Utilizing different methods for visualizing susceptibility from a single multi-gradient echo dataset

Differentiating platinum coated brachytherapy seeds and gold fiducial markers with varying off-resonant frequency offsets

PURPOSE

To develop an off-resonant frequency filtered method to selectively differentiate between implanted gold fiducial markers and platinum coated brachytherapy seeds.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The magnetic susceptibilities for gold fiducial markers and brachytherapy seeds differ in magnitude and also in their signs, resulting in B₀-field inhomogeneity patterns with opposite main lobes. A pulse sequence used to localize brachytherapy seeds with positive contrast, centre-out radial sampling with off-resonance reception (co-RASOR), was used to reconstruct images with a range of off-resonant frequency offsets. The proposed method utilizes two frequency filters to selectively reconstruct maximum intensity projections through band-pass regions where each seed has its maximal localized hyperintensity. Seeds were simulated and then placed in gel and tissue phantoms to validate the technique using orthogonal 2D slices with seeds both parallel and perpendicular to the B₀-field.

RESULTS

Dual-plane 2D co-RASOR sequences were reconstructed off-resonance with applied frequency filters to create two projections displaying each seed, which were then colour-coded to negative and positive frequencies. Phantom validation showed that each seed contains its maximal CNR in opposing frequency regions as predicted. Local maxima can also appear in both negative and positive frequency regions. The relative difference between the signal of each seed and these local maxima ranged from 1.19 to 3.73, and an image threshold was determined in all cases. Tissue validation showed the technique differentiates seeds correctly and is limited by the hyperintensity patterns observed in the co-RASOR method.

CONCLUSIONS

Dual-plane co-RASOR offers sub-millimetre positive contrast from implanted seeds that contain unique off-resonant frequency maxima, which frequency filters can selectively differentiate.

Resolution and registration in dual-plane co-RASOR MR

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has superior soft tissue contrast and lower interobserver variability compared to computed tomography and advances in equipment and pseudo-CT estimation have allowed for MR-only radiation therapy planning. Dedicated MR sequences have been used to localize paramagnetic structures with positive contrast, and most implanted seeds are gold fiducial markers (GFMs). We used a fast, dual-plane co-RASOR sequence to localize implanted GFMs with positive contrast in phantom and tissue to assess their resolution and registration accuracy of registration to CT. Off-resonant reconstructions of co-RASOR images were able to resolve GFMs down to 5 mm apart at 12 cm FOV. No systematic biases were observed by comparing registration of co-RASOR and bSSFP to CT images in an MR-compatible Lego phantom with a set of highly visible known points. The standard deviations of the MR to CT distance errors were  <0.5 mm in all directions. We separated the component due to registration by comparing the two MR sequences, which had a maximum standard deviation of 0.36 mm in the SI-direction. Registration using the positive contrast points in a porcine sample phantom showed increased errors, but co-RASOR still performs acceptably with a target registration error of  <0.75 mm. The dual-plane co-RASOR sequence could then be used for both registration and image tracking when performing MR-only radiation therapy planning.

Direct in vitro comparison of six three-dimensional positive contrast methods for susceptibility marker imaging

PURPOSE

To compare different techniques for positive contrast imaging of susceptibility markers with MRI for three-dimensional visualization. As several different techniques have been reported, the choice of the suitable method depends on its properties with regard to the amount of positive contrast and the desired background suppression, as well as other imaging constraints needed for a specific application.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Six different positive contrast techniques are investigated for their ability to image at 3 Tesla a single susceptibility marker in vitro. The white marker method (WM), susceptibility gradient mapping (SGM), inversion recovery with on-resonant water suppression (IRON), frequency selective excitation (FSX), fast low flip-angle positive contrast SSFP (FLAPS), and iterative decomposition of water and fat with echo asymmetry and least-squares estimation (IDEAL) were implemented and investigated.

RESULTS

The different methods were compared with respect to the volume of positive contrast, the product of volume and signal intensity, imaging time, and the level of background suppression. Quantitative results are provided, and strengths and weaknesses of the different approaches are discussed.

CONCLUSION

The appropriate choice of positive contrast imaging technique depends on the desired level of background suppression, acquisition speed, and robustness against artifacts, for which in vitro comparative data are now available.

Selective depiction of susceptibility transitions using Laplace-filtered phase maps

In this work, we aim to demonstrate the ability of Laplace-filtered three-dimensional (3D) phase maps to selectively depict the susceptibility transitions in an object. To realize this goal, it is first shown that both the Laplace derivative of the z component of the static magnetic field in an object and the Laplacian of the corresponding phase distribution may be expected to be zero in regions of constant or linearly varying susceptibility and to be nonzero when there is an abrupt change in susceptibility, for instance, at a single point, a ridge, an interface, an edge or a boundary. Next, a method is presented by which the Laplace derivative of a 3D phase map can be directly extracted from the complex data, without the need for phase unwrapping or subtraction of a reference image. The validity of this approach and of the theory behind it is subsequently demonstrated by simulations and phantom experiments with exactly known susceptibility distributions. Finally, the potential of the Laplace derivative analysis is illustrated by simulations with a Shepp-Logan digital brain phantom and experiments with a gel phantom containing positive and negative focal susceptibility deviations.

Combined off-resonance imaging and T2 relaxation in the rotating frame for positive contrast MR imaging of infection in a murine burn model

PURPOSE

To develop novel magnetic resonance (MR) imaging methods to monitor accumulation of macrophages in inflammation and infection. Positive-contrast MR imaging provides an alternative to negative-contrast MRI, exploiting the chemical shift induced by ultra-small superparamagnetic iron-oxide (USPIO) nanoparticles to nearby water molecules. We introduce a novel combination of off-resonance (ORI) positive-contrast MRI and T(2ρ) relaxation in the rotating frame (ORI-T(2ρ)) for positive-contrast MR imaging of USPIO.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We tested ORI-T(2ρ) in phantoms and imaged in vivo the accumulation of USPIO-labeled macrophages at the infection site in a mouse model of burn trauma and infection with Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA). PA infection is clinically important. The USPIO nanoparticles were injected directly in the animals in solution, and macrophage labeling occurred in vivo in the animal model.

RESULTS

We observed a significant difference between ORI-T(2ρ) and ORI, which leads us to suggest that ORI-T(2ρ) is more sensitive in detecting USPIO signal. To this end, the ORI-T(2ρ) positive contrast method may prove to be of higher utility in future research.

CONCLUSION

Our results may have direct implications in the longitudinal monitoring of infection, and open perspectives for testing novel anti-infective compounds.

Susceptibility gradient quantization by MRI signal response mapping (SIRMA) to dephaser

PURPOSE

Susceptibility effects are a very efficient source of contrast in magnetic resonance imaging. However, detection is hampered by the fact the induced contrast is negative. In this work, the SIgnal Response MApping (SIRMA) to dephaser method is proposed to map susceptibility gradient to improve visualization.

METHODS

In conventional gradient echo acquisitions, the echo formation of susceptibility affected spins is shifted in k-space, the shift being proportional to the susceptibility gradient. Susceptibility gradients map can be produced by measuring this induced shifts. The SIRMA method measures these shifts from a series of dephased images collected with additional incremental dephasers. These additional dephasers correspond either to a slice refocusing gradient offset or to a reconstruction window off-centering. The signal intensity profile as a function of the additional dephaser was determined on a pixel-by-pixel basis from the ensemble of dephased images. Susceptibility affected voxels presented a signal response profile maximum shifted compared to nonaffected voxels ones. Shift magnitude and sign were measured for each pixel to determine susceptibility gradients and produce a susceptibility gradient map.

RESULTS

In vitro experiments demonstrated the ability of the method to map gradient inhomogeneities induced by a cylinder. Quantization accuracy was evaluated comparing SIRMA images and simulations performed on the well-characterized air filled cylinder model. Performances of the SIRMA method, evaluated in vitro on cylinders filled with various superparamagnetic iron oxide SPIO concentrations, showed limited influence of acquisition parameters. Robustness of the method was then assessed in vivo after an infusion of SPIO-loaded nanocapsules into the rat brain using a convection-enhanced drug delivery approach. The region of massive susceptibility gradient induced by the SPIO-loaded nanocapsules was clearly delineated on SIRMA maps and images were compared to T2* weighted images, Susceptibility Gradient Map (SGM), and histological Perl's staining slice. The potential for quantitative evaluation of SPIO distribution volume was demonstrated.

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed method is a promising technique for a wide range of applications especially in molecular or cellular imaging with respect to its quantitative nature and its computational simplicity.