Randomized Trial of a Sexual Health Video Intervention for Black and Hispanic Adolescent Females

Improving young patient - practitioner communication about sexual health during medical visits

OBJECTIVES

Young people face barriers that lead to gaps in sexual and reproductive health care communications. Issues such as discomfort discussing sexual health lead to inadequate delivery of services resulting in unintended pregnancies and STIs. Closing this communication gap between patients and health care practitioners would improve communication and health outcomes. The objective of this study was to gain feedback from focus groups about: (a) barriers and facilitators to communication surrounding sexual health and (b) the feasibility and acceptability of a question prompt list (QPL) and informational video emphasizing asking questions about sexual health during medical visits as tools young people could use to be more involved during visits.

METHODS

Three focus groups were conducted: two with young adults (n=14) and one with practitioners (n=5) of sexual/reproductive health care services. Practitioners were recruited from healthcare clinics.

RESULTS

Young adults were aged 18-22 years old. Participants identified barriers to communication such as embarrassment over sexual health topics and practitioner assumptions about patients' base of knowledge. A facilitator to communication was patient-friendly language. Focus group participants offered suggestions on how to improve the QPL as well as themes that should be covered in an educational video. Participants viewed the QPL and educational video as useful for encouraging conversations between patient and practitioner.

CONCLUSIONS

Many barriers obstruct communication between young adults and practitioners on topics relating to sexual health. Both the QPL and an educational video could be used to enhance patient-practitioner communication.

Clinic Staff Perceptions of Implementing a Sexual and Reproductive Health Entertainment-Education Program for Young Women of Color

Objective

Entertainment-education interventions remain underutilized in sexual and reproductive health (SRH) despite evidence that they can be effective and place a low burden on staff. This study explores perceived facilitators and barriers for implementing an entertainment-education video intervention for 18- to 19-year-old African American and Latina women in SRH clinics.

Design

Cross-sectional online survey (n=100) and telephone interviews (n=19) were completed May through August 2018.

Setting

SRH clinics were located across 32 US states and 1 Canadian province.

Participants

SRH clinic staff were diverse in type of clinic, role, and geography and were recruited using purposive sampling.

Methods

Bivariate analyses were used for quantitative data, and thematic analysis was used for qualitative data.

Main Outcome Measures

Intervention acceptability, perceived feasibility, and likely uptake were assessed using agreement statements (survey) and open-ended questions (interviews and survey).

Results

Interviewed clinic staff described the intervention as engaging, educational, and promising for improving client SRH knowledge and behaviors. Nearly all (95%) survey respondents said showing the video would be feasible. Most (56%) indicated likely uptake, which was significantly associated with perceived feasibility (P=.000), acceptability (P≤.001), and working at a public health clinic (P=.023). Implementation barriers included the video's potential relevance to only certain clients and the need for additional information or staff and/or management buy-in.

Conclusions

This is the first study to assess perceived implementation facilitators and barriers of an entertainment-education video intervention among SRH clinic staff. The intervention was well received, with certain barriers potentially alleviated by offering information about entertainment-education and multiple implementation methods. These findings can help improve dissemination efforts for video-based entertainment-education interventions in clinics serving young women of color.

Innovation to Impact: Introduction to the Special Issue on Evidence from the Teen Pregnancy Prevention Program Experiment with Innovation

Congress has provided funding for the federal Teen Pregnancy Prevention (TPP) Program since 2009 for spending beginning in Fiscal Year 2010. Designated TPP programs develop, test, and evaluate innovations for reducing teen pregnancy, teen pregnancy disparities, and associated risk factors and for promoting positive youth development. Since its inception, the TPP Program has experimented with multiple uniquely structured cohorts of innovation and demonstration projects, producing critical insights into equitable and effective public health innovation while also serving as a highly productive contributor of evidence-based, TPP innovations for scale. This article briefly documents the innovation history of the TPP Program and its iterations in response to the shifting needs of the field. We then synthesize findings from the fifteen TPP innovators published in this special edition. We highlight emergent priorities of the TPP Program informed by this federal experiment in rigorous adolescent sexual health innovation development, testing, evaluation, and scaling and conclude by discussing how the TPP program adapted and refined its approach for fostering dynamic innovation-to-scale projects over time.

Toward an Effective Innovation Framework for Federal Grant-Making: an Exploration into OPA's Teen Pregnancy Prevention Program

States, local, tribal, and territorial governments received almost 20% of all federal spending in fiscal year 2022, about $1.2 trillion dollars (US Office of Management and Budget, 2023a). For a strong, well-functioning democracy, the federal government must be able to disperse grant funds efficiently and effectively. Rates of teen pregnancy in the USA, while decreasing in recent years, are still consistently higher than that of other western industrialized nations (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2023). The Office of Population Affairs' (OPA) Teen Pregnancy Prevention program combines cutting edge research with innovative grant distribution to creatively tackle this issue. In this commentary, we explore some of the strengths of OPA's grant distribution program in the hope that others may emulate best practices from this program. Specifically, the special issue highlights how OPA's grant program took a customer-centered focus by prioritizing work with end users and community. This evidence-based focus enabled the testing of ideas, which in turn could be iterated and scaled up. Through grantee innovation networks, they created space for external expertise, creative thinking, and diversity of thought. Other programs, policymakers, and their partners may learn from OPA's success, which arises from three core characteristics: (1) their funding stature allows long-term and flexible allocation of funding toward innovation; (2) OPA focuses on creating and supporting local communities and networks of innovation; (3) OPA emphasizes evidence-based decision-making and rigorous evaluation throughout the grant process. With a fifth of the federal budget being dispersed through grant-making and teen pregnancy still at high rates, OPA offers an exciting avenue for innovation and success in both of these areas. This commentary concludes with some recommendations for future practice.