Hemispherectomy: a schematic review of the current techniques

Outcome after hemispherotomy in patients with intractable epilepsy: Comparison of techniques in the Italian experience

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to evaluate clinical characteristics and outcome of hemispherotomy in children and adolescents with hemispheric refractory epilepsy in an Italian cohort of patients.

METHODS

We retrospectively evaluated the clinical course and outcome of 92 patients with refractory epilepsy who underwent hemispherotomy in three Italian epilepsy centers between 2006 and 2016. Three different approaches for hemispherotomy were used: parasagittal, modified parasagittal, and lateral.

RESULTS

Mean age at epilepsy onset was 1.8 ± 2.51 years, and mean duration of epilepsy prior to surgery was 7.4 ± 5.6 years. Mean age at surgery was 9.2 ± 8.0 years. After a mean follow-up of 2.81 ± 2.4 years, 66 of 90 patients (two lost from follow-up, 73.3%) were seizure-free (Engel class I). The etiology of epilepsy was related to acquired lesions (encephalomalacia or gliosis) in 44 patients (47.8%), congenital malformations (cortical dysplasia, hemimegalencephaly, other cortical malformations) in 38 (41.3%), and progressive conditions (Rasmussen or Sturge-Weber syndrome) in 10 patients (10.9%). Regarding seizure outcome, we could not identify statistically significant differences between vertical and lateral approaches (p = 0.154). Seizure outcome was not statistically different in patients with congenital vs acquired or progressive etiologies (p = 0.43). Acute postoperative seizures (APOS) correlated with poor outcome (p < 0.05). On multivariate analysis, presurgical focal to bilateral tonic-clonic seizures (Odds Ratio (OR) = 3.63, 95% Confidence Interval (CI): 1.86-15.20, p = 0.048) independently predicted seizure recurrence. Twenty-one patients (22.8%) exhibited postoperative complications, with no unexpected and persistent neurological deficit. More than 50% of the patients completely tapered drugs.

SIGNIFICANCE

Our data confirm hemispherotomy to be a safe and effective procedure in patients with drug resistant epilepsies due to hemispheric lesions. Presurgical focal to bilateral tonic-clonic seizures are the strongest predictor of seizure recurrence after surgery, independently from the type of hemispherotomy.

Neural Substrates of Blindsight After Hemispherectomy

Blindsight is a visual phenomenon whereby hemianopic patients are able to process visual information in their blind visual field without awareness. Previous research demonstrating the existence of blindsight in hemianopic patients has been criticized for the nature of the paradigms used, for the presence of methodological artifacts, and for the possibility that spared islands of visual cortex may have sustained the phenomenon because the patients generally had small circumscribed lesions. To respond to these criticisms, the authors have been investigating for several years now residual visual abilities in the blind field of hemispherectomized patients in whom a whole cerebral hemisphere has been removed or disconnected from the rest of the brain. These patients have offered a unique opportunity to establish the existence of blindsight and to investigate its underlying neuronal mechanisms because in these cases, spared islands of visual cortex cannot be evoked to explain the presence of visual abilities in the blind field. In addition, the authors have been using precise behavioral paradigms, strict control for potential methodological artifacts such as light scatter, fixation, criterion effects, and macular sparing, and they have utilized new neuroimaging techniques such as diffusion tensor imaging tractography to enhance their understanding of the phenomenon. The following article is a review of their research on the involvement of the superior colliculi in blindsight in hemispherectomized patients. NEUROSCIENTIST 13(5):506—518, 2007.

Hemispheric surgery for refractory epilepsy: a systematic review and meta-analysis with emphasis on seizure predictors and outcomes

OBJECT

Conflicting conclusions have been reported regarding several factors that may predict seizure outcomes after hemispheric surgery for refractory epilepsy. The goal of this study was to identify the possible predictors of seizure outcome by pooling the rates of postoperative seizure freedom found in the published literature.

METHODS

A comprehensive literature search of PubMed, Embase, and the Cochrane Library identified English-language articles published since 1970 that describe seizure outcomes in patients who underwent hemispheric surgery for refractory epilepsy. Two reviewers independently assessed article eligibility and extracted the data. The authors pooled rates of seizure freedom from papers included in the study. Eight potential prognostic variables were identified and dichotomized for analyses. The authors also compared continuous variables within seizure-free and seizure-recurrent groups. Random- or fixed-effects models were used in the analyses depending on the presence or absence of heterogeneity.

RESULTS

The pooled seizure-free rate among the 1528 patients (from 56 studies) who underwent hemispheric surgery was 73%. Patients with an epilepsy etiology of developmental disorders, generalized seizures, nonlateralization on electroencephalography, and contralateral MRI abnormalities had reduced odds of being seizure-free after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Hemispheric surgery is an effective therapeutic modality for medically intractable epilepsy. This meta-analysis provides useful evidence-based information for the selection of candidates for hemispheric surgery, presurgical counseling, and explanation of seizure outcomes.

Hemispherotomy in Rasmussen encephalitis: long-term outcome in an Italian series of 16 patients

Surgical disconnection of the affected hemisphere is considered the treatment of choice for Rasmussen encephalitis (RE), however few data on long-term outcomes after disconnective surgery are available. We report on long-term seizure, cognitive and motor outcomes after disconnective surgery in 16 (8 M, 8 F) RE patients. Pre- and post-operative evaluations included long-term video-EEG monitoring, MRI, assessment of motor function, and cognitive evaluation. Hemispherotomy, by various techniques was used to obtain functional disconnection of the affected hemisphere. The patients, of median current age 23.5 years, range 12-33, were operated on between 1993 and 2009. Median age at disease onset was 5.8 years (range 3-11.4). Median time from seizure onset to surgery was 3.8 years, range 8 months to 21 years. Post-surgical follow-up was a median of 9.5 years, range 3-20. At surgery all patients were receiving two or more antiepileptic drugs (AEDs). All but three patients were seizure-free at latest follow-up. AEDs had been stopped in ten patients; in the remaining six AEDs were markedly reduced. Postural control improved in all patients. Gain in cognitive functioning was significantly (p=0.002) related to disease duration. The long-term outcomes, in terms of seizure control, motor improvement, and cognitive improvement provide important support for disconnective surgery as first choice treatment for RE.

Rasmussen's encephalitis presenting as focal cortical dysplasia

Rasmussen's encephalitis is a rare syndrome characterized by intractable seizures, often associated with epilepsia partialis continua and symptoms of progressive hemispheric dysfunction. Seizures are usually the hallmark of presentation, but antiepileptic drug treatment fails in most patients and is ineffective against epilepsia partialis continua, which often requires surgical intervention. Co-occurrence of focal cortical dysplasia has only rarely been described and may have implications regarding pathophysiology and management. We describe a rare case of dual pathology of Rasmussen's encephalitis presenting as a focal cortical dysplasia (FCD) and discuss the literature on this topic.

Ipsilateral and contralateral auditory brainstem response reorganization in hemispherectomized patients

Background. Cortical hemispherectomy leads to degeneration of ipsilateral subcortical structures, which can be observed long term after the operation. Therefore, reorganization of the brainstem auditory pathway might occur. The aim of this study was to assess reorganization of brainstem auditory pathways by measuring the auditory brainstem response (ABR) in long-term hemispherectomized patients. Methods. We performed bilateral monaural stimulation and measured bilateral ABR in 8 patients ~20 years after hemispherectomy and 10 control subjects. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed in patients to assess structural degeneration. Results. All patients showed degenerated ipsilateral brainstem structures by MRI but no significant differences in bilateral recording ABR wave latencies. However, nonsurgical-side stimulation elicited significantly longer wave V latencies compared to surgical-side stimulation. Differences in bilateral ABR were observed between hemispherectomized patients and control subjects. Waves III and V latencies elicited by nonsurgical-side stimulation were significantly longer than those in control subjects; surgical-side stimulation showed no significant differences. Conclusions. (1) Differences in ABR latency elicited by unilateral stimulation are predominantly due to bilateral brainstem auditory pathway activity rather than to changes in brainstem volume; (2) ABR Waves III and V originate predominantly in the contralateral brainstem; and (3) subcortical auditory pathways appear to reorganize after long term hemispherectomy.

[Seizure outcomes of cerebral hemispherectomy in adults: A systematic review and individual patient data meta-analysis]

OBJECTIVE

The objective of our study was to determine the seizure control rate of cerebral hemispherectomies in adult patients with drug-resistant epilepsy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A systematic review and individual patient data meta-analysis was carried out. Seven international databases and scientific meeting proceedings were reviewed. Individual patient data were analysed to establish potential factors associated with postoperative seizure control.

RESULTS

Eight articles that satisfied the pre-established selection criteria were identified. After a median follow-up of 70 months (interquartile range, 29-175.5), 79.4% of patients remained seizure-free. There were no statistically significant differences in age at onset of epilepsy, duration of epilepsy, age at surgery, time of follow-up, gender, surgical-laterality, aetiology and ictal EEG abnormalities between seizure-free patients and those with recurrences.

CONCLUSIONS

Cerebral hemispherectomy has a high seizure control rate in adult patients with drug-resistant epilepsy. None of the variables analysed in the present study were associated with surgical success.

Hemispherectomy in adults patients with severe unilateral epilepsy and hemiplegia

OBJECTIVES

To study postoperative seizure control of hemispherectomy in adults with epilepsy and evaluate changes of movement and speech function, intelligence quotient (IQ) and quality of life (QOL) after hemispherectomy.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed 25 adults who presented severe unilateral epilepsy and hemiplegia and underwent anatomic or functional hemispherectomy in between 2006 and 2011. Surgical outcomes, including seizure-control at last follow-up, changes of aphasia quotient, hemiplegic side motor function, IQ and QOL from pre-operative to 2 years follow-up, were investigated. Results were statistically analyzed with SPSS 18.0.

RESULTS

Nine functional hemispherectomies and 16 anatomic hemispherectomies were performed. Ninety-two percent of patients were seizure-free and 8% displayed Engel II grade seizure control after the procedure. Impaired movement function was present in 9 (36%) adults' upper limbs and 5 (20%) patients' lower limbs. The patients with age at seizure onset <3 years showed improvement in mean motor function of the upper limbs. Impaired speech was seen in 7 patients with left hemispherectomies. There was an overall improvement in the mean aphasia quotient and significant difference was found in amount of change in aphasia quotients between patients with different ages of onset. All of the patients' postoperative scores of overall QOL, full IQ, verbal IQ and performance IQ improved compared with pretreatment scores and those improvements were not associated with patient's age at seizure onset or surgical approach. However, significant difference was found in change of verbal IQ between patients with right hemispherectomies and those with left hemispherectomies. Surgical complications included a single case of hydrocephalus, and 6 transient complications.

CONCLUSIONS

Hemispherectomy presented good seizure control and improvement in QOL and IQ, and impairment on motor and speech function were mild. Furthermore, patients with early seizure onset could maintain movement function of upper limb and speech function improvement. Therefore, it is worth pursuing hemispherectomy in well-selected adults with severe unilateral epilepsy and hemiplegia.

Cortex mapping of ipsilateral somatosensory area following anatomical hemispherectomy: a MEG study

A remarkable preservation of sensorimotor function is observed in patients with refractory epilepsy who were treated by hemispherectomy. Cortical regions in the remaining hemisphere or contralateral subcortical region contribute to the residual sensorimotor function. Somatosensory evoked field (SEF) is used to investigate the residual sensory function in hemispherectomized patients. The SEFs are usually recorded with magnetoencephalography (MEG). The objective is to investigate the ipsilateral cortical regions associated with residual sensory function in hemispherectomized patients using somatosensory evoked field techniques. Six patients with anatomical hemispherectomy were included. Ipsilateral and contralateral sensory functions were assessed by physical examination. Somatosensory evoked fields to electrical stimulation of the bilateral median nerves were recorded by MEG in the hemispherectomized patients and six control subjects. The stimulus intensity was adjusted to the minimum threshold that elicited a thumb twitch. The presumed neuronal source was identified as the equivalent current dipole. Six patients demonstrated different degrees of residual sensory function. Three patients had somatosensory evoked field activation in the ipsilateral cortex upon electrical stimulation of the hemiplegic hand. In these patients the locations of the ipsilateral sensorimotor cortex activation were in the primary somatosensory cortex (SI). The latency of the reliable somatosensory evoked field after stimulation of the median nerve was significantly longer for responses from the hemiplegic side compared with responses to stimulation of the median nerve from the normal side. In conclusion, ipsilateral sensory function has a time-locked relation to the cortical electromagnetic activation in the SI area of hemispherectomized patients.

Palliative hemispherotomy in children with bilateral seizure onset

OBJECT

Intractable epilepsy is a significant burden on families and on the cognitive development and quality of life (QOL) of patients. Periinsular hemispherotomy (PIH) for medically intractable epilepsy can benefit patients who qualify for this procedure. The ideal hemispherotomy candidate has ipsilateral ictal and interictal epileptiform activity, unilateral MR imaging abnormalities, contralateral hemiplegia, and a normal contralateral hemisphere. However, certain patients present with a mixed picture of bilateral electroencephalography (EEG) findings and severe intractable epilepsy, prompting consideration of a more aggressive treatment approach. This report introduces the possibility of surgery for patients who normally would not meet criteria for this treatment modality.

METHODS

In this retrospective chart review, the authors report on 7 patients with bilateral seizure onset noted on routine or video-EEG monitoring. A QOL phone questionnaire, based on the Quality of Life in Childhood Epilepsy tool, was administered to a parent. The authors reviewed each patient's chart for surgical complications, changes in examination, QOL, limited neuropsychological outcomes, and seizure outcomes. They also investigated each chart for MR imaging and EEG findings as well as the patient's epilepsy clinic notes for seizure semiology and frequency.

RESULTS

All patients enjoyed a decrease in seizure frequency and a subjective increase in QOL after PIH. Five patients (71%) achieved Engel Class I or II seizure control. The mean follow-up was 3.64 years (2-5.3 years). One patient is now off all antiseizure medication. No patient had a decrement in Full Scale IQ on postsurgical testing, and 2 (28.5%) of 7 individuals had increased adaptive and social functioning. Postsurgical examination changes included hemiplegia and homonymous hemianopia.

CONCLUSIONS

Hemispherotomy in patients with intractable epilepsy is generally reserved for individuals with unilateral epileptiform abnormalities or lesions on MR imaging. Seven patients in this study benefited from surgery despite bilateral seizure onset with improvement in seizure control and overall QOL. Thus, bilateral ictal onset does not necessarily preclude consideration for hemispherotomy in selected patients with severe medically refractory epilepsy.

Speech and oral motor profile after childhood hemispherectomy

Hemispherectomy (disconnection or removal of an entire cerebral hemisphere) is a rare surgical procedure used for the relief of drug-resistant epilepsy in children. After hemispherectomy, contralateral hemiplegia persists whereas gross expressive and receptive language functions can be remarkably spared. Motor speech deficits have rarely been examined systematically, thus limiting the accuracy of postoperative prognosis. We describe the speech profiles of hemispherectomized participants characterizing their intelligibility, articulation, phonological speech errors, dysarthric features, and execution and sequencing of orofacial speech and non-speech movements. Thirteen participants who had undergone hemispherectomy (six left, seven right; nine with congenital, four with acquired hemiplegia; operated between four months and 13 years) were investigated. Results showed that all participants were intelligible but showed a mild dysarthric profile characterized by neuromuscular asymmetry and reduced quality and coordination of movements, features that are characteristic of adult-onset unilateral upper motor neuron dysarthria, flaccid-ataxic variant. In addition, one left and four right hemispherectomy cases presented with impaired production of speech and non-speech sequences. No participant showed evidence of verbal or oral dyspraxia. It is concluded that mild dysarthria is persistent after left or right hemispherectomy, irrespective of age at onset of hemiplegia. These results indicate incomplete functional re-organization for the control of fine speech motor movements throughout childhood, and provide no evidence of hemispheric differences.

Hemispherotomy: efficacy and analysis of seizure recurrence

OBJECT

Hemispherotomy generally is performed in hemiparetic patients with severe, intractable epilepsy arising from one cerebral hemisphere. In this study, the authors evaluate the efficacy of hemispherotomy and present an analysis of the factors influencing seizure recurrence following the operation.

METHODS

The authors performed a retrospective review of 49 patients (ages 0.2-20.5 years) who underwent functional hemispherotomy at their institution. The first 14 cases were traditional functional hemispherotomies, and included temporal lobectomy, while the latter 35 were performed using a modified periinsular technique that the authors adopted in 2003.

RESULTS

Thirty-eight of the 49 patients (77.6%) were seizure free at the termination of the study (mean follow-up 28.6 months). Of the 11 patients who were not seizure free, all had significant improvement in seizure frequency, with 6 patients (12.2%) achieving Engel Class II outcome and 5 patients (10.2%) achieving Engel Class III. There were no cases of Engel Class IV outcome. The effect of hemispherotomy was durable over time with no significant change in Engel class over the postoperative follow-up period. There was no statistical difference in outcome between surgery types. Analysis of factors contributing to seizure recurrence after hemispherotomy revealed no statistically significant predictors of treatment failure, although bilateral electrographic abnormalities on the preoperative electroencephalogram demonstrated a trend toward a worse outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

In the present study, hemispherotomy resulted in freedom from seizures in nearly 78% of patients; worthwhile improvement was demonstrated in all patients. The seizure reduction observed after hemispherotomy was durable over time, with only rare late failure. Bilateral electrographic abnormalities may be predictive of posthemispherotomy recurrent seizures.

Ipsilesional and contralesional sensorimotor function after hemispherectomy: differences between distal and proximal function

Previous studies have reported mainly on contralesional somatosensory and motor function after hemispherectomy. So far, ipsilesional impairments have received little attention even though these have been reported in patients with less extensive lesions. In the current study we assessed ipsilesional and contralesional sensorimotor function in a group of 12 patients with hemispherectomy. In addition, we focused on differences between distal and proximal function and investigated several factors that may have contributed to individual differences between patients. The tests included tapping, force production, tactile double simultaneous stimulation, pressure sensitivity, passive joint movement sense and sensitivity to hot and cold. Ipsilesional impairments were found on all tests, except passive joint movement sense. Unexpectedly, no significant ipsilateral distal-proximal gradient was found for any of the measures. Both the removal of the diseased cerebral hemisphere and possible changes to the remaining brain structures may have affected ipsilesional sensorimotor function. Contralesional performance was impaired on all tests except for passive joint movement in the shoulder. The contralesional impairments were characterized by a distal-proximal gradient measured on all tests, except that of sensitivity to hot and cold. Distal function was always most impaired. The difference between distal and proximal motor function is in agreement with the established concepts of the motor pathways, with the motoneurons innervating proximal muscles receiving bilateral cortical and subcortical input. Age at onset of original brain damage correlated significantly with passive joint movement sense. Patients with known abnormalities to the remaining brain structures performed inferior on the tapping test only. No effect was found of the hemispheric side of removal.