Structural analysis of arylsulfonamide-based carboxylic acid derivatives: a QSAR study to identify the structural contributors toward their MMP-9 inhibition

An updated patent review of matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) inhibitors (2021-present)

INTRODUCTION

Matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) are strongly interlinked with the progression and mechanisms of several life-threatening diseases including cancer. Thus, novel MMP inhibitors (MMPIs) as promising drug candidates can be effective in combating these diseases. However, no MMPIs are marketed to date due to poor pharmacokinetics and lower selectivity. Therefore, this review was performed to study the newer MMPIs patented after the COVID-19 period for an updated perspective on MMPIs.

AREAS COVERED

This review highlights patents related to MMPIs, and their therapeutic implications published between January 2021 and August 2023 available in the Google Patents, Patentscope, and Espacenet databases.

EXPERT OPINION

Despite various MMP-related patents disclosed up to 2020, newer patent applications in the post-COVID-19 period decreased a lot. Besides major MMPs, other isoforms (i.e. MMP-3 and MMP-7) have gained attention recently for drug development. This may open up newer dimensions targeting these MMPs for therapeutic advancements. The isoform selectivity and bioavailability are major concerns for effective MMPI development. Thus, adopting theoretical approaches and experimental methodologies can unveil the development of novel MMPIs with improved pharmacokinetic profiles. Nevertheless, the involvement of MMPs in cancer, and the mechanisms of such MMPs in other diseases should be extensively studied for novel MMPI development.

Employing comparative QSAR techniques for the recognition of dibenzofuran and dibenzothiophene derivatives toward MMP-12 inhibition

Among various matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs), MMP-12 is one of the potential targets for cancer and other diseases. However, none of the MMP-12 inhibitors has passed the clinical trials to date. Therefore, designing potential MMP-12 inhibitors as new drug molecules can provide effective therapeutic strategies for several diseases. In this study, a series of dibenzofuran and dibenzothiophene derivatives were subjected to different 2D and 3D-QSAR techniques to point out the crucial structural contributions highly influential toward the MMP-12 inhibitory activity. These techniques identified some structural attributes of these compounds that are responsible for influencing their MMP-12 inhibition. The carboxylic group may enhance proper binding with catalytic Zn²⁺ ion at the MMP-12 active site. Again, the i-propyl sulfonamido carboxylic acid function contributed positively toward MMP-12 inhibition. Moreover, the dibenzofuran moiety conferred stable binding at the S1' pocket for higher MMP-12 inhibition. The steric and hydrophobic groups were found favourable near the furan ring substituted at the dibenzofuran moiety. Besides these ligand-based approaches, molecular docking and molecular dynamic (MD) simulation studies not only elucidated the importance of several aspects of these MMP-12 inhibitors while disclosing the significance of the finding of these QSAR studies and their influences toward MMP-12 inhibition. The MD simulation study also revealed stable and compact binding between such compounds at the MMP-12 active site. Therefore, the findings of these validated ligand-based and structure-based molecular modeling studies can aid the development of selective and potent lead molecules that can be used for the treatment of MMP-12-associated diseases.Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.

Insight into the structural requirements of gelatinases (MMP-2 and MMP-9) inhibitors by multiple validated molecular modelling approaches: Part II

Inhibition of the matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) is effective against metastasis of secondary tumours. Previous MMP inhibitors have failed in clinical trials due to their off-target toxicity in solid tumours. Thus, newer MMP inhibitors now have paramount importance. Here, different molecular modelling techniques were applied on a dataset of 110 gelatinase (MMP-2 and MMP-9) inhibitors. The objectives of the present study were to identify structural fingerprints for gelatinase inhibition and also to develop statistically validated QSAR models for the screening and prediction of different derivatives as MMP-2 (gelatinase A) and MMP-9 (gelatinase B) inhibitors. The Bayesian classification study provided the ROC values for the training set of 0.837 and 0.815 for MMP-2 and MMP-9, respectively. The linear model also produced the leave-one-out cross-validated Q² of 0.805 (eq. 1, MMP-2) and 0.724 (eq. 2, MMP-9), an r² of 0.845 (eq. 1, MMP-2) and 0.782 (eq. 2, MMP-9), an r²_Pred of 0.806 (eq. 1, MMP-2) and 0.732 (eq. 2, MMP-9). Similarly, non-linear learning models were also statistically significant and reliable. Overall, this study may help in the rational design of newer compounds with higher gelatinase inhibition to fight against both primary and secondary cancers in future.

Applying comparative molecular modelling techniques on diverse hydroxamate-based HDAC2 inhibitors: an attempt to identify promising structural features for potent HDAC2 inhibition

Histone deacetylase 2 (HDAC2) has been implicated in a variety of cardiovascular and neurodegenerative disorders as well as in cancers. Thus, HDAC2 has become an exclusive target for anticancer drug development. Therefore, the development of newer HDAC2 inhibitors in disease conditions is a prime goal to restrain such a scenario. Although a handful of HDAC inhibitors was accepted for the treatment of HDAC-related disease conditions, the non-selective nature of these entities is one of the major setbacks in the treatment of specific HDAC isoform-related pathophysiology. In this framework, the analyses of pre-existing molecules are essential to identify the important structural features that can fulfil the requirements for the cap and linker moieties to obtain potent and effective HDAC2 inhibition. Thus, in this study, the implementation of a combined comparative 2D and 3D molecular modelling techniques was done on a group of 92 diverse hydroxamate derivatives having a wide range of HDAC2 inhibitory potency. Besides other crucial features, this study upheld the importance of groups like triazole and benzyl moieties along with the molecular fields that are crucial for regulating HDAC2 inhibition. The outcomes of this study may be employed for the designing of HDAC2 inhibitors in future.

A robust classification-dependent multi-molecular modelling study on some biphenyl sulphonamide based MMP-8 inhibitors

Matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) are a group of zinc and calcium-dependent endopeptidases, which contribute to different physiological and biological activities via extracellular matrix (ECM) degradation. Matrix metalloproteinase-8 (MMP-8) belongs to type-II collagenases of the MMP family that has contribution in several physiological disorders such as cardiovascular diseases, joint, renal, digestive and respiratory disorders as well as in cancer. In clinical study, MMP-8 is found to be associated with periodontal disease condition. Therefore, MMP-8 specific inhibitors should be developed to target these disorders. The biphenyl sulphonamide (BPS) moiety is one of the crucial structural characteristics found in several MMP-8 inhibitors. Here, different classification-based molecular modelling methods were used to explore the structural features that lead to the activity variation of a series of MMP-8 inhibitors possessing a BPS moiety. Our current classification-based structural analysis of these BPS-derived MMP-8 inhibitors was able to identify the importance of several structural features such as the tetrahydroisoquinoline and N-Boc pyridyl groups, which have positive influences on MMP-8 inhibition. This study was also reflected the importance of the zinc-binding groups (ZBGs) like the hydroxamate and phosphonate for potent and sub-nanomolar range MMP-8 inhibition, which may benefit the development of highly potent MMP-8 inhibitors.

Engineered s-Triazine-Based Dendrimer-Honokiol Conjugates as Targeted MMP-2/9 Inhibitors for Halting Hepatocellular Carcinoma

Despite the advances in developing MMP-2/9 inhibitors, off-target side effects and pharmacokinetics problems remain major challenges hindering their clinical success in cancer therapy. However, recent targeting strategies have clearly revitalized MMP research. Herein, we introduce new s-triazine-based dendrimers endowed with intrinsic MMP-2/9 inhibitory potential and tetherable to hepatocellular carcinoma-specific targeting ligands and anticancer agents via biodegradable linkages for targeted therapy. The designed dendrimeric platform was built with potential zinc-binding branching linkers (hydrazides) and termini (carboxylic acids and hydrazides) to confer potency against MMP-2/9. Preliminary cytotoxicity screening and MMP-2/9 inhibition assay of the free dendrimers revealed promising potency (MMP-9; IC₅₀ =0.35-0.57 μM, MMP-2; IC₅₀ =0.39-0.77 μM) within their safe doses (EC₁₀₀ =94.15-42.75 μM). The hydrazide dendrimer was comparable to NNGH and superior to the carboxylic acid analogue. MTT assay showed that the free dendrimers were superior to the reference anticancer agent honokiol. Their anticancer potency was enhanced by HK conjugation, targeting ligands installation and PEGylation as exemplified by the hydrazide dendrimer conjugate (TPG₃ -NH₂ )-SuHK-FA-SuPEG (Huh-7; IC₅₀ =5.54 μM, HepG-2; IC₅₀ =10.07 μM) being 4 folds more active than HK, followed by the carboxylic acid conjugate (TPG₃ -OH)-HK-LA-PEG (Huh-7; IC₅₀ =14.97, HepG-2; IC₅₀ =21.29 μM). This was consistent with apoptosis studies.

Insight into the structural requirement of aryl sulphonamide based gelatinases (MMP-2 and MMP-9) inhibitors - Part I: 2D-QSAR, 3D-QSAR topomer CoMFA and Naïve Bayes studies - First report of 3D-QSAR Topomer CoMFA analysis for MMP-9 inhibitors and jointly inhibitors of gelatinases together

Gelatinases [gelatinase A - matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2), gelatinase B - matrix metalloproteinase-9 (MMP-9)] play key roles in many disease conditions including cancer. Despite some research work on gelatinases inhibitors both jointly and individually had been reported, challenges still exist in achieving potency as well as selectivity. Here in part I of a series of work, we have reported the structural requirement of some arylsulfonamides. In particular, regression-based 2D-QSARs, topomer CoMFA (comparative molecular field analysis) and Bayesian classification models were constructed to refine structural features for attaining better gelatinase inhibitory activity. The 2D-QSAR models exhibited good statistical significance. The descriptors nsssN, SHBint6, SHBint7, PubchemFP629 were directly correlated with the MMP-2 binding affinities whereas nsssN, SHBint10 and AATS2i were directly proportional to MMP-9 binding affinities. The topomer CoMFA results indicated that the steric and electrostatic fields play key roles in gelatinase inhibition. The established Naïve Bayes prediction models were evaluated by fivefold cross validation and an external test set. Furthermore, important molecular descriptors related to MMP-2 and MMP-9 binding affinities and some active/inactive fragments were identified. Thus, these observations may be helpful for further work of aryl sulphonamide based gelatinase inhibitors in future.