Isolation and molecular characterization of a tomato brown rugose fruit virus mutant breaking the tobamovirus resistance found in wild Solanum species

Genetic analysis of tomato brown rugose fruit virus reveals evolutionary adaptation and codon usage bias patterns

Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV) poses a significant threat to tomato production worldwide, prompting extensive research into its genetic diversity, evolutionary dynamics, and adaptive strategies. In this study, we conducted a comprehensive analysis of ToBRFV at the codon level, focusing on codon usage bias, selection pressures, and evolutionary patterns across multiple genes. Our analysis revealed distinct patterns of codon usage bias and selection pressures within the ToBRFV genome, with varying levels of genetic diversity and evolutionary constraints among different genes. We observed a transition/transversion bias of 2.07 across the entire ToBRFV genome, with the movement protein (MP) gene exhibiting the highest transition/transversion bias and SNP density, suggesting potential evolutionary pressures or a higher mutation rate in this gene. Furthermore, our study identified episodic positive selection primarily in the MP gene, highlighting specific codons subject to adaptive changes in response to host immune pressures or environmental factors. Comparative analysis of codon usage bias in the coat protein (CP) and RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) genes revealed gene-specific patterns reflecting functional constraints and adaptation to the host's translational machinery. Our findings provide valuable insights into the molecular mechanisms driving ToBRFV evolution and adaptation, with implications for understanding viral pathogenesis, host-virus interactions, and the development of control strategies. Future research directions include further elucidating the functional significance of codon usage biases, exploring the role of episodic positive selection in viral adaptation, and leveraging these insights to inform the development of effective antiviral strategies and crop protection measures.

Single amino acid change in tomato brown rugose fruit virus breaks virus-specific resistance in new resistant tomato cultivar

Introduction

Tomato cultivation across the world is severely affected by emerging plant viruses. An effective method for protection of commercial crops against viral threats is the use of cultivars harboring resistance genes. Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV), a recently emerged tobamovirus, is able to overcome the dominant Tm-22 resistance that is present in the majority of commercial tomato cultivars. In an effort to alleviate the severe consequences of ToBRFV on tomato production, tomato breeding companies are developing new cultivars with varying levels of resistance against ToBRFV.

Methods

In the present study, cultivars with a new resistant phenotype against ToBRFV were screened against a wild-type isolate of ToBRFV, and subsequently, their performance under commercial greenhouse conditions was monitored. Following the identification of ToBRFV symptoms in a commercial greenhouse-where both new resistant and susceptible cultivars were interplanted-these cultivars were more closely examined.

Results

The presence of ToBRFV was molecularly confirmed on both cultivar types suggesting that the new resistance had been broken. High-throughput sequencing (HTS) was used to study the complete genomes of viral isolates present in the two cultivar types. The analysis revealed a single amino acid change at position 82 of the movement protein of ToBRFV in the isolate present in the new resistant cultivar compared with the isolate identified in the susceptible cultivar.

Discussion

A screening bioassay, that was performed to compare the infectivity of the two ToBRFV isolates, confirmed that only the isolate with this specific amino acid change could successfully infect the resistant cultivar, overcoming the new resistance against ToBRFV.

Advances and Prospects of Virus-Resistant Breeding in Tomatoes

Plant viruses are the main pathogens which cause significant quality and yield losses in tomato crops. The important viruses that infect tomatoes worldwide belong to five genera: Begomovirus, Orthotospovirus, Tobamovirus, Potyvirus, and Crinivirus. Tomato resistance genes against viruses, including Ty gene resistance against begomoviruses, Sw gene resistance against orthotospoviruses, Tm gene resistance against tobamoviruses, and Pot 1 gene resistance against potyviruses, have been identified from wild germplasm and introduced into cultivated cultivars via hybrid breeding. However, these resistance genes mainly exhibit qualitative resistance mediated by single genes, which cannot protect against virus mutations, recombination, mixed-infection, or emerging viruses, thus posing a great challenge to tomato antiviral breeding. Based on the epidemic characteristics of tomato viruses, we propose that future studies on tomato virus resistance breeding should focus on rapidly, safely, and efficiently creating broad-spectrum germplasm materials resistant to multiple viruses. Accordingly, we summarized and analyzed the advantages and characteristics of the three tomato antiviral breeding strategies, including marker-assisted selection (MAS)-based hybrid breeding, RNA interference (RNAi)-based transgenic breeding, and CRISPR/Cas-based gene editing. Finally, we highlighted the challenges and provided suggestions for improving tomato antiviral breeding in the future using the three breeding strategies.

Breaking Boundaries: The Perpetual Interplay Between Tobamoviruses and Plant Immunity

Plant viruses of the genus Tobamovirus cause significant economic losses in various crops. The emergence of new tobamoviruses such as the tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV) poses a major threat to global agriculture. Upon infection, plants mount a complex immune response to restrict virus replication and spread, involving a multilayered defense system that includes defense hormones, RNA silencing, and immune receptors. To counter these defenses, tobamoviruses have evolved various strategies to evade or suppress the different immune pathways. Understanding the interactions between tobamoviruses and the plant immune pathways is crucial for the development of effective control measures and genetic resistance to these viruses. In this review, we discuss past and current knowledge of the intricate relationship between tobamoviruses and host immunity. We use this knowledge to understand the emergence of ToBRFV and discuss potential approaches for the development of new resistance strategies to cope with emerging tobamoviruses.

Tomato Brown Rugose Fruit Virus Pandemic

Tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV) is an emerging tobamovirus. It was first reported in 2015 in Jordan in greenhouse tomatoes and now threatens tomato and pepper crops around the world. ToBRFV is a stable and highly infectious virus that is easily transmitted by mechanical means and via seeds, which enables it to spread locally and over long distances. The ability of ToBRFV to infect tomato plants harboring the commonly deployed Tm resistance genes, as well as pepper plants harboring the L resistance alleles under certain conditions, limits the ability to prevent damage from the virus. The fruit production and quality of ToBRFV-infected tomato and pepper plants can be drastically affected, thus significantly impacting their market value. Herein, we review the current information and discuss the latest areas of research on this virus, which include its discovery and distribution, epidemiology, detection, and prevention and control measures, that could help mitigate the ToBRFV disease pandemic.

Bioinformatic-based approach for mutagenesis of plant immune Tm-22 receptor to confer resistance against tomato brown rugose fruit virus (ToBRFV)

Nucleotide-binding leucine-rich repeat (NLR) plant immune receptors mediate the recognition and activation of defense signaling pathways in response to intra- and extracellular pathogens. Several NLR such as Tm-2 and Tm-2² have been introgressed into commercial solanaceous varieties to confer protection against different tobamoviruses. Particularly, Tm-2² was used during recent decades to confer resistance against tobacco mosaic virus, tomato mottle mosaic virus and tomato mosaic virus, which recognizes the viral movement protein (MP). However, tomato brown rugose fruit virus(ToBRFV), a novel tobamovirus, can avoid the protection conferred by Tm-2² due to the presence of key substitutions in the MP. The aim of this work was to identify the key amino acid residues involved in the interaction between Tm-2² and ToBRFV MP through bioinformatic analyses, and to identify potential Tm-2² mutations that could generate greater binding affinity. In silico 3D structure prediction, molecular docking, and computational affinity methods were performed. We predicted that R350, H384 and K385 Tm-2² residues are relevant for the interaction with MP, and two mutations (H384W and K385L) were identified as putative sites to increase the affinity of Tm-2² to the MP with the potential elicitation of resistance against ToBRFV.