Molecular characterization of domestic and exotic potato virus S isolates and a global analysis of genomic sequences

Cas13d-mediated multiplex RNA targeting confers a broad-spectrum resistance against RNA viruses in potato

CRISPR-Cas systems endow the bacterial and archaeal species with adaptive immune mechanisms to fend off invading phages and foreign plasmids. The class 2 type VI CRISPR/Cas effector Cas13d has been harnessed to confer the protection against RNA viruses in diverse eukaryotic species. However a vast number of different viruses can potentially infect the same host plant resulting in mixed infection, thus necessitating the generation of crops with broad-spectrum resistance to multiple viruses. Here we report the repurposing of CRISPR/Cas13d coupled with an endogenous tRNA-processing system (polycistronic tRNA-gRNA, PTG) to target the multiple potato RNA viruses. Expression of Cas13d and four different gRNAs were observed in transgenic potato lines expressing the Cas13d/PTG construct. We show that the Cas13d/PTG transgenic plants exhibit resistance to either PVY, PVS, PVX or PLRV alone or two/three viruses simultaneously by reducing viral accumulation in plant cells. In sum, our findings provide an efficient strategy for engineering crops that can simultaneously resist infection by multiple RNA viruses.

Molecular Analysis of the Global Population of Potato Virus S Redefines Its Phylogeny, and Has Crop Biosecurity Implications

In 2020, 264 samples were collected from potato fields in the Turkish provinces of Bolu, Afyon, Kayseri and Niğde. RT-PCR tests, with primers which amplified its coat protein (CP), detected potato virus S (PVS) in 35 samples. Complete CP sequences were obtained from 14 samples. Phylogenetic analysis using non-recombinant sequences of (i) the 14 CP's, another 8 from Tokat province and 73 others from GenBank; and (ii) 130 complete ORF, RdRp and TGB sequences from GenBank, found that they fitted within phylogroups, PVS^I, PVS^II or PVS^III. All Turkish CP sequences were in PVS^I, clustering within five subclades. Subclades 1 and 4 were in three to four provinces, whereas 2, 3 and 5 were in one province each. All four genome regions were under strong negative selection constraints (ω = 0.0603-0.1825). Considerable genetic variation existed amongst PVS^I and PVS^II isolates. Three neutrality test methods showed PVS^III remained balanced whilst PVS^I and PVS^II underwent population expansion. The high fixation index values assigned to all PVS^I, PVS^II and PVS^III comparisons supported subdivision into three phylogroups. As it spreads more readily by aphid and contact transmission, and may elicit more severe symptoms in potato, PVS^II spread constitutes a biosecurity threat for countries still free from it.

First report of potato virus S and potato virus Y in tomatoes from Croatia

Potato virus Y (PVY, genus Potyvirus) is an economically important aphid-transmissible virus with a very wide host range reported in many tomato-growing areas (Rivarez et al. 2021). Potato virus S (PVS, genus Carlavirus) has a limited host range (Lin et al. 2014) and occurs in tomato (Predajňa et al. 2017), mostly in mixed infections with other viruses. In 2021, greenhouse tomatoes from Vidovec (46° 17' 3.4'' N, 16° 15' 37.0'' E) in the northwestern and Sedlarica (45° 54' 23.0'' N, 17° 12' 0.5'' E) in the eastern regions of Croatia were surveyed for virus-like diseases. In total, 30 plants were sampled (12 from Vidovec and 18 from Sedlarica) showing symptoms of mild mottling, leaf rugosity and mild bronzing followed by leaf necroses later in the season. Nucleic acids were extracted from leaves by adapted CTAB procedure (Murray and Thompson 1980) and DNase treated. Four representative samples from Vidovec and four from Sedlarica were pooled for high throughput sequencing (HTS). After rRNA depletion (RiboMinus™ Plant Kit for RNA-Seq, Invitrogen) and polyA tailing, two location specific libraries (PCR-cDNA sequencing kit, Oxford Nanopore Technologies) were prepared for nanopore HTS on MinION Mk1C device. From Vidovec samples, 459,285 raw reads (mean length 354 nt) were obtained and 206,718 (mean length 446 nt) from Sedlarica and mapped (Minimap2, v.2.17) against Kraken2 viral genome sequences database (https://benlangmead.github.io/aws-indexes/k2). The number of reads mapped to PVS genome was 1004 from Vidovec (coverage depth 1.56) and those mapped to PVY genome were 781 (coverage depth 0.99) and 57 (coverage depth 1), from Vidovec and Sedlarica, respectively. The PVS complete consensus genome from Vidovec (ON468562, 8485 nt) had 99.09% nucleotide identity (BLASTn) to a potato isolate from the Netherlands (MF418030). The PVY consensus genome sequences from Vidovec (ON505007, 9698 nt) and Sedlarica (ON505008, 9698 nt) had respectively 98.37% and 98.48% identities to a tomato isolate from Slovakia (MW685827). Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) was performed for all 30 samples and amplicons were Sanger sequenced, with primers PVS-7773F/PVS-3'endR for a 720 nt PVS genome portion spanning the 3'-part of the CP and a complete 11K gene (Lin et al. 2014) and PVY-2F/2R primers for a 510 nt portion of PVY CP gene (Aramburu et al. 2006). Only one tomato out of 12 ('Borana') from Vidovec harbored PVS in the mixed infection with PVY. Two additional tomatoes from Vidovec and two from Sedlarica were infected solely by PVY. Amplicon sequences of PVS (ON651427) and PVY (ON707000-4, ON734067-8) had 100% identity with the HTS assembled sequences. The PVS isolate from Croatia grouped with PVSO (ordinary) strain in phylogenetic analysis and the PVY isolates from both sites grouped with the PVY-NTN strain (Cox and Jones 2010). Although PVY is considered to be widespread in tomato (Nikolić et al. 2018; Rivarez et al. 2021), this is its first report from Croatia. PVS, newly reported from Croatia here, is probably not associated with the symptoms recorded because the same symptomatology was observed in the singly and mixed infected 'Borana' tomato plants. The occurrence of PVY in the geographically distant (100 km apart) Vidovec and Sedlarica, suggests that it is widespread in the continental Croatia where tomatoes are commercially grown in plastic greenhouses. Further analyses are needed to elucidate PVY and PVS epidemiology and impact on the local tomato production.

Occurrence and distribution of viruses infecting potato in Russia

Potato viral disease has been a major problem in potato production worldwide including Russia. Here, we detected Potato Virus M (PVM), P (PVP), S (PVS), Y (PVY), and X (PVX) and Potato Leaf Roll Virus (PLRV) by RT-PCR on potato leaves and tubers from the Northwestern (NW), Volga (VF), and Far Eastern (FE) federal districts of Russia. Each sample was co-infected with up to five viruses. RT-PCR disclosed all six viruses in NW, three in VF, and five in FE. Phylogenetic analyses of PVM and PVS strains resolved all PVM isolates in Group O (ordinary) and all PVS isolates in Group O. Seven PVY strains were detected, and they included only recombinants. PVY recombinants were thus the dominant potato virus strains in Russia, although they widely varied among the regions. Our research provides insights into the geographical distribution and genetic variability of potato viruses in Russia.

Construction and characterization of an infectious cDNA clone of potato virus S developed from selected populations that survived genetic bottlenecks

BACKGROUND

Infectious cDNA clones are a powerful tool for studies on RNA viruses using reverse genetics. Potato virus S (PVS) is a carlavirus with a worldwide distribution. Although the complete genome sequences of many PVS isolates have been reported, the construction of an infectious cDNA clone of PVS is yet to be reported. The aim of this study is the development and molecular characterization of an infectious cDNA clone of PVS.

METHODS

A full-length cDNA clone pPVS-H-FL-AB was constructed by connecting eight cDNA clones of PVS isolate H95. Capped RNA transcripts from pPVS-H-FL-AB and a modified clone pPVS-H-FL-H, containing the consensus genome sequence of PVS-H95, proved to be non-infectious. Therefore, a full-length cDNA clone pPVS-H-FL-β was reconstructed from PVS-H00, isolated from PVS-H95 populations by repeating a single local lesion isolation in Chenopodium quinoa three times; PVS-H00 appeared to be a selected variant that survived genetic bottlenecks. The sequence of cDNA clone pPVS-H-FL-β was determined as the genome sequence of PVS-H00 and compared with the consensus sequence of PVS-H95 genome.

RESULTS

All Nicotiana occidentalis plants inoculated with ≥0.2 μg capped RNA transcripts from pPVS-H-FL-β developed symptoms on upper leaves, as observed with PVS-H00 inoculation. Similar levels of viral genomic and subgenomic RNAs and coat protein were detected in systemically infected leaves. Sequence comparison of PVS-H95 and PVS-H00 revealed 370 nucleotide polymorphisms (4.4% of the entire genome sequence), causing 91 amino acid substitutions in six open reading frames (ORFs). The infectivity of chimeric RNAs derived from recombinants between the two cDNA clones revealed that the lack of infectivity of pPVS-H-FL-H transcripts was due to ORF1, which encodes replicase and harbors 80 amino acid substitutions compared with pPVS-H-FL-β. Approximately 71.3% amino acid substitutions in replicase were located within the variable region of unknown function between the putative methyltransferase and ovarian tumor-like protease domains.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first report of the development of an infectious cDNA clone of PVS. Our analyses suggest that PVS population within a plant exists as quasispecies and the replicase sequence diversity of PVS obstruct the construction of a full-length infectious cDNA clone.

Monoclonal antibody-based serological assays for detection of Potato virus S in potato plants

Potato virus S (PVS) often causes significant losses in potato production in potato-growing countries. In this study, the ordinary strain of PVS (PVS^O) was purified from PVS-infected potato plants and used as the immunogen to produce hybridomas secreting monoclonal antibodies (MAbs). Five highly specific and sensitive murine MAbs (1A3, 16C10, 18A9, 20B12, and 22H4) against PVS were prepared using conventional hybridoma technology. Using these MAbs, tissue print-enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), dot-ELISA, and double-antibody sandwich (DAS)-ELISA were developed for sensitive and specific detection of PVS infection in potato plants. The results of sensitivity assays revealed that PVS could be reliably detected in PVS-infected leaf crude extracts diluted at 1:10 240 and 1:163 840 (w/v, g/ml) in phosphate buffer saline (PBS) by dot-ELISA and DAS-ELISA, respectively. Twenty-two samples collected from potato fields in Yunnan Province, China were tested for PVS infection using the serological assays we had developed, and 14 of them were found to be positive. This indicates that PVS is now prevalent in potato fields in Yunnan Province.

The Biology and Phylogenetics of Potato virus S Isolates from the Andean Region of South America

Biological characteristics of 11 Potato virus S (PVS) isolates from three cultivated potato species (Solanum spp.) growing in five Andean countries and 1 from Scotland differed in virulence depending on isolate and host species. Nine isolates infected Chenopodium quinoa systemically but two others and the Scottish isolate remained restricted to inoculated leaves; therefore, they belonged to biologically defined strains PVS^A and PVS^O, respectively. When nine wild potato species were inoculated, most developed symptomless systemic infection but Solanum megistacrolobum developed systemic hypersensitive resistance (SHR) with one PVS^O and two PVS^A isolates. Andean potato cultivars developed mostly asymptomatic primary infection but predominantly symptomatic secondary infection. In both wild and cultivated potato plants, PVS^A and PVS^O elicited similar foliage symptoms. Following graft inoculation, all except two PVS^O isolates were detected in partially PVS-resistant cultivar Saco, while clone Snec 66/139-19 developed SHR with two isolates each of PVS^A and PVS^O. Myzus persicae transmitted all nine PVS^A isolates but none of the three PVS^O isolates. All 12 isolates were transmitted by plant-to-plant contact. In infective sap, all isolates had thermal inactivation points of 55 to 60°C. Longevities in vitro were 25 to 40 days with six PVS^A isolates but less than 21 days for the three PVS^O isolates. Dilution end points were 10^-3 for two PVS^O isolates but 10^-4 to 10^-6 with the other isolates. Complete new genome sequences were obtained from seven Andean PVS isolates; seven isolates from Africa, Australia, or Europe; and single isolates from S. muricatum and Arracacia xanthorhiza. These 17 new genomes and 23 from GenBank provided 40 unique sequences; however, 5 from Eurasia were recombinants. Phylogenetic analysis of the 35 nonrecombinants revealed three major lineages, two predominantly South American (SA) and evenly branched and one non-SA with a single long basal branch and many distal subdivisions. Using least squares dating and nucleotide sequences, the two nodes of the basal PVS trifurcation were dated at 1079 and 1055 Common Era (CE), the three midphylogeny nodes of the SA lineages at 1352, 1487, and 1537 CE, and the basal node to the non-SA lineage at 1837 CE. The Potato rough dwarf virus/Potato virus P (PVS/PRDV/PVP) cluster was sister to PVS and diverged 5,000 to 7,000 years ago. The non-SA PVS lineage contained 18 of 19 isolates from S. tuberosum subsp. tuberosum but the two SA lineages contained 6 from S. tuberosum subsp. andigena, 4 from S. phureja, 3 from S. tuberosum subsp. tuberosum, and 1 each from S. muricatum, S. curtilobum, and A. xanthorrhiza. This suggests that a potato-infecting proto-PVS/PRDV/PVP emerged in South America at least 5,000 years ago, became endemic, and diverged into a range of local Solanum spp. and other species, and one early lineage spread worldwide in potato. Preventing establishment of the SA lineages is advised for all countries still without them.

RT-PCR Differentiation, Molecular and Pathological Characterization of Andean and Ordinary Strains of Potato virus S in Potatoes in China

A survey of potatoes in a field in Hubei, China, for common potato viruses revealed that Potato virus S (PVS) was the most abundant virus. To unveil the strain identity of the virus, primers specific to the ordinary and/or Andean strains of PVS (i.e., PVS^O and PVS^A) were designed. RT-PCR using these primers successfully detected PVS^O and PVS^A in the samples. Sequence analysis of the amplicons confirmed the correctness of the RT-PCR assay. Two isolates, PVS HB24 and PVS HB7, representing PVS^O and PVS^A, respectively, were chosen for molecular and biological characterization. Both isolates contained a genome of 8,453 nt in length with six open reading frames. They shared a sequence identity of 79.5% at the complete genome sequence level. Phylogenetic analysis placed PVS HB24 and PVS HB7 to PVS^O and PVS^A clades, respectively. PVS HB24 induced chlorotic local lesions on the inoculated leaves but no visible symptom on the upper uninoculated leaves of Chenopodium quinoa after mechanical inoculation, whereas PVS HB7 induced both local and systemic symptoms on C. quinoa. ELISA and RT-PCR confirmed that PVS HB7 infected C. quinoa systemically whereas PVS HB24 failed to do so. Both isolates infected potato cv. Shepody and Solanum chacoense asymptomatically, but did not infect Nicotiana occidentalis and N. tobaccum cv. Samsun.