Persistent orthostatic headache without intracranial hypotension: which treatment?

Cerebrospinal Fluid Refill Test as a Novel Diagnostic Tool for Cerebrospinal Fluid Hypovolemia: Preliminary Result

OBJECTIVE

Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) hypovolemia presents with orthostatic headaches due to CSF leakage. However, a direct association between the lack of CSF and clinical symptoms has not been found. CSF hypovolemia can be improved by refilling CSF. Therefore, we assessed the validity of a CSF refill test.

METHODS

From November 2019 to August 2021, we included 10 patients (≥18 years old) with potential CSF hypovolemia, clear orthostatic headaches, and a CSF opening pressure <10 cmH₂O. In the CSF refill test, 10 mL of artificial CSF was injected intrathecally. The primary outcome was improvement in orthostatic headache assessed using a visual analog scale (VAS), while the secondary outcomes were the 10-m walk time and adverse events. When the symptoms temporarily improved after intrathecal injection, the patients underwent radiologic imaging to identify the CSF leak, and an epidural blood patch was proposed accordingly.

RESULTS

All patients showed post-test improvements in the VAS score (median [interquartile range], pretest 63.0 [50.3-74.3] vs. post-test 1.5 [0.0-26.0]). The 10-m walk time also significantly improved (9.5 [8.5-10.2] s vs. 8.2 [7.9-8.7] s). One patient experienced temporary right leg numbness associated with a lumbar puncture. After radiologic investigation, 9 patients underwent epidural blood patches, of which 6 were completely cured, and 3 revealed partial improvement.

CONCLUSIONS

The cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) refill test was safe and effective in demonstrating the direct association between the lack of CSF and clinical symptoms and may help predict the outcome of an epidural blood patch.

Update on "Treatment of orthostatic headache without intracranial hypotension: A case report" - nine years later

BACKGROUND

In 2013, one of the authors described a 36-year-old female with orthostatic headache without documented intracranial hypotension or evidence of cerebrospinal fluid leak, despite extensive workup. Headache was unresponsive to conservative treatment since 2010, showed only transient benefit after repeated epidural blood patches while vitamin A supplementation resulted in progressive improvement.

CASE

Since 2013, the patient followed a relapsing and remitting course yet relapse control became difficult after a drug induced liver injury required vitamin A discontinuation in 2017, when her headache became chronic. Greater occipital nerve blocks provided pain relief as alternative but were stopped due to the pandemic and her latest severe relapse, in late 2020, required not only restarting anaesthetic blocks and aggressive medication management, but also reassessing and treating comorbidities (obstructive sleep apnoea and major depressive disorder) with modest benefit.

CONCLUSION

Orthostatic headache without intracranial hypotension is rare, with only 28 cases reported so far, all treated empirically and all treatment options revealing to be mostly ineffective. Vitamin A anecdotally appeared to be useful in our case but had to be stopped for severe side effects, so unfavourable long-term prognosis, in ours and 2/3 of the reported cases, seems to be the rule in this intriguing entity.