Patient with multiple morphological abnormalities of sperm flagella caused by a novel ARMC2 mutation has a favorable pregnancy outcome from intracytoplasmic sperm injection

Genetic etiological spectrum of sperm morphological abnormalities

PURPOSE

Male infertility manifests in the form of a reduction in sperm count, sperm motility, or the loss of fertilizing ability. While the loss of sperm production can have mixed reasons, sperm structural defects, cumulatively known as teratozoospermia, have predominantly genetic bases. The aim of the present review is to undertake a comprehensive analysis of the genetic mutations leading to sperm morphological deformities/teratozoospermia.

METHODS

We undertook literature review for genes involved in sperm morphological abnormalities. The genes were classified according to the type of sperm defects they cause and on the basis of the level of evidence determined by the number of human studies and the availability of a mouse knockout.

RESULTS

Mutations in the SUN5, CEP112, BRDT, DNAH6, PMFBP1, TSGA10, and SPATA20 genes result in acephalic sperm; mutations in the DPY19L2, SPATA16, PICK1, CCNB3, CHPT1, PIWIL4, and TDRD9 genes cause globozoospermia; mutations in the AURKC gene cause macrozoospermia; mutations in the WDR12 gene cause tapered sperm head; mutations in the RNF220 and ADCY10 genes result in small sperm head; mutations in the AMZ2 gene lead to vacuolated head formation; mutations in the CC2D1B and KIAA1210 genes lead to pyriform head formation; mutations in the SEPT14, ZPBP1, FBXO43, ZCWPW1, KATNAL2, PNLDC1, and CCIN genes cause amorphous head; mutations in the SEPT12, RBMX, and ACTL7A genes cause deformed acrosome formation; mutations in the DNAH1, DNAH2, DNAH6, DNAH17, FSIP2, CFAP43, AK7, CHAP251, CFAP65, ARMC2 and several other genes result in multiple morphological abnormalities of sperm flagella (MMAF).

CONCLUSIONS

Altogether, mutations in 31 genes have been reported to cause head defects and mutations in 62 genes are known to cause sperm tail defects.

The Molecular Basis of Multiple Morphological Abnormalities of Sperm Flagella and Its Impact on Clinical Practice

Multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella (MMAF) is a specific form of severe flagellar or ciliary deficiency syndrome. MMAF is characterized by primary infertility with abnormal morphology in the flagella of spermatozoa, presenting with short, absent, bent, coiled, and irregular flagella. As a rare disease first named in 2014, studies in recent years have shed light on the molecular defects of MMAF that comprise the structure and biological function of the sperm flagella. Understanding the molecular genetics of MMAF may provide opportunities for the development of diagnostic and therapeutic strategies for this rare disease. This review aims to summarize current studies regarding the molecular pathogenesis of MMAF and describe strategies of genetic counseling, clinical diagnosis, and therapy for MMAF.

SPEM1 Gene Mutation in a Case with Sperm Morphological Defects Leading to Male Infertility

The present study aimed at identifying the genetic mutation responsible for teratozoospermic infertility in a case with coiled sperm tails. A 33-year-old infertile male was diagnosed with teratozoospermic infertility, with sperm head in coiled (HIC) tail as the most common deformity. We employed whole exome sequencing to identify the genetic cause in this case. Exome sequencing data was filtered using the following criteria: MAF (< 0.003), ALFA project (< 0.001), 1000 Genomes (< 0.003), Granthem (> 50), Polyphen-2 (> 0.70), SIFT (< 0.03), and PhyloP (> = 0) scores. Shortlisted variants were looked in the in-house 29 exomes data available with us, and the variants that affected conserved amino acid residues or led to insertion/deletion or to protein-truncation with a Combined Annotation Dependent Depletion (CADD) score ≥ 10 were shortlisted. The variants thus populated were prioritized according to their roles in spermiogenesis. The study identified a heterozygous mutation c.826C > T (Arg276Trp) in the SPEM1 gene as a potential pathogenic variant that led to teratozoospermic infertility in the case under investigation. The mutation had a minor allele frequency of 0.00008176 in the gnomAd database and was absent in the Indian Genome Variations database. This is the first human study reporting a mutation in the SPEM1 gene as a cause of coiled sperm tails.

Identification of novel homozygous asthenoteratospermia-causing ARMC2 mutations associated with multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella

PURPOSE

To identify the genetic causes of multiple morphological abnormalities in sperm flagella (MMAF) and male infertility in patients from two unrelated Han Chinese families.

METHODS

Whole-exome sequencing was conducted using blood samples from the two individuals with MMAF and male infertility. Hematoxylin and eosin staining and scanning electron microscopy were performed to evaluate sperm morphology. Ultrastructural and immunostaining analyses of the spermatozoa were performed. The HEK293T cells were used to confirm the pathogenicity of the variants.

RESULTS

We identified two novel homozygous missense ARMC2 variants: c.314C > T: p.P105L and c.2227A > G: p.N743D. Both variants are absent or rare in the human population genome data and are predicted to be deleterious. In vitro experiments indicated that both ARMC2 variants caused a slightly increased protein expression. ARMC2-mutant spermatozoa showed multiple morphological abnormalities (bent, short, coiled, absent, and irregular) in the flagella. In addition, the spermatozoa of the patients revealed a frequent absence of the central pair complex and disrupted axonemal ultrastructure.

CONCLUSION

We identified two novel ARMC2 variants that caused male infertility and MMAF in Han Chinese patients. These findings expand the mutational spectrum of ARMC2 and provide insights into the complex causes and pathogenesis of MMAF.

Biallelic mutations in CFAP54 cause male infertility with severe MMAF and NOA

BACKGROUND

Spermatogenic impairments can lead to male infertility by different pathological conditions, such as multiple morphological abnormalities of the sperm flagella (MMAF) and non-obstructive azoospermia (NOA). Genetic factors are involved in impaired spermatogenesis.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Here, we performed genetic analyses through whole-exome sequencing in a cohort of 334 Han Chinese probands with severe MMAF or NOA. Biallelic variants of CFAP54 were identified in three unrelated men, including one homozygous frameshift variant (c.3317del, p.Phe1106Serfs*19) and two compound heterozygous variants (c.878G>A, p.Arg293His; c.955C>T, p.Arg319Cys and c.4885C>T, p.Arg1629Cys; c.937G>A, p.Gly313Arg). All of the identified variants were absent or extremely rare in the public human genome databases and predicted to be damaging by bioinformatic tools. The men harbouring CFAP54 mutations exhibited abnormal sperm morphology, reduced sperm concentration and motility in ejaculated semen. Significant axoneme disorganisation and other ultrastructure abnormities were also detected inside the sperm cells from men harbouring CFAP54 mutations. Furthermore, immunofluorescence assays showed remarkably reduced staining of four flagellar assembly-associated proteins (IFT20, IFT52, IFT122 and SPEF2) in the spermatozoa of CFAP54-deficient men. Notably, favourable clinical pregnancy outcomes were achieved with sperm from men carrying CFAP54 mutations after intracytoplasmic sperm injection treatment.

CONCLUSION

Our genetic analyses and experimental observations revealed that biallelic deleterious mutations of CFAP54 can induce severe MMAF and NOA in humans.

Clinical detection, diagnosis and treatment of morphological abnormalities of sperm flagella: A review of literature

Sperm carries male genetic information, and flagella help move the sperm to reach oocytes. When the ultrastructure of the flagella is abnormal, the sperm is unable to reach the oocyte and achieve insemination. Multiple morphological abnormalities of sperm flagella (MMAF) is a relatively rare idiopathic condition that is mainly characterized by multiple defects in sperm flagella. In the last decade, with the development of high-throughput DNA sequencing approaches, many genes have been revealed to be related to MMAF. However, the differences in sperm phenotypes and reproductive outcomes in many cases are attributed to different pathogenic genes or different pathogenic mutations in the same gene. Here, we will review information about the various phenotypes resulting from different pathogenic genes, including sperm ultrastructure and encoding proteins with their location and functions as well as assisted reproductive technology (ART) outcomes. We will share our clinical detection and diagnosis experience to provide additional clinical views and broaden the understanding of this disease.