New perspectives on photosynthetic phosphorylation in the light of a torsional mechanism of energy transduction and ATP synthesis

Symmetry breaking and mismatch in the torsional mechanism of ATP synthesis by FOF1-ATP synthase: mathematical number theory proof and its chemical and biological implications

Can mathematical proofs be employed for the solution of fundamental molecular-level problems in biology? Recently, I mathematically tackled complex mechanistic problems arising during the synthesis of the universal biological currency, adenosine triphosphate (ATP) by the FOF1-ATP synthase, nature's smallest rotary molecular motor, using graph-theoretical and combinatorial approaches for the membrane-bound FO and water-soluble F1 domains of this fascinating molecule (see Nath in Theory Biosci 141:249‒260, 2022 and Theory Biosci 143:217‒227, 2024). In the third part of this trilogy, I investigate another critical aspect of the molecular mechanism-that of coupling between the FO and F1 domains of the ATP synthase mediated by the central γ-subunit of ∼ 1 nanometer diameter. According to Nath's torsional mechanism of energy transduction and ATP synthesis the γ-subunit twists during ATP synthesis and the release of stored torsional energy in the central γ-stalk causes conformational changes in the catalytic sites that lead to ATP synthesis, with 1 ATP molecule synthesized per discrete 120° rotation. The twisted γ-subunit breaks the symmetry of the molecule, and its residual torsional strain is shown to readily accommodate any symmetry mismatch existing between FO and F1. A mathematical number theory proof is developed to quantify the extent of symmetry mismatch at any angular position during rotation and derive the conditions for the regaining of symmetry at the end of a 360° rotation. The many chemical and biological implications of the mechanism and the mathematical proof are discussed in detail. Finally, suggestions for further mathematical development of the subject based on ideas from symmetry and group theory have been made. In sum, the answer to the question posed at the beginning of the Abstract is a resounding YES. There exists new, relatively unexplored territory at the interface of mathematics and molecular biology, especially at the level of molecular mechanism. It is hoped that more mathematicians and scientists interested in interdisciplinary work are encouraged to include in their research program approaches of this type-a mathematical proofs-inspired molecular biology-that have the power to lead to new vistas. Such molecular-scale mechanistic problems in biology have proved extraordinarily difficult to solve definitively using conventional experimental, theoretical, and computational approaches.

Thermodynamic analysis of energy coupling by determination of the Onsager phenomenological coefficients for a 3×3 system of coupled chemical reactions and transport in ATP synthesis and its mechanistic implications

The nonequilibrium coupled processes of oxidation and ATP synthesis in the fundamental process of oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) are of vital importance in biosystems. These coupled chemical reaction and transport bioenergetic processes using the OXPHOS pathway meet >90% of the ATP demand in aerobic systems. On the basis of experimentally determined thermodynamic OXPHOS flux-force relationships and biochemical data for the ternary system of oxidation, ion transport, and ATP synthesis, the Onsager phenomenological coefficients have been computed, including an estimate of error. A new biothermokinetic theory of energy coupling has been formulated and on its basis the thermodynamic parameters, such as the overall degree of coupling, q and the phenomenological stoichiometry, Z of the coupled system have been evaluated. The amount of ATP produced per oxygen consumed, i.e. the actual, operating P/O ratio in the biosystem, the thermodynamic efficiency of the coupled reactions, η, and the Gibbs free energy dissipation, Φ have been calculated and shown to be in agreement with experimental data. At the concentration gradients of ADP and ATP prevailing under state 3 physiological conditions of OXPHOS that yield Vmax rates of ATP synthesis, a maximum in Φ of ∼0.5J(hmgprotein)-1, corresponding to a thermodynamic efficiency of ∼60% for oxidation on succinate, has been obtained. Novel mechanistic insights arising from the above have been discussed. This is the first report of a 3 × 3 system of coupled chemical reactions with transport in a biological context in which the phenomenological coefficients have been evaluated from experimental data.

The Warburg Effect Reinterpreted 100 yr on: A First-Principles Stoichiometric Analysis and Interpretation from the Perspective of ATP Metabolism in Cancer Cells

The Warburg Effect is a longstanding enigma in cancer biology. Despite the passage of 100 yr since its discovery, and the accumulation of a vast body of research on the subject, no convincing biochemical explanation has been given for the original observations of aerobic glycolysis in cancer cell metabolism. Here, we have worked out a first-principles quantitative analysis of the problem from the principles of stoichiometry and available electron balance. The results have been interpreted using Nath's unified theory of energy coupling and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthesis, and the original data of Warburg and colleagues have been analyzed from this new perspective. Use of the biomass yield based on ATP per unit substrate consumed, [Formula: see text], or the Nath-Warburg number, NaWa has been shown to excellently model the original data on the Warburg Effect with very small standard deviation values, and without employing additional fitted or adjustable parameters. Based on the results of the quantitative analysis, a novel conservative mechanism of synthesis, utilization, and recycling of ATP and other key metabolites (eg, lactate) is proposed. The mechanism offers fresh insights into metabolic symbiosis and coupling within and/or among proliferating cells. The fundamental understanding gained using our approach should help in catalyzing the development of more efficient metabolism-targeting anticancer drugs.

Coupling and biological free-energy transduction processes as a bridge between physics and life: Molecular-level instantiation of Ervin Bauer's pioneering concepts in biological thermodynamics

The nonequilibrium coupled processes of oxidation and ATP synthesis in the biological process of oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) are fundamental to all life on our planet. These steady-state energy transduction processes ‒ coupled by proton and anion/counter-cation concentration gradients in the OXPHOS pathway ‒ generate ∼95 % of the ATP requirement of aerobic systems for cellular function. The rapid energy cycling and homeostasis of metabolites involved in this coupling are shown to be responsible for maintenance and regulation of stable nonequilibrium states, the latter first postulated in pioneering biothermodynamics work by Ervin Bauer between 1920 and 1935. How exactly does this occur? This is shown to be answered by molecular considerations arising from Nath's torsional mechanism of ATP synthesis and two-ion theory of energy coupling developed in 25 years of research work on the subject. A fresh analysis of the biological thermodynamics of coupling that goes beyond the previous work of Stucki and others and shows how the system functions at the molecular level has been carried out. Thermodynamic parameters, such as the overall degree of coupling, q of the coupled system are evaluated for the state 4 to state 3 transition in animal mitochondria with succinate as substrate. The actual or operative P to O ratio, the efficiency of the coupled reactions, η, and the Gibbs energy dissipation, Φ have been calculated and shown to be in good agreement with experimental data. Novel mechanistic insights arising from the above have been discussed. A fourth law/principle of thermodynamics is formulated for a sub-class of physical and biological systems. The critical importance of constraints and time-varying boundary conditions for function and regulation is discussed in detail. Dynamic internal structural changes essential for torsional energy storage within the γ-subunit in a single molecule of the FOF1-ATP synthase and its transduction have been highlighted. These results provide a molecular-level instantiation of Ervin Bauer's pioneering concepts in biological thermodynamics.

Phosphorus Chemistry at the Roots of Bioenergetics: Ligand Permutation as the Molecular Basis of the Mechanism of ATP Synthesis/Hydrolysis by FOF1-ATP Synthase

The integration of phosphorus chemistry with the mechanism of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis requires dynamical information during ATP turnover and catalysis. Oxygen exchange reactions occurring at β-catalytic sites of the FOF1-ATP synthase/F1-ATPase imprint a unique record of molecular events during the catalytic cycle of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis. They have been shown to provide valuable time-resolved information on enzyme catalysis during ATP synthesis and ATP hydrolysis. The present work conducts new experiments on oxygen exchange catalyzed by submitochondrial particles designed to (i) measure the relative rates of Pi-ATP, Pi-HOH, and ATP-HOH isotope exchanges; (ii) probe the effect of ADP removal on the extent of inhibition of the exchanges, and (iii) test their uncoupler sensitivity/resistance. The objectives have been realized based on new experiments on submitochondrial particles, which show that both the Pi-HOH and ATP-HOH exchanges occur at a considerably higher rate relative to the Pi-ATP exchange, an observation that cannot be explained by previous mechanisms. A unifying explanation of the kinetic data that rationalizes these observations is given. The experimental results in (ii) show that ADP removal does not inhibit the intermediate Pi-HOH exchange when ATP and submitochondrial particles are incubated, and that the nucleotide requirement of the intermediate Pi-HOH exchange is adequately met by ATP, but not by ADP. These results contradicts the central postulate in Boyer's binding change mechanism of reversible catalysis at a F1 catalytic site with Keq~1 that predicts an absolute requirement of ADP for the occurrence of the Pi-HOH exchange. The prominent intermediate Pi-HOH exchange occurring under hydrolytic conditions is shown to be best explained by Nath's torsional mechanism of energy transduction and ATP synthesis/hydrolysis, which postulates an essentially irreversible cleavage of ATP by mitochondria/particles, independent from a reversible formation of ATP from ADP and Pi. The explanation within the torsional mechanism is also shown to rationalize the relative insensitivity of the intermediate Pi-HOH exchange to uncouplers observed in the experiments in (iii) compared to the Pi-ATP and ATP-HOH exchanges. This is shown to lead to new concepts and perspectives based on ligand displacement/substitution and ligand permutation for the elucidation of the oxygen exchange reactions within the framework of fundamental phosphorus chemistry. Fast mechanisms that realize the rotation/twist, tilt, permutation and switch of ligands, as well as inversion at the γ-phosphorus synchronously and simultaneously and in a concerted manner, have been proposed, and their stereochemical consequences have been analyzed. These considerations take us beyond the binding change mechanism of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis in bioenergetics.

Beyond binding change: the molecular mechanism of ATP hydrolysis by F1-ATPase and its biochemical consequences

F1-ATPase is a universal multisubunit enzyme and the smallest-known motor that, fueled by the process of ATP hydrolysis, rotates in 120o steps. A central question is how the elementary chemical steps occurring in the three catalytic sites are coupled to the mechanical rotation. Here, we performed cold chase promotion experiments and measured the rates and extents of hydrolysis of preloaded bound ATP and promoter ATP bound in the catalytic sites. We found that rotation was caused by the electrostatic free energy change associated with the ATP cleavage reaction followed by Pi release. The combination of these two processes occurs sequentially in two different catalytic sites on the enzyme, thereby driving the two rotational sub-steps of the 120o rotation. The mechanistic implications of this finding are discussed based on the overall energy balance of the system. General principles of free energy transduction are formulated, and their important physical and biochemical consequences are analyzed. In particular, how exactly ATP performs useful external work in biomolecular systems is discussed. A molecular mechanism of steady-state, trisite ATP hydrolysis by F1-ATPase, consistent with physical laws and principles and the consolidated body of available biochemical information, is developed. Taken together with previous results, this mechanism essentially completes the coupling scheme. Discrete snapshots seen in high-resolution X-ray structures are assigned to specific intermediate stages in the 120o hydrolysis cycle, and reasons for the necessity of these conformations are readily understood. The major roles played by the "minor" subunits of ATP synthase in enabling physiological energy coupling and catalysis, first predicted by Nath's torsional mechanism of energy transduction and ATP synthesis 25 years ago, are now revealed with great clarity. The working of nine-stepped (bMF1, hMF1), six-stepped (TF1, EF1), and three-stepped (PdF1) F1 motors and of the α3β3γ subcomplex of F1 is explained by the same unified mechanism without invoking additional assumptions or postulating different mechanochemical coupling schemes. Some novel predictions of the unified theory on the mode of action of F1 inhibitors, such as sodium azide, of great pharmaceutical importance, and on more exotic artificial or hybrid/chimera F1 motors have been made and analyzed mathematically. The detailed ATP hydrolysis cycle for the enzyme as a whole is shown to provide a biochemical basis for a theory of "unisite" and steady-state multisite catalysis by F1-ATPase that had remained elusive for a very long time. The theory is supported by a probability-based calculation of enzyme species distributions and analysis of catalytic site occupancies by Mg-nucleotides and the activity of F1-ATPase. A new concept of energy coupling in ATP synthesis/hydrolysis based on fundamental ligand substitution chemistry has been advanced, which offers a deeper understanding, elucidates enzyme activation and catalysis in a better way, and provides a unified molecular explanation of elementary chemical events occurring at enzyme catalytic sites. As such, these developments take us beyond binding change mechanisms of ATP synthesis/hydrolysis proposed for oxidative phosphorylation and photophosphorylation in bioenergetics.

The Need for Consistency with Physical Laws and Logic in Choosing Between Competing Molecular Mechanisms in Biological Processes: A Case Study in Modeling ATP Synthesis

Traditionally, proposed molecular mechanisms of fundamental biological processes have been tested against experiment. However, owing to a plethora of reasons-difficulty in designing, carrying out, and interpreting key experiments, use of different experimental models and systems, conduct of studies under widely varying experimental conditions, fineness in distinctions between competing mechanisms, complexity of the scientific issues, and the resistance of some scientists to discoveries that are contrary to popularly held beliefs-this has not solved the problem despite decades of work in the field/s. The author would like to prescribe an alternative way: that of testing competing models/mechanisms for their adherence to scientific laws and principles, and checking for errors in logic. Such tests are fairly commonly carried out in the mathematics, physics, and engineering literature. Further, reported experimental measurements should not be smaller than minimum detectable values for the measurement technique employed and should truly reflect function of the actual system without inapplicable extrapolation. Progress in the biological fields would be greatly accelerated, and considerable scientific acrimony avoided by adopting this approach. Some examples from the fundamental field of ATP synthesis in oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) have been reviewed that also serve to illustrate the approach. The approach has never let the author down in his 35-yr-long experience on biological mechanisms. This change in thinking should lead to a considerable saving of both time and resources, help channel research efforts toward solution of the right problems, and hopefully provide new vistas to a younger generation of open-minded biological scientists.

Molecular-level understanding of biological energy coupling and transduction: Response to "Chemiosmotic misunderstandings"

In a recent paper entitled "Chemiosmotic misunderstandings", it is claimed that "enough shortcomings in Mitchell's chemiosmotic theory have not been found and that a novel paradigm that offers at least as much explanatory power as chemiosmosis is not ready." This view is refuted by a wealth of molecular-level experimental data and strong new theoretical and computational evidence. It is shown that the chemiosmotic theory was beset with a large number of major shortcomings ever since the time when it was first proposed in the 1960s. These multiple shortcomings and flaws of chemiosmosis were repeatedly pointed out in incisive critiques by biochemical authorities of the late 20th century. All the shortcomings and flaws have been shown to be rectified by a quantitative, unified molecular-level theory that leads to a deeper and far more accurate understanding of biological energy coupling and ATP synthesis. The new theory is shown to be consistent with pioneering X-ray and cryo-EM structures and validated by state-of-the-art single-molecule techniques. Several new biochemical experimental tests are proposed and constructive ways for providing a revitalizing conceptual background and theory for integration of the available experimental information are suggested.

Oxidative phosphorylation revisited

The fundamentals of oxidative phosphorylation and photophosphorylation are revisited. New experimental data on the involvement of succinate and malate anions respectively in oxidative phosphorylation and photophosphorylation are presented. These new data offer a novel molecular mechanistic explanation for the energy coupling and ATP synthesis carried out in mitochondria and chloroplast thylakoids. The mechanism does not suffer from the flaws in Mitchell's chemiosmotic theory that have been pointed out in many studies since its first appearance 50 years ago, when it was hailed as a ground-breaking mechanistic explanation of what is perhaps the most important process in cellular energetics. The new findings fit very well with the predictions of Nath's torsional mechanism of energy transduction and ATP synthesis. It is argued that this mechanism, based on at least 15 years of experimental and theoretical work by Sunil Nath, constitutes a fundamentally different theory of the energy conversion process that eliminates all the inconsistencies in Mitchell's chemiosmotic theory pointed out by other authors. It is concluded that the energy-transducing complexes in oxidative phosphorylation and photosynthesis are proton-dicarboxylic acid anion cotransporters and not simply electrogenic proton translocators. These results necessitate revision of previous theories of biological energy transduction, coupling, and ATP synthesis. The novel molecular mechanism is extended to cover ATP synthesis in prokaryotes, in particular to alkaliphilic and haloalkaliphilic bacteria, essentially making it a complete theory addressing mechanistic, kinetic, and thermodynamic details. Finally, based on the new interpretation of oxidative phosphorylation, quantitative values for the P/O ratio, the amount of ATP generated per redox package of the reduced substrates, are calculated and compared with experimental values for fermentation on different substrates. It is our hope that the presentation of oxidative phosphorylation and photophosphorylation from a wholly new perspective will rekindle scientific discussion of a key process in bioenergetics and catalyze new avenues of research in a truly interdisciplinary field.