Physiological and transcriptomic analyses of a yellow-green mutant with high photosynthetic efficiency in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)

Thylakoid ultrastructural variations in chlorophyll-deficient wheat: aberrations or structural acclimation?

MAIN CONCLUSION

A structural re-modeling of the thylakoid system, including granum size and regularity, occurs in chlorophyll-deficient wheat mutants affected by photosynthetic membrane over-reduction. In the chloroplast of land plants, the thylakoid system is defined by appressed grana stacks and unstacked stroma lamellae. This study focuses on the variations of the grana organization occurring in outdoor-grown wheat mutants characterized by low chlorophyll content and a tendency for photosynthetic membrane over-reduction. Triticum aestivum ANK-32A and Triticum durum ANDW-7B were compared to their corresponding WT lines, NS67 and LD222, respectively. Electron micrographs of chloroplasts were used to calculate grana ultrastructural parameters. Photosynthetic parameters were obtained by modulated chlorophyll fluorescence and applying Light Curves (LC) and Rapid Light Curves (RLC) protocols. For each photosynthetic parameter, the difference Δ(RLC-LC) was calculated to evaluate the flexible response to light in the examined lines. In the mutants, fewer and smaller disks formed grana stacks characterized by a marked increase in lateral and cross-sectional irregularity, both negatively correlated with the number of layers per granum. A relationship was found between membrane over-reduction and granum structural irregularity. The possible acclimative significance of a greater proportion of stroma-exposed grana domains in relieving the excess electron pressure on PSI is discussed.

Mechanism of growth inhibition mediated by disorder of chlorophyll metabolism in rice (Oryza sativa) under the stress of three polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

Photosynthesis mediated by chlorophyll metabolism is the basis for plant growth, and also the important regulatory mechanism of carbon pool in cropland ecosystems. Soil organic pollutants induced growth inhibition in crop plants, herein, we conducted an in-depth investigation on the effects of three representative polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), including phenanthrene (PHE), pyrene (PYR), and benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) on rice (Oryza sativa) growth and photosynthesis. PAHs were absorbed via root uptake and accumulated in leaves, causing the swelling of thylakoids and the increase of osmiophilic granules in chloroplasts. The actual quantum efficiency of PSII was significantly decreased under the stress of PHE, PYR, and BaP by 29.9%, 11.9%, and 24.1% respectively, indicating the inhibition in photon absorption and transfer, which was consistent with the decrease of chlorophyll a (22.3%-32.2% compared to the control) in rice leaves. Twenty-two encoding genes involved in chlorophyll metabolism were determined and the results indicated that the expression of chlorophyll synthetases was downregulated by over 50% whereas the degradation process was promoted. Consequently, the production of carbohydrates and the carbon fixation were inhibited, which revealed by the downregulation of intermediate metabolites in Calvin cycle and the declined carboxylation rate. The disturbed photosynthesis resulted in the decrease of the biomasses of both roots (21.0%-42.7%) and leaves (6.4%-22.1%) under the tested PAH stresses. The findings of this study implied that the photosynthetic inhibition was possibly attributed to the disorder of chlorophyll metabolism, thus providing novel insights into the mechanism of growth inhibition induced by organic pollutants and theoretical basis for the estimation of cropland carbon sequestration potential.

Long-Term Alleviation of the Functional Phenotype in Chlorophyll-Deficient Wheat and Impact on Productivity: A Semi-Field Phenotyping Experiment

Wheat mutants with a reduced chlorophyll synthesis are affected by a defective control of the photosynthetic electron flow, but tend to recover a wild-type phenotype. The sensitivity of some mutants to light fluctuations suggested that cultivation outdoors could significantly impact productivity. Six mutant lines of Triticum durum or Triticum aestivum with their respective wild-type cultivars were cultivated with a regular seasonal cycle (October-May) in a semi-field experiment. Leaf chlorophyll content and fluorescence parameters were analysed at the early (November) and late (May) developmental stages, and checked for correlation with morphometric and grain-production parameters. The alleviation of the phenotype severity concerned primarily the recovery of the photosynthetic-membrane functionality, but not the leaf chlorophyll content. Photosystem II (PSII) was less photoprotected in the mutants, but a moderate PSII photoinhibition could help control the electron flow into the chain. The accumulation of interchain electron carriers was a primary acclimative response towards the naturally fluctuating environment, maximally exploited by the mature durum-wheat mutants. The mutation itself and/or the energy-consuming compensatory mechanisms markedly influenced the plant morphogenesis, leading especially to reduced tillering, which in turn resulted in lower grain production per plant. Consistently with the interrelation between early photosynthetic phenotype and grain-yield per plant, chlorophyll-fluorescence indexes related to the level of photoprotective thermal dissipation (pNPQ), photosystem II antenna size (ABS/RC), and pool of electron carriers (Sm) are proposed as good candidates for the in-field phenotyping of chlorophyll-deficient wheat.

Fast chlorophyll a fluorescence induction (OJIP) phenotyping of chlorophyll-deficient wheat suggests that an enlarged acceptor pool size of Photosystem I helps compensate for a deregulated photosynthetic electron flow

The wheat lines affected by a decrease in the leaf chlorophyll content typically experience a biomass loss. A known major problem of the chlorophyll-deficient wheat mutants is their limited prevention of Photosystem I (PSI) over-reduction brought about by an insufficient cyclic electron flow, potentially exposing them to a higher sensitivity to light fluctuations. However, the resistance of some mutant lines against fluctuating light suggests the occurrence of regulatory processes compensating for the defect in cyclic electron flow. In this study, a phenotyping approach based on fast chlorophyll a fluorescence induction (OJIP transient), corroborated by P700 redox kinetics, was applied to a collection of chlorophyll-deficient wheat lines, grown under continuous or fluctuating light. Quantitative parameters calculated from the OJIP transient are considered informative about Photosystem II (PSII) functional antenna size and photochemistry, as well as the functioning of the entire photosynthetic electron transport chain. The mutants tended to recover a wild-type-like chlorophyll content, and mature plants could hardly be distinguished based on their effective PSII antenna size. Nevertheless, specific OJIP-derived parameters were strongly correlated with the phenotype severity, in particular the amplitude of the I-P phase and the I-P/J-P amplitude ratio, which are indicative of a more capacitive pool of PSI final electron acceptors (ferredoxin and ferredoxin-NADP⁺ oxidoreductase, FNR). We propose that the enlargement of such pool of electron carriers is a compensatory response operating at the acceptor side of PSI to alleviate potentially harmful over-reduced states of PSI. Our results also suggest that, in chlorophyll-deficient mutants, higher F_V /F_M cannot prove a superior PSII photochemistry and wider I-P phase is not indicative of a higher relative content of PSI.

Effects of reduced chlorophyll content on photosystem functions and photosynthetic electron transport rate in rice leaves

To elucidate the photosynthetic performance of rice mutant with low chlorophyll content, we assessed light energy conversion and photosynthetic electron transport at the flowering stage in rice of yellow-green leaf mutant (ygl) and a control with normal pigment content (IR36) under field conditions. The results showed that the reduced chlorophyll content and high expression levels of chlorophyll-binding protein genes suggested that ygl has smaller light-harvesting chlorophyll antennae. The small chlorophyll antenna size reduced non-photochemical quenching (NPQ) and generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS), and increased PSII efficiency in ygl. Analysis of the chlorophyll a fluorescence transient showed that the higher ratio of reaction-center chlorophylls and the total chlorophyll of PSII (γ_RC) improved excitation energy capture and electron transport efficiency of PSII in ygl. The IP amplitude (ΔV_IP) and the reduction rates of the pool of end electron acceptors in ygl increased, compared with IR36. These results suggest that the light absorbed by the mutant with reduced chlorophyll content was more efficiently partitioned to photosynthesis and could be used to improve photosynthetic efficiency.

Occurrence of albinism during wheat androgenesis is correlated with repression of the key genes required for proper chloroplast biogenesis

The phenomenon of albinism in wheat androgenesis is linked to the transcriptional repression of specific genes involved in chloroplast biogenesis during the first weeks of in vitro culture. Isolated microspore culture is widely used to accelerate breeding programs and produce new cultivars. However, in cereals and particularly in wheat, the use of this technique is limited due to the high proportion of regenerated albino plantlets. The causes and mechanisms leading to the formation of albino plantlets in wheat remain largely unknown and, to date, no concrete solution has been found to make it possible to overcome this barrier. We performed a molecular study of proplastid-to-chloroplast differentiation within wheat microspore cultures by analyzing the expression of 20 genes specifically involved in chloroplast biogenesis. Their expression levels were compared between two wheat genotypes that exhibit differential capacities to regenerate green plantlets, i.e., Pavon and Paledor, which produce high and low rates of green plants, respectively. We observed that chloroplast biogenesis within wheat microspores was affected as of the very early stages of the androgenesis process. A successful transition from a NEP- to a PEP-dependent transcription during early plastid development was found to be strongly correlated with the formation of green plantlets, while failure of this transition was strongly correlated with the regeneration of albino plantlets. The very low expression of plastid-encoded 16S and 23S rRNAs within plastids of the recalcitrant genotype Paledor suggests a low translation activity in albino plastids. Furthermore, a delay in the activation of the transcription of nuclear encoded key genes like GLK1 related to chloroplast biogenesis was observed in multicellular structures and pro-embryos of the genotype Paledor. These data help to understand the phenomenon of albinism in wheat androgenesis, which appears to be linked to the transcriptional activation of specific genes involved in the initial steps of chloroplast biogenesis that occurs between days 7 and 21 of in vitro culture.

Natural variations of BrHISN2 provide a genetic basis for growth-flavour trade-off in different Brassica rapa subspecies

Selection for yield during B. rapa breeding may have unintended consequences for other traits, such as flavour. LYH-type (light yellow head) Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa ssp. pekinensis) and wucai (Brassica rapa L. ssp. chinensis var. rosularis) varieties are becoming popular because of their unique flavour and yellow leaves. However, the molecular mechanism underlying the interplay for these traits remains unknown. We conducted a fine mapping and genome-wide exploration analysis of the leaf yellowing of LYH and wucai, including transgenic plants, to identify causal genes. We identified that BrHISN2, a rate-limiting enzyme in histidine biosynthesis, causes leaf yellowing by destroying LYH chloroplasts. Normal growing Brhisn2 mutant plants became etiolated and senesced at the cotyledon-seedling stage. Sequence variations in the promoter confers cold-dependent expression on BrHISN2, probably resulting in leaf yellowing in LYH and wucai. Insertions of two DRE cis elements and the subsequent recruitment of two CBF2 proteins by the DREs to the promoter provided the cold-induced expression plasticity of BrHISN2 in plants. Both LYH and wucai are farmed in the fall, in which the temperature gradually decreases, therefore the CBF2-BrHISN2 module probably maximises the benefits of gene-environment interaction for breeding. We determined the mechanistic connections of chlorophyll synthesis and the growth-flavour trade-off in these B. rapa varieties.

Mesophyll conductance, photoprotective process and optimal N partitioning are essential to the maintenance of photosynthesis at N deficient condition in a wheat yellow-green mutant (Triticum aestivum L.)

The major effect of nitrogen (N) deficiency is the inhibition on CO₂ assimilation regulated by light energy absorption, transport and conversion, as well as N allocation. In this study, a yellow-green wheat mutant (Jimai5265yg) and its wild type (Jimai5265, WT) were compared between 0 mM N (N₀) and 14 mM N (N₁₄) treatments using hydroponic experiments. The mutant exhibited higher photosynthetic efficiency (A_n) than WT despite low chlorophyll (Chl) content in non-stressed conditions. The photosynthetic advantages of the mutant were maintained under N deficient condition. The quantitative analysis of limitations to photosynthesis revealed that CO₂ diffusion associated with mesophyll conductance (g_m) was the dominant limitation. Relative easiness to gain CO₂ in the chloroplast contributed to the higher A_n of Jimai5265yg. N deficiency induced the photoinhibition of PSII, but the cyclic electron transport and photochemical activity of PSI was higher in Jimai5265yg compared to Jimai5265, which was a protective mechanism to avoid photodamage. Because of the sharp drop of A_n, N deficient seedlings had much lower photosynthetic N use efficiency (PNUE). However, N deficiency increased the relative content of photosynthetic N (N_psn) and decreased the relative content of storage N (N_store). The range of change in N partitioning induced by N deficiency was smaller for Jimai5265yg compared to WT. The less insensitive to N deficiency for the mutant in terms of photosynthetic property and N partitioning suggested that g_m, cyclic electron transport around PSI and more optimal N partitioning pattern is necessary to sustain photosynthesis under N deficient condition.

Comparative transcriptome analysis of differentially expressed genes related to the physiological changes of yellow-green leaf mutant of maize

Chlorophylls, green pigments in chloroplasts, are essential for photosynthesis. Reduction in chlorophyll content may result in retarded growth, dwarfism, and sterility. In this study, a yellow-green leaf mutant of maize, indicative of abnormity in chlorophyll content, was identified. The physiological parameters of this mutant were measured. Next, global gene expression of this mutant was determined using transcriptome analysis and compared to that of wild-type maize plants. The yellow-green leaf mutant of maize was found to contain lower contents of chlorophyll a, chlorophyll b and carotenoid compounds. It contained fewer active PSII centers and displayed lower values of original chlorophyll fluorescence parameters than the wild-type plants. The real-time fluorescence yield, the electron transport rate, and the net photosynthetic rate of the mutant plants showed reduction as well. In contrast, the maximum photochemical quantum yield of PSII of the mutant plants was similar to that of the wild-type plants. Comparative transcriptome analysis of the mutant plants and wild-type plants led to the identification of differentially expressed 1,122 genes, of which 536 genes were up-regulated and 586 genes down-regulated in the mutant. Five genes in the chlorophyll metabolism pathway, nine genes in the tricarboxylic acid cycle and seven genes related to the conversion of sucrose to starch displayed down-regulated expression. In contrast, genes encoding a photosystem II reaction center PsbP family protein and the PGR5-like protein 1A (PGRL1A) exhibited increased transcript abundance.

Agave angustifolia albino plantlets lose stomatal physiology function by changing the development of the stomatal complex due to a molecular disruption

Stomatal development is regulated by signaling pathways that function in multiple cellular programs, including cell fate and cell division. However, recent studies suggest that molecular signals are affected by CO₂ concentration, light intensity, and water pressure deficit, thereby modifying distribution patterns and stomatic density and likely other foliar features as well. Here, we show that in addition to lacking chloroplasts, the albino somaclonal variants of Agave angustifolia Haw present an irregular epidermal development and morphological abnormalities of the stomatal complex, affecting the link between the stomatal conductance, transpiration and photosynthesis, as well as the development of the stoma in the upper part of the leaves. In addition, we show that changes in the transcriptional levels of SPEECHLESS (SPCH), TOO MANY MOUTHS (TMM), MITOGEN-ACTIVATED PROTEIN KINASE 4 and 6 (MAPK4 and MAPK6) and FOUR LIPS (FLP), all from the meristematic tissue and leaf, differentially modulate the stomatal function between the green, variegated and albino in vitro plantlets of A. angustifolia. Likewise, we highlight the conservation of microRNAs miR166 and miR824 as part of the regulation of AGAMOUS-LIKE16 (AGL16), recently associated with the control of cell divisions that regulate the development of the stomatal complex. We propose that molecular alterations happening in albino cells formed from the meristematic base can lead to different anomalies during the transition and specification of the stomatal cell state in leaf development of albino plantlets. We conclude that the molecular alterations in the meristematic cells in albino plants might be the main variable associated with stoma distribution in this phenotype.

Phenotyping of isogenic chlorophyll-less bread and durum wheat mutant lines in relation to photoprotection and photosynthetic capacity

In our experiments, we examined high light responses and photosynthetic capacity of chlorophyll-less isogenic mutant lines of hexaploid bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) and tetraploid durum wheat (Triticum durum L.) in comparison to parental lines representing the wild type (WT), in two growth phases and two environments. In young plants, we observed a typical yellow-green phenotype with low chlorophyll content, significantly lower CO₂ assimilation rate, elevated chlorophyll a-to-b ratio and insufficient regulation of linear electron transport. In the mutants grown in a moderate light in the growth chamber, a typical "chlorina" phenotype almost disappeared or, at least, was significantly alleviated in later growth stages, including the values of CO₂ assimilation and the majority of the measured parameters related to photoprotective responses. On the other hand, in the case of the mutant lines grown in direct sunlight and fluctuating environment, the chlorophyll-less phenotype was evident also in latter growth phases. The chlorophyll-less phenotype was more severe in the durum wheat mutant lines compared to the bread wheat. For example, the durum wheat mutant lines grown outdoors expressed lower flexibility of photoprotective responses, including lower non-photochemical quenching and low rate of cyclic electron flow compared to WT or bread wheat mutants. Based on the analyses, we have identified a set of parameters providing information on the specific photosynthetic traits typical for the chlorophyll-less phenotype. Thus, the proposed way of phenotyping may serve for efficient selection of mutant genotypes for future research or screening activities. As a general result, we observed that the decrease of the chlorophyll content due to mutation was always associated with improper regulation of linear electron transport and a limited ability to prevent over-reduction of PSI acceptor side, regardless of the genotype, environment, and growth stage. This can partly explain why the low chlorophyll mutants were not successful in the evolution of higher plants, despite the photosynthetic capacity observed is high enough and they are fully competitive with wild-type plants in non-fluctuating controlled environment.