Hormesis and paradoxical effects of pea (Pisum sativum L.) parameters upon exposure to formaldehyde in a wide range of doses

The hormetic response of heart rate of fish embryos to contaminants - Implications for research and policy

Evidence of contaminant-induced hormesis is rapidly accumulating, while the underlying mechanisms of hormesis are becoming increasingly understood. Recent developments in this research area, and especially the emergence of the nuclear factor-erythroid factor 2-related factor 2 (Nrf2) as the master mechanism, suggest that contaminants can induce cardiac hormetic responses. This paper collates significant evidence of hormetic response of the heart rate of fish embryos to contaminants, in particular antibiotics, microplastics, and herbicides, characterized by a low-dose increase (tachycardia) and a high-dose decrease (bradycardia). The increase often occurs at doses about 100-800 times smaller than the no-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL). There are also indications for even triphasic responses, which include a sub-hormetic decrease of the heart rate by doses over 10⁶ times smaller than the NOAEL. Such sub-NOAEL effects cannot be captured by linear-no-threshold (LNT) and threshold models, raising concerns about environmental health and highlighting the pressing need to consider hormetic responses in the ecological risk assessment. A visionary way forward is proposed, but addressing this research bottleneck would require improved research designs with enhanced ability and statistical power to study diphasic and triphasic responses of heart rate.

Atmospheric Pb induced hormesis in the accumulator plant Tillandsia usneoides

While numerous studies reported hormesis in plants exposed to heavy metals, metals were commonly added in the growth substrate (e.g. soil or solution). The potential of heavy metals in the atmosphere to induce hormesis in plants, however, remains unknown. In this study, we exposed the widely-used accumulator plant Tillandsia usneoides to 10 atmospheric Pb concentrations (0-25.6 μg·m^-3) for 6 or 12 h. Three types of dose-response relationships between different response endpoints (biomarkers) and Pb concentrations were found for T. usneoides. The first was a monophasic dose response, in which the response increased linearly with increasing Pb concentrations, as seen for metallothionein (MT) content after a 6-h exposure. The second and dominating type was a biphasic-hormetic dose response, exhibited by malondialdehyde (MDA), superoxide anion radical (O₂^-), and superoxide dismutase (SOD) after 6 or 12 h of exposure and by glutathione (GSH) and MT content after 12 h of treatment. The third type was a triphasic dose response, as seen for leaf electric conductivity after 6 or 12 h of exposure and GSH after 6 h of exposure. This finding suggests that Pb inhibited the response of T. usneoides at very low concentrations, stimulated it at low-to-moderate concentrations, and inhibited it at higher concentrations. Our results demonstrate diverse adaptation mechanisms of plants to stress, in the framework of which alternating between up- and down-regulation of biomarkers is at play when responding to different levels of toxicants. The emergence of the triphasic dose response will further enhance the understanding of time-dependent hormesis.

Environmental hormesis of non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms in plants

Adaptive responses of plants are important not only for local processes in populations and communities but also for global processes in the biosphere through the primary production of ecosystems. In recent years, the concept of environmental hormesis has been increasingly used to explain the adaptive responses of living organisms, including plants, to low doses of natural factors, both abiotic and biotic, as well as various anthropogenic impacts. However, the issues of whether plant hormesis is similar/different when it is induced by mild stressors having different specific effects and what is the contribution of hormetic stimulation of non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms in plant resilience to strong stressors (i.e., preconditioning) remains unclear. This paper analyses hormetic stimulation of non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms in plants and its significance for preconditioning, the phenomenon of the hormetic trade-off for these mechanisms, and the position of hormetic stimulation of non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms in the system of plant adaptations to environmental challenges. The analysis has shown that both non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms of plants can be stimulated hormetically by mild stressors and are important for plant preconditioning. Due to limited plant resources, non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms have hormetic trades-offs 1 (hormesis accompanied by the deterioration of some plant traits) and 2 (hormesis of some plant traits with the invariability of others). At the same time, hormetic trade-off 2 is observed much more often than hormetic trade-off 1, at least, this was demonstrated here for non-specific adaptive responses of plants. The hormetic stimulation of non-specific and specific adaptive mechanisms is part of the inducible adaptation of plants caused by stress factors and is an adaptation to random (unpredictable) changes in the environment.

Formaldehyde: Another hormesis-inducing chemical

Formaldehyde (FA) is a naturally-occurring compound, produced endogenously in diverse living organisms. It also occurs widely in the environment due to anthropogenic (e.g. used as a chemical intermediate) and natural sources (e.g. a component of the volatile organic compounds blends emitted by plants). While FA is considered a potential carcinogen, living organisms have the ability to cope with FA, and some minimum endogenous levels of FA may be required for health. Recently, genetic engineering approaches transferring biological information from one organism to another led to increased assimilation of and conferred genetic-based tolerance to FA in plants-microorganisms systems. Here, we propose that FA commonly induces hormesis, a hypothesis that we confirm by collating evidence from various published studies with animals, plants, and microorganisms. The stimulation by low doses below the no-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL) was modest in magnitude, in agreement with the general hormesis literature. In plants, among the endpoints showing hormesis were growth, lipid peroxidation, and photosynthetic pigments. In various animal cells, hormesis was observed in cell proliferation and viability, responses that were related to mechanisms, such as activation of phosphorylated ERK (extra-cellular signaling-regulated kinase) expression, acceleration of the process of cell division, and enhancement of the Warburg effect (i.e. use of glycolysis by tumor cells to produce energy for rapid growth). Hormetic in vitro responses were reported in several cancerous/tumorous cell lines, suggesting that FA has the potential to influence tumor promotion within a specific concentration range and biological context. These observations suggest that FA commonly acts in an hormetic manner with implications for study designs across a broad range of biological models and in the assessment of environmental and human risks associated with FA exposures.

Estimating the frequency of hormesis and other non-monotonic responses in plants experiencing road traffic pollution in urban areas and experimental pollutant exposure

Various plant traits are widely utilised to assess environment health. However, non-monotonic responses in plants (hormesis and non-hormetic ones) can induce an incorrect assessment of contamination level because they have maximums and/or minimums. Hence, an increase in the pollution level will not always be accompanied by plant index deteriorations. The frequencies of non-monotonic responses, especially non-hormetic responses, have been insufficiently studied for plant traits. This study analysed the frequencies of non-monotonic changes in plants experiencing urban chemical pollution (B. pendula, T. cordata and T. officinale) and with different pollutant exposures (heavy metals, herbicide glyphosate, formaldehyde and sodium chloride) in experiments (T. aestivum and P. sativum). In the city, we evaluated the traits in plants with the same ontogenetic stages on plots near roads with various traffic and similar abiotic conditions. In urban areas, non-monotonic responses were found in both woody (B. pendula and T. cordata) and herbaceous (T. officinale) species for most traits. Their frequencies corresponded to the proportion of monotonic responses (B. pendula) or were even higher (T. cordata and T. officinale). In studied trees, non-monotonic responses were more common in biochemical traits compared with non-biochemical ones. With experimental pollutant exposure, non-monotonic responses were obtained for most traits of both dicotyledonous (P. sativum) and monocotyledonous (T. aestivum) plants, and their frequency was significantly higher than for monotonic ones. Non-hormetic responses significantly prevailed among non-monotonic changes of plant indexes in the city and experiments. Thus, it is necessary to consider both hormesis and non-hormetic responses to assess correctly environmental quality using plant indexes.

Change of Leaf Trait Asymmetry Type in Tilia cordata Mill. and Betula pendula Roth under Air Pollution

Leaf fluctuating asymmetry (FA) is widely used as an environmental stress index, including pollution. Besides FA, leaf bilateral traits can have directional asymmetry (DA) and antisymmetry (AS), which are considered hereditary. Leaf FA transitioning to DA/AS or mixed asymmetry, under air pollution, has been insufficiently investigated. This study analysed leaf asymmetry types in Tilia cordata Mill. and Betula pendula Roth under traffic air pollution over several years. In addition, the relations of such transitions to pollution, and their effect on FA-integrated index, were studied. The asymmetry types of all studied leaf traits varied with air pollution increase, as well as in control trees in different years. T. cordata most often had FA transition to DA/mixed asymmetry, while B. pendula rarely had a mixed asymmetry and FA transitions to DA/AS were observed with the same frequency. Air pollution impacted FA transitions to other asymmetry types. In most cases their frequency changed non-monotonically that corresponded to hormesis and paradoxical effects. However, FA integrated index in studied trees did not depend on change of leaf asymmetry type. Thus, DA and AS in studied plants were not exclusively hereditary. Hence, the changes of leaf asymmetry type should be considered when using leaf FA in environment assessment.

Magnitude of the mixture hormetic response of soil alkaline phosphatase can be predicted based on single conditions of Cd and Pb

In soil ecosystems, it is very challenging to predict mixture hormesis effects. In the present study, soil alkaline phosphatase (ALP) was selected to investigate and predict its potential hormetic responses under Cd and Pb stresses. Typical reverse U-shaped dose-response relationships between ALP activities and the single and combined Cd and Pb were observed, showing a hormetic response of soil itself. The maximum stimulatory magnitudes ranged in 8.0 - 8.6% under 0.004 - 0.2 mg/kg Cd and 80 - 400 mg/kg Pb, respectively. An enhanced stimulation of 15.7% occurred under the binary mixtures of 0.6 mg/kg Cd and 200 mg/kg Pb. In addition, a dosage-independent binary linear regression model was proposed based on an assumption of a linear relationship between the single and combined hormetic responses under Cd and Pb. Our model can well predict ALP's responses in the presence of the two metals' mixtures (p < 0.1). Our findings provided new understandings to hormesis in soil.

A general model of hormesis in biological systems and its application to pest management

Hormesis, a phenomenon whereby exposure to high levels of stressors is inhibitory but low (mild, sublethal and subtoxic) doses are stimulatory, challenges decision-making in the management of cancer, neurodegenerative diseases, nutrition and ecotoxicology. In the latter, increasing amounts of a pesticide may lead to upsurges rather than declines of pests, ecological paradoxes that are difficult to predict. Using a novel re-formulation of the Ricker population equation, we show how interactions between intervention strengths and dose timings, dose–response functions and intrinsic factors can model such paradoxes and hormesis. A model with three critical parameters revealed hormetic biphasic dose and dose timing responses, either in a J-shape or an inverted U-shape, yielding a homeostatic change or a catastrophic shift and hormetic effects in many parameter regions. Such effects were enhanced by repeated pulses of low-level stimulations within one generation at different dose timings, thereby reducing threshold levels, maximum responses and inhibition. The model provides insights into the complex dynamics of such systems and a methodology for improved experimental design and analysis, with wide-reaching implications for understanding hormetic effects in ecology and in medical and veterinary treatment decision-making. We hypothesized that the dynamics of a discrete generation pest control system can be determined by various three-parameter spaces, some of which reveal the conditions for occurrence of hormesis, and confirmed this by fitting our model to both hormetic data from the literature and to a non-hormetic dataset on pesticidal control of mirid bugs in cotton.

Applications of SERS in the Detection of Stress-Related Substances

A wide variety of biotic and abiotic stresses continually attack plants and animals, which adversely affect their growth, development, reproduction, and yield realization. To survive under stress conditions, highly sophisticated and efficient tolerance mechanisms have been evolved to adapt to stresses, which consist of the variation of effector molecules playing vital roles in physiological regulation. The development of a sensitive, facile, and rapid analytical methods for stress factors and effector molecules detection is significant for gaining deeper insight into the tolerance mechanisms. As a nondestructive analysis technique, surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) has unique advantages regarding its biosensing applications. It not only provides specific fingerprint spectra of the target molecules, conformation, and structure, but also has universal capacity for simultaneous detection and imaging of targets owing to the narrow width of the Raman vibrational bands. Herein, recent progress on biotic and abiotic stresses, tolerance mechanisms and effector molecules is summarized. Moreover, the development and promising future trends of SERS detection for stress-related substances combined with nanomaterials as substrates and SERS tags are discussed. This comprehensive and critical review might shed light on a new perspective for SERS applications.