Otolith Membrane Herniation, not Semicircular Canal Duct Dilation, Is Associated with Decreased Caloric Responses in Ménière's Disease

Do measures of gain asymmetry and catch-up saccades improve video head impulse test agreement with caloric results?

Objective

To investigate the relative sensitivity and agreement of caloric testing and video head impulse test (vHIT) across four groups of vestibular disorders.

Methods

Caloric and vHIT results of 118 patients with either Ménière's disease, vestibular neuritis/labyrinthitis, vestibular migraine, or vestibular schwannoma were retrospectively analyzed. vHIT gain, gain asymmetry, and catch-up-saccades (≥100°/sec) were compared with reference limits of 91 controls.

Results

Abnormal caloric results and vHIT gain were recorded in 57.6 % and 33.1 % of patients, respectively. Consideration of all three measures increased vHIT sensitivity to 43.2 %, and concordance with caloric results improved from 66.1 % to 70.3 %. A significant interaction effect confirmed the relationship between tests depended on the diagnosis (p = 0.013). Vestibular migraine and vestibular neuritis/labyrinthitis produced similar results on both tests, usually normal and abnormal respectively. Vestibular schwannoma produced more caloric abnormalities than vHIT gain but not compared with catch-up-saccades and gain asymmetry; Ménière's disease produced more caloric abnormalities than all vHIT measures. When vHIT was normal (all measures), a 37 % canal paresis was 90 % specific for Ménière's disease.

Conclusions

Rates of vHIT catch-up-saccades and gain asymmetry can improve sensitivity and concordance with caloric testing, but this is disease-dependent.

Significance

vHIT outcome measures are complementary to the caloric test and each other.

Dizziness in Primary Care

Dizziness is a prevalent symptom in the general population and is among the most common reasons patients present for medical evaluations. This article focuses on high yield information to support primary clinicians in the efficient and effective evaluation and management of dizziness. Key points are as follows: do not anchor on the type of dizziness symptom, do use symptom timing and prior medical history to inform diagnostics probabilities, do evaluate for hallmark examination findings of vestibular disorders, and seek out opportunities to deliver evidence-based interventions particularly the canalith repositioning maneuver and gaze stabilization exercises.

Impact of endolymphatic hydrops on the function of the horizontal canal during caloric stimulation in Ménière's disease

PURPOSE

When a dizzy patient with episodic vertigo has an abnormal caloric and a normal video head impulse test (vHIT), this caloric-vHIT dissociation provides vital information for a diagnosis of Ménière's disease (MD). Endolymphatic hydrops (EH), a histological marker of MD, is hypothesized to be involved in the caloric-vHIT dissociation in MD through hydropic duct distension of the horizontal semicircular canal (SC). This study was designed to determine the impact of EH on the function of horizontal SC during caloric stimulation.

METHODS

Caloric test and vHIT were used to evaluate the function of horizontal SC every six months, annual magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was used to evaluate the degree of EH size in the vestibule, and monthly vertigo and hearing evaluation was done for 12 months. EH shrinkage was defined as the size change of vestibular EH from significant to none.

RESULTS

Among 133 MD patients evaluated for eligibility, 67 patients with caloric-vHIT dissociation entered the study. Fifteen participants had EH shrinkage (G-I), while 52 participants had no remarkable EH change (G-II). Average values (IQR) of the maximum slow phase velocity in G-I and G-II were 29.6 (13.0-34.0) and 25.9 (17.3-31.3), respectively, at baseline, 26.1 (9.0-38.0) and 23.6 (18.0-28.3) at 12 months. Two-factor repeated-measures ANOVA showed no significant differences between the groups (P = 0.486). The values of vestibulo-ocular reflex gain of the horizontal SC in G-I and G-II remained above 0.8 during the study period.

CONCLUSIONS

EH detected by MRI shows limited correlation with caloric stimulation results.

Posterior Semicircular Canal Dehiscence with Vestibulo-Ocular Reflex Reduction for the Affected Canal at the Video-Head Impulse Test: Considerations to Pathomechanisms

Posterior semicircular canal dehiscence (PSCD) has been demonstrated to result in a third mobile window mechanism (TMWM) in the inner ear similar to superior semicircular canal dehiscence (SSCD). Typical clinical and instrumental features of TMWM, including low-frequency conductive hearing loss (CHL), autophony, pulsatile tinnitus, sound/pressure-induced vertigo and enhanced vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials, have been widely described in cases with PSCD. Nevertheless, video-head impulse test (vHIT) results have been poorly investigated. Here, we present six patients with PSCD presenting with a clinical scenario consistent with a TMWM and an impaired vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) for the affected canal on vHIT. In two cases, an additional dehiscence between the facial nerve and the horizontal semicircular canal (HSC) was detected, leading to a concurrent VOR impairment for the HSC. While in SSCD, a VOR gain reduction could be ascribed to a spontaneous "auto-plugging" process due to a dural prolapse into the canal, the same pathomechanism is difficult to conceive in PSCD due to a different anatomical position, making a dural herniation less likely. Alternative putative pathomechanisms are discussed, including an endolymphatic flow dissipation during head impulses as already hypothesized in SSCD. The association of symptoms/signs consistent with TMWM and a reduced VOR gain for the posterior canal might address the diagnosis toward PSCD.

[The "difficult" patient-pearls and pitfalls of vestibular diagnostic tests: Part 2 : Difficult aspects of vestibular laboratory testing]

Patients with the cardinal symptoms "vertigo" or "dizziness" may be a real challenge for the treating otorhinolaryngologist. While the first part of this educational series was focused on history taking and bedside neurotological examination, the present paper is devoted to difficult aspects of vestibular laboratory testing, including getting the indication right, what to do if my patient is not able to fully cooperate during the tests, how to choose the adequate diagnostic procedure depending on the patient's comorbidities, how to interpret discordant results of various tests. Finally the paper addresses which conclusions can be drawn (and cannot be drawn) from normal findings in vestibular testing and how to communicate this result to the dizzy patient.

Comparative utility of vestibular function tests in patients with peripheral and central vestibular dysfunction

Background

Bithermal caloric irrigation, video head impulse test (vHIT), and rotational testing are commonly used to assess peripheral vestibular function, but the relative clinical utility of each test in differentiating patients with peripheral vestibulopathy is debated.

Objectives

To determine whether (1) the combination of two or more vestibular tests enhances diagnostic utility over a single test; (2) abnormal test results on vestibular tests correlate with one another.

Methods

Retrospective analysis of data collected from multidisciplinary vestibular clinics at two academic medical centers from 2016 to 2022.

Results

150 patients (54.10 ± 15.09 years, 88 females) were included. No individual test was significantly better at predicting the presence of peripheral vestibular damage (p > 0.05). vHIT test results improved significantly when combined with either the caloric test (p = 0.007) or rotary chair test (p = 0.039). Caloric and rotational testing had high sensitivity (74.65% and 76.06%, respectively) and specificity (83.54% and 78.48%, respectively). vHIT demonstrated excellent specificity (89.87%) but poor sensitivity (47.89%). Caloric, vHIT, and rotary chair tests results did not correlate with one another (p > 0.05).

Conclusions

Vestibular function tests have comparable diagnostic utility, yet each offers unique advantages. Caloric and rotational testing may be best suited for screening peripheral damage and vHIT may function ideally as a confirmatory test.

Neurological update: neuro-otology 2023

Much has changed since our last review of recent advances in neuro-otology 7 years ago. Unfortunately there are still not many practising neuro-otologists, so that most patients with vestibular problems need, in the first instance, to be evaluated and treated by neurologists whose special expertise is not neuro-otology. The areas we consider here are mostly those that almost any neurologist should be able to start managing: acute spontaneous vertigo in the Emergency Room-is it vestibular neuritis or posterior circulation stroke; recurrent spontaneous vertigo in the office-is it vestibular migraine or Meniere's disease and the most common vestibular problem of all-benign positional vertigo. Finally we consider the future: long-term vestibular monitoring and the impact of machine learning on vestibular diagnosis.

Types of Inheritance and Genes Associated with Familial Meniere Disease

Meniere disease (MD) is a rare disorder of the inner ear defined by sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) associated with episodes of vertigo and tinnitus. The phenotype is variable, and it may be associated with other comorbidities such as migraine, respiratory allergies, and several autoimmune disorders. The condition has a significant heritability according to epidemiological and familial segregation studies. Familial MD is found in 10% of cases, the most frequently found genes being OTOG, MYO7A, and TECTA, previously associated with autosomal dominant and recessive non-syndromic SNHL. These findings suggest a new hypothesis where proteins involved in the extracellular structures in the apical surface of sensory epithelia (otolithic and tectorial membranes) and proteins in the stereocilia links would be key elements in the pathophysiology of MD. The ionic homeostasis of the otolithic and tectorial membranes could be critical to suppress the innate motility of individual hair cell bundles. Initially, focal detachment of these extracellular membranes may cause random depolarization of hair cells and will explain changes in tinnitus loudness or trigger vertigo attacks in early stages of MD. With the progression of the disease, a larger detachment will lead to an otolithic membrane herniation into the horizontal semicircular canal with dissociation in caloric and head impulse responses. Familial MD shows different types of inheritance, including autosomal dominant and compound recessive patterns and implementation of genetic testing will improve our understanding of the genetic structure of MD.