Shunt infusion studies: impact on patient outcome, including health economics

Assessment of CSF Dynamics Using Infusion Study: Tips and Tricks

Idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus, secondary chronic hydrocephalus, and other cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) disorders are often challenging to diagnose. Since shunt surgery is usually the only therapeutic option and carries significant morbidity, optimal patient selection is crucial. The tap test is the most commonly used prognostic test to confirm the diagnosis but lacks sensitivity. The lumbar infusion study (LIS) appears to be a better option, offering additional information on brain dynamics without increasing morbidity. However, this technique remains underused. In this narrative review, supported by the extensive experience of several European expert centers, we detail the physiological basis, indications, and CSF dynamics parameters that can be measured. We also discuss technical modalities and variations, including one versus 2 needles, patient positioning, and the site of CSF measurement, as well as in vivo shunt testing. Finally, we discuss the limitations and morbidity associated with the LIS. This review aims to assist teams wishing to incorporate LIS into their screening tools for chronic hydrocephalus and other CSF disorders.

A Male Patient with Hydrocephalus via Multimodality Diagnostic Approaches: A Case Report

Introduction: Idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus (iNPH) is a kind of hydrocephalus that is easily to be misdiagnosed with brain atrophy due to the similarity of ventricular dilation and cognitive impairment. In this case, we present an old male patient who was diagnosed with iNPH by multimodality approaches. Outcomes: A 68-year-old male patient, with deteriorated gait, declined cognitive function for at least 3 years and urinary incontinence for 3 months. The doctors suspected him a patient with hydrocephalus or Alzheimer's disease based on his symptoms. We used multimodality diagnostic approaches including brain imaging, cerebrospinal fluid tap test, continuous intracranial pressure monitoring, and infusion study to make the final diagnosis of iNPH. He underwent ventriculoperitoneal shunt surgery and was well recovered. Conclusion: This case demonstrates the efficacy of using multimodality approaches for iNPH diagnosis, which saves patient time and clinical cost, worthy of further promotion.

Embracing uncertainty in cerebrospinal fluid dynamics: A Bayesian approach to analysing infusion studies

Introduction

Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) infusion test analysis allows recognizing and appropriately evaluating CSF dynamics in the context of normal pressure hydrocephalus (NPH), which is crucial for effective diagnosis and treatment. However, existing methodology possesses drawbacks that may compromise the precision and interpretation of CSF dynamics parameters.

Research question

This study aims to circumvent these constraints by introducing an innovative analysis method grounded in Bayesian inference.

Material and methods

A single-centre retrospective cohort study was conducted on 858 patients who underwent a computerized CSF infusion test between 2004 and 2020. We developed a Bayesian framework-based method for parameter estimation and compared the results to the current, gradient descent-based approach. We evaluated the accuracy and reliability of both methods by analysing erroneous prediction rates and curve fitting errors.

Results

The Bayesian method surpasses the gradient descent approach, reflected in reduced inaccurate prediction rates and an improved goodness of model fit. On whole cohort level both techniques produced comparable results. However, the Bayesian method holds an added advantage by providing uncertainty intervals for each parameter. Sensitivity analysis revealed significance of the CSF production rate parameter and its interplay with other variables. The resistance to CSF outflow demonstrated excellent robustness.

Discussion and conclusion

The proposed Bayesian approach offers a promising solution for improving robustness of CSF dynamics assessment in NPH, based on CSF infusion tests. Additional provision of the uncertainty measure for each diagnostic metric may perhaps help to explain occasional poor diagnostic performance of the test, offering a robust framework for improved understanding and management of NPH.

Mathematical modelling of cerebral haemodynamics and their effects on ICP

Introduction

Electrical-equivalence mathematical models that integrate vascular and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) compartments perform well in simulations of dynamic cerebrovascular variations and their transient effects on intracranial pressure (ICP). However, ICP changes due to sustained vascular diameter changes have not been comprehensively examined. We hypothesise that changes in cerebrovascular resistance (CVR) alter the resistance of the bulk flow of interstitial fluid (ISF).

Research question

We hypothesise that changes in CVR alter the resistance of the bulk flow of ISF, thus allowing simulations of ICP in response to sustained vascular diameter changes.

Material and methods

A lumped parameter model with vascular and CSF compartments was constructed and converted into an electrical analogue. The flow and pressure responses to transient hyperaemic response test (THRT) and CSF infusion test (IT) were observed. Arterial blood pressure (ABP) was manipulated to simulate ICP plateau waves. The experiments were repeated with a modified model that included the ISF compartment.

Results

Simulations of the THRT produced identical cerebral blood flow (CBF) responses. ICP generated by the new model reacted in a similar manner as the original model during ITs. Plateau pressure reached during ITs was however higher in the ISF model. Only the latter was successful in simulating the onset of ICP plateau waves in response to selective blood pressure manipulations.

Discussion and conclusion

Our simulations highlighted the importance of including the ISF compartment, which provides mechanism explaining sustained haemodynamic influences on ICP. Consideration of such interactions enables accurate simulations of the cerebrovascular effects on ICP.

Managing Idiopathic Normal Pressure Hydrocephalus: Need for a Change of Mindset

Idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus (iNPH) refers to a complex brain disorder characterized by ventricular enlargement and the classic Hakim's triad of gait and balance difficulties, urinary incontinence, and cognitive impairment. It predominantly affects older patients in the absence of an identified cause. As the elderly population continues to increase, iNPH becomes a growing concern in the complex spectrum of neuro-geriatric care, with significant socio-economic implications. However, unlike other well-structured management approaches for neurodegenerative disorders, the management of iNPH remains largely uncodified, leading to suboptimal care in many cases. In this article, we highlighted the challenges of current practice and identify key points for an optimal structuration of care for iNPH. Adopting a global approach to iNPH could facilitate a progressive shift in mindset, moving away from solely aiming to cure an isolated neurological disease with uncertain outcomes to providing comprehensive care that focuses on improving the daily life of frail patients with complex neurodegenerative burdens, using tailored goals.

Slit ventricle syndrome: Historical considerations, diagnosis, pathophysiology, and treatment review

After the introduction of shunt treatment for the management of childhood hydrocephalus, a wide variety of complications related to this treatment modality have been recognized. The entity of slit ventricle syndrome (alternatively, symptomatic ventricular coaptation) is one of them, is frequently encountered in the pediatric population and its symptom complex resembles that of shunt failure. We conducted research on PubMed^®, MEDLINE^®, and Web of Science^®, using the keywords: “slit ventricles,” “slit ventricle syndrome,” “SVS” and “ventricular coaptation.” The aim of our review was to trace the advances made through the past decades, concerning our knowledge about the clinical characteristics, pathophysiology, and treatment options of this entity. The discrepancy among researchers about the offending etiology and the optimum treatment algorithm of this entity, as well as the necessity of an updated concept regarding shunt over drainage is analyzed. The multiple treatment modalities proposed and pathophysiologic mechanisms implicated for the treatment of slit ventricle syndrome illustrate the complexity of this entity. Consequently, the issue requires more detailed evaluation. In this review, we comment on all the main facets related to shunt over drainage and the resultant slit ventricle syndrome.

CSF Dynamics for Shunt Prognostication and Revision in Normal Pressure Hydrocephalus

BACKGROUND

Despite the quantitative information derived from testing of the CSF circulation, there is still no consensus on what the best approach could be in defining criteria for shunting and predicting response to CSF diversion in normal pressure hydrocephalus (NPH).

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to review the lessons learned from assessment of CSF dynamics in our center and summarize our findings to date. We have focused on reporting the objective perspective of CSF dynamics testing, without further inferences to individual patient management.

DISCUSSION

No single parameter from the CSF infusion study has so far been able to serve as an unquestionable outcome predictor. Resistance to CSF outflow (Rout) is an important biological marker of CSF circulation. It should not, however, be used as a single predictor for improvement after shunting. Testing of CSF dynamics provides information on hydrodynamic properties of the cerebrospinal compartment: the system which is being modified by a shunt. Our experience of nearly 30 years of studying CSF dynamics in patients requiring shunting and/or shunt revision, combined with all the recent progress made in producing evidence on the clinical utility of CSF dynamics, has led to reconsidering the relationship between CSF circulation testing and clinical improvement.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite many open questions and limitations, testing of CSF dynamics provides unique perspectives for the clinician. We have found value in understanding shunt function and potentially shunt response through shunt testing in vivo. In the absence of infusion tests, further methods that provide a clear description of the pre and post-shunting CSF circulation, and potentially cerebral blood flow, should be developed and adapted to the bed-space.

Shunt Testing In Vivo: Illustration of Partially Obstructed Ventricular Catheter by In-Growing Choroid Plexus

Assessing shunt function in vivo presents a diagnostic challenge. Infusion studies can be a cost-effective and minimally invasive aid in the assessment of shunt function in vivo. We describe a case of a patient who after a foramen magnum decompression for type I Chiari malformation developed bilateral posterior fossa subdural hygromas and mild hydrocephalus, eventually necessitating insertion of a ventriculoperitoneal shunt. The patient returned with symptoms that were concerning for infection of the shunt. A bedside infusion study helped confirm that the ventricular catheter was partially obstructed by in-growing choroid plexus, but also that the shunt was no longer necessary. Partial blockage due to in-growing choroid plexus was confirmed during surgery to remove the shunt. We discuss the behaviour of in-growing choroid plexus and how partial obstruction can be detected with the use of an infusion study, as well as how this compares to the pattern observed in complete shunt obstruction. The benefits of using infusion studies in the assessment of shunt function are also explored.