Identification of bacteria associated with underground parts of Crocus sativus by 16S rRNA gene targeted metagenomic approach

Functional analysis and comparative genomics of Rahnella perminowiae S11P1 and Variovorax sp. S12S4, two plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria isolated from Crocus sativus L. (saffron) rhizosphere

BACKGROUND

Rahnella perminowiae S11P1 and Variovorax sp. S12S4 are two plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria that were previously isolated from the rhizosphere of Crocus sativus L. (saffron), and have demonstrated interesting PGP activities and promising results when used as inoculants in field trials. To further elucidate the molecular mechanisms underlying their beneficial effects on plant growth, comprehensive genome mining of S11P1 and S12S4 and comparative genomic analysis with closely related strains were conducted.

RESULTS

Functional annotation of the two strains predicted a large number of genes involved in auxin and siderophore production, nitrogen fixation, sulfur metabolism, organic acid biosynthesis, pyrroloquinoline quinone production, 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) deaminase activity, volatile organic compounds production, and polyamine biosynthesis. In addition, numerous genes implicated in plant-bacteria interactions, such as those involved in chemotaxis and quorum sensing, were predicted. Moreover, the two strains carried genes involved in bacterial fitness under abiotic stress conditions. Comparative genomic analysis revealed an open pan-genomic structure for the two strains. COG annotation showed that higher fractions of core and accessory genes were involved in the metabolism and transport of carbohydrates and amino acids, suggesting the metabolic versatility of the two strains as effective rhizosphere colonizers. Furthermore, this study reports the first comparison of Multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA) and core-based phylogenies of the Rahnella and Variovorax genera.

CONCLUSIONS

The present study unveils the molecular mechanisms underlying plant growth promotion and biocontrol activity of S11P1 and S12S4, and provides a basis for their further biotechnological application in agriculture.

How binomial (traditional rainfed olive grove-Crocus sativus) crops impact the soil bacterial community and enhance microbial capacities

Intercropping can favour the yield of the main crop. However, because of the potential competition among woody crops, this system is rarely used by farmers. To increase knowledge about the intercropping system, we have explored three different combinations of alley cropping in rainfed olive groves compared to conventional management (CP): (i) Crocus sativus (D-S); (ii) Vicia sativa/Avena sativa in annual rotation (D-O); and (iii) Lavandula x intermedia (D-L). Different soil chemical properties were analyzed to evaluate the effects of alley cropping, while 16S rRNA amplification and enzymatic activities were determined to study the changes that occurred in soil microbial communities and activity. In addition, the influence of intercropping on the potential functionality of the soil microbial community was measured. Data revealed that the intercropping systems highly affected the microbial community and soil properties. The D-S cropping system increased soil total organic carbon and total nitrogen that were correlated with the bacterial community, indicating that both parameters were the main drivers shaping the structure of the bacterial community. The D-S soil cropping system had significantly higher relative abundances of the phyla Bacteroidetes, Proteobacteria, and Patescibacteria compared to the other systems and the genera Adhaeribacter, Arthrobacter, Rubellimicrobium, and Ramlibacter, related to C and N functions. D-S soil was also related to the highest relative abundances of Pseudoarthrobacter and Haliangium, associated with the plant growth-promoting effect, antifungal activity, and a potential P solubilizer. A potentially increase of C fixation and N fixation in soils was also observed in the D-S cropping system. These positive changes were related to the cessation of tillage and the development of a spontaneous cover crop, which increased soil protection. Thus, management practices that contribute to increasing soil cover should be encouraged to improve soil functionality.

Microbiome contributes to phenotypic plasticity in saffron crocus

Saffron crocus is a sterile plant species that propagates vegetatively, and consequently, narrow genetic variation is detected in this species. Besides the narrow genetic variation, there is significant phenotypic variation in different traits in this plant. Here we tested this hypothesis that plant microbiome is a major contributor to the phenotypic variation. We focused our analysis on culturable bacteria that were dominant in saffron fields with high stigma yield compared to the fields with low stigma yield. Following this strategy, four rhizospheric (Cupriavidus metallidurans, Bacillus sp., Solibacillus sp., and Planococcus sp.) and two endophytic bacteria (Serratia oryzae and S. odorifera) were identified. The effects of the bacteria on the growth and development of the model plant Arabidopsis were assessed both in agar plate and pot assays. Results showed that these bacteria influence the vegetative growth and flowering time of Arabidopsis. In the next step, corms of saffron were inoculated with these bacteria and the growth and development of the saffron plants were monitored for five months. Remarkably, inoculation of the bacteria had significant influence on vegetative growth, flowering time, and stigma yield of saffron crocus. Furthermore, one of the bacteria, C. metallidurans, is reported here for the first time as a naturally occurring plant-associated bacteria. Altogether our results suggest that plant microbiome is an important factor in phenotypic variation in saffron crocus.

Diversity of Rhizo-Bacteriome of Crocus sativus Grown at Various Geographical Locations and Cataloging of Putative PGPRs

Earlier plant growth promoting rhizo-bacteria (PGPRs) were isolated from the plants, by cultivation based techniques and the interaction was mostly thought to be bilateral. The routine bilateral study, with no information on the associated microbiome, could be one of the reasons for the limited success of PGPRs in the field conditions. Keeping in view the role of PGPRs in rhizo-bacteriome on the growth and production of plant, the present study was aimed at studying the diversity of the rhizo-bacteriome of saffron grown across three geographical locations namely Kashmir, Kishtwar and Bengaluru. Variation in the rhizo-bacteriome of saffron growing across 10 different sites from 3 geographical locations was studied using 16S rDNA amplicon metagenomic sequencing. 16 bacterial phyla, 261 genera and 73 bacterial species were cataloged from all the rhizosphere samples. Proteobacteria was a dominant phylum in all the rhizosphere samples. Rhizo-bacteriome of saffron grown in Kishtwar was found to be significantly different from the rhizo-bacteriome of saffron grown in Kashmir and Bengaluru. Interestingly, the rhizo-bacteriome of saffron grown in Bengaluru was very similar to the saffron grown in Kashmir, thereby indicating that the rhizo-bacteriome in saffron is “plant driven” as the corm sown in Bengaluru were from Kashmir. Despite variation in rhizo-bacteriome, core rhizo-bacteriome in saffron was identified that was represented by 53 genera and eight bacterial species belonging to 11 phyla irrespective of their geographical distribution. In addition, 21 PGPRs were reported for the first time from the saffron rhizosphere. The high yielding saffron field Wuyan was found to have the highest number of PGPRs; this indicates that the presence of PGPR is important for yield enhancement than diversity. The two PGPR Rhizobium leguminosarum and Luteibacter rhizovicinus were reported from all the locations except Kishtwar that had escaped isolation in our previous attempts using cultivation based techniques. It is being proposed instead of going for random isolation and screening for PGPRs from plant rhizosphere, an alternate strategy using metagenomic cataloging of the rhizo-bacteriome community and cultivation of the dominant PGPR should be undertaken. This strategy will help in the selection of dominant PGPRs, specific to the plant in question.

Microbiome Fingerprint as Biomarker for Geographical Origin and Heredity in Crocus sativus: A Feasibility Study

Host–microbiome interactions are specific and not random, making them defining entities for the host. The hypothesis proposed by various researchers earlier, that both plants and animals harbor specific inheritable core microbiome, is being augmented in the present study. Additionally, a case for using microbial fingerprint as a biomarker, not only for plant identification but also as a geographical indicator, has been investigated, taking Crocus sativus, saffron, as a study material. Crocus sativus, a monogenetic herb, on account of its male sterility and vegetative propagation, is reported to lack genome based molecular markers. Cormosphere microbiome (microbiome associated with corm) has been compared across three geographical locations, in two continents, to identify the core and unique microbiome, during the vegetative phase of its growth. Microbiome analysis done at phylum and genus level, using next generation sequencing technology, revealed that cormosphere at three locations harbored common phyla. At genus level, 24 genera were found common to all three geographical locations, indicating them to be part of the core microbiome of saffron. However, there were some bacterial genera unique to Kashmir, Kishtwar, and Morocco that can be used to develop microbial markers/geographical indicators for saffron grown in these regions. This is a preliminary study, indicating that the location specific bacterial community can be used to develop microbial barcodes but needs further augmentation with high coverage data from other saffron growing geographical regions.

Field evaluation of PGP Bacillus sp. strain D5 native to Crocus sativus, in traditional and non traditional areas, and mining of PGP genes from its genome

Native Bacillus sp. strain D5 coded as (Bar D5) has been isolated from the saffron corm that showed plant growth promotion (PGP) properties and also inhibits the growth of corm rot causing Fusarium oxysporum R1 (Fox R1) in-vitro. Bar D5 was more efficient PGP bacterium in comparison to earlier reported native bio-formulations by our group. Pot assays and field evaluation of Bar D5 confirmed its in-vivo efficacy for PGP traits and biocontrol activity as well. Pot trials were followed by field trials at traditional (Kishtwar) and non-traditional (R.S Pura) saffron cultivation areas in Jammu and Kashmir. At both places, Bar D5 bio-formulation treatment led to the increase in root number & length, shoot number & length, flower number and number & weight of daughter corms. Additionally, it also decreased the corm rot disease incidence significantly. Priming of corms with bio-formulation resulted in the reduction of pathogenic fungal load by three fold at the depth of corm sowing from ground level. The shelf life/viability of Bar D5 based bio-formulation was found to be 52% (viable spores) for one year at room temperature. Draft genome sequence of Bar D5 revealed the presence of genes necessary for PGP and biocontrol activity. Further, confirmation of gene sequences and annotation was done by amplification, re-sequencing and mapping of PGP and biocontrol genes on draft genome. Bar D5 based bio-formulation can be provided to companies/researchers interested in saffron cultivation or bio-formulation production for commercial exploitation, since saffron is grown as revenue crop across continents. The present study bridges the gap between genomics and its field application.

Comparative Metagenomics Reveal Phylum Level Temporal and Spatial Changes in Mycobiome of Belowground Parts of Crocus sativus

Plant-fungal associations have been explored by routine cultivation based approaches and cultivation based approaches cannot catalogue more than 5% of fungal diversity associated with any niche. In the present study, an attempt has been made to catalogue fungal diversity associated with belowground parts i.e. rhizosphere and cormosphere, of Crocus sativus (an economically important herb) during two growth stages, using cultivation independent ITS gene targeted approach, taking bulk soil as reference. The 454 pyrosequencing sequence data analysis suggests that the fungal diversity was niche and growth stage specific. Fungi diversity, in the present case, was not only different between the two organs (roots and corm) but the dominance pattern varies between the cormosphere during two growth stages. Zygomycota was dominant fungal phylum in the rhizosphere whereas Basidiomycota was dominant in cormosphere during flowering stage. However in cormosphere though Basidiomycota was dominant phylum during flowering stage but Zygomycota was dominant during dormant stage. Interestingly, in cormosphere, the phyla which was dominant at dormant stage was rare at flowering stage and vice-versa (Basidiomycota: Flowering = 93.2% Dormant = 0.05% and Zygomycota: Flowering = 0.8% Dormant = 99.7%). At genus level, Rhizopus was dominant in dormant stage but was rare in flowering stage (Rhizopus: Dormant = 99.7% Flowering = 0.55%). This dynamics is not followed by the bulk soil fungi which was dominated by Ascomycota during both stages under study. The genus Fusarium, whose species F. oxysporum causes corm rot in C. sativus, was present during both stages with slightly higher abundance in roots. Interestingly, the abundance of Rhizopus varied a great deal in two stages in cormosphere but the abundance of Fusarium was comparable in two growth stages (Bulk soil Flowering = 0.05%, Rhizosphere Flowering = 1.4%, Cormosphere Flowering = 0.06%, Bulk soil Dormant = 2.47% and cormosphere dormant = 0.05%). This is the first report on the fungal diversity associated with the root of Crocus sativus and first report on the fungi associated with corm of any plant with the temporal and spatial variation in the fungal community structure.