Revealing substituent effects on the concerted interaction of pnicogen, chalcogen, and halogen bonds in substituted s-triazine ring

Unique Dispersion-Induced Tetrel Bond with Co-operative σ-hole-Induced Pnicogen Bond in the POCl3-Acetone Heterodimer: Experimental Confirmation at Low Temperatures

Both tetrel and pnicogen bonds are known to be induced through σ-/π-holes. This work reports computational and experimental evidence of the carbonyl carbon of acetone hosting a tetrel bond by dispersion rather electrostatic forces, for the first time, while phosphorus of POCl₃ sustains pnicogen bonding via the σ-hole. Heterodimers of POCl₃ with acetone (CH₃COCH₃) have been isolated within inert gas matrixes of Ar and N₂ at 12 K. Characteristic vibrational bands at P═O stretching of POCl₃ and C═O stretching of CH₃COCH₃ have been obtained in support of the computations. The potential energy surface has been traced computationally using ab initio and density functional methods. CH₃COCH₃ harboring such a tetrel bond, in itself, is quite intriguing. The interplay of these interactions has been comprehended by the quantum theory of atoms in molecules, natural bond orbital, energy decomposition, electrostatic potential mapping, and noncovalent interaction analyses.

Intermolecular hydrogen bonds between 1,4-benzoquinones and HF molecule: Synergetic effects, reduction potentials and electron affinities

Some biological activities of quinones can be attributed to the H-bonding ability of acceptor oxygen atoms. According to the results obtained from the quantum mechanical calculations performed on a wide variety of complexes between the 1,4-benzoquinone (BQ) derivatives and HF molecules, the interplay between H-bonds and individual H-bond interaction energies (E_HB) can be affected by the substituents placed on the six-membered ring of BQ. The total binding energies of complexes become more negative by the electron donating substituents (EDSs) while the changes are reversed by the electron withdrawing substituents (EWSs). The mutual interplay between the X-BQ⋯(HF)_n (n=1-3) interactions has been investigated using the geometrical parameters, synergetic energies (SE) and the E_HB values. Hydrogen bonding decreases the reduction potentials (E⁰_red) and increases the electron affinities (EA) of X-BQ derivatives. Linear relationships have been observed between the E⁰_red (and EA) values and the Hammett constants of substituents.

Novel pnicogen bonding interactions with silylene as an electron donor: covalency, unusual substituent effects and new mechanisms

An analogue of carbene, singlet silylene (H3P=N)2Si, was paired with the mono-substituted phosphines XH2Y (X = P, As, and Sb; Y = F, Cl, Br, and I) to form unconventional pnicogen-bonded complexes. All structures have Cs symmetry except the Sb complex, showing a deviation from this symmetry due to the coexistence of H···H interactions. The P and As complexes have different geometries from conventional pnicogen-bonded ones because the Y-X···Si line shows a large deviation from the molecular plane composed of two N atoms and one Si atom of (H3P=N)2Si. This deviation can be attributed to a new formation mechanism of the pnicogen bond due to the combined result of the LPSi→ BD*X-Y and LPX→ LP*Si orbital interactions. Generally, the pnicogen bond becomes stronger in the order of F < Cl < Br < I and weaker in the order of P > As > Sb, exhibiting an unexpected substitution effect and dependence on the nature of the pnicogen atom. These orders are inconsistent with the MEP on the X atom but can be better explained by the above orbital interactions. The Si···X interaction displays a character of covalent or partially covalent interaction, evidenced by the high interaction energy of -59.9 to -105.4 kJ mol(-1) as well as the negative energy density and the great charge transfer.

Theoretical calculations of π-type pnicogen bonds in the triad intermolecular complexes

The pnicogen bonding interactions of PCl3and π-electron systems (acetylene, ethylene, benzene) were calculated by using MP2/aug-cc-pVDZ method and the effect of hydrogen bond on pnicogen bond systems were investigated. It has been indicated that the hydrogen bonding and the pnicogen bonding interactions have influence on each other and the positively cooperative effect has been detected. The interaction energies of pnicogen bonded supramolecular system were also calculated by using DFT method (M06-2X) and some simple comparisons with those by using MP2 method were made. It has been disclosed from natural bond orbitals (NBO) analysis that more the amount of charge transfer of pnicogen bonding interaction, the greater the stability of the corresponding complex. Through AIM topological analysis, it has been revealed that the electron density of pnicogen bond BCP point is positively correlated with the stability of trimeric complex. Electron localization function (ELF) was also adopted to analyze the nature of pnicogen bonding interactions. Furthermore, density difference function (DDF) method was adopted to analyze the variation of electron density of pnicogen bond system because of hydrogen bond.

Influence of substituent effects on the formation of P···Cl pnicogen bonds or halogen bonds

Ab initio MP2/aug'-cc-pVTZ calculations have been carried out in search of equilibrium structures with P···Cl pnicogen bonds or halogen bonds on the potential energy surfaces H2FP:ClY for Y = F, NC, Cl, CN, CCH, CH3, and H. Three different types of halogen-bonded complexes with traditional, chlorine-shared, and ion-pair bonds have been identified. Two different pnicogen-bonded complexes have also been found on these surfaces. The most electronegative substituents F and NC form only halogen-bonded complexes, while the most electropositive substituents CH3 and H form only pnicogen-bonded complexes. The halogen-bonded complexes involving the less electronegative groups Cl and CN are more stable than the corresponding pnicogen-bonded complexes, while the pnicogen-bonded complexes with CCH are more stable than the corresponding halogen-bonded complex. Traditional halogen-bonded complexes are stabilized by charge transfer from the P lone pair to the Cl-A σ* orbital, where A is the atom of Y directly bonded to Cl. Charge transfer from the Cl lone pair to the P-F σ* orbital stabilizes pnicogen-bonded complexes. As a result, the H2FP unit becomes positively charged in halogen-bonded complexes and negatively charged in pnicogen-bonded complexes. Spin-spin coupling constants (1X)J(P-Cl) for complexes with traditional halogen bonds increase with decreasing P-Cl distance, reach a maximum value for complexes with chlorine-shared halogen bonds, and then decrease and change sign when the bond is an ion-pair bond. (1p)J(P-Cl) coupling constants across pnicogen bonds tend to increase with decreasing P-Cl distance.

Electron transfer in pnicogen bonds

As a new type of noncovalent interactions, pnicogen bond between a VA group element (N, P, and As) and an electron donor (Lewis base) has grabbed attention in recent several years. Here we employ the block-localized wave function (BLW) based energy decomposition scheme to probe the bonding nature in a series of substituted phosphines X(n)PH(3-n) complexed with ammonia. As the BLW method can derive the optimal monomer orbitals in a complex with the electron transfer among monomers quenched, we can effectively examine the HOMO-LUMO interaction in these pnicogen bonding systems. Among various energy components, electron transfer energy together with the polarization energy dominates the pnicogen bonding energy. Although usually it is assumed that the electron transfer from ammonia to substituted phosphines occurs in the form of n → σ*(XP) hyperconjugative interaction, we identify a kind of new pathway when X = NO2 and CN, i.e., n → dπ*, which results from the interaction between the π orbital of cyano or nitro substituent and d orbitals on P. But still this picture of electron transfer using a single pair of orbitals is greatly simplified, as the electron density difference (EDD) maps corresponding to the overall electron transfer processes show the accumulation of electron density on the P side opposite to the X-P bond, with insignificant or even negligible gain of electron density on the substituent group side. Thus, the EDD maps tend to support the concept of σ-hole in pnicogen bonds.