Physeal histological morphology after thermal epiphysiodesis using radiofrequency ablation

Microwave Ablation of the Pig Growth Plate: Proof of Concept for Minimally Invasive Epiphysiodesis

BACKGROUND

Different surgical methods for epiphysiodesis of limb length discrepancy (LLD) have been described. Although these methods are variably effective, they are associated with morbidity (pain and limp) and potential complications. Microwave ablation is a less-invasive opportunity to halt growth by selectively destroying the growth plate via thermal energy to treat LLD in children.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

In this proof-of-concept study using an in vivo pig model, we asked: (1) What is the durability of response 2 to 4 months after microwave ablation of the tibial growth plate as measured by length and angulation of the tibia via a CT scan? (2) Was articular cartilage maintained as measured by standard histologic staining for articular cartilage viability?

METHODS

To develop an in vivo protocol for microwave ablation, we placed microwave antennas adjacent to the proximal tibia growth plate in the cadaveric hindlimbs of 18 3-month-old pigs. To determine the suitable time, we varied ablation from 90 to 270 seconds at 65-W power settings. After sectioning the tibia, we visually assessed for discoloration (implying growth plate destruction) that included the central growth plate but did not encroach into the epiphysis in a manner that could disrupt the articular surface. Using this information, we then performed microwave ablation on three live female pigs (3.5 to 4 months old) to evaluate physiologic changes and durability of response. A postprocedure MRI was performed to ensure the intervention led to spatial growth plate alterations similar to that seen in cadavers. This was followed by serial CT, which was used to assess the potential effect on local bone and growth until the animals were euthanized 2 to 4 months after the procedure. We analyzed LLD, angular deformity, and bony deformity using CT scans of both tibias. The visibility of articular cartilage was compared with that of the contralateral tibia via standard histologic staining, and growth rates of the proximal tibial growth plate were compared via fluorochrome labeling.

RESULTS

Eighteen cadaveric specimens showed ablation zones across the growth plate without visual damage to the articular surface. The three live pigs did not exhibit changes in gait or require notable pain medication after the procedure. Each animal demonstrated growth plate destruction, expected limb shortening (0.8, 1.2, and 1.5 cm), and bony cavitation around the growth plate. Slight valgus bone angulation (4º, 5º, and 12º) compared with the control tibia was noted. No qualitatively observable articular cartilage damage was encountered from the histologic comparison with the contralateral tibia for articular cartilage thickness and cellular morphology.

CONCLUSION

A microwave antenna placed into a pig's proximal tibia growth plate can slow the growth of the tibia without apparent pain and alteration of gait and function.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Further investigation and refinement of our animal model is ongoing and includes shorter ablation times and comparison of dynamic ablation (moving the antennae during the ablation) as well as static ablation of the tibia from a medial and lateral portal. These refinements and planned comparison with standard mechanical growth arrest in our pig model may lead to a similar approach to ablate growth plates in children with LLD.

Thermal Damage in Orthopaedics

There are numerous potential sources of thermal damage encountered in orthopaedic surgery. An understanding of the preclinical mechanisms of thermal damage in tissues is necessary to minimize iatrogenic injuries and use these mechanisms therapeutically. Heat generation is a phenomenon that can be used to a surgeon's benefit, most commonly for hemostasis and local control of tumors. It is simultaneously one of the most dangerous by-products of orthopaedic techniques as a result of burring, drilling, cementation, and electrocautery and can severely damage tissues if used improperly. Similarly, cooling can be used to a surgeon's advantage in some orthopaedic subspecialties, but the potential for harm to tissues is also great. Understanding the potential of a given technique to rapidly alter local temperature-and the range of temperatures tolerated by a given tissue-is imperative to harness the power of heat and cold. In all subspecialties of orthopaedic surgery, thermal damage is a relevant topic that represents a direct connection between preclinical and clinical practice.

Effect of Thermal Ablation on Growth Plates: A Study to Explore the Thermal Threshold of Rabbit Growth Plates During Microwave Ablation

PURPOSE

To explore the temperature threshold of thermal damage to growth plates.

METHODS

Nine rabbits were divided into three groups for femoral ablation, exposing the growth plate to different temperatures (T1 = 43-45 °C; T2 = 46-48 °C; T3 = 49-51 °C). After 5 weeks, the changes in the femurs were assessed by macroscopic images, micro-CT, haematoxylin and eosin staining, and immunohistochemistry of Col2a1 (type II collagen). At the cellular level, rabbit epiphyseal chondrocytes were exposed to 37 °C, 44 °C, 47 °C and 50 °C for 5 min. Then, proliferation and chondrogenic differentiation were detected.

RESULTS

The rabbits in the T2 and T3 groups developed length discrepancies and axial deviations of femurs, abnormal newly formed bone in the marrow cavity, disorganized growth plates and decreased Col2a1 expression. At the cellular level, the cells exposed to 47 °C and 50 °C for 5 min showed decreased viability, increased apoptosis, decreased extracellular matrix synthesis and decreased matrix mineralization. However, the changes in rabbits in the T1 group and cells at 44 °C did not show a significant difference.

CONCLUSION

The ablation of growth plates at temperatures above 45 °C for 5 min results in decreased chondrocyte viability and disorganized growth plates, leading to growth disturbances. Further studies are warranted to confirm these promising initial results.

A Preclinical Pilot Study on the Effects of Thermal Ablation on Lamb Growth Plates

(1) Background: Thermal ablation has been demonstrated to affect the bone growth of osteoid osteoma in adolescents. Growth modulation due to thermal heat in children is conceivable, but has not yet been established. We used lamb extremities as a preclinical model to examine the effect of thermal ablation on growth plates in order to evaluate its potential for axial or longitudinal growth modulation in pediatric patients. (2) Methods: Thermal ablation was performed by electrocautery on eight different growth plates of the legs and distal radii of a stillborn lamb. After treatment, target hits and the physical extent of the growth plate lesions were monitored using micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) and histology. (3) Results: Lesions and their physical extent could be quantified in 75% of the treated extremities. The histological analysis revealed that the disruption of tissue was confined to a small area and the applied heat did not cause the entire growth plate to be disrupted or obviously damaged. (4) Conclusions: Thermal ablation by electrocautery is minimally invasive and can be used for targeted disruption of small areas in growth plates in the animal model. The results suggest that thermal ablation can be developed into a suitable method to influence epiphyseal growth in children.

Assessing the safety of an epiphyseal plate biopsy in a translational lamb model

The literature demonstrates that obtaining a biopsy of the physis may be beneficial for diagnostic purposes. A small biopsy of the epiphyseal plate may allow for earlier detection of certain conditions and be used to monitor the healing of diseased and/or damaged physes. However, due to the fear of a growth arrest in a growing child, biopsies are not currently performed. In this study, we investigated the effects of a biopsy of the epiphyseal plate in 3-month-old lambs. A total of 4.2 mm biopsy samples were captured in the proximal tibiae and distal femora physes. The lambs were monitored 12- and 24-week post-biopsy. Computed tomography (CT) and micro-CT scans were obtained to determine if any angular deformities occurred, while scanning electron microscope (SEM) and histological analysis were utilized to assess the bone response due to the biopsy. The contralateral limbs served as unaltered controls for direct comparison within each lamb. The data demonstrated no signs of angular deformities following a 4.2 mm biopsy of the physis. Bone growth/elongation was confirmed by CT, SEM, and fluorochrome analyses and indicated that the lambs were in fact immature and still growing at the time of the biopsy. Clinical Significance: This investigation demonstrated that a small biopsy of the epiphyseal plate can be obtained safely without the cause of growth arrest and angular deformities. The ability to precisely diagnose, treat, and/or monitor at-risk children at an earlier timepoint by way of a biopsy sample could be an important advancement in regard to researching diseased and/or damaged physes.