Ultrasound-guided synovial biopsy improves diagnosis of septic arthritis in acute arthritis without enough analyzable synovial fluid: a retrospective analysis of 176 arthritis from a French rheumatology department

Predictive value of joint fluid volume on advanced pre-procedure imaging related to success of arthrocentesis and presence of septic arthritis

PURPOSE

Septic arthritis is a dangerous medical condition requiring prompt diagnosis, often via arthrocentesis. A "dry tap" occurs when no fluid is aspirated. We hypothesized that the absence of a joint effusion on pre-procedure advanced imaging would reliably predict a dry tap and exclude septic arthritis.

METHODS

A cohort of 217 arthrocentesis cases of large joints (hips, shoulders, knees) from our institution, with pre-procedure advanced imaging (CT, MR, US) of the same joint performed within the previous 48 h, was analyzed. Exclusion criteria included non-native joints or inadequate imaging of the affected joint. These cases underwent blinded review by 4 radiologists who measured the deepest pocket of joint fluid on the pre-procedure imaging. Wilcoxon rank-sum test was performed comparing joint fluid pocket size to outcomes of successful aspiration and final diagnosis.

RESULTS

A smaller average joint pocket fluid size was present on advanced imaging in both dry taps compared with successful arthrocenteses (p < .0001), and in uninfected joints compared with septic joints (p = .0001). However, the overlap of values was too great to allow for a perfectly predictive cutoff. 29% (5/17) of patients with no visible joint fluid on pre-aspiration imaging underwent successful arthrocentesis, one case representing septic arthritis.

CONCLUSION

Volume of joint fluid on advanced pre-arthrocentesis imaging cannot reliably predict subsequent dry tap nor exclude septic arthritis.

Imaging approach to prosthetic joint infection

The diagnosis of prosthetic joint infection (PJI) remains challenging, despite multiple available laboratory tests for both serum and synovial fluid analysis. The clinical symptoms of PJI are not always characteristic, particularly in the chronic phase, and there is often significant overlap in symptoms with non-infectious forms of arthroplasty failure. Further exacerbating this challenge is lack of a universally accepted definition for PJI, with publications from multiple professional societies citing different diagnostic criteria. While not included in many of the major societies' guidelines for diagnosis of PJI, diagnostic imaging can play an important role in the workup of suspected PJI. In this article, we will review an approach to diagnostic imaging modalities (radiography, ultrasound, CT, MRI) in the workup of suspected PJI, with special attention to the limitations and benefits of each modality. We will also discuss the role that image-guided interventions play in the workup of these patients, through ultrasound and fluoroscopically guided joint aspirations. While there is no standard imaging algorithm that can universally applied to all patients with suspected PJI, we will discuss a general approach to diagnostic imaging and image-guided intervention in this clinical scenario.

Synovial biopsies for molecular definition of rheumatoid arthritis and treatment response phenotyping: where can we improve?

INTRODUCTION

The extensive knowledge gained in the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) pathogenesis has led to therapeutic advances. However, up to 10-20% of patients fail to respond to multiple therapeutic agents being classified as multi-drugresistant. A key challenge moving forward will be the implementation of synovial biopsies in clinical practice to facilitate the shift from the current trial-and-error strategy toward new forms of clinical trials. Biomarker-driven trials have the potential to improve drug selection and patient stratification, reduce economic costs and unnecessary drug-related toxicity.

AREAS COVERED

This special report explores the clinical and research applications of synovial biopsy, the advancement in the molecular pathobiology of RA to better understand disease pathogenesis and treatment response, and the way forward for the paradigm shift needed.

EXPERT OPINION

In the current era of highly targeted biologic drugs which have dramatically transformed the outlook of RA patients, the use of synovial biopsy represents a valuable practical tool to dissect disease pathogenesis and, consequently, treatment response. In the near future, it is hoped that technological advances will allow for speeding up synovial molecular analysis and that the design of new biomarker-driven trials will enable the allocation of patients to more effective treatment.

Best practices for ultrasound-guided synovial biopsy in the United States

The target organ in many forms of inflammatory arthritis is the synovium. However, synovial tissue has historically been perceived as either difficult to obtain or of little practical value. Ultrasound-guided synovial biopsy [UGSB] is a safe and well-tolerated bedside procedure that is established in Europe and rapidly growing in popularity in the United States. The technique can be mastered by rheumatologists who are already experienced in ultrasound-guided procedures such as joint aspirations. The USGB procedure allows the proceduralist to access small, medium, and large joints and is inexpensive and less invasive compared to surgical alternatives. The relative ease of obtaining this tissue, along with recent research suggesting that synovium may have more clinical and investigational utility than previously thought, has led clinicians and researchers to a new appreciation of the role of synovial biopsy in both the clinical and research setting. In this manuscript, the authors present recommendations on best practices for ultrasound-guided synovial biopsy in the United States, based on our initial training with well-established experts overseas and our own subsequent collective experience in performing numerous synovial biopsies in the United States over the past 7 years for both clinical and research indications. We envision a future where UGSB is more frequently incorporated in the standard diagnostic workup of arthritis and drives novel research initiatives.

The Diagnostic and Prognostic Value of Synovial Fluid Analysis in Joint Diseases

Liquid biopsy is an emergent test method for the diagnosis and prognosis in the clinic. Joint fluid, also known as synovial fluid, contains a variety of bioactive constituents that can be selectively detected and further evaluated in a convenient fashion. Therefore, synovial fluid analysis functions as a specific form of liquid biopsy and plays a vital role in numerous joint diseases. In spite of the component analysis of aspirated synovial fluid beingconsidered as the gold standard for diagnosis of joint infections, biopsy of joint fluid benefits the initial diagnosis and long-term prognosis of degenerative, inflammatory, autoimmune, traumatic, congenital, and even neoplastic joint diseases. The convenience and accuracy for disease evaluation are significantly elevated as a result of the combination of synovial fluid analysis and other novel clinical technologies. In this review, we shed light on the latent role of synovial fluid in the diagnosis and prognosis of articular diseases and proposed future prospects for relevant research in this field.

Retrospective evaluation of 103 cases of septic arthritis in dogs

OBJECTIVE

This study examines inciting causes, diagnosis, treatment and risk factors for the recurrence and outcome of septic arthritis (SA) in dogs.

STUDY DESIGN

Medical records spanning 17 years from five referral hospitals were surveyed for presumptive and confirmed cases of SA.

RESULTS

SA was identified in 103 cases. Spontaneous septic SA was the most common inciting cause. The most commonly affected joints were the stifle (40%) and elbow (24%). Pre-existing osteoarthritis (OA) was present in 63% of septic joints and was associated with recurrence (p = 0.03). Treatment with antibiotics prior to presentation was associated with a negative synovial fluid culture (p = 0.014). A successful outcome was associated with early treatment (p = 0.001) and SA due to direct penetration (p = 0.04) or spontaneous cause (p = 0.003). Recurrence was more likely in dogs with unsuccessful outcomes (p = 0.004) and bodyweights >30 kg (p = 0.009).

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

SA should be considered as a differential diagnosis in large breed dogs with pre-existing OA presenting with either an acute or chronic monoarthropathy. In the majority of cases, a successful outcome was achieved regardless of treatment type. Recurrence rates were low, but associated with pre-existing OA and higher bodyweight. Although treatment should be implemented as soon as possible to maximise outcome success, synovial fluid samples should ideally be obtained before empiric antibiotic administration.

The Crucial Questions on Synovial Biopsy: When, Why, Who, What, Where, and How?

In the majority of joint diseases, changes in the organization of the synovial architecture appear early. Synovial tissue analysis might provide useful information for the diagnosis, especially in atypical and rare joint disorders, and might have a value in case of undifferentiated inflammatory arthritis, by improving disease classification. After patient selection, it is crucial to address the dialogue between the clinician and the pathologist for adequately handling the sample, allowing identifying histological patterns depending on the clinical suspicion. Moreover, synovial tissue analysis gives insight into disease progression helping patient stratification, by working as an actionable and mechanistic biomarker. Finally, it contributes to an understanding of joint disease pathogenesis holding promise for identifying new synovial biomarkers and developing new therapeutic strategies. All of the indications mentioned above are not so far from being investigated in everyday clinical practice in tertiary referral hospitals, thanks to the great feasibility and safety of old and more recent techniques such as ultrasound-guided needle biopsy and needle arthroscopy. Thus, even in rheumatology clinical practice, pathobiology might be a key component in the management and treatment decision-making process. This review aims to examine some essential and crucial points regarding why, when, where, and how to perform a synovial biopsy in clinical practice and research settings and what information you might expect after a proper patient selection.

Ultrasound-Guided Synovial Biopsy: A Review

Ultrasound-guided synovial biopsy is a safe, well-tolerated, and effective method to collect good-quality synovial tissue from all types of joints for clinical and research purposes. Although synovial biopsy cannot be used to distinguish between types of inflammatory rheumatic disease, analysis of synovial tissue has led to remarkable advances in the understanding of the pathobiology of rheumatoid arthritis and other inflammatory rheumatic diseases. Synovitis is the hallmark of these diseases; hence, accessing the core of the pathological process, synovial tissue, provides an opportunity to gather information with potential diagnostic and prognostic utility.

Bacterial Septic Arthritis of the Adult Native Knee Joint: A Review

» Acute bacterial septic arthritis of the knee is an orthopaedic emergency and, if left untreated, can result in substantial joint degradation. » Important risk factors for development of septic arthritis include age of >60 years, recent bacteremia, diabetes, cancer, cirrhosis, renal disease, drug or alcohol abuse, a history of corticosteroid injection, a recent injury or surgical procedure, a prosthetic joint, and a history of rheumatoid arthritis. » The diagnosis is primarily based on history and clinical presentation of a red, warm, swollen, and painful joint with limited range of motion. Laboratory values and inflammatory markers from serum and joint fluid may serve as adjuncts when there is clinical suspicion of septic arthritis. » The initial and general antibiotic regimen should cover methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and gram-negative and gram-positive organisms. The antibiotic regimen should be specified following the culture results of the infected joint. » Operative management involves either arthrotomy or arthroscopy of the knee with thorough irrigation and debridement of all infected tissue. The Gächter classification is useful in establishing a prognosis or in determining the need for an extensive debridement.

Synovial biopsies in clinical practice and research: current developments and perspectives

Synovial biopsy techniques have developed and widely expanded over the past few years, in particular due to the development of ultrasound-guided procedures. This article reviews the different techniques, clinical applications, and the latest advances in translational research as well as current challenges and perspectives. The first part focuses on different techniques available for biopsy, along with their feasibility, success rate, tolerance, and training requirements. In the second part, clinical applications are described. Data on diagnostic performances are reported, especially regarding septic arthritis. Translational research applications are described and explained in the final part, from the early histological studies and the first description of pathotype to more recent technologies involving -omics. Latest developments involving single-cell RNA sequence analysis have allowed the discovery of new cell subpopulations with remarkable roles in RA pathophysiology. These studies pave the ground for the discovery of new therapeutic targets and the implementation of personalized therapy in RA.

Key Point •This review provides an overview of synovial biopsy techinques and applications especially in clinical and translational research.

Primarily treated patients versus referred patients in the treatment of native septic arthritis of digits: a retrospective comparative study

BACKGROUND

Septic arthritis of digits needs urgent treatment. When treatments delayed or insufficient, patients may be referred to the upper-level hospital due to uncontrolled infection. We reviewed the treatment history of referred patients and compared the microorganisms and the clinical course of both primary and referred patients as relevant studies are rare.

METHODS

In this retrospective review of consecutive case series, 45 patients (primary, n = 11; referred, n = 34) were treated with multiple irrigation and debridement. Cefazolin was used as empiric antibiotics, then changed according to microbiologic study. Previously used antibiotics, treatment delay, surgical history of the referred patients were reviewed. Identified microorganisms, required surgical intervention, hospital stay, radiologic outcome, functional outcomes were compared between both groups.

RESULTS

In the referred patients, methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) was commonly found and cefazolin was susceptible in only 15% of the cases. Longer hospital stay, prolonged antibiotic therapy, more surgical intervention including flap surgery was required to treat the referred patients. Postoperative pain was not severe in daily activities, but the final range of motion was significantly less in the referred patients compared to the primary patients.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that in the treatment of uncontrolled septic arthritis of the digits, antibiotic agents covering MRSA may shorten the duration of antibiotic therapy in areas of high MRSA incidence. Besides, more number of I & D including flap surgery may be required for the referred patients compared with the primary patients. These findings can help the surgeon in setting up a treatment plan or in counseling of referred patients with uncontrolled septic arthritis of the digits.

Safety and tolerability of ultrasound-guided synovial needle biopsy in Japanese arthritis patients

OBJECTIVES

We sought to clarify the safety and tolerability of ultrasound (US)-guided synovial needle biopsy in hand and knee joints in Japanese arthritis patients.

METHODS

A total of nine consecutive arthritis patients were recruited and scheduled for US-guided synovial needle biopsies. Patients completed a safety questionnaire and patient-reported outcomes (PRO) data of joint pain, stiffness, and swelling pre- and postbiopsy. We also recorded patients' characteristics and willingness to undergo a second biopsy by the same technique. All synovial needle biopsy samples were assessed with pathological and microbial examination to verify whether clinical evaluation was possible.

RESULTS

Five and 4 patients underwent US-guided biopsy from hand and knee joints, respectively. PRO data showed no significant differences in pain, swelling, or stiffness levels before and after biopsy, with a mean 11.8 samples collected per procedure. No significant complications, including joint infection, bleeding, or vasovagal signs, were reported. Histologically adequate synovial tissue was identified in 83 (78%) samples. We were able to submit the biopsy samples to pathological and bacterial analysis to exclude septic arthritis.

CONCLUSION

We demonstrated that a minimally invasive US-guided needle biopsy is a safe and well-tolerated procedure and the synovial tissue collected was of adequate quality for pathological analysis.

Septic Arthritis: An Evidence-Based Review of Diagnosis and Image-Guided Aspiration

OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this evidence-based review is to equip radiologists to discuss and interpret findings obtained with various imaging modalities, guide patient selection for percutaneous aspiration, and safely perform arthrocentesis to assess for infection in both native and prosthetic joints. CONCLUSION. Septic arthritis is an emergency that can lead to rapidly progressive, irreversible joint damage. Despite the urgency associated with this diagnosis, there remains a lack of consensus regarding many aspects of the management of native and periprosthetic joint infections.

2020 French recommendations on the management of septic arthritis in an adult native joint

Septic arthritis (SA) in an adult native joint is a rare condition but a diagnostic emergency due to the morbidity and mortality and the functional risk related to structural damage. Current management varies and the recommendations available are dated. The French Rheumatology Society (SFR) Bone and Joint Infection Working Group, together with the French Language Infectious Diseases Society (SPILF) and the French Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery Society (SOFCOT) have worked according to the HAS methodology to devise clinical practice recommendations to diagnose and treat SA in an adult native joint. One new focus is on the importance of microbiological documentation (blood cultures and joint aspiration) before starting antibiotic treatment, looking for differential diagnoses (microcrystal detection), the relevance of a joint ultrasound to guide aspiration, and the indication to perform a reference X-ray. A cardiac ultrasound is indicated only in cases of SA involving Staphylococcus aureus, oral streptococci, Streptococcus gallolyticus or Enterococcus faecalis, or when infective endocarditis is clinically suspected. Regarding treatment, we stress the importance of medical and surgical collaboration. Antibiotic therapies (drugs and durations) are presented in the form of didactic tables according to the main bacteria in question (staphylococci, streptococci and gram-negative rods). Probabilistic antibiotic therapy should only be used for patients with serious symptoms. Lastly, non-drug treatments such as joint drainage and early physical therapy are the subject of specific recommendations.

Synovial Tissue Biopsy Collection by Rheumatologists: Ready for Clinical Implementation?

Synovial tissue from arthritis patients is increasingly used for both basic pathophysiological and clinical translational research. This development has been spurred by the development of biotechnological techniques for analysis of complex tissues and the validation of ultrasound guided biopsies for easier tissue sampling. This increasing use of synovial tissue raises questions on standardization of methodologies for tissue processing and cellular & molecular analyses. Furthermore, it raises the question if synovial tissue biopsy analysis may be more widely implemented in clinical practice, what are the methodological hurdles for implementation and what are the lessons that can be learned from previous experience. This will be the focus of this review.

Clinical Applications of Synovial Biopsy

The synovial tissue is a primary target of multiple diseases characterized by different pathogenic mechanisms, including infective, deposition, neoplastic, and chronic immune-inflammatory pathologies. Synovial biopsy can have a relevant role in differential diagnosis of specific conditions in clinical practice, although its exploitation remains relatively limited. In particular, no validated synovial-tissue-derived biomarkers are currently available in the clinic to aid in the diagnosis and management in most frequent forms of chronic inflammatory arthropathies, namely rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and the spondyloarthritides (SpA). In this brief review, we will discuss the current spectrum of clinical applications of synovial biopsy in routine rheumatologic care and will provide an analysis of the perspectives for its potential exploitation in patients with chronic inflammatory arthritides.

Efficacy of Integrating a Novel 16-Gene Biomarker Panel and Intelligence Classifiers for Differential Diagnosis of Rheumatoid Arthritis and Osteoarthritis

Introducing novel biomarkers for accurately detecting and differentiating rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and osteoarthritis (OA) using clinical samples is essential. In the current study, we searched for a novel data-driven gene signature of synovial tissues to differentiate RA from OA patients. Fifty-three RA, 41 OA, and 25 normal microarray-based transcriptome samples were utilized. The area under the curve random forests (RF) variable importance measurement was applied to seek the most influential differential genes between RA and OA. Five algorithms including RF, k-nearest neighbors (kNN), support vector machines (SVM), naïve-Bayes, and a tree-based method were employed for the classification. We found a 16-gene signature that could effectively differentiate RA from OA, including TMOD1, POP7, SGCA, KLRD1, ALOX5, RAB22A, ANK3, PTPN3, GZMK, CLU, GZMB, FBXL7, TNFRSF4, IL32, MXRA7, and CD8A. The externally validated accuracy of the RF model was 0.96 (sensitivity = 1.00, specificity = 0.90). Likewise, the accuracy of kNN, SVM, naïve-Bayes, and decision tree was 0.96, 0.96, 0.96, and 0.91, respectively. Functional meta-analysis exhibited the differential pathological processes of RA and OA; suggested promising targets for further mechanistic and therapeutic studies. In conclusion, the proposed genetic signature combined with sophisticated classification methods may improve the diagnosis and management of RA patients.