What we know that could influence future treatment of phenylketonuria

State-of-the-Art 2019 on Gene Therapy for Phenylketonuria

Phenylketonuria (PKU) is considered to be a paradigm for a monogenic metabolic disorder but was never thought to be a primary application for human gene therapy due to established alternative treatment. However, somewhat unanticipated improvement in neuropsychiatric outcome upon long-term treatment of adults with PKU with enzyme substitution therapy might slowly change this assumption. In parallel, PKU was for a long time considered to be an excellent test system for experimental gene therapy of a Mendelian autosomal recessive defect of the liver due to an outstanding mouse model and the easy to analyze and well-defined therapeutic end point, that is, blood l-phenylalanine concentration. Lifelong treatment by targeting the mouse liver (or skeletal muscle) was achieved using different approaches, including (1) recombinant adeno-associated viral (rAAV) or nonviral naked DNA vector-based gene addition, (2) genome editing using base editors delivered by rAAV vectors, and (3) by delivering rAAVs for promoter-less insertion of the PAH-cDNA into the Pah locus. In this article we summarize the gene therapeutic attempts of correcting a mouse model for PKU and discuss the future implications for human gene therapy.

[Phenotypic and molecular characterization of a Colombian family with phenylketonuria]

INTRODUCTION

Phenylketonuria is a metabolic disorder characterized by severe neurological involvement and behavioral disorder, whose early diagnosis enables an effective treatment to avoid disease sequelae, thus changing the prognosis. Objective: To characterize a family with phenylketonuria in Colombia at clinical, biochemical and molecular levels. Materials and methods: The population consisted of seven individuals of a consanguineous family with four children with suggestive symptoms of phenylketonuria. After signing an informed consent, blood and urine samples were taken for colorimetric tests and high performance liquid and thin layer chromatographies. DNA extraction and sequencing of the 13 exons of the PAH gene were performed in all subjects. We designed primers for each exon with the Primer 3 software using automatic sequencing equipment Abiprism 3100 Avant. Sequences were analyzed using the SeqScape, v2.0, software. Results: We described the clinical and molecular characteristics of a Colombian family with phenylketonuria and confirmed the presence of the mutation c.398_401delATCA. We established a genotype-phenotype correlation, highlighting the interesting clinical variability found among the affected patients despite having the same mutation in all of them. Conclusions: Early recognition of this disease is very important to prevent its neurological and psychological sequelae, given that patients reach old age without diagnosis or proper management.

Intellectual and Developmental Status in Children With Hyperphenylalaninemia and PKU Who Were Screened in a National Program

BACKGROUND

Hyperphenylalaninemia (HPA) and Phenylkeonuria (PKU) are metabolic errors caused by deficiency of phenylalanine hydroxylase enzyme, which results in increased level of phenylalanine. This increase is toxic to the growing brain.

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to compare the intellectual and developmental status in HPA and PKU children with normal population in national screening program.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In a historical cohort study, 41 PKU patients who had the inclusion criteria and 41 healthy children were evaluated. Wechsler preschool and primary scale of intelligence-3rd edition (WPPI-3) was used in order to assess the intellectual status of children 4 years and older and Ages and stages questionnaire (ASQ) was used to assess the developmental status of children 5 years and younger.

RESULTS

In intellectual test comparison, the two groups showed significant difference in Wechsler's performance intelligence score and some performance subscales (P-value < 0.01). In comparison of developmental status, no significant difference was observed between the two groups (P-value > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Even with early diagnosis and treatment of PKU patients, these children show some deficiencies intellectually compared to normal children. This study emphasizes on necessity for screening intellectual and developmental status of PKU patients so that effective medical or educational measures can taken in case of deficiencies.

Biochemical, Metabolic, and Behavioral Characteristics of Immature Chronic Hyperphenylalanemic Rats

Phenylketonuria and hyperphenylalanemia are inborn errors in metabolism of phenylalanine arising from defects in steps to convert phenylalanine to tyrosine. Phe accumulation causes severe mental retardation that can be prevented by timely identification of affected individuals and their placement on a Phe-restricted diet. In spite of many studies in patients and animal models, the basis for acquisition of mental retardation during the critical period of brain development is not adequately understood. All animal models for human disease have advantages and limitations, and characteristics common to different models are most likely to correspond to the disorder. This study established similar levels of Phe exposure in developing rats between 3 and 16 days of age using three models to produce chronic hyperphenylalanemia, and identified changes in brain amino acid levels common to all models that persist for ~16 h of each day. In a representative model, local rates of glucose utilization (CMRglc) were determined at 25-27 days of age, and only selective changes that appeared to depend on Phe exposure were observed. CMRglc was reduced in frontal cortex and thalamus and increased in hippocampus and globus pallidus. Behavioral testing to evaluate neuromuscular competence revealed poor performance in chronically-hyperphenylalanemic rats that persisted for at least 3 weeks after cessation of Phe injections and did not occur with mild or acute hyperphenylalanemia. Thus, the abnormal amino acid environment, including hyperglycinemia, in developing rat brain is associated with selective regional changes in glucose utilization and behavioral abnormalities that are not readily reversed after they are acquired.

Clinical therapeutics for phenylketonuria

Phenylketonuria was amongst the first of the metabolic disorders to be characterised, exhibiting an inborn error in phenylalanine metabolism due to a functional deficit of the enzyme phenylalanine hydroxylase. It affects around 700,000 people around the globe. Mutations in the gene coding for hepatic phenylalanine hydroxylase cause this deficiency resulting in elevated plasma phenylalanine concentrations, leading to cognitive impairment, neuromotor disorders and related behavioural symptoms. Inception of low phenylalanine diet in the 1950s marked a revolution in the management of phenylketonuria and has since been a vital element of all therapeutic regimens. However, compliance to dietary therapy has been found difficult and newer supplement approaches are being examined. The current development of gene therapy and enzyme replacement therapeutics may offer promising alternatives for the management of phenylketonuria. This review outlines the pathological basis of phenylketonuria, various treatment regimes, their associated challenges and the future prospects of each approach. Briefly, novel drug delivery systems which can potentially deliver therapeutic strategies in phenylketonuria have been discussed.

Antioxidant treatment strategies for hyperphenylalaninemia

Hyperphenylalaninemia (HPA) leads to increased oxidative stress in patients with phenylketonuria (PKU) and in animal models of PKU. Early diagnosis and immediate adherence to a phenylalanine-restricted diet prevents HPA and, consequently, severe brain damage. However, treated adolescent and adult PKU patients have difficulties complying with the diet, leading to an oscillation of phenylalanine levels and associated oxidative stress. The brain is especially susceptible to reactive species, and oxidative stress might add to the impaired cognitive function found in these patients. The restricted PKU diet has a very limited nutrient content from natural foods and almost no animal protein, which reduces the intake of important compounds. These specific compounds can act as scavengers of reactive species and can be co-factors of antioxidant enzymes. Supplementation with nutrients, vitamins, and tetrahydropterin has given quite promising results in patients and animal models. Antioxidant supplementation has been studied in HPA, however there is no consensus about its always beneficial effects. In this way, regular exercise could be a beneficial addition on antioxidant status in PKU patients. A deeper understanding of PKU molecular biochemistry, and genetics, as well as the need for improved targeted treatment options, could lead to the development of new therapeutic strategies.

The mechanism of BH4 -responsive hyperphenylalaninemia--as it occurs in the ENU1/2 genetic mouse model

The Pah(enu1/enu2) (ENU1/2) mouse is a heteroallelic orthologous model displaying blood phenylalanine (Phe) concentrations characteristic of mild hyperphenylalaninemia. ENU1/2 mice also have reduced liver phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH) protein content (∼20% normal) and activity (∼2.5% normal). The mutant PAH protein is highly ubiquitinated, which is likely associated with its increased misfolding and instability. The administration of a single subcutaneous injection of l-Phe (1.1 mg l-Phe/g body weight) leads to an approximately twofold to threefold increase of blood Phe and phenylalanine/tyrosine (Phe/Tyr) ratio, and a 1.6-fold increase of both nonubiquitinated PAH protein content and PAH activity. It also results in elevated concentrations of liver 6R-l-erythro-5,6,7,8-tetrahydrobiopterin (BH(4)), potentially through the influence of Phe on GTP cyclohydrolase I and its feedback regulatory protein. The increased BH(4) content seems to stabilize PAH. Supplementing ENU1/2 mice with BH(4) (50 mg/kg/day for 10 days) reduces the blood Phe/Tyr ratio within the mild hyperphenylalaninemic range; however, PAH content and activity were not elevated. It therefore appears that BH(4) supplementation of ENU1/2 mice increases Phe hydroxylation levels through a kinetic rather than a chaperone stabilizing effect. By boosting blood Phe concentrations, and by BH(4) supplementation, we have revealed novel insights into the processing and regulation of the ENU1/2-mutant PAH.

Positive effect of a simplified diet on blood phenylalanine control in different phenylketonuria variants, characterized by newborn BH4 loading test and PAH analysis

Until today, the mainstay of phenylketonuria (PKU) treatment is a phenylalanine (Phe)-restricted diet. Strict dietary treatment decreases flexibility and autonomy and still has a major impact on patients and their families. Compliance is often poor, particularly in adolescence. The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of the intake of fruits and vegetables containing Phe less than 100 mg/100g ('simplified diet'), as recommended by WHO for all individuals, instead of classical totally restricted diet on the course and treatment control of the disease in a well-characterized PKU cohort (n=80). All individual blood Phe measurements of each patient (1992-2009) were statistically analyzed before and after diet switch. Epidemiological data, age at diagnosis, PAH mutations, BH(4) responsiveness, as well as Phe control measurements and detailed diet information were tabulated in a local database. 62.5% had BH4 loading test and 40% had PAH analysis; 50/80 switched from classical to simplified diet, including 26 classical PKU, 13 moderate PKU, 7 mild PKU and 4 mild hyperphenylalaninemia (HPA). Median Phe levels on a simplified diet did not differ significantly to the median Phe levels on classical diet in all disease groups. Our results indicate that a simplified diet has no negative effect on blood Phe control in patients with hyperphenylalaninemia, independent of severity of the phenotype or the age at diet switch, over the period of 3 years. Thus, a simpler approach to dietary treatment of PKU available to all HPA patients is more likely to be accepted and adhered by patients and might also increase quality of life.

Optimized loading test to evaluate responsiveness to tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4) in Brazilian patients with phenylalanine hydroxylase deficiency

INTRODUCTION

Recent studies showed that phenylalanine (Phe) plasma concentrations may decrease in some patients with hyperphenylalaninemia (HPA) due to phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH) deficiency, after the administration of tetrahydrobiopterin (BH(4)).

OBJECTIVE

To determine responsiveness to a single dose of BH(4) administered according to an innovative protocol using a combined Phe and BH(4) loading test in Brazilian phenylketonuria (PKU) patients.

METHODS

Patient age should be ≥ 4 years, and median Phe plasma concentration ≤ 600 μmol/L when following dietary restrictions. Participants received a simple Phe loading test using 100mg/kg L-Phe (Test 1) and a combined Phe+BH(4) loading test using 100mg/kg L-Phe and 20mg/kg/BH(4) (Test 2). Blood samples were collected at baseline and 3, 11 and 27 h after Phe ingestion (T0, T1, T2 and T3). Responsiveness was defined as: criterion A: plasma Phe reduction of ≥ 30% at T1 and T2 for Tests 1 and 2; criterion B: plasma Phe reduction of ≥ 30% at T1 and T3 for Tests 1 and 2; and criterion C: at least 30% difference of the areas under the Phe curve for Tests 1 and 2.

RESULTS

Eighteen patients (median age 12 yrs; 8 classical PKU; 10 mild PKU) participated in the study. Six patients (2 classical PKU; 4 mild PKU) were classified as responsive according to at least one of the criteria. Responsiveness was concordant when criteria A + B we compared with criterion C (kappa = 0.557; p = 0.017). Of the patients whose genotype was available (n = 16), six had data about BH(4)-responsiveness genotypes described in the literature, which were in agreement with our findings.

CONCLUSION

The comparison of simple Phe loading and combined Phe + BH(4) loading seems to be an optimal method to evaluate responsiveness to BH(4) in patients with good metabolic control.

5-Hydroxytryptophan during critical postnatal period improves cognitive performances and promotes dendritic spine maturation in genetic mouse model of phenylketonuria

Although phenylketonuria (PKU) is the most common genetic cause of mental retardation, the cellular mechanisms underlying impaired brain function are still unclear. Using PAHenu2 mice (ENU2), the genetic mouse model of PKU, we previously demonstrated that high phenylalanine levels interfere with brain tryptophan hydroxylase activity by reducing the availability of serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine, 5-HT), crucial for maturation of neuronal connectivity in the prefrontal cortex (PFC), around the third postnatal week, a critical period for cortical maturation. 5-Hydroxytryptophan (5-HTP), the product of tryptophan hydroxylation, is known to be a better treatment to increase brain 5-HT levels. In this study we investigated the role of 5-HT during the early postnatal period in cognitive disturbances and in cortical dendritic alterations of PKU subjects by restoring temporarily (postnatal days 14-21) physiological brain levels of 5-HT in ENU2 through 5-HTP treatment. In adult ENU2 mice early 5-HTP treatment reverses cognitive deficits in spatial and object recognition tests accompanied by an increase in spine maturation of pyramidal neurons in layer V of the prelimbic/infralimbic area of the PFC, although locomotor deficits are not recovered by treatment. Taken together, our results support the hypothesis that mental retardation in PKU depends on reduced availability of brain 5-HT during critical developmental periods that interferes with cortical maturation and point to 5-HTP supplementation as a highly promising additional tool to heal PKU patients.

Introduction of sapropterin dihydrochloride as standard of care in patients with phenylketonuria

Sapropterin dihydrochloride, a synthetic, stable form of the tetrahydrobiopterin cofactor of phenylalanine hydroxylase, has been shown to reduce plasma phenylalanine (Phe) levels in a significant portion of patients with phenylketonuria (PKU). When we undertook introducing this medication to our PKU clinic population, the challenges of recalling and reconnecting with a variably treated and variably compliant patient population became apparent. We offered a trial of sapropterin to all of our clinic patients with PKU. In order to determine responsiveness, we used a two tier dose escalation protocol. After diet records were taken, and baseline plasma Phe levels were established, a 7-day trial of sapropterin at 10mg/kg/day was started. At day 8, plasma phenylalanine levels were measured. Patients were considered to be responders if they had a 30% reduction in plasma Phe. If they did not respond, the dose of sapropterin was increased to 20 mg/kg/day, and levels were rechecked again in 8 days. Patients who were not responders at this time continued sapropterin for a total of 30 days and had Phe levels checked one last time. Patients who were responders and who were on a Phe-restricted diet underwent gradual liberalization of their diet to the maximum tolerated natural protein intake while still maintaining plasma levels in the acceptable treatment range of 120-360 micromol/L. In our population, 36/39 patients with hyperphenylalaninemia (HPA) who were offered a trial of sapropterin elected to start sapropterin. Five of 36 patients were non-adherent with diet records and/or medication doses and we were unable to determine if they were responders. We were unable to categorize 2 of 31 of the patients who completed the trial as responders due to dietary issues, though they were probably responders. Of the 29 patients who completed the sapropterin trial and we could categorize, 18/29 (62%) were determined to be responders. Patients were classified based on their off-diet diagnostic plasma phenylalanine levels as classical PKU (>1200 micromol/L) and variant PKU (>400 and <1200 micromol/L). The group with variant PKU had a 100% response rate, and patients with classical PKU had a 27% response rate. For the patients in the responder group who were on Phe-restricted diet, we were able to liberalize most diets, in two cases to unrestricted protein intake. We also had unexpected beneficial findings in our clinic experience, including positive behavioral improvements in an adult severely affected by untreated PKU. Even in patients who were not considered to be responders, the introduction of sapropterin provided a tool to reconnect with patients and re-introduce beneficial dietary measures.

Phenylketonuria management from an European perspective: a commentary

Phenylketonuria is discussed from an European perspective, addressing the need of common definitions of terms commonly used, the need of a world-wide guideline on the diagnosis and treatment of phenylketonuria, the differences between existing European guidelines, and day-to-day care, further directives for the near future, and changing the concept from compliance to concordance, in which patients have a more clearly defined responsibility.

Comparison of adeno-associated virus pseudotype 1, 2, and 8 vectors administered by intramuscular injection in the treatment of murine phenylketonuria

Phenylketonuria (PKU) is caused by hepatic phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH) deficiency and is associated with systemic accumulation of phenylalanine (Phe). Previously we demonstrated correction of murine PKU after intravenous injection of a recombinant type 2 adeno-associated viral vector pseudotyped with type 8 capsid (rAAV2/8), which successfully directed hepatic transduction and Pah gene expression. Here, we report that liver PAH activity and phenylalanine clearance were also restored in PAH-deficient mice after simple intramuscular injection of either AAV2 pseudotype 1 (rAAV2/1) or rAAV2/8 vectors. Serotype 2 AAV vector (rAAV2/2) was also investigated, but long-term phenylalanine clearance has been observed only for pseudotypes 1 and 8. Therapeutic correction was shown in both male and female mice, albeit more effectively in males, in which correction lasted for the entire period of the experiment (>1 year). Although phenylalanine levels began to rise in female mice at about 8-10 months after rAAV2/8 injection they remained only mildly hyperphenylalaninemic thereafter and subsequent supplementation with synthetic tetrahydrobiopterin resulted in a transient decrease in blood phenylalanine. Alternatively, subsequent administration of a second vector with a different AAV pseudotype to avoid immunity against the previously administrated vector was also successful for long-term treatment of female PKU mice. Overall, this relatively less invasive gene transfer approach completes our previous studies and allows comparison of complementary strategies in the development of efficient PKU gene therapy protocols.

Reassessment of phenylalanine tolerance in adults with phenylketonuria is needed as body mass changes

Lifelong treatment of phenylketonuria (PKU) includes a phenylalanine (phe) restricted diet that provides sufficient phe for growth and maintenance plus phe-free amino acid formula to meet requirements for protein, energy and micronutrients. Phe tolerance (mg phe/kg body weight/day) is the amount of phe those with PKU can consume and maintain acceptable blood phe levels; it requires individual assessment because of varying phenylalanine hydroxylase activity. The objective was to reassess phe tolerance in eight adults with PKU considering phe requirements, blood phe levels, genotype and phe tolerance at 5 years of age. Subjects had not received a personalized assessment of phe tolerance in several years, and five subjects were overweight, body mass index (BMI) 25-28. With the guidance of a metabolic dietitian, seven subjects increased phe tolerance (by 15-173%) without significantly increasing blood phe concentration. Increased phe tolerance was associated with both improved dietary compliance and inadequate phe intake at the onset of the protocol compared with current requirements. Improved dietary compliance reflected increased consumption of protein equivalents from amino acid formula and increased frequency of formula intake, from 2.2 to 3 times per day. Predictors of higher final phe tolerance following reassessment included being male and having a lower BMI (R(2)=0.588). This suggests that the rising trend of overweight and obesity may affect assessment of phe tolerance in adults. Therefore, interaction with the metabolic dietitian to reassess phe tolerance in relation to body mass is essential throughout adulthood to insure adequate intake of phe to support protein synthesis and prevent catabolism.

Large neutral amino acids supplementation in phenylketonuric patients

Phenylketonuria is an inborn error of amino acid metabolism that results in severe mental retardation if not treated early and appropriately. The traditional treatment, consisting of a low-phenylalanine diet, is usually difficult to maintain throughout adolescence and adulthood, resulting in undesirable levels of blood phenylalanine and consequent neurotoxicity. The neurotoxicity of phenylalanine is enhanced by its transport mechanism across the blood-brain barrier, which has the highest affinity for phenylalanine compared with the other large neutral amino acids that share the same carrier. The supplementation of large neutral amino acids in phenylketonuric patients has been showing interesting results. Plasma phenylalanine levels can be reduced, which may guarantee important metabolic and clinical benefits to these patients. Although long-term studies are needed to determine the efficacy and safety of large neutral amino acids supplements, the present state of knowledge seems to recommend their prescription to all phenylketonuric adult patients who are non-compliant with the low-phenylalanine diet.