Microcalcification Segmentation from Mammograms: A Morphological Approach

Advancing Breast Cancer Diagnosis through Breast Mass Images, Machine Learning, and Regression Models

Breast cancer results from a disruption of certain cells in breast tissue that undergo uncontrolled growth and cell division. These cells most often accumulate and form a lump called a tumor, which may be benign (non-cancerous) or malignant (cancerous). Malignant tumors can spread quickly throughout the body, forming tumors in other areas, which is called metastasis. Standard screening techniques are insufficient in the case of metastasis; therefore, new and advanced techniques based on artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning, and regression models have been introduced, the primary aim of which is to automatically diagnose breast cancer through the use of advanced techniques, classifiers, and real images. Real fine-needle aspiration (FNA) images were collected from Wisconsin, and four classifiers were used, including three machine learning models and one regression model: the support vector machine (SVM), naive Bayes (NB), k-nearest neighbors (k-NN), and decision tree (DT)-C4.5. According to the accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity results, the SVM algorithm had the best performance; it was the most powerful computational classifier with a 97.13% accuracy and 97.5% specificity. It also had around a 96% sensitivity for the diagnosis of breast cancer, unlike the models used for comparison, thereby providing an exact diagnosis on the one hand and a clear classification between benign and malignant tumors on the other hand. As a future research prospect, more algorithms and combinations of features can be considered for the precise, rapid, and effective classification and diagnosis of breast cancer images for imperative decisions.

Automatic Calcification Morphology and Distribution Classification for Breast Mammograms With Multi-Task Graph Convolutional Neural Network

The morphology and distribution of microcalcifications are the most important descriptors for radiologists to diagnose breast cancer based on mammograms. However, it is very challenging and time-consuming for radiologists to characterize these descriptors manually, and there also lacks of effective and automatic solutions for this problem. We observed that the distribution and morphology descriptors are determined by the radiologists based on the spatial and visual relationships among calcifications. Thus, we hypothesize that this information can be effectively modelled by learning a relationship-aware representation using graph convolutional networks (GCNs). In this study, we propose a multi-task deep GCN method for automatic characterization of both the morphology and distribution of microcalcifications in mammograms. Our proposed method transforms morphology and distribution characterization into node and graph classification problem and learns the representations concurrently. We trained and validated the proposed method in an in-house dataset and public DDSM dataset with 195 and 583 cases,respectively. The proposed method reaches good and stable results with distribution AUC at 0.812 ± 0.043 and 0.873 ± 0.019, morphology AUC at 0.663 ± 0.016 and 0.700 ± 0.044 for both in-house and public datasets. In both datasets, our proposed method demonstrates statistically significant improvements compared to the baseline models. The performance improvements brought by our proposed multi-task mechanism can be attributed to the association between the distribution and morphology of calcifications in mammograms, which is interpretable using graphical visualizations and consistent with the definitions of descriptors in the standard BI-RADS guideline. In short, we explore, for the first time, the application of GCNs in microcalcification characterization that suggests the potential of using graph learning for more robust understanding of medical images.

DeepMiCa: Automatic segmentation and classification of breast MIcroCAlcifications from mammograms

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Breast cancer is the world's most prevalent form of cancer. The survival rates have increased in the last years mainly due to factors such as screening programs for early detection, new insights on the disease mechanisms as well as personalised treatments. Microcalcifications are the only first detectable sign of breast cancer and diagnosis timing is strongly related to the chances of survival. Nevertheless microcalcifications detection and classification as benign or malignant lesions is still a challenging clinical task and their malignancy can only be proven after a biopsy procedure. We propose DeepMiCa, a fully automated and visually explainable deep-learning based pipeline for the analysis of raw mammograms with microcalcifications. Our aim is to propose a reliable decision support system able to guide the diagnosis and help the clinicians to better inspect borderline difficult cases.

METHODS

DeepMiCa is composed by three main steps: (1) Preprocessing of the raw scans (2) Automatic patch-based Semantic Segmentation using a UNet based network with a custom loss function appositely designed to deal with extremely small lesions (3) Classification of the detected lesions with a deep transfer-learning approach. Finally, state-of-the-art explainable AI methods are used to produce maps for a visual interpretation of the classification results. Each step of DeepMiCa is designed to address the main limitations of the previous proposed works resulting in a novel automated and accurate pipeline easily customisable to meet radiologists' needs.

RESULTS

The proposed segmentation and classification algorithms achieve an area under the ROC curve of 0.95 and 0.89 respectively. Compared to previously proposed works, this method does not require high performance computational resources and provides a visual explanation of the final classification results.

CONCLUSION

To conclude, we designed a novel fully automated pipeline for detection and classification of breast microcalcifications. We believe that the proposed system has the potential to provide a second opinion in the diagnosis process giving the clinicians the opportunity to quickly visualise and inspect relevant imaging characteristics. In the clinical practice the proposed decision support system could help reduce the rate of misclassified lesions and consequently the number of unnecessary biopsies.

Improving the Quantitative Analysis of Breast Microcalcifications: A Multiscale Approach

Accurate characterization of microcalcifications (MCs) in 2D digital mammography is a necessary step toward reducing the diagnostic uncertainty associated with the callback of indeterminate MCs. Quantitative analysis of MCs can better identify MCs with a higher likelihood of ductal carcinoma in situ or invasive cancer. However, automated identification and segmentation of MCs remain challenging with high false positive rates. We present a two-stage multiscale approach to MC segmentation in 2D full-field digital mammograms (FFDMs) and diagnostic magnification views. Candidate objects are first delineated using blob detection and Hessian analysis. A regression convolutional network, trained to output a function with a higher response near MCs, chooses the objects which constitute actual MCs. The method was trained and validated on 435 screening and diagnostic FFDMs from two separate datasets. We then used our approach to segment MCs on magnification views of 248 cases with amorphous MCs. We modeled the extracted features using gradient tree boosting to classify each case as benign or malignant. Compared to state-of-the-art comparison methods, our approach achieved superior mean intersection over the union (0.670 ± 0.121 per image versus 0.524 ± 0.034 per image), intersection over the union per MC object (0.607 ± 0.250 versus 0.363 ± 0.278) and true positive rate of 0.744 versus 0.581 at 0.4 false positive detections per square centimeter. Features generated using our approach outperformed the comparison method (0.763 versus 0.710 AUC) in distinguishing amorphous calcifications as benign or malignant.

A novel machine learning approach on texture analysis for automatic breast microcalcification diagnosis classification of mammogram images

PURPOSE

Screening programs use mammography as a diagnostic tool for the early detection of breast cancer. Mammogram enhancement is used to increase the local contrast of the mammogram so that the lesions are more visible in the advanced image. For accurate diagnosis in the early stage of breast cancer, the appearance of masses and microcalcification on the mammographic image are two important indicators. The objective of this study was to evaluate the feasibility of the automatic separation of images of breast tissue microcalcifications and also to evaluate its accuracy.

METHODS

The research was carried out by using two techniques of image enhancement and highlighting of breast tissue microcalcifications for the desired areas by regional ROI based on fuzzy system and also Gabor filtering method. After determining the clusters of breast tissue microcalcifications, the clusters are classified using the decision tree classification algorithm. Then, for segmentation, samples suspected of microcalcification are highlighted and masked, and in the last stage, tissue characteristics are extracted. Subsequently, with the help of an artificial neural network (ANN), determining the benign and malignant types of segmented ROI clusters was accomplished. The proposed system is trained with a Digital Database for Screening Mammography (DDSM) developed by the University of South Florida, USA, and the simulations are performed under MATLAB software and the results are compared with previous work.

RESULTS

The results of this training performed under this work show an accuracy of 93% and an improvement of sensitivity above 95%.

CONCLUSION

The result indicates that the proposed approach can be applied to ensure breast cancer diagnosis.

A New Collaborative Classification Process for Microcalcification Detection Based on Graphs and Knowledge Propagation

In this paper, we propose a new collaborative process that aims to detect macrocalcifications from mammographic images while minimizing false negative detections. This process is made up of three main phases: suspicious area detection, candidate object identification, and collaborative classification. The main concept is to operate on the entire image divided into homogenous regions called superpixels which are used to identify both suspicious areas and candidate objects. The collaborative classification phase consists in making the initial results of different microcalcification detectors collaborate in order to produce a new common decision and reduce their initial disagreements. The detectors share the information about their detected objects and associated labels in order to refine their initial decisions based on those of the other collaborators. This refinement consists of iteratively updating the candidate object labels of each detector following local and contextual analyses based on prior knowledge about the links between super pixels and macrocalcifications. This process iteratively reduces the disagreement between different detectors and estimates local reliability terms for each super pixel. The final result is obtained by a conjunctive combination of the new detector decisions reached by the collaborative process. The proposed approach is evaluated on the publicly available INBreast dataset. Experimental results show the benefits gained in terms of improving microcalcification detection performances compared to existing detectors as well as ordinary fusion operators.

Automated quantitative assessment of amorphous calcifications: Towards improved malignancy risk stratification

BACKGROUND

Amorphous calcifications noted on mammograms (i.e., small and indistinct calcifications that are difficult to characterize) are associated with high diagnostic uncertainty, often leading to biopsies. Yet, only 20% of biopsied amorphous calcifications are cancer. We present a quantitative approach for distinguishing between benign and actionable (high-risk and malignant) amorphous calcifications using a combination of local textures, global spatial relationships, and interpretable handcrafted expert features.

METHOD

Our approach was trained and validated on a set of 168 2D full-field digital mammography exams (248 images) from 168 patients. Within these 248 images, we identified 276 image regions with segmented amorphous calcifications and a biopsy-confirmed diagnosis. A set of local (radiomic and region measurements) and global features (distribution and expert-defined) were extracted from each image. Local features were grouped using an unsupervised k-means clustering algorithm. All global features were concatenated with clustered local features and used to train a LightGBM classifier to distinguish benign from actionable cases.

RESULTS

On the held-out test set of 60 images, our approach achieved a sensitivity of 100%, specificity of 35%, and a positive predictive value of 38% when the decision threshold was set to 0.4. Given that all of the images in our test set resulted in a recommendation of a biopsy, the use of our algorithm would have identified 15 images (25%) that were benign, potentially reducing the number of breast biopsies.

CONCLUSIONS

Quantitative analysis of full-field digital mammograms can extract subtle shape, texture, and distribution features that may help to distinguish between benign and actionable amorphous calcifications.

A new conditional region growing approach for microcalcification delineation in mammograms

Microcalcifications (MCs) are considered as the first indicator of breast cancer development. Their morphology, in terms of shape and size, is considered as the most important criterion that determines their malignity degrees. Therefore, the accurate delineation of MC is a cornerstone step in their automatic diagnosis process. In this paper, we propose a new conditional region growing (CRG) approach with the ability of finding the accurate MC boundaries starting from selected seed points. The starting seed points are determined based on regional maxima detection and superpixel analysis. The region growing step is controlled by a set of criteria that are adapted to MC detection in terms of contrast and shape variation. These criteria are derived from prior knowledge to characterize MCs and can be divided into two categories. The first one concerns the neighbourhood searching size. The second one deals with the analysis of gradient information and shape evolution within the growing process. In order to prove the effectiveness and the reliability in terms of MC detection and delineation, several experiments have been carried out on MCs of various types, with both qualitative and quantitative analysis. The comparison of the proposed approach with state-of-the art proves the importance of the used criteria in the context of MC delineation, towards a better management of breast cancer. Graphical Abstract Flowchart of the proposed approach.

Breast Cancer Segmentation Methods: Current Status and Future Potentials

Early breast cancer detection is one of the most important issues that need to be addressed worldwide as it can help increase the survival rate of patients. Mammograms have been used to detect breast cancer in the early stages; if detected in the early stages, it can drastically reduce treatment costs. The detection of tumours in the breast depends on segmentation techniques. Segmentation plays a significant role in image analysis and includes detection, feature extraction, classification, and treatment. Segmentation helps physicians quantify the volume of tissue in the breast for treatment planning. In this work, we have grouped segmentation methods into three groups: classical segmentation that includes region-, threshold-, and edge-based segmentation; machine learning segmentation; and supervised and unsupervised and deep learning segmentation. The findings of our study revealed that region-based segmentation is frequently used for classical methods, and the most frequently used techniques are region growing. Further, a median filter is a robust tool for removing noise. Moreover, the MIAS database is frequently used in classical segmentation methods. Meanwhile, in machine learning segmentation, unsupervised machine learning methods are more frequently used, and U-Net is frequently used for mammogram image segmentation because it does not require many annotated images compared with other deep learning models. Furthermore, reviewed papers revealed that it is possible to train a deep learning model without performing any preprocessing or postprocessing and also showed that the U-Net model is frequently used for mammogram segmentation. The U-Net model is frequently used because it does not require many annotated images and also because of the presence of high-performance GPU computing, which makes it easy to train networks with more layers. Additionally, we identified mammograms and utilised widely used databases, wherein 3 and 28 are public and private databases, respectively.

Breast Mass Detection in Mammography Based on Image Template Matching and CNN

In recent years, computer vision technology has been widely used in the field of medical image processing. However, there is still a big gap between the existing breast mass detection methods and the real-world application due to the limited detection accuracy. It is known that humans locate the regions of interest quickly and further identify whether these regions are the targets we found. In breast cancer diagnosis, we locate all the potential regions of breast mass by glancing at the mammographic image from top to bottom and from left to right, then further identify whether these regions are a breast mass. Inspired by the process of human detection of breast mass, we proposed a novel breast mass detection method to detect breast mass on a mammographic image by stimulating the process of human detection. The proposed method preprocesses the mammographic image via the mathematical morphology method and locates the suspected regions of breast mass by the image template matching method. Then, it obtains the regions of breast mass by classifying these suspected regions into breast mass and background categories using a convolutional neural network (CNN). The bounding box of breast mass obtained by the mathematical morphology method and image template matching method are roughly due to the mathematical morphology method, which transforms all of the brighter regions into approximate circular areas. For regression of a breast mass bounding box, the optimal solution should be searched in the feasible region and the Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) is suitable for solving the problem of searching the optimal solution within a certain range. Therefore, we refine the bounding box of breast mass by the PSO algorithm. The proposed breast mass detection method and the compared detection methods were evaluated on the open database Digital Database for Screening Mammography (DDSM). The experimental results demonstrate that the proposed method is superior to all of the compared detection methods in detection performance.

A Screening CAD Tool for the Detection of Microcalcification Clusters in Mammograms

Breast cancer is the most common cancer diagnosed in women worldwide. Up to 50% of non-palpable breast cancers are detected solely through microcalcification clusters in mammograms. This article presents a novel and completely automated algorithm for the detection of microcalcification clusters in a mammogram. A multiscale 2D non-linear energy operator is proposed for enhancing the contrast between the microcalcifications and the background. Several texture, shape, intensity, and histogram of oriented gradients (HOG)-based features are used to distinguish microcalcifications from other brighter mammogram regions. A new majority class data reduction technique based on data distribution is proposed to counter data imbalance problem. The algorithm is able to achieve 100% sensitivity with 2.59, 1.78, and 0.68 average false positives per image on Digital Database for Screening Mammography (scanned film), INbreast (direct radiography) database, and PGIMER-IITKGP mammogram (direct radiography) database, respectively. Thus, it might be used as a second reader as well as a screening tool to reduce the burden on radiologists.

Computer Aided Detection of Clustered Microcalcification: A Survey

BACKGROUND

This paper attempts to pinpoint different techniques for Pectoral Muscle (PM) segmentation, Microcalcification (MC) detection and classification in digital mammograms. The segmentation of PM and detection of MC and its classification are mostly based on image processing and data mining techniques.

DISCUSSION

The review centered on major techniques in image processing and data mining that is employed for PM segmentation, MC detection and classification in digital mammograms. Breast cancer is one of the significant causes of death among women aged above 40. Mammography is considered the most successful means for prompt and timely detection of breast cancers. One notable visual indication of the malignant growth is the appearance of Masses, Architectural Distortions, and Microcalcification Clusters (MCCs). There are some disadvantages and hurdles for mankind viewers, and it is hard for radiologists to supply both precise and steady assessment for a large number of mammograms created in extensive screening. Computer Aided Detection has been employed to help radiologists in detecting MC and MCCs. The automatic recognition of malignant MCCs could be very helpful for diagnostic purpose. In this paper, we summarize the methods of automatic detection and classification of MCs in digitized mammograms. Pectoral muscle segmentation techniques are also summarized.

CONCLUSION

The techniques used for segmentation of PM, MC detection and classification in a digitized mammogram are reviewed.

Multiscale connected chain topological modelling for microcalcification classification

Computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) systems can be employed to help classify mammographic microcalcification clusters. In this paper, a novel method for the classification of the microcalcification clusters based on topology/connectivity has been introduced. The proposed method is distinct from existing techniques which concentrate on morphology and texture of microcalcifications and surrounding tissue. The proposed approach used multiscale morphological relationship of connectivity between microcalcifications where connected chains between nearest microcalcifications were generated at each scale. Subsequently, graph connectivity features at each scale were extracted to estimate the topological connectivity structure of microcalcification clusters for benign versus malignant classification. The proposed approach was evaluated using publicly available digitized datasets: MIAS and DDSM, in addition to the digital OPTIMAM dataset. The classification of features using KNN obtained a classification accuracy of 86.47±1.30%, 90.0±0.00%, 82.5±2.63%, 76.75±0.66% for the DDSM, MIAS-manual, MIAS-auto and OPTIMAM datasets respectively. The study showed that topological/connectivity modelling using a multiscale approach was appropriate for microcalcification cluster analysis and classification; topological connectivity and distribution can be linked to clinical understanding of microcalcification spatial distribution.

Microcalcification detection in full-field digital mammograms: A fully automated computer-aided system

BACKGROUND

Microcalcification clusters in mammograms can be considered as early signs of breast cancer. However, their detection is a very challenging task because of different factors: large variety of breast composition, highly textured breast anatomy, impalpable size of microcalcifications in some cases, as well as inherent low contrast of mammograms. Thus, the need to support the clinicians' work with an automatic tool.

METHODS

In this work a three-phases approach for clustered microcalcification detection is presented. Specifically, it is made up of a pre-processing step, aimed at highlighting potentially interesting breast structures, followed by a single microcalcification detection step, based on Hough transform, that is able to grasp the innate characteristic shape of the structures of interest. Finally, a cluster identification step to group microcalcifications is carried out by means of a clustering algorithm able to codify expert domain rules.

RESULTS

The detection performance of the proposed method has been evaluated on 364 mammograms of 182 patients obtaining a true positive ratio of 91.78% with 2.87 false positives per image.

CONCLUSIONS

Experimental results demonstrated that the proposed method is able to detect microcalcification clusters in digital mammograms showing performance comparable to different methodologies exploited in the state-of-art approaches, with the advantage that it does not require any training phase and a large set of data. The performance of the proposed approach remains high even for more difficult clinical cases of mammograms of young women having high-density breast tissue thus resulting in a reduced contrast between microcalcifications and surrounding dense tissues.

Detection of potential microcalcification clusters using multivendor for-presentation digital mammograms for short-term breast cancer risk estimation

PURPOSE

We explore using the number of potential microcalcification clusters detected in for-presentation mammographic images (the images which are typically accessible to large epidemiological studies) a marker of short-term breast cancer risk.

METHODS

We designed a three-step algorithm for detecting potential microcalcification clusters in for-presentation digital mammograms. We studied association with short-term breast cancer risk using a nested case control design, with a mammography screening cohort as a source population. In total, 373 incident breast cancer cases (diagnosed at least 3 months after a negative screen at study entry) and 1466 matched controls were included in our study. Conditional logistic regression Wald tests were used to test for association with the presence of microcalcifications at study entry. We compared results of these analyses to those obtained using a Computer-aided Diagnosis (CAD) software (VuComp) on corresponding for-processing images (images which are used clinically, but typically not saved).

RESULTS

We found a moderate agreement between our measure of potential microcalcification clusters on for-presentation images and a CAD measure on for-processing images. Similar evidence of association with short-term breast cancer risk was found (P =  1 × 10 - 10 and P =  9 × 10 - 09 , for our approach on for-presentation images and for the CAD measure on for-processing images, respectively) and interestingly both measures contributed independently to association with a short-term risk (P =  9 × 10 - 03 for the CAD measure, adjusted for our proposed method and P =  1 × 10 - 04 for our proposed method, adjusted for the CAD measure).

CONCLUSION

Meaningful measurement of potential microcalcifications, in the context of short-term breast cancer risk assessment, is feasible for for-presentation images across a range of vendors. Our algorithm for for-presentation images performs similarly to a CAD algorithm on for-processing images, hence our algorithm can be a useful tool for research on microcalcifications and their role on breast cancer risk, based on large-scale epidemiological studies with access to for-presentation images.

Pattern Recognition and Size Prediction of Microcalcification Based on Physical Characteristics by Using Digital Mammogram Images

Breast cancer is one of the life-threatening cancers occurring in women. In recent years, from the surveys provided by various medical organizations, it has become clear that the mortality rate of females is increasing owing to the late detection of breast cancer. Therefore, an automated algorithm is needed to identify the early occurrence of microcalcification, which would assist radiologists and physicians in reducing the false predictions via image processing techniques. In this work, we propose a new algorithm to detect the pattern of a microcalcification by calculating its physical characteristics. The considered physical characteristics are the reflection coefficient and mass density of the binned digital mammogram image. The calculation of physical characteristics doubly confirms the presence of malignant microcalcification. Subsequently, by interpolating the physical characteristics via thresholding and mapping techniques, a three-dimensional (3D) projection of the region of interest (RoI) is obtained in terms of the distance in millimeter. The size of a microcalcification is determined using this 3D-projected view. This algorithm is verified with 100 abnormal mammogram images showing microcalcification and 10 normal mammogram images. In addition to the size calculation, the proposed algorithm acts as a good classifier that is used to classify the considered input image as normal or abnormal with the help of only two physical characteristics. This proposed algorithm exhibits a classification accuracy of 99%.