Second Tier Testing to Reduce the Number of Non-actionable Secondary Findings and False-Positive Referrals in Newborn Screening for Severe Combined Immunodeficiency

Targeted DNA Methylation Analysis Facilitates Leukocyte Counts in Dried Blood Samples

BACKGROUND

Cell-type specific DNA methylation (DNAm) can be employed to determine the numbers of leukocyte subsets in blood. In contrast to conventional methods for leukocyte counts, which are based on cellular morphology or surface marker protein expression, the cellular deconvolution based on DNAm levels is applicable for frozen or dried blood. Here, we further enhanced targeted DNAm assays for leukocyte counts in clinical application.

METHODS

DNAm profiles of 40 different studies were compiled to identify CG dinucleotides (CpGs) with cell-type specific DNAm using a computational framework, CimpleG. DNAm levels at these CpGs were then measured with digital droplet PCR in venous blood from 160 healthy donors and 150 patients with various hematological disorders. Deconvolution was further validated with venous blood (n = 75) and capillary blood (n = 31) that was dried on Whatman paper or on Mitra microsampling devices.

RESULTS

In venous blood, automated cell counting or flow cytometry correlated well with epigenetic estimates of relative leukocyte counts for granulocytes (r = 0.95), lymphocytes (r = 0.97), monocytes (r = 0.82), CD4 T cells (r = 0.84), CD8 T cells (r = 0.94), B cells (r = 0.96), and NK cells (r = 0.72). Similar correlations and precisions were achieved for dried blood samples. Spike-in with a reference plasmid enabled accurate epigenetic estimation of absolute leukocyte counts from dried blood samples, correlating with conventional venous (r = 0.86) and capillary (r = 0.80) blood measurements.

CONCLUSIONS

The advanced selection of cell-type specific CpGs and utilization of digital droplet PCR analysis provided accurate epigenetic blood counts. Analysis of dried blood facilitates self-sampling with a finger prick, thereby enabling easier accessibility to testing.

Case report: IKZF1-related early-onset CID is expected to be missed in TREC-based SCID screening but can be identified by determination of KREC levels

This report illustrates a case that would have been missed in the most common screening algorithms used worldwide in newborn screening (NBS) for severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID). Our patient presented with a clinical picture that suggested a severe inborn error of immunity (IEI). The 6-month-old baby had normal T-cell receptor excision circle (TREC) levels but no measurable level of kappa-deleting recombination excision circles (KRECs) in the NBS sample. A de novo IKZF1-mutation (c.476A>G, p.Asn159Ser) was found. The clinical picture, immunologic workup, and genetic result were consistent with IKZF1-related combined immunodeficiency (CID). Our patient had symptomatic treatment and underwent allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT). IKZF1-related CID is a rare, serious, and early-onset disease; this case provides further insights into the phenotype, including KREC status.

Screening Newborns for Low T Cell Receptor Excision Circles (TRECs) Fails to Detect Immunodeficiency, Centromeric Instability, and Facial Anomalies Syndrome

BACKGROUND

Assessment of T-cell receptor excision circles (TRECs) in dried blood spots of newborns allows the detection of severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) (T cells <300/μL at birth) with a presumed sensitivity of 100%. TREC screening also identifies patients with selected combined immunodeficiency (CID) (T cells >300/μL, yet <1500/μL at birth). Nevertheless, relevant CIDs that would benefit from early recognition and curative treatment pass undetected.

OBJECTIVE

We hypothesized that TREC screening at birth cannot identify CIDs that develop with age.

METHODS

We analyzed the number of TRECs in dried blood spots in archived Guthrie cards of 22 children who had been born in the Berlin-Brandenburg area between January 2006 and November 2018 and who had undergone hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation (HSCT) for inborn errors of immunity.

RESULTS

All patients with SCID would have been identified by TREC screening, but only 4 of 6 with CID. One of these patients had immunodeficiency, centromeric instability, and facial anomalies syndrome type 2 (ICF2). Two of 3 patients with ICF whom we have been following up at our institution had TREC numbers above the cutoff value suggestive of SCID at birth. Yet all patients with ICF had a severe clinical course that would have justified earlier HSCT.

CONCLUSIONS

In ICF, naïve T cells may be present at birth, yet they decline with age. Therefore, TREC screening cannot identify these patients. Early recognition is nevertheless crucial, as patients with ICF benefit from HSCT early in life.

Efficient screening strategies for severe combined immunodeficiencies in newborns

INTRODUCTION

Severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) is one of the most severe forms of inborn errors of immunity (IEI), affecting both cellular and humoral immunity. Without curative treatment such as hematopoietic stem cell transplantation or gene therapy, affected infants die within the first year of life. Due to the severity of the disease, asymptomatic status early in life, and improved survival in the absence of pretransplant infections, SCID was considered a suitable candidate for newborn screening (NBS).

AREAS COVERED

Many countries have introduced SCID screening based on T-cell receptor excision circle (TREC) detection in their NBS programs. Screening an entire population is a radical departure from previous paradigms in the field of immunology. Efficient screening strategies are cost-efficient and balance high sensitivity while preventing high numbers of referrals. NBS for SCID is accompanied by (actionable) secondary findings, but many NBS programs have optimized their screening strategy by adjusting algorithms or including second-tier tests. Harmonization of screening terminology is of great importance for international shared learning.

EXPERT OPINION

The expansion of NBS is driven by the development of new test modalities and treatment options. In the near future, other techniques such as next-generation sequencing will pave the way for NBS of other IEI. Exciting times await for population-based screening programs.

Demographic, clinical, immunological, and molecular features of iranian national cohort of patients with defect in DCLRE1C gene

BACKGROUND

DCLRE1C gene mutation leads to Artemis deficiency, a severe form of combined immunodeficiency (SCID). Impaired DNA repair and block in early adaptive immunity maturation results in T-B-NK+ immunodeficiency associated with radiosensitivity. Recurrent infections early in life are the main characteristic of Artemis patients.

METHOD

Among 5373 registered patients, 9 Iranian patients (33.3% female) with confirmed DCLRE1C mutation were identified since 1999-2022. The demographic, clinical, immunological and genetic features were collected through retrospective investigation of medical records and using next generation sequencing.

RESULTS

Seven patients were born in a consanguineous family (77.8%). The median age of onset was 6.0 (5.0-17.0) months. Severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) was clinically detected at a median (IQR) age of 7.0 (6.0-20.5) months, following a median diagnostic delay of 2.0 (1.0-3.5) months The most typical first presentation was pneumonia (44.4%) and otitis media (3.33%), followed by BCG lymphadenitis (22.2%) and gastroenteritis (11.1%). The most prevalent manifestations were respiratory tract infections (including otitis media) (66.6%) and chronic diarrhea (66.6%). In addition, juvenile idiopathic arthritis (P5) and celiac disease and idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (P9) as autoimmune disorders were reported in 2 patients. All patients had reduced B CD19+ and CD4+ cell counts. IgA deficiency occurred in 77.8% of individuals.

CONCLUSION

Recurrent infections particulary respiratory tract infection and chronic diarrhea during the first months of life in patients born to consanguineous parents should raise the suspicion for inborn errors of immunity, even in the presence of normal growth and development.

News in immunology

The field of immunology has undergone a very significant development in recent decades, which has been reflected especially in the beginning of this millennium in significant advances in the understanding of the immune system and in the application of this knowledge in practice. The progress and acceleration of research and advances in the field of immunology was further prompt by the unexpected onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. The intense scientific work has not only led to the development of our understanding of the immune response to viruses, but also to the rapid conversion of this knowledge into practical pandemic management on a global scale, as exemplified by the development of vaccines against SARS-Cov-2 virus. The pandemic era has further contributed to the acceleration of the application of not only biological discoveries but also technological approaches into practical applications, such as use of advanced mathematics, computer science and, more recently, artificial intelligence which are all are adding to the advances that are significantly moving the field of immunology forward. In this communication, we present specific advances in particular areas of immunopathology, which are mainly allergy, immunodeficiency, immunity and infection, vaccination, autoimmune diseases and cancer immunology.

Proximal urea cycle defects are challenging to detect with newborn screening: Results of a prospective pilot study using post-analytical tools

The purpose of this pilot project was to evaluate the efficacy of the Collaborative Integrated Laboratory Reports (CLIR) postanalytical tools from Mayo Clinic for detection of newborns with proximal urea cycle disorders (PUCD) in the Georgia newborn screening program that uses the underivatized Neobase2 kit (Perkin Elmer). We evaluated 138,560 newborn screening (NBS) samples (between 125,000 and 130,000 children) and used the CLIR result interpretation guidelines to stratify results. Children at higher risk of having a PUCD received follow-up services including confirmatory lab testing (ammonia, plasma amino acids, urine orotic acid) or a repeat NBS sample. We made multiple adjustments to our CLIR PUCD tool and to our follow-up algorithms in order to reduce false positives. Regardless, a high number of NBS samples resulted with false positives in part due to the glutamine peak also containing lysine. No children were diagnosed with a PUCD during our study period, and the Emory Genetics Metabolic Center is unaware of any children diagnosed outside of the NBS system during that time. Based on our experience, PUCD is not suitable for statewide NBS using Neobase2 and CLIR. Other methodologies that can separate glutamine from other amino acids may have better performance.

Future Perspectives of Newborn Screening for Inborn Errors of Immunity

Newborn screening (NBS) programs continue to expand due to innovations in both test methods and treatment options. Since the introduction of the T-cell receptor excision circle (TREC) assay 15 years ago, many countries have adopted screening for severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) in their NBS program. SCID became the first inborn error of immunity (IEI) in population-based screening and at the same time the TREC assay became the first high-throughput DNA-based test in NBS laboratories. In addition to SCID, there are many other IEI that could benefit from early diagnosis and intervention by preventing severe infections, immune dysregulation, and autoimmunity, if a suitable NBS test was available. Advances in technologies such as KREC analysis, epigenetic immune cell counting, protein profiling, and genomic techniques such as next-generation sequencing (NGS) and whole-genome sequencing (WGS) could allow early detection of various IEI shortly after birth. In the next years, the role of these technical advances as well as ethical, social, and legal implications, logistics and cost will have to be carefully examined before different IEI can be considered as suitable candidates for inclusion in NBS programs.

Economic Evaluation of Different Screening Strategies for Severe Combined Immunodeficiency Based on Real-Life Data

Although several countries have adopted severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) into their newborn screening (NBS) program, other countries are still in the decision process of adding this disorder in their program and finding the appropriate screening strategy. This decision may be influenced by the cost(-effectiveness) of these screening strategies. In this study, the cost(-effectiveness) of different NBS strategies for SCID was estimated based on real-life data from a prospective implementation study in the Netherlands. The cost of testing per child for SCID was estimated at EUR 6.36. The cost of diagnostics after screen-positive results was assessed to vary between EUR 985 and 8561 per child dependent on final diagnosis. Cost-effectiveness ratios varied from EUR 41,300 per QALY for the screening strategy with T-cell receptor excision circle (TREC) ≤ 6 copies/punch to EUR 44,100 for the screening strategy with a cut-off value of TREC ≤ 10 copies/punch. The analysis based on real-life data resulted in higher costs, and consequently in less favorable cost-effectiveness estimates than analyses based on hypothetical data, indicating the need for verifying model assumptions with real-life data. The comparison of different screening strategies suggest that strategies with a lower number of referrals, e.g., by distinguishing between urgent and less urgent referrals, are favorable from an economic perspective.

First Year of TREC-Based National SCID Screening in Sweden

Screening for severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) was introduced into the Swedish newborn screening program in August 2019 and here we report the results of the first year. T cell receptor excision circles (TRECs), kappa-deleting element excision circles (KRECs), and actin beta (ACTB) levels were quantitated by multiplex qPCR from dried blood spots (DBS) of 115,786 newborns and children up to two years of age, as an approximation of the number of recently formed T and B cells and sample quality, respectively. Based on low TREC levels, 73 children were referred for clinical assessment which led to the diagnosis of T cell lymphopenia in 21 children. Of these, three were diagnosed with SCID. The screening performance for SCID as the outcome was sensitivity 100%, specificity 99.94%, positive predictive value (PPV) 4.11%, and negative predictive value (NPV) 100%. For the outcome T cell lymphopenia, PPV was 28.77%, and specificity was 99.95%. Based on the first year of screening, the incidence of SCID in the Swedish population was estimated to be 1:38,500 newborns.