Intraoperative use of high-field MRI in hypothalamic hamartomas associated with epilepsy: clinico-pathological presentation of five adult patients

Hypothalamic Hamartoma related epilepsy: A systematic review exploring clinical, neuropsychological, and psychiatric outcome after surgery

The post-surgical outcome for Hypothalamic Hamartoma (HH) related epilepsy in terms of seizure freedom (SF) has been extensively studied, while cognitive and psychiatric outcome has been less frequently reported and defined. This is a systematic review of English language papers, analyzing the post-surgical outcome in series of patients with HH-related epilepsy (≥5 patients, at least 6 months follow-up), published within January 2002-December 2022. SF was measured using Engel scale/equivalent scales. We looked at the outcome related to different surgical techniques, and HH types according to Delalande classification. We evaluated the neuropsychological and neuropsychiatric status after surgery, and the occurrence of post-surgical complications. Forty-six articles reporting 1318 patients were included, of which ten pediatric series. SF was reported in 686/1222 patients (56,1%). Delalande classification was reported in 663 patients from 24 studies, of which 70 were type I HH (10%), 320 were type II HH (48%), 189 were type III HH (29%) and 84 were type IV HH (13%). The outcome in term of SF was reported in 243 out of 663 patients. SF was reported in 12 of 24 type I HH (50%), 80 of 132 type II HH (60,6%), 32 of 59 type III HH (54,2%) and 12 of 28 type IV HH (42,9%). SF was reached in 129/262 (49,2%) after microsurgery, 102/199 (51,3%) after endoscopic surgery, 46/114 (40,6%) after gamma knife surgery, 245/353 (69,4%) after radiofrequency thermocoagulation, and 107/152 (70,4%) after MRI-guided laser interstitial thermal therapy. Hyperphagia/weight gain were the most reported surgical complications. Others were electrolyte alterations, diabetes insipidus, hypotiroidism, transient hyperthermia/poikilothermia. The highest percentage of memory deficits was reported after microsurgery, while hemiparesis and cranial nerves palsy were reported after microsurgery or endoscopic surgery. Thirty studies reported developmental delay/intellectual disability in 424/819 (51,7%) patients. 248/346 patients obtained a global improvement (72%), 70/346 were stable (20%), 28/346 got worse (8%). 22 studies reported psychiatric disorders in 257/465 patients (55,3%). 78/98 patients improved (80%), 13/98 remained stable (13%), 7/98 got worse (7%). Most of the patients had non-structured cognitive/psychiatric assessments. Based on the available data, the surgical management in patients with HH related epilepsy should be individualized, aiming to reach not only the best epilepsy result, but also the optimal cognitive and psychiatric outcome.

Seizure outcomes and safety profiles of surgical options for epilepsy associated to hypothalamic hamartomas. A systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Several surgical options are available for treating hypothalamic hamartoma-related epilepsy but their respective efficacy and safety profiles are poorly defined.

METHODS

A literature search identified English-language articles reporting series of patients (minimum 3 patients with a follow-up ≥12 months) operated on by either microsurgery, endoscopic surgery, radiosurgery, radiofrequency thermocoagulation or laser interstitial thermal therapy for hypothalamic hamartoma-related epilepsy. The unit of analysis was each selected study. Pooled rates of seizure freedom and of neurological and endocrinological complications were analyzed using meta-analysis to calculate both fixed and random effects. The results of meta-analyses were compared.

RESULTS

Thirty-nine studies were included. There were 568 and 514 participants for seizure outcome and complication analyses, respectively. The pairwise comparison showed that: i) the proportion of seizure-free cases was significantly lower for radiosurgery as compared to microsurgery, radiofrequency thermocoagulation and laser ablation, and significantly lower for endoscopic surgery as compared to radiofrequency thermocoagulation; ii) the proportion of permanent hypothalamic dysfunction was significantly higher for microsurgery as compared to all other techniques, and significantly lower for endoscopic surgery as compared to radiofrequency thermocoagulation and laser ablation; iii) the incidence of permanent neurological disorders was significantly higher for microsurgery as compared to endoscopic surgery, radiosurgery and radiofrequency thermocoagulation, and significantly lower for radiosurgery as compared to laser ablation.

CONCLUSIONS

Minimally invasive surgical techniques, including endoscopic surgery, radiofrequency thermocoagulation and laser ablation, represent an acceptable compromise between efficacy and safety in the treatment of hypothalamic hamartoma-related epilepsy. Microsurgery and radiosurgery should be considered in carefully selected cases.

Intraoperative magnetic resonance imaging in epilepsy surgery: A systematic review and meta-analysis

This systematic review investigated the added value of intraoperative magnetic resonance imaging (iMRI)-guidance in epilepsy surgery, compared to conventional non-iMRI surgery, with respect to the rate of gross total resection (GTR), postoperative seizure freedom, neurological deficits, non-neurological complications and reoperations. A comprehensive literature search was conducted using Medline, Embase, PubMed, and Cochrane Reviews databases. Randomized control trials, case control or cohort studies, and surgical case series published from January 1993 to February 2021 that reported on iMRI-guided epilepsy surgery outcomes for either adults or children were eligible for inclusion. Studies comparing iMRI-guided epilepsy surgery to non-iMRI surgery controls were selected for meta-analysis using random-effects models. Forty-two studies matched the selection criteria and were used for qualitative synthesis and ten of these were suitable for meta-analysis. Overall, studies included various 0.2-3.0 Tesla iMRI systems, contained small numbers with heterogenous clinical characteristics, utilized subjective GTR reporting, and had variable follow-up durations. Meta-analysis demonstrated that the use of iMRI-guidance led to statistically significant higher rates of GTR (RR = 1.31 [95% CI = 1.10-1.57]) and seizure freedom (RR = 1.44 [95% CI = 1.12-1.84]), but this was undermined by moderate to significant statistical heterogeneity between studies (I² = 55% and I² = 71% respectively). Currently, there is only level III-2 evidence supporting the use of iMRI-guidance over conventional non-iMRI epilepsy surgery, with respect to the studied outcomes.

Open resection of hypothalamic hamartomas for intractable epilepsy revisited, using intraoperative MRI

INTRODUCTION

Hypothalamic hamartomas (HHs) are rare non-neoplastic lesions which cause drug-resistant epilepsy with associated behavioural, psychiatric and endocrine issues. With the development of new minimally invasive techniques for the treatment of HH, there is a need to reappraise the effectiveness and safety of each approach. We review the outcomes of HH patients treated surgically, utilizing intraoperative magnetic resonance imaging (IOMRI), by a team of Alder Hey NHS Foundation Trust tumour and epilepsy neurosurgeons since 2011.

METHODS

Patient records of all HH cases operated on since 2011 were reviewed to confirm history of presentation and clinical outcomes.

RESULTS

Ten patients have undergone surgery for HH under the dual care of Alder Hey tumour and epilepsy neurosurgeons during this period. Eight cases had a midline transcallosal, interforniceal approach with the remaining 2 having a transcallosal, transforaminal approach. All patients had an IOMRI scan, with 40% needing further tumour resection post-IOMRI. Forty percent had a total resection, 3 patients had near-total resection and 3 patients had subtotal resection (~ 30% tumour residual on post-operative MRI). No new neurological complications developed post-operatively. Hypothalamic axis derangements were seen in 3 cases, including 1 diabetes insipidus with hypocortisolaemia, 1 hypodipsia and 1 transient hyperphagia. Eighty percent are seizure free; the remaining two patients have had significant improvements in seizure frequency.

CONCLUSIONS

IOMR was used to tailor the ideal tumour resection volume safely based on anatomy of the lesion, which combined with the open transcallosal, interforniceal route performed by surgeons experienced in the approach resulted in excellent, safe and effective seizure control.