Dual mass spectrometry as a tool to improve annotation and quantification in targeted plasma lipidomics

Effects of wolfberry (Lycium barbarum) consumption on the human plasma lipidome and its association with cardiovascular disease risk factors: a randomized controlled trial of middle-aged and older adults

Background

Long-term wolfberry intake as part of a healthy dietary pattern was recognized to have beneficial vascular outcomes. Characterization of the plasma lipidome may further provide comprehensive insights into pathways underlying these cardiovascular protective effects.

Objective

We analyzed the plasma lipidome of subjects who adhered to a healthy dietary pattern either with or without wolfberry and investigated the associations between the plasma lipidomic profile and cardiovascular health-related indicators.

Methods

In this 16-week, parallel design, randomized controlled trial, middle-aged and older adults (n = 41) were provided dietary counseling and assigned to either consume or not consume 15 g of wolfberry daily. At baseline and post-intervention, plasma lipidomics was assayed, and its relationships with classical CVD risk factors, vascular health, oxidant burden, carotenoids status, body composition, and anthropometry were examined.

Results

From the plasma lipidome, 427 lipid species from 26 sub-classes were quantified. In the wolfberry and control groups, significant changes were prominent for 27 and 42 lipid species, respectively (P < 0.05 with > 0.2-fold change). Fold changes for seven lipid species were also markedly different between the two groups. Examining the relationships between the plasma lipidome and CVD-related risk factors, total cholesterol revealed a marked positive correlation with 13 ceramide species, while HDL-cholesterol which was notably increased with wolfberry consumption showed a positive correlation with 10 phosphatidylcholine species. Oxidant burden, as represented by plasma 8-isoprostanes, was also inversely associated with lipidomic triglycerides and ether-triglycerides (41 species) and directly associated with hexosylceramides (eight species) and sphingomyelins (six species). There were no differential associations with CVD risk detected between groups.

Conclusion

Characteristic alterations to the plasma lipidome were observed with healthy dietary pattern adherence and wolfberry consumption. An examination of these fluctuations suggests potential biochemical mechanisms that may mediate the antioxidant and cardiovascular protective effects of healthy dietary pattern adherence and wolfberry intake. This study was registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT0353584.

The state of the art in plant lipidomics

Lipids are a group of compounds with diverse structures that perform several important functions in plants. To unravel and better understand their in vivo functions, plant biologists have been using various lipidomic technologies including liquid-chromatography (LC)-mass spectrometry (MS). However, there are still significant challenges in LC-MS based plant lipidomics, which need to be addressed. In this review, we provide an overview of the key developments in LC-MS based lipidomic approaches to detect and identify plant lipids with emphasis on areas that can be further improved. Given that the cellular lipidome is estimated to contain hundreds of thousands of lipids,^1,2 many of the lipid structures remain to be discovered. Furthermore, the plant lipidome is considered to be significantly more complex compared to that of mammals. Recent technical developments in mass spectrometry have made the detection of novel lipids possible; hence, approaches that can be used for plant lipid discovery are also discussed.

An improved strategy for analysis of lipid molecules utilising a reversed phase C30 UHPLC column and scheduled MS/MS acquisition

Measuring physiochemically diverse molecules (including lipids) which vary significantly in their concentrations poses a great analytical challenge. In untargeted lipidomics studies, reversed phase chromatography coupled with data-dependent MS/MS acquisition (DDA) is frequently applied. The optimal assay should deliver a high number of detected compounds with associated fragmentation data. In this work, we introduce novel 30 and 50 min UHPLC assays utilising lipid separation on a C30 stationary phase with a modified DDA strategy using smaller precursor m/z ranges scheduled for different lipid classes across the retention time range (defined as scheduled MS/MS). To evaluate the efficiency of the novel assays, mammalian tissue extracts (lamb liver, kidney and heart) were analysed and data were compared to a 15 min reversed phase C18 assay with multiple traditional DDA injections. The 30 min C30 assay detected double the number of detected compounds compared to the 15 min C18 assay. Applying the scheduled MS/MS DDA strategy with a single injection, a similar number of annotated lipids were reported compared to the traditional DDA strategy applied with five replicate injections on a C18 column. A longer 50 min C30 chromatographic assay did not result in an expected improvement in the chromatographic separation of overlapping isomer peaks compared to the 30 min method but did result in loss of accuracy of peak picking algorithms. We recommend the 30 min C30 assay with scheduled MS/MS acquisition as an efficient tool to analyse complex biological matrices and to annotate lipid species based on MS/MS data.