Tremendous impact of substituent group on the extraction and selectivity to Am(III) over Eu(III) by diaryldithiophosphinic acids: experimental and DFT analysis

Tuning Selectivity to f-Elements through Bonding and Solvation Effects of a Sulfur Donor Ligand

Bis(2,4,4-trimethylpentyl)dithiophosphinic acid, commonly referred to as HBTMPDTP or Cyanex301, is a sulfur-donating ligand that shows considerable promise in the challenging task of separating trivalent actinides (An3+) from lanthanides (Ln3+). Although its effectiveness has been established, the specific molecular details about the preference of HBTMPDTP for americium over europium have remained a mystery, puzzling researchers for over two decades. This study presents a comprehensive, dual-driven separation mechanism for this complex system combining experimental and theoretical approaches. A critical finding is the increased covalency in An-S bonds compared to Ln-S bonds, which plays a significant role in HBTMPDTP's intrinsic selectivity for An3+ over Ln3+. This leads to the formation of distinct An3+ and Ln3+ species, enhancing the ligand's actinide selectivity. Additionally, it provides crucial insights into the coordination chemistry of f-elements with sulfur-donating ligands, thereby deepening our understanding of this intricate field.

Probing Substituent Effect on Nickel-Sulfur Bond Covalency in Ni(II)-Dithiophosphinate Complexes by Sulfur K-Edge XAS and DFT Calculations

Complexes of Ni(II) with a series of aryl or alkyl substituent dithiophosphinic acids were characterized by crystallographic structure, sulfur K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS), and density functional theory (DFT). In these complexes, Ni(II) coordinates with four sulfur atoms from two dithiophosphinate anions form a well-defined square-planar structure. Despite the minor differences in the geometry parameters among the complexes, the electronic structure is affected significantly by the substituent group attached to dithiophosphinic acid. In particular, the addition of ortho-CF3 group to the aryl ring constrains the orientation of the aryl ring and enhances the conjugation between the aryl ring and the coordinating core. Sulfur K-edge XAS spectra help further reveal the electronic structure of the complexes. Both the pre-edge feature and rising-edge feature provide abundant information on the molecular orbitals and show a distinctive effect of the substituent groups on the electronic structure of the complexes, which is supposedly relevant to the ligand's performance in Ln(III)/An(III) separation.

Covalency between the uranyl ion and dithiophosphinate by sulfur K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy and density functional theory

The dithiophosphinic acids (HS2PR2) have been used for the selective separation of trivalent actinides (AnIII) from lanthanides (LnIII) over the past decades. The substituents on the dithiophosphinic acids dramatically impact the separation performance, but the mechanism is still open for debate. In this work, two dithiophosphinic acids with significantly different AnIII/LnIII separation performance, i.e. diphenyl dithiophosphinic acid (HS2PPh2) and bis(ortho-trifluoromethylphenyl) dithiophosphinic acid [HS2P(o-CF3C6H4)2], are employed to understand the substituent effect on the bonding covalency between the S2PR2- anions (R = Ph and o-CF3C6H4) and the uranyl ion by sulfur K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) in combination with density functional theory calculations. The two UO2(S2PR2)(EtOH) complexes display similar XAS spectra, in which the first pre-edge feature with an intensity of 0.16 is entirely attributed to the transitions from S 1s orbitals to the unoccupied molecular orbitals due to the mixing between U 5f and S 3p orbitals. The Mulliken population analysis indicates that the amount of \% S 3p character in these orbitals is essentially identical for the UO2(S2PPh2)2(EtOH) and UO2[S2P(o-CF3C6H4)2]2(EtOH) complexes, which is lower than that in the U 6d-based orbitals. The essentially identical covalency in U-S bonds for the two UO2(S2PR2)2(EtOH) complexes are contradictory to the significantly different AnIII/LnIII separation performance of the two dithiophosphinic acids, thus the covalency seems to be unable to account for substituent effects in the AnIII/LnIII separation by the dithiophosphinic acids. The results in this work provide valuable insight into the understanding of the mechanism in the AnIII/LnIII separation by the dithiophosphinic acids.

New tetradentate N,O-hybrid phenanthroline-derived organophosphorus extractants for the separation and complexation of trivalent actinides and lanthanides

Comparison of the extraction and separation properties between two novel phenanthroline-derived organophosphorus ligands, Et-Ph-BPPhen and Et-Ph-PIPhen.

Improving the theoretical description of Ln(III)/An(III) separation with phosphinic acid ligands: a benchmarking study of structure and selectivity

The efficient separation of trivalent lanthanides from minor actinides with soft-donor ligands, while showing experimental promise, has theorists continuing to search for suitable approaches for describing and interpreting selectivity. To remedy this, we employ several computational methods in describing the structure of model M(H₂PX₂)₃ complexes, with M = Eu and Am, and X = O, S, Se, and Te, and predicting the selectivity of model phosphinic acid ligands in Eu(III)/Am(III) separation. After first establishing a set of MP2 and CCSD(T)-DKH3 results as benchmarks, we evaluate several density functionals and descriptions of valence shells for their accuracy with respect to metal-ligand bonding and selectivity. We find that commonly employed functionals with a 0-27% range of exact exchange used with small-core effective core potentials or with an explicit treatment of the relativistic effects (DKH2) incorrectly predict a decrease in the metal-ligand bond distance in going from Eu(III) to Am(III) and completely fail to track a selectivity trend, even giving a wrong sign for some or all ligands. Surprisingly, when these functionals are used in conjunction with an f-in-core description of metal ions, the correct trend in selectivity is recovered, though Am-X distances are overestimated in relation to Eu-X. Functionals with high components of exact exchange (50%) and double-hybrid functionals are reasonably aligned with benchmark results, pointing to the problems of DFT with small exact exchange fractions to handle f-electrons. Natural bond orbital analyses reveal that these poorly performing functionals disproportionately overpopulate outer f orbitals in the model complexes. We anticipate that recommendations resulting from this work will lead to more accurate theoretical descriptions of lanthanide/actinide selectivity with soft-donor chalcogen-based ligands in the future.

Permanganometric Titration for the Quantification of Purified Bis(2,4,4-trimethylpentyl)dithiophosphinic Acid in n-Dodecane

The organic soluble extractant bis(2,4,4-trimethylpentyl)dithiophosphinic acid, often called Cyanex 301 (HC301), has shown selectivity for preferentially extracting trivalent actinides over the lanthanides in the treatment of used nuclear fuel. To maintain control and efficiency of a separation process using this extractant, it is necessary to accurately know specific parameters of the system, including the concentration of HC301 in the organic phase, at any given time. Here, the ability to quickly determine the concentration of HC301 in n-dodecane was tested by a one-step permanganometric titration in an organic solution using a double-beam UV-vis spectrophotometer. The addition of HC301 in n-dodecane to solutions of KMnO₄ was found to decolorize the KMnO₄ solutions, but the HC301 was best quantified in terms of decolorization in acetone. This decolorization allowed for the creation of a linear analytical curve relating the amount of KMnO₄ consumed to the amount of HC301 added. Cross-validation of this analytical curve reproduced the known amount of HC301 with an average difference of 1.73% and a maximum of 4.03%.