Clinically applied procedures for human ovarian tissue cryopreservation result in different levels of efficacy and efficiency

Endometriotic tissue fragments are viable after cryopreservation in an ex vivo tissue model recapitulating the fibrotic microenvironment

STUDY QUESTION

Is it possible to establish an ex vivo endometriosis model using cryopreserved endometriotic tissue fragments?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Cryopreserved endometriotic tissue fragments remain viable after thawing and during at least 3 days of culture and can therefore be used to establish an ex vivo endometriosis model to efficiently test potential therapeutic agents.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Endometriosis is the most prevalent benign gynecologic disease with an enormous societal burden; however, curative therapies are still lacking. To efficiently test potential new therapies, an ex vivo model based on previously cryopreserved endometriotic tissue that recapitulates the different endometriosis subtypes and their microenvironment is highly desirable.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

Endometriotic tissue fragments of three different subtypes were obtained from 28 patients by surgical resection. After cryopreservation and thawing, viability and metabolic activity of these tissue fragments were assessed. Viability was compared with fresh fragments from 11 patients directly after surgical removal. Experimental intervention studies were performed in cryopreserved and thawed tissue fragments from two patients to confirm the usability of these tissues for ex vivo intervention studies.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Endometriotic tissue fragments (n = 45) were cryopreserved according to three different protocols. After thawing, fragments were cultured for 24 h. A resazurin-based assay was performed to assess the metabolic activity of the tissue fragments. In addition, cell type-specific viability was analyzed by VivaFix, Hoechst 33342, and α-smooth muscle actin immunofluorescence staining and confocal microscopy. The presence of endometriosis was histologically confirmed based on hematoxylin-eosin staining. Cryopreserved and thawed tissue fragments were treated for 72 h with pirfenidone or metformin and COL1A1 and CEMIP gene expressions were assessed using RT-PCR and RT-qPCR, either in the whole tissue fragments or in myofibroblasts isolated by laser capture microdissection.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Metabolic activity of endometriotic tissue fragments obtained from peritoneal (PER), ovarian (OMA), and deep (DE) endometriotic lesions was well preserved after cryopreservation in a dimethyl sulfoxide-based medium and was comparable with fresh tissue fragments. Relative metabolic activity compared to fresh tissue was 70% (CI: 92-47%) in PER, 43% (CI: 53-15%) in OMA and 94% (CI: 186-3%) in DE lesions. In fragments from PE lesions 92% (CI: 87-96%), from OMA lesions 95% (CI: 91-98%), and from DE lesions 88% (CI: 78-98%) of cells were viable after cryopreservation and thawing followed by a 24-h culture period. Differences in gene expression of fibrotic markers COL1A1 and CEMIP after 72-h treatment with pirfenidone or metformin could be detected in whole tissue fragments and in isolated myofibroblasts, indicating that cryopreserved and thawed endometriotic tissue fragments are suitable for testing anti-fibrotic interventions.

LARGE SCALE DATA

N/A.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

Viability and metabolic activity of the endometriotic tissue fragments may have been partially compromised by damage sustained during the surgical procedure, contributing to inter-sample variance.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

The storage of viable endometriotic tissue fragments for later usage in an ex vivo model creates the possibility to efficiently test potential new therapeutic strategies and facilitates the exchange of viable endometriotic tissue between different research laboratories.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This study was not financially supported by external funding. The authors declare no competing interest.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

N/A.

The effect of different vitrification protocols on cell survival in human ovarian tissue: a pilot study

Background

Vitrification has superseded the slow freezing method for cryopreservation of oocytes, embryos, and sperm, but there are as yet no standard protocols for its use in ovarian tissue cryopreservation (OTC). Published protocols diverge mainly with regard to the extent of supplementation of dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) to the vitrification medium, and to the use of an open or closed vitrification system.

We investigated the viability of cells after vitrification/warming, using ovarian tissue of transgender patients, by means of Fluorescence Activated Cells Sorting (FACS), and histomorphological analyses using a DMSO-containing (P1) and a DMSO-free protocol (P2) in an open or closed vitrification setting.

Results

Twelve ovarian samples were donated from female-to-male transgender patients: 6 were vitrified according to protocol 1, the other 6 according to protocol 2. The amount of viable cells was 90.1% (P1) and 88.4% (P2) before vitrification. After vitrification and subsequent warming, viable cells were reduced to 82.9% (P1, p = 0.093) and 72.4% (P2, p = 0.019). When comparing the closed and the open systems, the decline in cell viability from pre- to post-vitrification was significant only for the latter (p = 0.037). Histological examination reveals no significant differences with respect to degenerated follicles before or after vitrification.

Conclusion

These results led us to conclude that a protocol containing DMSO results in a higher viability of ovarian cells than a protocol that uses ethylene glycol as cryoprotective agent in vitrification. The use of an open vitrification system led to significant decline in the rate of viable cells.

Trial registration

NCT03649087, retrospectively registered 28.08.2018.

Post-thawing and culture comparison of three routine slow freezing methods for human ovarian tissue cryopreservation: Histological, molecular, and hormonal aspects

To find the gold standard out of three pre-established routine slow freezing (SF) methods, ovarian cortex tissues of nine transsexual individuals were cryopreserved and compared to each other, as well as the control (fresh) samples. Histological, genomic, and endocrinological effects of the SFs were assessed post-thawing and after a seven-day culture period. SF1 included 10% dimethyl-sulfoxide (Me2SO) in the base medium (BM), SF2 had 1.5 M/L ethylene-glycol (EG) and 0.1 M/L sucrose in the BM, and SF3 consisted of 6% Me2SO, 6% EG and 0.15 M/L sucrose in the BM. The cortical tissue strips went under a programmed cooling process and were stored in liquid nitrogen. Histological criteria (tissue damage and follicular quality), as well as gene expression levels, were assessed in the thawed and control tissues. Half of the thawed and control tissues were cultured for seven days and their histology, genetic profile, and hormonal status were examined as the reflection of the avascular tension effect. Post-thawing tissue damage was similar between all groups but significantly increased post-culture (P < 0.05). The percentages of high-quality follicles diminished in all SFs after thawing and culture (P < 0.05) except for the similarity of post-thawing SF3, compared to control. The genetic profile of the tissue after thawing and culture suggested quiescence/activation balance in SF1 and 2 and significant down-regulation in SF3, compared to the control specimens (P < 0.05). Post-thawing BAX:BCL2 was higher than control in SF1 and SF3 (P < 0.05), while this ratio in SF2 was similar to the control. However, after culture this ratio was similar to that of control in SF3 and diminished in SF1 and 2 (P < 0.05). The expression levels of gap-junction genes showed dramatic pre- and post-thawing fluctuations in all groups. After culture, estradiol in SF3 was significantly higher than SF1 and 2 (P < 0.05). In addition, progesterone in SF3 was similar to control but significantly lower in SF1 and 2 (P < 0.05). In conclusion, all SFs showed advantages and disadvantages, and the follicular quality and its function depend on the type of cryoprotectant and the speed of thawing. The effects of freezing/thawing continue to appear during the seven days of culture. According to the results of this study, SF3 seems to be more promising in keeping the follicles functional and safe from cell damage during culture.

Assessing the use of tumor-specific DARPin-toxin fusion proteins for ex vivo purging of cancer metastases from human ovarian cortex before autotransplantation

OBJECTIVE

To assess the use of tumor-specific designed ankyrin repeat proteins (DARPins) fused to a domain of Pseudomonas aeruginosa exotoxin A for purging of cancer metastases from the ovarian cortex.

DESIGN

Experimental study.

SETTING

University medical center.

PATIENT(S)

Human ovarian cortex.

INTERVENTION(S)

Ovarian cortex harboring artificially induced breast cancer metastases was treated with DARPins targeted to epithelial cell adhesion molecule (EpCAM) and human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

The presence of any remaining cancer cells after purging was analyzed by (immuno)histochemistry and reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction. Effects on the viability of the ovarian cortex were determined by (immuno)histology, a follicular viability assay, and an assay to determine the in vitro growth capacity of small follicles.

RESULT(S)

After purging with EpCAM-targeted DARPin, all EpCAM-positive breast cancer cells were eradicated from the ovarian cortex. Although treatment had no effect on the morphology or viability of small follicles, a sharp decrease in oocyte viability during in vitro growth was observed, presumably due to low-level expression of EpCAM on oocytes. The HER2-targeted DARPins had no detrimental effects on the morphology, viability, or in vitro growth of small follicles. HER2-positive breast cancer foci were fully eliminated from the ovarian cortex, and the reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction showed a decrease to basal levels of HER2 mRNA after purging.

CONCLUSION(S)

Purging cancer metastases from ovarian cortex without impairing ovarian tissue integrity is possible by targeting tumor cell surface proteins with exotoxin A-fused DARPins. By adapting the target specificity of the cytotoxic DARPin fusions, it should be possible to eradicate metastases from all types of malignancies.

Complete Purging of Ewing Sarcoma Metastases from Human Ovarian Cortex Tissue Fragments by Inhibiting the mTORC1 Signaling Pathway

Restoration of fertility by autologous transplantation of ovarian cortex tissue in former cancer patients may lead to the reintroduction of malignancy via the graft. Pharmacological ex vivo purging of ovarian cortex fragments prior to autotransplantation may reduce the risk of reseeding the cancer. In this study we have investigated the capacity of Everolimus (EVE), an inhibitor of the mammalian target of rapamycin complex 1 (mTORC1) signaling pathway, to eradicate Ewing’s sarcoma (ES) from ovarian tissue by a short-term ex vivo treatment. Exposure of experimentally induced ES tumor foci in ovarian tissue to EVE for 24 h completely eliminated the malignant cells without detrimental effects on follicle morphology, survival or early folliculogenesis. This indicates that effective purging of ovarian cortex tissue from contaminating ES tumor foci is possible by short-term exposure to EVE.

Purging human ovarian cortex of contaminating leukaemic cells by targeting the mitotic catastrophe signalling pathway

PURPOSE

Is it possible to eliminate metastasised chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML) and acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) cells from ovarian cortex fragments by inhibition of Aurora B/C kinases (AURKB/C) without compromising ovarian tissue or follicles?

METHODS

Human ovarian cortex tissue with experimentally induced tumour foci of CML, AML and primary cells of AML patients were exposed to a 24h treatment with 1 μM GSK1070916, an AURKB/C inhibitor, to eliminate malignant cells by invoking mitotic catastrophe. After treatment, the inhibitor was removed, followed by an additional culture period of 6 days to allow any remaining tumour cells to form new foci. Ovarian tissue integrity after treatment was analysed by four different assays. Appropriate controls were included in all experiments.

RESULTS

Foci of metastasised CML and AML cells in ovarian cortex tissue were severely affected by a 24h ex vivo treatment with an AURKB/C inhibitor, leading to the formation of multi-nuclear syncytia and large-scale apoptosis. Ovarian tissue morphology and viability was not compromised by the treatment, as no significant difference was observed regarding the percentage of morphologically normal follicles, follicular viability, glucose uptake or in vitro growth of small follicles between ovarian cortex treated with 1 μM GSK1070916 and the control.

CONCLUSION

Purging of CML/AML metastases in ovarian cortex is possible by targeting the Mitotic Catastrophe Signalling Pathway using GSK1070916 without affecting the ovarian tissue. This provides a therapeutic strategy to prevent reintroduction of leukaemia and enhances safety of autotransplantation in leukaemia patients currently considered at high risk for ovarian involvement.

Markers of vitality in ovaries of transmen after long-term androgen treatment: a prospective cohort study

BACKGROUND

Gender-affirming hormone therapy has been hypothesized to reduce the patient's reproductive potential in transmen, although the exact long-term effects on future fertility are unknown.

METHODS

In this prospective cohort study we aimed to evaluate ovaries of 20 transmen by using hormone serum levels, histomorphological analysis and fluorescence activated cells sorting (FACS) analysis - in order to assess the amount of vital cells.

RESULTS

The median total number of follicles per field of view was 39 (IQR 12-122). Of all follicles (n = 1661), the vast majority was primordial (n = 1505, 90.6%), followed by primary (n = 76, 4.6%), abnormal (n = 63, 3.8%) and secondary follicles (n = 17, 1.0%). FACS analysis was available for 13 samples (65.0%) and the median frequency of vital cells was 87.5% (IQR, 77.7-95.4%). Both a higher age (p = 0.032) and a lower BMI (p = 0.003) were significantly associated with a higher frequency of vital cells.

CONCLUSION

The majority of ovarian cells after long-term androgen treatment were vital in FACS analysis and histomorphological evaluation revealed a normal cortical follicle distribution. These results are currently exploratory, but might be promising for issues on fertility preservation.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

The study was approved by the ethics committee of the Medical University of Vienna (EK 2240/2016) and was retrospectively registered in the Current Controlled Trials Register (registration number NCT03649087 , date of registration: 28.08.2018).

Ovarian tissue vitrification is more efficient than slow freezing to preserve ovarian stem cells in CF-1 mice

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to investigate the efficacy of protocols for mice ovary cryopreservation to compare the differences in Mouse Vasa Homologue expression (a germline cell marker) and ovarian viability after vitrification or slow freezing.

METHODS

Female CF1 mice aged 40-45 days were randomly divided into three groups: Control, vitrification or slow freezing. Their ovaries were surgically removed, rinsed in saline solution and cryopreserved. For vitrification, we used a commercial protocol and for slow freeze, we used 1.5 M ethylene glycol (EG) as cryoprotectant. After that, the ovaries were processed for histological an immunohistochemical analysis, and counting of primordial, primary, pre-antral and antral follicles.

RESULTS

No significant difference was found in the proportion of high-quality primordial, primary and pre-antral follicles after thawing/warming in the slow freezing and vitrification groups. The immunohistochemistry for MVH antibody demonstrated that the slow freeze group had a higher number of unmarked cells (p=0.012), indicating a harmful effect on the MVH expression in the ovarian tissue, where the cell structure is complex.

CONCLUSION

Although both protocols indicated similar results in the histological analysis of follicular counts, the vitrification protocol was significantly better to preserve ovarian stem cells, an immature germ cell population. These cells are able to self-renew having regeneration potential, and may be effective for the treatment of ovarian failure and consequently infertility.

Overnight ovarian tissue transportation for centralized cryobanking: a feasible option

RESEARCH QUESTION

Is overnight transportation of ovarian tissue before cryopreservation in a centralized cryobank from the FertiPROTEKT network feasible?

DESIGN

Data from 1810 women with cryopreserved ovarian tissue after overnight transportation from December 2000 to December 2017 were analysed with a focus on transportation, tissue activity parameters and pregnancy, and delivery rates after transplantation.

RESULTS

A total of 92.4% of tissue samples arrived at ideal temperatures of 2-8°C, 0.4% were transported at temperatures lower than ideal and 6.4% were transported at temperatures that were too high, generally due to mishandling of the inlayed cool packs of the transportation boxes. In 62 women, 78 tissue transplantations were carried out. A subgroup of 30 women who underwent a single orthotopic transplantation with fulfilled criteria of a complete follow-up after transplantation until the end of study, a premature ovarian insufficiency after gonadotoxic therapy as well as the absence of pelvic radiation, was further analysed. In this group, transplantations into a peritoneal pocket accounted for 90%. Transplants were still active at 1 year and above after transplantation in 93.3%. Pregnancy and delivery rates were 46.7% and 43.3%, respectively, with one ongoing pregnancy at the end of the study.

CONCLUSIONS

Overnight transportation for central cryobanking is a feasible concept that results in high reproducible success rates through standardized professional tissue freezing and storage.

Concept Paper on the Technique of Cryopreservation, Removal and Transplantation of Ovarian Tissue for Fertility Preservation

The cryopreservation of ovarian tissue with subsequent transplantation of the tissue represents an established method of fertility protection for female patients who have to undergo gonadotoxic therapy. The procedure can be performed at any point in the cycle and thus generally does not lead to any delay in oncological therapy. With the aid of this procedure, more than 130 births to date worldwide have been able to be recorded. The birth rate is currently approximately 30% and it can be assumed that this will increase through the further optimisation of the cryopreservation and surgical technique. The concept paper presented here is intended to provide guidance for managing cryopreservation and transplantation of ovarian tissue to German-speaking reproductive medicine centres.

Impact of vitrification on granulosa cell survival and gene expression

INTRODUCTION

Cryopreservation of ovarian tissue is an essential step in Ovarian Tissue Banking. In order to prevent the formation of ice crystals, typically the tissue is slowly frozen using a cryoprotectant. As an alternative the method of ultra-fast freezing by vitrification becomes more attention for freezing ovarian tissue because it has successfully been used for oocytes, embryos and sperm. However the impact of vitrification on granulosa cells, which are an essential part of ovarian tissue is uncertain.

AIM

In this study, we have therefore analysed the influence of vitrification on the survival rates of granulosa cells, the impact of DMSO or ethylenglycol containing vitrification protocols and investigated to what extent the gene expression of apoptosis- and temperature-sensitive genes changes.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We used the human granulosa cell line KGN as a model for human granulosa cells and determined the survival rate and cell cycle stages by FACS analyses. The change in gene expression was determined by quantitative PCR analyses.

RESULTS

Our results show that vitrification is possible in granulosa cells but it reduces cell viability and leads to fluctuations in the cell cycle. The DMSO containing protocol results in a lower amount of dead cells than the ethylenglycol containing protocol. Gene expression analysis reveals that TNF-alpha expression is strongly increased after vitrification, while other apoptosis or temperature-related genes seem to stay unaffected.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that vitrification influences the viability of human granulosa cells. Furthermore, our results suggest that this could be mediated by a change in TNF-alpha gene expression.

Complete protection against cryodamage of cryopreserved whole bovine and human ovaries using DMSO as a cryoprotectant

Purpose

This study aims to determine the optimal cryopreservation protocol for whole ovaries intended for preservation of fertility in women.

Methods

We investigated the optimal cryopreservation procedure for whole ovaries in a bovine model. The following parameters were investigated to determine their effect on ovarian tissue viability: type of cryoprotectant, administration route of the cryoprotectant (perfusion and/or submersion), and the maximum tolerable interval between death of the animal and start of the cryopreservation process. The resulting optimal cryopreservation procedure for bovine ovaries was subsequently tested on human ovaries. In vitro glucose uptake, histology, and immunohistochemistry were used to assess the integrity of the ovarian tissue.

Results

Starting the cryopreservation procedure (including perfusion with and submersion in DMSO) within 10–15 min after death of the animal proved critical, resulting in a 90–100% protection level against cryodamage. When cryopreserving human ovaries using the same protocol, over 95% protection against cryodamage was observed on all tissue levels. In addition, no apparent morphological damage to either the follicles or the vascular endothelium was observed.

Conclusion

Our findings suggest that using the optimized protocol presented in this paper allows good cryopreservation of whole human ovaries and represents an important step in considering whole ovary autotransplantation for clinically applied fertility preservation.