A new Strategy to Improve Drug Delivery to the Maxillary Sinuses: The Frequency Sweep Acoustic Airflow

Advancements in acoustic drug delivery for paranasal sinuses: A comprehensive review

Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) impacts patients' quality of life and healthcare costs. Traditional methods of drug delivery, such as nasal sprays and irrigation, have limited effectiveness. Acoustic Drug Delivery (ADD) using a nebulizer offers targeted delivery of drug to the sinuses, which may improve the treatment of CRS. This review examines the influence of aerosol particle characteristics, aero-acoustic parameters, inlet flow conditions, and acoustic waves on sinus drug delivery. Key findings reveal that smaller particles improve the ADD efficiency, whereas larger sizes or increased density impair it. The oscillation amplitude of the air plug in the ostium is crucial for the ADD efficiency. Introducing acoustic waves at the NC-sinus system's resonance frequency improves aerosol deposition within sinuses. Future research should address advanced models, optimizing particle characteristics, investigating novel acoustic waveforms, incorporating patient-specific anatomy, and evaluating long-term safety and efficacy. Tackling these challenges, ADD could offer more effective and targeted treatments for sinus-related conditions such as CRS.

Acoustic Aerosol Delivery: Assessing of Various Nasal Delivery Techniques and Medical Devices on Intrasinus Drug Deposition

This study aims to evaluate the impact of the nasal delivery technique and nebulizing technologies (using different frequencies of oscillating airflow) for acoustic aerosol targeting of maxillary sinuses. Sodium fluoride (chemical used as a marker), tobramycin (drug used as a marker) and ^99mTc-DTPA (radiolabel aerosol) were used to assess the intrasinus aerosol deposition on a nasal cast. Two commercial medical devices (PARI SINUS nebulizer and NL11SN ATOMISOR nebulizer) and various nasal delivery techniques (one or two nostrils connected to the aerosol inlet, the patient with the soft palate closed or open during the acoustic administration of the drug, the presence or not of flow resistance in the nostril opposite to the one allowing the aerosol to be administered) were evaluated. The closed soft palate condition showed a significant increase in drug deposition even though no significant difference in the rest of the nasal fossae was noticed. Our results clearly demonstrated a higher intrasinus aerosol deposition (by a factor 2-3; respectively 0.03 ± 0.007% vs. 0.003 ± 0.0002% in the right maxillary sinus and 0.027 ± 0.006% vs. 0.013 ± 0.004% in the left maxillary sinus) using the acoustic airflow generated by the PARI SINUS compared to the NL11SN ATOMISOR. The results clearly demonstrated that the optimal conditions for aerosol deposition in the maxillary sinuses were obtained with a closed soft palate. Thus, the choice of the nebulizing technology (and mainly the frequency of the pulsating aerosol generated) and also the recommendation of the best nasal delivery technique are key factors to improve intrasinus aerosol deposition.

In vitro - in vivo correlation of intranasal drug deposition

In vitro - in vivo correlation (IVIVC) allows prediction of in vivo drug deposition from a nasally inhaled drug based on in vitro drug measurements. In vitro measurements include physical particle characterization and, more recently, deposition studies using anatomical models. Currently, there is a lack of IVIVC for deposition measurements in anatomical models, especially for deposition patterns in various nasal cavity regions. Therefore, improvement of in vitro and in vivo measurement methods and knowledge about nasal deposition mechanisms should help IVIVC in the future.

Nebulised Gadolinium-Based Nanoparticles for a Multimodal Approach: Quantitative and Qualitative Lung Distribution Using Magnetic Resonance and Scintigraphy Imaging in Isolated Ventilated Porcine Lungs

Purpose

This study aims at determining lung distribution of gadolinium-based polysiloxane nanoparticles, AGuIX^® (small rigid platform - SRP), as a potential theranostic approach by the pulmonary route.

Methods

First, the aerodynamic size distribution and the aerosol output rate were thoroughly characterized. Then, a multimodal approach using magnetic resonance (MR) and gamma-camera (GC) imaging allows to assess the deposition of the aerosolised nanoparticles in the respiratory tract using isolated ventilated porcine lungs.

Results

The SRP has proven to be radiolabelled by radioisotope with a good yield. Crude SRP or radiolabelled ones showed the same aerodynamic size distribution and output as a conventional molecular tracer, as sodium fluoride. With MR and GC imaging approaches, the nebulised dose represented about 50% of the initial dose of nanoparticles placed in the nebuliser. Results expressed as proportions of the deposited aerosol showed approximately a regional aerosol deposition of 50% of the deposited dose in the lungs and 50% in the upper airways. Each technique assessed a homogeneous pattern of deposited nanoparticles in Lungs. MR observed a strong signal enhancement with the SRP, similar to the one obtained with a commonly used MRI contrast agent, gadoterate meglumine.

Conclusion

As a known theranostic approach by intravenous administration, SRP appeared to be easily aerosolised with a conventional nebuliser. The present work proves that pulmonary administration of SRP is feasible in a human-like model and allows multimodal imaging with MR and GC imaging. This work presents the proof of concept of SRP nebulisation and aims to generate preclinical data for the potential clinical transfer of SRP for pulmonary delivery.

Acoustically-driven drug delivery to maxillary sinuses: Aero-acoustic analysis

This paper investigates the effect of aero-acoustic parameters on the efficiency of acoustically-driven drug delivery (ADD) to human maxillary sinus (MS). To be more specific, the effect of the frequency, amplitude at the acoustic excitation, and the inlet mean flow rate on the efficiency of ADD to the MS is studied. Direct computational aero-acoustics, using a validated computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model, has been utilised to carry out the parametric study. The transport pattern of the particles (drugs) in the presence of an external acoustic field has been investigated through the discrete phase model. Extensive computational simulations have revealed that the most important parameter in acoustically-driven drug delivery to the MS is the amplitude of the oscillation of the air plug in the ostium, which is largest when the combination of nasal cavity and MS is at resonance. Also, it has been found that the amplitude of the inlet acoustic wave has a direct correlation with the efficiency of the drug delivery to the MS. Moreover, the inlet mean airflow rate adversely affects the efficiency of the drug delivery to the MS. The results of this study suggest that applying an external acoustic field after distributing the drug particles with no mean flow results in a better drug delivery than in the presence of an inlet mean flow.

The impact of geometrical parameters on acoustically driven drug delivery to maxillary sinuses

Acoustically driven nebulized drug delivery (acoustic aerosol delivery) is the most efficient noninvasive technique for drug delivery to maxillary sinuses (MS). This method is based on the oscillation of the air plug inside the ostium to transport drug particles from the nasal cavity (NC) to the MS. The larger the wavelength of the air plug oscillation in the ostium, the greater the penetration of drug particles to the MS. However, using this technique, the maximum drug delivery efficiency achieved to date is 5%, which means 95% of the aerosolized drugs do not enter the MS and are wasted. Since the largest amplitude of the air plug oscillation occurs at its resonance frequency, to achieve an improved MS drug delivery efficiency, it is important to determine the resonance frequency of the nose-sinus combination accurately. This paper aims to investigate the impact of geometrical parameters on the resonance frequency of the nose-sinus model. Both experimental and computational acoustic models, along with the theoretical analysis, were conducted to determine the resonance frequency of an idealized nose-sinus model. The computational modeling was carried out using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and finite element analysis (FEA), whereas in the analytical solution, the mathematical relationships developed for a conventional Helmholtz resonator were employed. A series of experiments were also conducted to measure the resonance frequency of a realistic NC-MS combination. The results demonstrated a good agreement between the experimental and CFD modeling, while the FEA and theoretical analysis showed a significant deviation from the experimental data. Also, it was shown that the resonance frequency of the idealized nose-sinus model increases by up to twofold with increasing the ostium diameter from 3 to 9 mm; however, it has an inverse relationship with the ostium length and sinus volume. It was also reported that the resonance frequency of the nose-sinus model is independent of the NC width and MS shape.

Toward smart Nebulization: Engineering acoustic airflow to penetrate maxillary sinuses in chronic rhinosinusitis

Treating chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) by nebulization requires an airflow capable to deliver medication to deep target sites beyond the nasal valve. Fixed frequency acoustic airflow technology is currently available, mainly as post-surgical therapy, but still have not been able to realize the full potential of direct nose to paranasal sinuses delivery. Reported herein are the application of frequency sweep acoustic airflow and the optimization of its frequency range, sweep cycle duration and intensity. The resonant frequencies of the model's maxillary sinuses can be estimated using the Helmholtz resonator theory. Results indicated a resonant frequency of 479 Hz for the right maxillary sinus and one of 849 Hz for the left maxillary sinus. The highest intrasinus deposition within the experiments are from sweep cycle duration of 1 s, intensity of 80 dB, and frequency range of 100-850 Hz. The optimal range of frequency determined from experiments is in good agreement with the corresponding frequency range obtained from the Helmholtz resonator theory. Results reveal a significantly enhanced maxillary sinus drug deposition. This technique affords the potential of treating CRS.

Experimental human-like model to assess the part of viable Legionella reaching the thoracic region after nebulization

The incidence of Legionnaires’ disease (LD) in European countries and the USA has been constantly increasing since 1998. Infection of humans occurs through aerosol inhalation. To bridge the existing gap between the concentration of Legionella in a water network and the deposition of bacteria within the thoracic region (assessment of the number of viable Legionella), we validated a model mimicking realistic exposure through the use of (i) recent technology for aerosol generation and (ii) a 3D replicate of the human upper respiratory tract. The model’s sensitivity was determined by monitoring the deposition of (i) aerosolized water and Tc^99m radio-aerosol as controls, and (ii) bioaerosols generated from both Escherichia coli and Legionella pneumophila sg 1 suspensions. The numbers of viable Legionella prior to and after nebulization were provided by culture, flow cytometry and qPCR. This study was designed to obtain more realistic data on aerosol inhalation (vs. animal experimentation) and deposition at the thoracic region in the context of LD. Upon nebulization, 40% and 48% of the initial Legionella inoculum was made of cultivable and non-cultivable cells, respectively; 0.7% of both populations reached the filter holder mimicking the thoracic region in this setup. These results are in agreement with experimental data based on quantitative microbial risk assessment methods and bring new methods that may be useful for preventing LD.

Understanding the mechanisms underlying pulsating aerosol delivery to the maxillary sinus: In vitro tests and computational simulations

BACKGROUND

Pulsating aerosol delivery has been demonstrated in depositing medications into paranasal sinuses. However, its mechanisms are not fully understood. Influences of the nasal anatomy and sound frequency on intrasinus delivery are not yet clear.

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to gain a better understanding of the mechanisms for enhanced intrasinus delivery with pulsating sound. Specifically, effects of the pulsation frequency, ostium size, and sinus shape on the intrasinus dosage and resonance frequency would be examined.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Both experiments and computational modeling were conducted to understand the pulsating aerosol delivery in both idealized (two-bottle) and realistic nose-sinus models. A computational model of intrasinus pulsation delivery was developed using COMSOL and was cross-validated with both experimental and theoretical results.

RESULTS

In contrast to previous studies, seemingly erratic relations between the intrasinus dosage and ostium diameter were observed in experiments, which suggested a more complicated particle transport mechanism. Improved agreement was achieved when grouping the ostium size and sinus volume into the resonance frequency, and therefore, validated the hypothesis that intrasinus deposition strongly depends on the resonance frequency. Extensive computational simulations revealed that the deposition was highest at the resonance frequency and decreased gradually at off-resonance frequencies. The resonance frequency depended on the ostium and sinus morphology, but was independent of the nasal cavity.

CONCLUSION

Results of this study verified the hypothesis of resonance being the mechanism for enhanced particle deposition in the maxillary sinus. A better knowledge of the relationship between sinus dosages, pulsating frequency, and nasal morphometry is essential for improving the design of intrasinus delivery devices.

Micron-sized and submicron-sized aerosol deposition in a new ex vivo preclinical model

Background

The knowledge of where particles deposit in the respiratory tract is crucial for understanding the health effects associated with inhaled drug particles.

Method

An ex vivo study was conducted to assess regional deposition patterns (thoracic vs. extrathoracic) of radioactive polydisperse aerosols with different size ranges [0.15 μm–0.5 μm], [0.25 μm–1 μm] and [1 μm–9 μm]. SPECT/CT analyses were performed complementary in order to assess more precisely the regional deposition of aerosols within the pulmonary tract.

Experiments were set using an original respiratory tract model composed of a human plastinated head connected to an ex vivo porcine pulmonary tract. The model was ventilated by passive expansion, simulating pleural depressions. Aerosol was administered during nasal breathing.

Results

Planar scintigraphies allowed to calculate the deposited aerosol fractions for particles in the three size ranges from sub-micron to micron The deposited fractions obtained, for thoracic vs. extra-thoracic regions respectively, were 89 ± 4 % vs. 11 ± 4 % for [0.15 μm–0.5 μm], 78 ± 5 % vs. 22 ± 5 % for [0.25 μm–1 μm] and 35 ± 11 % vs.65 ± 11 % for [1 μm–9 μm].

Conclusion

Results obtained with this new ex vivo respiratory tract model are in good agreement with the in vivo data obtained in studies with baboons and humans.