Decision-Making Regarding Newborn Circumcision: A Qualitative Analysis

Decisional conflict in American parents regarding newborn circumcision

BACKGROUND

Decisional conflict surrounding the topic of circumcision in the newborn male is assumed in some parents but has not been quantified or qualified. It is known that parents often base their decision on cultural and social factors and that physician discussions do affect ultimate decision-making. Information on parents' decision-making surrounding newborn circumcision and ways to mitigate conflict or uncertainty around the decision-making process is needed to better counsel them appropriately.

OBJECTIVES

To identify the presence or absence of decisional conflict in parents-to-be deciding whether or not to circumcise their child as well as to identify determinants of this conflict to direct future educational measures.

STUDY DESIGN

Parents presenting to obstetrics clinic as well as contacted by institutional email were recruited using convenience sampling and completed the validated Decisional Conflict Scale (DCS). A smaller subset of subjects were recruited via institutional email to complete semi-structured interviews regarding the decision-making process and specifically uncertainty regarding the decision. Descriptive statistics and unpaired t tests were used for analysis of survey data. For interview data, an iterative, grounded theory methodology was used.

RESULTS

173 subjects completed the DCS. 12% of all participants had high decisional conflict. Intuitively, those who had not yet decided whether to circumcise had the highest proportion of high DCS (69%), followed by those who had decided to circumcise (9.3%) and those who had decided not to circumcise (1.7%). 24 subjects were interviewed, and based on their DCS scores and interview responses were classified as low, intermediate and high conflict. Three primary themes emerged delineating the high from low conflict groups. There were notable differences in the feelings of subjects regarding knowledge and feeling informed, the importance of particular values and clarity of the roles of these values in decision-making, and feelings of supported decision-making. These themes were used to create a visual model depicting the individual needs of each decision-maker (Fig. 1).

DISCUSSION

This study highlights the need for decision support for parents that is not only information-based but focuses on values clarity and supported decision-making. This study provides a jumping-off point for creation of shared decision-making tools directed at individual needs. The limitations of this study are a single institution design and homogeneous population, so when designing materials, additional unrecognized needs will likely be identified.

CONCLUSION

A small, but real proportion of parents-to-be experience significant uncertainty around the decision to circumcise their newborn boys. Identified needs of parents include feeling informed, feeling supported and clarification of important values related to the problem.

A comprehensive comparison of the early and late complications of surgical circumcision in neonates and children: A cohort study

Background and Aims

Major circumcision complications are rare; however, circumcision arouses distress in some special cases. The present study aimed to compare infancy and childhood regarding the frequency and relative risk of early and late complications of circumcision.

Methods

This study was a retrospective cohort data analysis including 240 neonates and 240 children referred for circumcision from 2015 to 2021. All circumcisions were performed using the surgical dorsal-ventral slits method. A Cox proportional hazard model was used to assess the relative risk (RR) of complications at a confidence Interval of 95%.

Results

The mean age was 19.32 ± 6.5 days for the neonates and 46.1 ± 8.8 months for the children. In general, complications occurred in 61 boys (12.7%), 40 neonates (8.3%), and 21 children (4.4%) (p˂0.001). Bleeding was the most common early complication in six neonates (2.5%) and three children (1.3%), and meatal stenosis was the most common late complication in 10 neonates (4.2%) and four children (1.6%). Meatal web was observed in 11 neonates (4.6%) and four children (1.6%), and the incomplete removal of the prepuce, as "not very satisfactory", was also noticed in nine neonates (3.75%) and three children (1.3%). The circumcision complications were significantly more frequent in neonates than in children (RR = 2.6, 95% CI 1.46-4.71, p<0.001). The neonatal circumcisions had a significant risk of the incomplete removal of the prepuce, meatal web, and meatal stenosis compared to children (RR = 3, 95% CI 5.83-10.81, p<0.04; RR = 2.75, 95% CI 0.9-8.3, p˂0.03; RR = 2.5, 95% CI 0.8-7.75, p<0.04, respectively).

Conclusion

The risk of complications is higher in neonates than children. The incomplete removal of prepuce, meatal web, and meatal stenosis are significantly higher in neonates than in children. Before prohibiting or recommending this procedure, practitioners should provide comprehensive information about its risks and benefits. Parents should weigh up the risks and benefits and make the best decision regarding their personal beliefs and customs.

YouTube as a source for information on newborn male circumcision: Is YouTube a reliable patient resource?

INTRODUCTION

YouTube is the most popular open access media-sharing platform and is the second most visited websites worldwide. However, due to a lack of peer-review, YouTube is largely unregulated and can be susceptible to the spread of biased or misleading information.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the quality and potential bias of videos pertaining to newborn male circumcision (NMC) on YouTube.

MATERIALS & METHODS

A YouTube search was performed on August 27, 2021 using the search term 'circumcision', and the top 100 videos were analyzed by two independent reviewers. Videos were categorized into groupings based on their source, and each video was evaluated for bias and was determined to be either pro-circumcision, anti-circumcision or neutral. Video quality was assessed using the DISCERN instrument (1-5 scale) and the Global Quality Scale (GQS) (1-5 scale). Video popularity was measured using the video power index (VPI).

RESULTS

We found that the overall quality of videos on YouTube pertaining to NMC is generally low (DISCERN: 2.9 ± 0.7, GQS: 2.9 ± 1.1). When describing potential bias, 56% of videos were neutral and 44% were biased, of which 30% being anti-circumcision and 14% being pro-circumcision. Videos which were neutral, produced by health channels, or which featured physicians were associated with the highest quality ratings. However, when correlating total video views and likes with our quality assessments, we observed a significant negative correlation between the overall popularity of a video and its DISCERN (ρ = -0.297, p = 0.031) and GQS quality ratings (ρ = -0.274, p = 0.048).

CONCLUSION

Information pertaining to NMC on YouTube is generally of low quality and has a high potential for bias. Lower quality content is overrepresented on YouTube and tended to be more popular than higher quality content. Patients and their families should be cautious when accessing YouTube for health information pertaining to NMC.