Effect of enveloping and disinfection methods on artefact formation on enveloped PSP plate images

Effect of 3 different disinfection methods on the image quality of photostimulable phosphor plates

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to assess the effects of 3 disinfection protocols on the quality of images acquired with a photostimulable phosphor (PSP) plate system.

STUDY DESIGN

Thirty DIGORA Optime PSP plates were divided into 3 groups of 10. Group 1 was disinfected with 95% ethanol. Group 2 was disinfected using germicidal disposable wipes. Group 3 was disinfected with 95% ethanol, followed by hydrogen peroxide gas sterilization. Images of a quality assurance phantom were acquired on each plate before disinfection (baseline images). Disinfection and imaging cycles were repeated 45 times for each plate. Changes in image quality were assessed between baseline and final images. Image quality was evaluated for dynamic range, spatial resolution, and contrast perceptibility. The Fisher exact test was used to detect statistically significant differences among the 3 disinfection methods relative to decreases in image quality parameters between the baseline and final radiographs. Additionally, for each group, the Z-test was used to detect statistically significant decreases in image quality parameters between baseline and final images. The significance level was established at P < .05.

RESULTS

No statistically significant differences were detected among the disinfection groups or relative to baseline values for any group at a 5% significance level.

CONCLUSIONS

Hydrogen peroxide gas may be considered to prevent cross-contamination while preserving image quality. Regular quality assurance testing is recommended to maintain image quality over time.

Disinfection of intraoral photostimulable phosphor plates with 70% ethyl alcohol and 70% isopropyl alcohol alters image contrast and produces image artifacts

OBJECTIVE

This study evaluated changes in image quality and the presence and size of artifacts on radiographs obtained with photostimulable phosphor (PSP) plates after disinfection with 70% ethyl alcohol and 70% isopropyl alcohol.

STUDY DESIGN

Eight PSP receptors (4 Express and 4 VistaScan) were used for the investigation. Two Express and 2 VistaScan receptors were disinfected with 70% ethyl alcohol, and 2 Express and 2 VistaScan receptors were disinfected with 70% isopropyl alcohol. Before disinfection and after every 5 disinfections, 2 radiographs of an aluminum stepwedge and 2 radiographs of an acrylic block were acquired using each receptor. The gray values of the radiographs were analyzed regarding contrast, density, uniformity, and noise. Four oral radiologists evaluated the images for the presence of artifacts, and 2 measured the artifacts.

RESULTS

Differences in image contrast were significantly larger with isopropyl alcohol (P < .0001). Artifact size was significantly greater with the VistaScan system when isopropyl alcohol was used as the disinfectant (P < .0001). The correlation between the number of disinfections and artifact size was moderately positive with the Express system (P < .05) and strongly positive with the VistaScan system (P < .05) with both disinfectants.

CONCLUSIONS

Small artifacts restricted to the edges of the image were observed with disinfection using both types of alcohol, and a positive correlation was found between artifact size and the number of disinfections. However, artifacts appeared earlier and of greater size with the VistaScan system when disinfected with 70% isopropyl alcohol. Thus, we recommend using 70% ethyl alcohol to disinfect PSP receptors, with attention placed on its action and evaporation times.

Analysis of image defects in digital intraoral radiography based on photostimulable phosphor plates

OBJECTIVES

In digital intraoral radiography (DIR), images with defects caused by the digital process are sometimes produced. Hence, we analyzed DIR images with defects taken using the photostimulable phosphor (PSP) plate method and then classified these images based on the causes of the defect. The aim of this study was to classify defects in DIR using the PSP plate system, and to discuss the causes of each type of defect and the methods that can prevent their occurrence.

METHODS

Images with defects due to the two PSP plate systems (Arcana and Arcana Mira) were selected and classified according to the defect. Image defects caused by geometrical techniques that occur in both the film and PSP plate methods were excluded from this study. Moreover, changes in the rate of occurrence of images with defects over time were analyzed in this study.

RESULTS

The defects in images obtained by the PSP plate system were classified into six types, which were further divided into those caused by machine error or human error. Both types of error could influence the diagnostic performance. Machine error accidentally and rarely occurred; thus, the prevention of such errors is difficult. However, human error, especially errors caused by photo-induced discharge, could be prevented using appropriate measures.

CONCLUSIONS

In DIR systems using the PSP plate method, human error should be prevented by education and training to improve operation.