Recycling, reuse, and circular economy: a challenge for ecotoxicological research

Ecotoxicological response surface analysis of salt and pH in textile effluent on Bacillus subtilis and Lactuca sativa

Textile effluents, although their composition can vary considerably, typically contain high levels of dissolved salts and exhibit wide variations in pH. Ecotoxicological studies regarding the effects of these parameters, however, have been limited owing to the need for sensitive and easy-to-handle bioindicators that require low amounts of sampling, are cost-effective, time-efficient, and ethically endorsed. This kind of study, additionally, demands robust multi-factorial statistical designs that can accurately characterize the individual and combined relationship between variables. In this research, Response Surface Methodology (RSM) was used to calculate the individual and interaction effects of NaCl concentration and pH value of a Simulated Textile Effluent (STE) on the development rate (DR) of the bioindicators: Bacillus subtilis bacteria and Lactuca sativa lettuce. The results demonstrated that the bioindicators were sensitive to both NaCl and pH factors, where the relative sensitivity relationship was B. subtilis > L. sativa. The quadratic equations generated in the experiments indicated that increased concentrations of 50-250 mg L-1 of NaCl caused a perturbance of 1.40%-34.40% on the DR of B. subtilis and 0.50%-12.30% on L. sativa. The pH factor at values of 3-11 caused an alteration of 27.00%-64.78% on the DR of the B. subtilis and 51.37%-37.37% on the L. sativa. These findings suggest that the selected bioindicators could serve as effective tools to assess the ecotoxicological effects of textile effluents on different ecological systems, and the RSM was an excellent tool to consider the ecotoxicological effects of the parameters and to describe the behavior of the results. In conclusion, the NaCl and pH factors may be responsible for disrupting different ecosystems, causing imbalances in their biodiversity and biomass. Before discharge or reuse, it is suggested to remove salts and neutralize pH from textile effluents and, mostly, develop novel, eco-friendlier textile processing techniques.

Measuring circularity of a manufacturing organization by using sustainable balanced scorecard

In recent years, circular economy has become a matter of great importance because of its ability to contribute toward economic, environmental, and social aspects of the sustainability. The circular economy approaches help in resource conservation by reducing, reusing, and recycling products/parts/components/materials. On the other hand, Industry 4.0 is coupled with emerging technologies, which support the firms in efficient resource utilization. These innovative technologies can transform the present manufacturing organizations by reducing resource extraction, CO2 emissions, environmental damage, and power consumption and improve it into a more sustainable manufacturing organization. Industry 4.0 along with circular economy concepts greatly improves the circularity performance. However, there is no framework found for measuring the circularity performance of the firm. Therefore, the current study aims to develop a framework for measuring performance in terms of circularity percentage. In this work, graph theory and matrix approach are employed for measuring the performance based on a sustainable balanced scorecard such as internal process, learning and growth, customer and financial with environmental and social perspectives. A case of an Indian barrel manufacturing organization is discussed for the illustration of proposed methodology. Based on "circularity index" of the organization and the maximum possible circularity index, the circularity was found to be 5.10%. It indicates that there is a huge potential for the improvement in the circularity of the organization. An in-depth sensitivity analysis and comparison are also performed to validate the findings. There are very few studies on measuring the circularity. The study developed the approach for measuring circularity, which may be utilized by industrialists and practitioners for improving the circularity.

An urgent call for circular economy advocates to acknowledge its limitations in conserving biodiversity

This discussion paper explores the relationship between biodiversity and the circular economy and the potential implications of this relationship. The circular economy has emerged as an alternative model to a traditional linear economy. It aims to tackle the resource exploitation that accompanies a linear economy and decouple economic growth from reliance on primary resources. In the face of global environmental degradation and an urgent need for change, the concept has become popular around the world and has led to the release of national policies and strategies on the circular economy. Problematically, while the basic concept is clear, it is ambiguous in how it will achieve some of its objectives, and it fails to address some key issues. In light of the accelerating rate of change, precipitous biodiversity decline is one such key issue. Through a content analysis of relevant circular economy publications, authors demonstrate that biodiversity protection is rarely mentioned in theory and policy. While the circular economy holds many benefits for society, its evasion of scrutiny has prevented it from manifesting in a comprehensive solution to environmental issues. The circular economy advocates for biomimicry, ecosystem service valuation, bioeconomy, and renewable energy. Each of these, however, has its own set of conflicts with biodiversity protection. Given the imminent need to protect biodiversity, the authors call for further research on the interaction between biodiversity and the circular economy, and for circular economy advocates to explicitly acknowledge the concept's limitations, thereby revealing the need for intersectional and complementary policies which aim to protect biodiversity.

Assessing enablers of e-waste management in circular economy using DEMATEL method: An Indian perspective

With increasing population, excessive use of electrical and electronic products and extreme demand of resources have compelled the linear economy to transform into Circular Economy (CE). In the current scenario, e-waste management has become the top priority of all the developed and developing nations especially those in the transition phase. The generation of e-waste has increased proportionally across the world and created an intense pressure on the firms to implement sustainable practices to redesign and recycle the products. The current status of the developing countries like India confronts number of challenges to manage e-waste produced, and the only possible solution is to minimize the waste generation and practicing recycling processes. For transforming into CEs, there is a need to identify the most influencing key enablers through which an effective and robust e-waste management (e-WM) system can be developed. An extensive literature review and expert judgments are expended to identify the most influencing key enablers of e-WM in circular economies, and, being the highest producer of e-waste, Mumbai (Maharashtra) has been chosen as the case location. To explore the strength of causal and effect enablers, the DEMATEL method is applied. This study has shown that 'Environmental management system' (EMS) is the most significant and important driving enabler to influence all the other existing enablers. This study has also highlighted that e-WM can be efficient if it focuses on producing eco-friendly products, developing strict legislations, building green image and supporting the producers to implement CE practices. This study helps stakeholders and policy makers to reduce the burden from the environment and focus on developing an efficient e-WM system on the basis of identified key enablers like EMS and collaboration with environmental partners to contribute towards CE transition.