28 patients presented post-traumatic C1-C2 instability, 8 patients presented degenerative disease, 1 patient was treated for pseudoarthrosis, 1 for tumour, 1 for OPLL and 1 for rheumatoid arthritis. All the screws were correctly positioned and there was no VA injury.

CONCLUSION

IAP screws can represent a safe alternative option for C2 fixation.