Presentation, progression, and predictors of ovarian insufficiency in classic galactosemia

Health and well-being of maturing adults with classic galactosemia

Long-term outcomes in classic galactosemia (CG) have been studied previously, but all prior studies have relied on cohorts of patients that were small in number, or heavily skewed toward children and young adults, or both. Here, we extend what is known about the health and well-being of maturing adults with CG by analyzing the results of anonymous custom surveys completed by 92 affected individuals, ages 30-78, and 38 unaffected sibling controls, ages 30-79. The median age for patients was 38.5 years and for controls was 41 years. These study participants hailed from 12 different countries predominantly representing Europe and North America. Participants reported on their general life experiences and outcomes in seven different domains including: speech/voice/language, cognition, motor function, cataracts, bone health, psychosocial well-being, and gastrointestinal health. We also queried women about ovarian function. Our results indicated a prevalence of long-term complications across all outcome domains that aligned with levels previously reported in younger cohorts. Given the sample size and age range of participants in this study, these findings strongly suggest that the adverse developmental outcomes commonly linked to CG are not progressive with age for most patients. We also tested four candidate modifiers for possible association with each of the outcomes followed, including: days of neonatal milk exposure, rigor of dietary galactose restriction in early childhood, current age, and home continent. We observed no associations that reached even nominal significance, except for the following: cataracts with neonatal milk exposure (p = 2.347e-04), cataracts with age (p = 0.018), and bone health with home continent (p = 0.03).

Long-term complications in classic galactosemia are not progressive

Classic galactosemia (CG) is a potentially lethal genetic disorder that results from profound deficiency of galactose-1-P uridylyltransferase. Despite early detection and life-long dietary restriction of galactose, which is the current standard of care, many patients with CG grow to experience a range of long-term developmental complications that can include difficulties with speech/voice/language, cognitive, motor, and psychosocial outcomes, among other problems. That these complications are common in CG is well-documented, but whether they are also progressive has been a point of controversy for decades. Here, we addressed the question of whether long-term outcomes in CG are progressive by analyzing a robust data set in each of 4 ways. First, we compared cross-sectional Vineland-3 Adaptive Behavior Scales scores for 101 cases and 65 unaffected sibling controls and found no evidence of consistently declining scores with age. Second, we analyzed longitudinal Vineland-3 subdomain scores for 45 cases and 34 controls to see if individual participants demonstrated developmental gains (positive slope) or losses (negative slope) over time. The changes in most growth scale value (GSV) scores, which are not normed, were positive for both cases and controls <10y, and either positive or near zero for participants ≥10y. In contrast, the slopes of most v-Scale scores, which are normed, were negative for many cases <10y, indicating that these children, while gaining milestones, were gaining them at a slower pace than their counterparts in the reference population. Third, we analyzed medical records from 76 cases, assigning ordinal scores for complications and gathering the quantitative results of relevant formal assessments where available. Both cross-sectional and longitudinal analyses of both ordinal and formal assessment scores confirmed that outcomes were mostly stable, albeit with some ups and downs in isolated cases. Finally, we analyzed data collected via custom family-response surveys from 124 cases and 67 controls regarding each participant's perceived symptom severity over time. Among cases, the percentages of respondents reporting worsening symptoms over time for speech, cognitive, motor, and psychosocial outcomes were 0.8%, 6.6%, 5.2%, and 9.8%, respectively. Among controls, the corresponding percentages were 0.0%, 1.5%, 1.5%, and 6.5%, respectively. These results provide compelling evidence that long-term developmental complications are not progressive for a majority of patients with CG.

Racial and ethnic diversity of classic and clinical variant galactosemia in the United States

Classic and clinical variant galactosemia (CG/CVG) are allelic, autosomal recessive disorders that result from deficiency of galactose-1-P uridylyltransferase (GALT). CG/CVG has been reported globally among patients of diverse ancestries, but most large studies of outcomes have included, almost exclusively, patients categorized as White or Caucasian. As a first step to explore whether the cohorts studied are representative of the CG/CVG population at large, we sought to define the racial and ethnic makeup of CG/CVG newborns in a diverse population with essentially universal newborn screening (NBS) for galactosemia: the United States (US). First, we estimated the predicted racial and ethnic distribution of CG/CVG by combining the reported demographics of US newborns from 2016 to 2018 with predicted homozygosity or compound heterozygosity of pathogenic, or likely pathogenic, GALT alleles from the relevant ancestral groups. Incorporating some simplifying assumptions, we predicted that of US newborns diagnosed with CG/CVG, 65% should be White (non-Hispanic), 23% should be Black (non-Hispanic), 10% should be Hispanic, and 2% should be Asian (non-Hispanic). Next, we calculated the observed racial and ethnic distribution of US newborns diagnosed with CG/CVG using available de-identified data from state NBS programs from 2016 to 2018. Of the 235 newborns in this cohort, 41 were categorized as other or unknown. Of the remaining 194, 66% were White (non-Hispanic or ethnicity unknown), 16% were Black (non-Hispanic or ethnicity unknown),15% were Hispanic, and 2% were Asian (non-Hispanic or ethnicity unknown). This observed distribution was statistically indistinguishable from the predicted distribution. To the limits of our study, these data confirm the racial and ethnic diversity of newborns with CG/CVG in the US, demonstrate an approach for estimating CG/CVG racial and ethnic diversity in other populations, and raise the troubling possibility that current understanding of long-term outcomes in CG/CVG may be skewed by ascertainment bias of the cohorts studied.

A multinational study of acute and long-term outcomes of Type 1 galactosemia patients who carry the S135L (c.404C > T) variant of GALT

Patients with galactosemia who carry the S135L (c.404C > T) variant of galactose-1-P uridylyltransferase (GALT), documented to encode low-level residual GALT activity, have been under-represented in most prior studies of outcomes in Type 1 galactosemia. What is known about the acute and long-term outcomes of these patients, therefore, is based on very limited data. Here, we present a study comparing acute and long-term outcomes of 12 patients homozygous for S135L, 25 patients compound heterozygous for S135L, and 105 patients homozygous for two GALT-null (G) alleles. This is the largest cohort of S135L patients characterized to date. Acute disease following milk exposure in the newborn period was common among patients in all 3 comparison groups in our study, as were long-term complications in the domains of speech, cognition, and motor outcomes. In contrast, while at least 80% of both GALT-null and S135L compound heterozygous girls and women showed evidence of an adverse ovarian outcome, prevalence was only 25% among S135L homozygotes. Further, all young women in this study with even one copy of S135L achieved spontaneous menarche; this is true for only about 33% of women with classic galactosemia. Overall, we observed that while most long-term outcomes trended milder among groups of patients with even one copy of S135L, many individual patients, either homozygous or compound heterozygous for S135L, nonetheless experienced long-term outcomes that were not mild. This was true despite detection by newborn screening and both early and life-long dietary restriction of galactose. This information should empower more evidence-based counseling for galactosemia patients with S135L.

Laparoscopic ovarian tissue harvesting for cryopreservation from a child with galactosemia

OBJECTIVE

To describe an approach to fertility preservation by a multidisciplinary team of reproductive endocrinology and infertility, pediatric gynecology and surgery, and genetics experts via ovarian tissue harvesting and cryopreservation for a toddler with galactosemia. Galactosemia is associated with progressive primary ovarian insufficiency (POI) and early intervention with ovarian tissue cryopreservation may help preserve fertility.

DESIGN

Video description of a tissue harvesting and cryopreservation technique.

SETTING

Academic institution.

PATIENT(S)

16-month-old female with classic galactosemia.

INTERVENTION(S)

At 6 months of age, despite good metabolic control, the infant's antimüllerian hormone (AMH) level was <0.015 ng/ml; luteinizing hormone level was 3.1 mIU/ml; and follicle stimulating hormone level was 30.2 mIU/ml. She was referred by her geneticist to the reproductive endocrinology and infertility specialist for fertility preservation. The AMH levels and pelvic magnetic resonance imaging findings of the patient were monitored over the next 9 months. Although the magnetic resonance imaging exam showed the presence of a dominant follicle in the right ovary and multiple small antral follicles in both ovaries at the age of 8 months, her laboratory assessment at the age of 14 months suggested impending POI (estradiol level <11.80 pg/mL; LH, 3.3 mIU/ml; follicle stimulating hormone, 35.97 mIU/ml; AMH, 0.03 ng/mL). At 16 months of age, given the low AMH levels, right ovary was laparoscopically harvested, so that a sufficient reserve of primordial follicles may be cryopreserved for fertility preservation. We dissected the mesosalpinx initially to separate the ovary from the tube in a manner that minimized the effects of cauterization on the ovary and preserved the fallopian tube.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Successful harvesting and cryopreservation of the ovarian tissue containing primordial follicles.

RESULT(S)

The right ovary, which measured 20 × 3 × 3mm, was bisected under a stereomicroscope along the hilum, trimmed to the cortical thickness of 1 mm and sliced into eight 4 × 4-mm pieces. These were then frozen with an established slow freezing protocol. The child was discharged the same day and had an uneventful postoperative course. A subsequent histological examination showed presence of primordial follicles, albeit at a reduced density for her age.

CONCLUSION(S)

Ovarian tissue cryopreservation is feasible in very young female children with rare genetic disorders associated with POI. We illustrated the unique aspects of performing these procedures in very young children.

Pathophysiology of long-term complications in classic galactosemia: What we do and do not know

Despite many decades of research involving both human subjects and model systems, the underlying pathophysiology of long-term complications in classic galactosemia (CG) remains poorly understood. In this review, intended for those already familiar with galactosemia, we focus on the big questions relating to outcomes, mechanism, and markers, drawing on relevant literature where available, attempting to navigate inconsistencies where they appear, and acknowledging gaps in knowledge where they persist.

SRT1720 plays a role in oxidative stress and the senescence of human trophoblast HTR8/SVneo cells induced by D-galactose through the SIRT1/FOXO3a/ROS signalling pathway

D-galactose (D-gal) is a reducing sugar widely distributed in food. In a pregnant animal model exposed to D-gal, D-gal was found to have toxic effects on both the mother and foetus through oxidative stress. However, little is known about the effect of D-gal exposure on the placenta and its underlying mechanism. In this study, we evaluated the effects of D-gal on HTR8/SVneo cells and the mechanisms in vitro. In the present study, the activity of HTR8/SVneo human trophoblasts decreased in a time- and concentration-dependent manner after exposure to D-gal. D-gal resulted in premature senescence of HTR8/SVneo cells, as confirmed by assessing β-galactosidase (SA-β-gal) activity and the expression of senescence-related factor p21. We also verified the damage of oxidative stress induced by D-gal by measuring the expression of reactive oxygen species (ROS), sirtuin 1 (SIRT1) and forkhead box O (FOXO) 3a. SRT1720, as a SIRT1 activator, mitigated D-gal-induced oxidative stress and senescence by upregulating SIRT1 and FOXO3a expression and reducing ROS production. Our data suggest that D-gal may induce HTR8/SVneo premature ageing through the SIRT1/FOXO3a/ROS signalling pathway mediated by oxidative stress and that SIRT1 protects cells from this damage.

Galactosaemia occurring in association with primary ovarian insufficiency, Addison's disease and chronic myeloid leukaemia

Classic galactosaemia is the most severe type, inherited in an autosomal recessive fashion and normally detected on newborn screening. It is caused by an inability to digest galactose due to a deficiency of galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT), resulting in an intolerance of feeds in the neonatal period, failure to thrive, hypoglycaemia, jaundice, cataracts, hepatomegaly, vomiting, diarrhoea, developmental delay and an increased risk of Escherichia coli sepsis. The long-term sequelae of this disorder include cognitive impairment, neurological symptoms, such as ataxia, nutritional deficiencies, such as calcium and vitamin D, and gonadal dysfunction. We report here a case of a 34-year-old woman with classic galactosaemia diagnosed in adulthood, developing primary ovarian insufficiency and osteoporosis as well as primary adrenal insufficiency and chronic myeloid leukaemia, which are two associations not seen in current literature. Further studies are needed to determine if an association exists between these diseases.

Premature ovarian insufficiency - the need for a genomic map

Premature ovarian insufficiency (POI) is a life-long disorder of heterogeneous etiology, presenting as adolescent primary amenorrhea in its most severe form, with an overall incidence of 1%. Idiopathic POI accounts for up to 70% of women with POI; and genomic, genetic, epidemiological, familial and cohort studies demonstrate a genetic component to this condition. Currently, the only genetic tests routinely performed in non-syndromic POI are FMR1 premutation and cytogenetics, the latter specifically for X-chromosome abnormalities. However, a myriad of genetic aberrations has been identified and implicated, some of which act in a monogenic Mendelian fashion. The presence of multiple genetic aberrations and the complexity of POI genomics are hardly surprising since the embryological formation of the primordial oocyte pool, postnatal oogenesis and folliculogenesis are all highly complex pathways. With this review, the aim is to discuss the current genetic etiologies in the emerging field of POI genomics. Promising candidate genes include STAG3, SYCE1, FIGLA, NOBOX, FSHR, BMP15 and INHA. This area has the potential to progress rapidly in light of advances in genomic technologies. The development of a POI genomic map not only will assist in understanding the underlying molecular mechanisms affecting ovarian function but will also be essential in designing predictive and diagnostic gene panels as well as future novel therapeutic strategies.

Pathophysiology and management of classic galactosemic primary ovarian insufficiency

Classic galactosemia is an inborn error of carbohydrate metabolism associated with early-onset primary ovarian insufficiency (POI) in young women. Our understanding of the consequences of galactosemia upon fertility and fecundity of affected women is expanding, but there are important remaining gaps in our knowledge and tools for its management, and a need for continued dialog so that the special features of the condition can be better managed. Here, we review galactosemic POI and its reproductive endocrinological clinical sequelae and summarize current best clinical practices for its management. Special consideration is given to the very early-onset nature of the condition in the pediatric/adolescent patient. Afterward, we summarize our current understanding of the reproductive pathophysiology of galactosemia, including the potential action of toxic galactose metabolites upon the ovary. Our work establishing that ovarian cellular stress reminiscent of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress is present in a mouse model of galactosemia, as well as work by other groups, are summarized.

LAY SUMMARY

Patients with the condition of classic galactosemia need to maintain a strict lifelong diet that excludes the sugar galactose. This is due to having mutations in enzymes that process galactose, resulting in the buildup of toxic metabolic by-products of the sugar. Young women with classic galactosemia often lose the function of their ovaries very early in life (termed 'primary ovarian insufficiency'), despite adherence to a galactose-restricted diet. This means that in addition to the consequences of the disease, these women also face infertility and the potential need for hormone replacement therapy. This article summarizes current strategies for managing the care of galactosemic girls and women and also what is known of how the condition leads to early primary ovarian insufficiency.

Puberty and fertility in classic galactosemia

Classic galactosemia is a rare inborn error of galactose metabolism with a birth prevalence of about 1/30,000-60,000. Long-term complications occurring despite dietary treatment consist of premature ovarian insufficiency (POI) and neurodevelopmental impairments. We performed with the French Reference Centers for Rare Diseases a multisite collaborative questionnaire survey for classic galactosemic patients. Its primary objective was to assess their puberty, pregnancy, gonadotropic axis, and pelvic morphology by ultrasound. The secondary objective was to determine predictive factors for pregnancy without oocyte donation. Completed questionnaires from 103 patients, 56 females (median age, 19 years (3-52 years)) and 47 males (median age, 19 years (3-45 years)), were analyzed. Among the 43 females older than 13 years old, mean age for breast development first stage was 13.8 years; spontaneous menarche occurred in 21/31 females at a mean age of 14.6 years. In these 21 women, 62% had spaniomenorrhea and 7/17 older than 30 years had amenorrhea. All age-groups confounded, FSH was above reference range for 65.7% of the patients, anti-Müllerian hormone and inhibin B were undetectable, and the ovaries were small with few or no follicles detected. Among the 5 females who sought to conceive, 4 had pregnancies. Among the 47 males, 1 had cryptorchidism, all have normal testicular function and none had a desire to conceive children. Thus, spontaneous puberty and POI are both common in this population. Spontaneous menarche seems to be the best predictive factor for successful spontaneous pregnancy.

A galactose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase-null rat model of classic galactosemia mimics relevant patient outcomes and reveals tissue-specific and longitudinal differences in galactose metabolism

Classic galactosemia (CG) is a potentially lethal inborn error of metabolism, if untreated, that results from profound deficiency of galactose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase (GALT), the middle enzyme of the Leloir pathway of galactose metabolism. While newborn screening and rapid dietary restriction of galactose prevent or resolve the potentially lethal acute symptoms of CG, by mid-childhood, most treated patients experience significant complications. The mechanisms underlying these long-term deficits remain unclear. Here we introduce a new GALT-null rat model of CG and demonstrate that these rats display cataracts, cognitive, motor, and growth phenotypes reminiscent of patients outcomes. We further apply the GALT-null rats to test how well blood biomarkers, typically followed in patients, reflect metabolic perturbations in other, more relevant tissues. Our results document that the relative levels of galactose metabolites seen in GALT deficiency differ widely by tissue and age, and that red blood cell Gal-1P, the marker most commonly followed in patients, shows no significant association with Gal-1P in other tissues. The work reported here establishes our outbred GALT-null rats as an effective model for at least four complications characteristic of CG, and sets the stage for future studies addressing mechanism and testing the efficacy of novel candidate interventions.

The natural history of classic galactosemia: lessons from the GalNet registry

BACKGROUND

Classic galactosemia is a rare inborn error of carbohydrate metabolism, caused by a severe deficiency of the enzyme galactose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase (GALT). A galactose-restricted diet has proven to be very effective to treat the neonatal life-threatening manifestations and has been the cornerstone of treatment for this severe disease. However, burdensome complications occur despite a lifelong diet. For rare diseases, a patient disease specific registry is fundamental to monitor the lifespan pathology and to evaluate the safety and efficacy of potential therapies. In 2014, the international Galactosemias Network (GalNet) developed a web-based patient registry for this disease, the GalNet Registry. The aim was to delineate the natural history of classic galactosemia based on a large dataset of patients.

METHODS

Observational data derived from 15 countries and 32 centers including 509 patients were acquired between December 2014 and July 2018.

RESULTS

Most affected patients experienced neonatal manifestations (79.8%) and despite following a diet developed brain impairments (85.0%), primary ovarian insufficiency (79.7%) and a diminished bone mineral density (26.5%). Newborn screening, age at onset of dietary treatment, strictness of the galactose-restricted diet, p.Gln188Arg mutation and GALT enzyme activity influenced the clinical picture. Detection by newborn screening and commencement of diet in the first week of life were associated with a more favorable outcome. A homozygous p.Gln188Arg mutation, GALT enzyme activity of ≤ 1% and strict galactose restriction were associated with a less favorable outcome.

CONCLUSION

This study describes the natural history of classic galactosemia based on the hitherto largest data set.

Metabolic perturbations in classic galactosemia beyond the Leloir pathway: Insights from an untargeted metabolomic study

Classic galactosemia (CG) is an autosomal recessive disorder that impacts close to 1/50000 live births in the United States, with varying prevalence in other countries. Following exposure to milk, which contains high levels of galactose, affected infants may experience rapid onset and progression of potentially lethal symptoms. With the benefit of early diagnosis, generally by newborn screening, and immediate and lifelong dietary restriction of galactose, the acute sequelae of disease can be prevented or resolved. However, long-term complications are common, and despite many decades of research, the bases of these complications remain unexplained. As a step toward defining the underlying pathophysiology of long-term outcomes in CG, we applied an untargeted metabolomic approach with mass spectrometry and dual liquid chromatography, comparing thousands of small molecules in plasma samples from 183 patients and 31 controls. All patients were on galactose-restricted diets. Using both univariate and multivariate statistical methods, we identified 252 differentially abundant features from anion exchange chromatography and 167 differentially abundant features from C₁₈ chromatography. Mapping these discriminatory features to putative metabolites and biochemical pathways revealed 14 significantly perturbed pathways; these included multiple redox, amino acid, and mitochondrial pathways, among others. Finally, we tested whether any discriminatory features also distinguished cases with mild vs more severe long-term outcomes and found multiple candidates, of which one achieved false discovery rate-adjusted q < 0.1. These results extend substantially from prior targeted studies of metabolic perturbation in CG and offer a new approach to identifying candidate modifiers and targets for intervention.