Corrosion of the Head-Stem Taper Junction-Are We on the Verge of an Epidemic?: Review Article

Taper wear in total joint arthroplasty can be reliably assessed with various coordinate measuring systems

In total joint arthroplasty, wear and corrosion at modular taper junctions is an issue with clinical implications, as ions and wear debris can lead to adverse tissue reactions. The quantification of the generated wear is, therefore, an important measure to judge the performance of such modular junctions. This applies to pre-clinical in vitro investigations as well as to retrospective investigations of retrieved implants. The volume of the worn material can be determined with coordinate measuring machines (CMMs), which can generally be classified as tactile and optical systems. The study aims on the comparison of a tactile with two optical CMM systems for the determination of taper wear. To do so, four taper samples-three trunnions and one bore taper-with different amounts of known volumetric wear (range 1.5 mm3 to 8.3 mm3) were fabricated. Wear volume, linear deviation and taper angle were determined with the different CMM systems. The tactile system yielded the highest deviation from the gravimetric reference values of about 0.3 mm3, while the optical systems exhibited deviations of about 0.1 mm3 and 0.2 mm3. Clinically relevant taper wear, however, is well measurable with all investigated systems.

Effect of Femoral Head Material, Surgeon Experience, and Assembly Technique on Simulated Head-Neck Total Hip Arthroplasty Impaction Forces

BACKGROUND

There is no standard method for assembling the femoral head onto the femoral stem during total hip arthroplasty (THA). This study aimed to measure and record dynamic 3-dimensional (3D) THA head-neck assembly loads from residents, fellows, and attending surgeons, for metal and ceramic femoral heads.

METHODS

An instrumented apparatus measured dynamic 3D forces applied through the femoral stem taper in vitro for 31 surgeons (11 attendings, 14 residents, 6 fellows) using their preferred technique (ie, number of hits or mallet strikes). Outcome variables included peak axial force, peak resultant force, impulse of the resultant force, loading rate of the resultant force, and off-axis angle. They were compared between femoral head material, surgeon experience level, and the number of hits per trial.

RESULTS

Average peak axial force was 6.92 ± 2.11kN for all surgeons. No significant differences were found between femoral head material. Attendings applied forces more "on-axis" as compared to both residents and fellows. Nine surgeons assembled the head with 1 hit, 3 with 2 hits, 14 with 3 hits, 2 with 4 hits, and 3 with ≥5 hits. The first hit of multihit trials was significantly lower than single-hit trials for all outcome measures except the off-axis angle. The last hit of multihit trials had a significantly lower impulse of resultant force than single-hit trials.

CONCLUSION

Differences in applied 3D force-time curve dynamic characteristics were found between surgeon experience level and single and multihit trials. No significant differences were found between femoral head material.

[Strength of the taper junction of modular revision hip stems : The influence of contamination of the taper junction and the joining condition on the relative motion and pull-off force between the stem and neck part of the MRP prosthesis]

INTRODUCTION

In revision surgery, modular implant components allow the surgeon to tailor the characteristics of the implant to the bone situation. Relative motion can occur at the tapered modular connection, leading to fretting corrosion and subsequent biological reactions, particularly due to poor assembly and contamination of the tapered connection. The aim of this study was to demonstrate whether incomplete assembly and inadvertent contamination of the modular taper causes a change in junction strength.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Modular taper junctions between the neck and the stem (n = 48) were divided into seven groups that differed with respect to contamination (native, contaminated, cleaned) and assembly conditions (secured, pre-tensioned and secured). Contamination was achieved by a combination of porcine bone particles and bovine blood. For each group, the number of rotations of the torque limiter while securing the conical connection was recorded. The implants were subjected to cyclic loading. DIC was used to determine neck rotation, micromotion and axial subsidence. Loosening torque of the locking screw and pull-off forces were measured as an equivalent of residual taper junction strength.

RESULTS

Contamination of the taper junction, especially in combination with improper assembly of the components, significantly increased the rotation (35.3 ± 13.7° vs. 2.4 ± 4.4°; p <0.001), micromotion (67.8 ± 16.9 μm vs. 5.1 ± 12.1 μm, p <0.001) and axial subsidence (‑34.1 ± 16.9 μm vs. 4.3 ± 10.9 μm; p <0.001) of the neck relative to the stem.

CONCLUSION

Intra-operatively, contamination of the taper surface can be identified by the need for multiple turns when tightening the locking screw. Correct cleaning with the new taper cleaning instrument and complete assembly with pre-tensioning may reduce the risk of early failure and fatigue fracture of the modular taper connection.

Can severity of trunnion damage be estimated by visual inspection alone?

Taper corrosion has been widely reported to be problematic for modular total hip arthroplasty implants. A simple and systematic method to evaluate taper damage with sufficient resolution is needed. We introduce a semiquantitative grading system for modular femoral tapers to characterize taper corrosion damage. After examining a unique collection of retrieved cobalt-chromium (CoCr) taper sleeves (n = 465) using the widely-used Goldberg system, we developed an expanded six-point visual grading system intended to characterize the severity, visible material loss, and absence of direct component contact due to corrosion. Female taper sleeve damage was evaluated by three blinded observers using the Goldberg scoring system and the expanded system. A subset (n = 85) was then re-evaluated following destructive cleaning, using both scoring systems. Material loss for this subset was quantified using metrology and correlated with both scoring systems. There was substantial agreement in grading among all three observers with uncleaned (n = 465) and with the subset of cleaned (n = 85) implants. The expanded scoring criteria provided a wider distribution of scores which ultimately correlated well with corrosion material loss. Cleaning changed the average scores marginally using the Goldberg criteria (p = 0.290); however, using the VGS, approximately 40% of the scores for all observers changed, increasing the average score from 4.24 to 4.35 (p = 0.002). There was a strong correlation between measured material loss and new grading scores. The expanded scoring criteria provided a wider distribution of scores which ultimately correlated well with corrosion material loss. This system provides potential advantages for assessing taper damage without requiring specialized imaging devices.

Interaction of surface topography and taper mismatch on head-stem modular junction contact mechanics during assembly in modern total hip replacement

Implant failure due to fretting corrosion at the head-stem modular junction is an increasing problem in modular total hip arthroplasty. The effect of varying microgroove topography on modular junction contact mechanics has not been well characterized. The aim of this study was to employ a novel, microgrooved finite element (FEA) model of the hip taper interface and assess the role of microgroove geometry and taper mismatch angle on the modular junction mechanics during assembly. A two-dimensional, axisymmetric FEA model was created using a modern 12/14 taper design of a CoCrMo femoral head taper and Ti6Al4V stem taper. Microgrooves were modeled at the contacting interface of the tapers and varied based on height and spacing measurements obtained from a repository of measured retrievals. Additionally, taper angular mismatch between the head and stem was varied to simulate proximal- and distal-locked engagement. Forty simulations were conducted to parametrically evaluate the effects of microgroove surface topography and angular mismatch on predicted contact area, contact pressure, and equivalent plastic strain. Multiple linear regression analysis was highly significant (p < 0.001; R2  > 0.74) for all outcome variables. The regression analysis identified microgroove geometry on the head taper to have the greatest influence on modular junction contact mechanics. Additionally, there was a significant second order relationship between both peak contact pressure (p < 0.001) and plastic strain (p < 0.001) with taper mismatch angle. These modeling techniques will be used to identify the implant parameters that maximize taper interference strength via large in-silico parametric studies.

Explant analysis and implant registries are both needed to further improve patient safety

In the early days of total joint replacement, implant fracture, material problems and wear presented major problems for the long-term success of the operation.

Today, failures directly related to the implant comprise only 2–3% of the reasons for revision surgeries, which is a result of the material and design improvements in combination with the standardization of pre-clinical testing methods and the post-market surveillance required by the legal regulation.

Arthroplasty registers are very effective tools to document the long-term clinical performance of implants and implantation techniques such as fixation methods in combination with patient characteristics.

Revisions due to implant failure are initially not reflected by the registries due to their small number.

Explant analysis including patient, clinical and imaging documentation is crucial to identify failure mechanisms early enough to prevent massive failures detectable in the registries.

In the past, early reaction was not always successful, since explant analysis studies have either been performed late or the results did not trigger preventive measures until clinical failures affected a substantial number of patients.

The identification of implant-related problems is only possible if all failures are reported and related to the number of implantations.

A system that analyses all explants from revisions attributed to implant failure is mandatory to reduce failures, allowing improvement of risk assessment in the regulatory process.

Importance of surgical assembly technique on the engagement of 12/14 modular tapers

Fretting-corrosion at the modular taper junction in total hip replacements (THR), leading to implant failure, has been identified as a clinical concern and has received increased interest in recent years. There are many parameters thought to affect the performance of the taper junction, with the assembly process being one of the few consistently identified to have a direct impact. Despite this, the assembly process used by surgeons during THR surgery differs from a suggested 'ideal' process. For example, taper junctions of cutting tools should be pushed together rather than impacted, while ensuring as much concentricity as possible between the male and female taper and loading axis. This study devised six simple assembly methodologies to investigate how surgical variations affect the success of the compressive fit achieved at the taper interface compared to a controlled assembly method, designed to represent a more 'ideal' scenario. Key findings from this study suggest that a more successful and repeatable engagement can be achieved by quasi-statically loading the male and female taper concentrically with the loading axis. This was shown by a greater disassembly to assembly force ratio of 0.626 ± 0.07 when assembled using the more 'ideal' process, compared to 0.480 ± 0.05 when using a method closer to that used by a surgeon intraoperatively. Findings from this study can be used to help inform new surgical instrumentation and an improved surgical assembly method.

Outcomes Following Revision for Mechanically Assisted Crevice Corrosion in a Single Femoral Design

BACKGROUND

Mechanically assisted crevice corrosion (MACC) is a described complication following metal-on-polyethylene (MoP) total hip arthroplasty (THA). The literature regarding outcomes following revision for MACC suggests that complication rates are high. The purpose of this investigation is to add to this literature with the largest reported series to date.

METHODS

This is a retrospective cohort study of 552 consecutive patients who underwent 621 MoP primary THAs. We identified patients who subsequently underwent revision THA for a diagnosis of MACC. All patients were implanted with the same implant combination (Accolade I stem/cobalt-chromium low friction ion treatment femoral head). Patient demographic, surgical, and laboratory data were collected. Follow-up was calculated from the revision surgery and Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score Joint Replacement and hip subjective values (HSV) were examined at final follow-up. Descriptive statistics were performed.

RESULTS

The revision rate for MACC was 11.6% and mean time to revision was 6.6 (±2.4) years. Revised patients (n = 69) had a mean preoperative serum cobalt-chromium ratio of 3.5 (±2.4). There were 8 cases of gross trunnion failure. At mean 3.2 (±1.9) years following revision, the overall major complication rate was 11.6% with a 5.8% reoperation rate. At final follow-up, mean Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score Joint Replacement scores were 83.2 (±15.6) and mean hip subjective value was 77.6 (±17.4). Revision resulted in significant increases in both parameters (P < .001).

CONCLUSION

The incidence of MACC in MoP THA is likely higher than previously reported, particularly for certain implant combinations. Revision surgery for MACC can achieve good outcomes but a high clinical suspicion with early detection and revision is likely key to success.

Experimental validation of the abrasive wear stage of the gross taper failure mechanism in total hip arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Gross taper failure (GTF) is a rare but catastrophic failure mode of the head-stem-taper junction of hip prostheses, facilitated by massive material loss. GTF is a two stage process initiated by corrosion leading to head bottoming out, followed by abrasive wear due to the head rotating on the stem. The purpose of this study was to reproduce the clinical failure patterns and to determine the material loss during simulated gait.

METHODS

Six cobalt-chromium alloy heads (36 mm, 12/14 taper) with three different head lengths (short / medium / extra long) were combined with stem taper replicas made from titanium alloy sized to achieve bottoming out. A hip simulator was used to simulate gait loading after (ISO 14242-1 for 2 million cycles).

RESULTS

Wear patterns from in-vitro testing match the clinical failure patterns. Stem taper wear increased linearly with time (p< 0.001). After two million cycles the material loss of short / medium / extra long heads was (M+-STD) 1168±242 mg / 400±23 mg / 94±12 mg on the stem side and 46±36 mg / 46±24 mg / 70±8 mg on the head side. Stem taper wear decreased with increasing head length (p=0.01), whereas clinical failures are mostly seen for long and extra long heads.

Assessing Taper Geometry, Head Size, Head Material, and Their Interactions in Taper Fretting Corrosion of Retrieved Total Hip Arthroplasty Implants

BACKGROUND

Decreased fretting and corrosion damage at the taper interface of retrieved ceramic-on-polyethylene total hip arthroplasty (THA) implants has been consistently reported; however, resultant fretting corrosion as a function of femoral head size and taper geometry has not been definitively explained.

METHODS

Eight cohorts were defined from 157 retrieved THA implants based on femoral head composition (n = 95, zirconia-toughened alumina, ZTA vs n = 62, cobalt-chromium alloy, CoCr), head size (n = 56, 32mm vs n = 101, 36mm), and taper geometry (n = 84, 12/14 vs n = 73, V40). THA implants were evaluated and graded for taper fretting and corrosion. Data were statistically analyzed, including via a 2³ factorial modeling.

RESULTS

Factorial-based analysis indicated the significant factors related to both resultant (summed) fretting and corrosion damage were head material and taper geometry; head material-taper geometry interaction was also a significant factor in resultant corrosion damage. Lower rates of moderate-to-severe fretting and corrosion damage were exhibited on ZTA heads (ZTA = 13%, CoCr = 38%), smaller heads (32mm = 18%, 36mm = 26%), and 12/14 tapers (12/14 = 13%, V40 = 35%). ZTA+32mm heads demonstrated the lowest rates of moderate-to-severe fretting and corrosion damage (12/14 = 2%, V40 = 7%), whereas CoCr heads with V40 tapers demonstrated the greatest rates of moderate-to-severe damage (32mm = 47%, 36mm = 59%).

CONCLUSION

In this series, retrieved implants with ZTA, 32-mm heads paired with 12/14 tapers exhibited lower rates of moderate-to-severe damage. Factorial analysis showed head material, taper geometry, and their interactions were the most significant factors associated with resultant damage grades. Isolating implant features may provide additional information regarding factors leading to fretting and corrosion damage in THA.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV (case series).

Nontribological corrosion modes dominate wrought CoCrMo acetabular taper corrosion: A retrieval study

Corrosion of modular metal-on-metal acetabular tapers in total hip arthroplasty (THA) systems is often attributed to mechanically driven processes. Recent findings suggest that mechanically assisted crevice corrosion (MACC) might not be the dominant cause of corrosion in shell-liner tapers. This study aims to document and present the corrosion modes observed in metal-metal acetabular liners. Twenty-one retrieved wrought CoCrMo liners were examined using digital optical microscopy (DOM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDS). Corrosion-related damage was documented in nonengagement taper regions, outside of direct taper contact. Within engagement regions, nonmechanically driven corrosion features (pitting, intergranular corrosion) were observed adjacent to fretting and material transfer, which rely on mechanical contact; corrosion independent of MACC was observed even in contact regions. Corrosion types observed included intergranular corrosion (IGC), pitting attack, phase boundary dissolution, all both outside and inside of taper junctions, and MACC within contact regions of the taper. Typical fretting scars associated with MACC were mostly absent, and were not always associated with corrosion damage where present. Finally, hard phase particles (Mo-Si-O) released from the wrought CoCrMo microstructure had redeposited within regions with material loss. Acetabular taper corrosion modes differ significantly from those in head-neck tapers and are dominated by electrochemically driven processes, not mechanical processes, as indicated by corrosion in noncontact regions. With greater prevalence of dual mobility hip implants, acetabular taper corrosion processes must be understood in order to limit their impact on device performance.

Quantification of assembly forces during creation of head-neck taper junction considering soft tissue bearing: a biomechanical study

Background

All current total hip arthroplasty (THA) systems are modular in design. Only during the operation femoral head and stem get connected by a Morse taper junction. The junction is realized by hammer blows from the surgeon. Decisive for the junction strength is the maximum force acting once in the direction of the neck axis, which is mainly influenced by the applied impulse and surrounding soft tissues. This leads to large differences in assembly forces between the surgeries. This study aimed to quantify the assembly forces of different surgeons under influence of surrounding soft tissue.

Methods

First, a measuring system, consisting of a prosthesis and a hammer, was developed. Both components are equipped with a piezoelectric force sensor. Initially, in situ experiments on human cadavers were carried out using this system in order to determine the actual assembly forces and to characterize the influence of human soft tissues. Afterwards, an in vitro model in the form of an artificial femur (Sawbones Europe AB, Malmo, Sweden) with implanted measuring stem embedded in gelatine was developed. The gelatine mixture was chosen in such a way that assembly forces applied to the model corresponded to those in situ. A study involving 31 surgeons was carried out on the aforementioned in vitro model, in which the assembly forces were determined.

Results

A model was developed, with the influence of human soft tissues being taken into account. The assembly forces measured on the in vitro model were, on average, 2037.2 N ± 724.9 N, ranging from 822.5 N to 3835.2 N. The comparison among the surgeons showed no significant differences in sex (P = 0.09), work experience (P = 0.71) and number of THAs performed per year (P = 0.69).

Conclusions

All measured assembly forces were below 4 kN, which is recommended in the literature. This could lead to increased corrosion following fretting in the head-neck interface. In addition, there was a very wide range of assembly forces among the surgeons, although other influencing factors such as different implant sizes or materials were not taken into account. To ensure optimal assembly force, the impaction should be standardized, e.g., by using an appropriate surgical instrument.

Pseudotumors in Total Joint Arthroplasty

»

The true incidence of pseudotumors in association with total joint arthroplasty is underestimated.

»

Pseudotumors occur with metal-on-metal, metal-on-polyethylene, and metal-on-ceramic articulations.

»

Metal ion levels should not be the only factor in decision-making regarding revision surgery.

»

Revision surgery is only indicated in symptomatic patients with clinical and radiographic findings and elevated metal ion levels.

»

Revision to a non-metal articulation is strongly suggested.

Polyethylene Wear With Ceramic and Metal Femoral Heads at 5 Years: A Randomized Controlled Trial With Radiostereometric Analysis

BACKGROUND

A common bearing combination in total hip arthroplasty today is a metal femoral head articulating with polyethylene in the cup. Ceramic heads are thought to be more resistant to third-body damage, and have better wettability and decreased surface roughness, which taken together have been suggested to result in less polyethylene wear. The purpose of this study is to compare the initial creep deformation and follow wear pattern, using radiostereometric analysis, of ceramic and metal femoral heads that articulate with a modern highly cross-linked polyethylene cup liner.

METHODS

Fifty patients with primary osteoarthritis and scheduled for an uncemented total hip arthroplasty were randomized 1:1 to either a ceramic (BIOLOX delta) or a metal (CoCr) femoral head. The patients were followed up for 5 years with repeated radiostereometric analysis examinations (postoperatively, then at 14 days, 3, 12, 24, and 60 months), as well as a hip-specific outcome questionnaire.

RESULTS

During the first 3 months both groups showed expected creep within the liner of 0.12 mm (standard deviation 0.03) for the ceramic and 0.08 mm (standard deviation 0.02) for the metal heads. Between 3 months and 5 years there was very little wear of the liner in either group, corresponding to 0.003 mm/y for ceramic and 0.007 mm/y for metal heads. There was no difference in cup migration or clinical outcome between the groups and no cups were revised.

CONCLUSION

With the introduction of modern highly cross-linked polyethylene, the ceramic head demonstrates no superiority when it comes to either early deformation or polyethylene wear compared with the metal head.

Geometric Variations of Modular Head-Stem Taper Junctions of Total Hip Replacements

Taper degradation in Total Hip Replacements (THR) has been identified as a clinical concern, and the degradation occurring at these interfaces has received increased interest in recent years. Wear and corrosion products produced at the taper junction are associated with adverse local tissue responses, leading to early failure and revision surgery. Retrieval and in-vitro studies have found that variations in taper design affect degradation. However, there is a lack of consistent understanding within the literature of what makes a good taper interface. Previous studies assessed different design variations using their global parameters assuming a perfect cone such as: taper length, cone angle and diameters. This study assessed geometrical variations of as-manufactured head and stem tapers and any local deviations from their geometry. The purpose of this study was to provide a greater insight into possible engagement, a key performance influencing parameter predicted by Morse taper connection theory. This was achieved by taking measurements of twelve different commercially available male tapers and six female tapers using a coordinate measurement machine (CMM). The results suggested that engagement is specific to a particular head-stem couple. This is subject to both their micro-scale deviations, superimposed on their macro-scale differences. Differences in cone angles between female and male tapers from the same manufacturer was found to create a predominately proximal contact. However, distally mismatched couples are present in some metal-on-metal head-stem couples. On a local scale, different deviation patterns were observed from the geometry which appeared to be linked to the manufacturing process. Future work will look at using this measurement methodology to fully characterise an optimal modular taper junction for a THR prosthesis.

Do SiNx coatings bear the potential to reduce the risk of micromotion in modular taper junctions?

Fretting corrosion is one contributor to the clinical failure of modular joint arthroplasty. It is initiated by micromotion in metal junctions exposed to fluids. Omitting metal-on-metal contacts could help to reduce the corrosion risk. The coating of one metal taper partner with a ceramic-based silicon nitride (SiNx) coating might provide this separation. The aim of the study was to identify whether a SiNx coating of the male taper component influences the micromotion within a taper junction. Hip prosthesis heads made of CoCr29Mo6 (Aesculap) and Ti6Al4V (Peter Brehm) were assembled (2000 N) to SiNx-coated and uncoated stem tapers made of Ti6Al4V and CoCr29Mo6 (2×2×2 combinations, each n = 4). Consecutive sinusoidal loading representing three daily activities was applied. Contactless relative motion in six degrees of freedom was measured using six eddy-current sensors. Micromotion in the junction was determined by compensating for the elastic deformation derived from additional monoblock measurements. After pull-off, the taper surfaces were microscopically inspected. Micromotion magnitude reached up to 8.4 ± 0.8 µm during loading that represented stumbling. Ti6Al4V stems showed significantly higher micromotion than those made of CoCr29Mo6, while taper coating had no influence. Statistical differences in pull-off forces were found for none of the taper junctions. Microscopy revealed CoCr29Mo6 abrasion from the head taper surface if combined with coated stem tapers. Higher micromotion of Ti6Al4V tapers was probably caused by the lower Young's modulus. Even in the contact areas, the coating was not damaged during loading. The mechanics of coated tapers was similar to uncoated prostheses. Thus, the separation of the two metal surfaces with the objective to reduce in vivo corrosion appears to be achievable if the coating is able to withstand in vivo conditions. However, the hard ceramic-based stem coating lead to undesirable debris from the CoCr29Mo6 heads during loading.

Mechanical failure of 113 uncemented modular revision femoral components

Aims

We evaluated a large database with mechanical failure of a single uncemented modular femoral component, used in revision hip arthroplasty, as the end point and compared them to a control group treated with the same implant. Patient- and implant-specific risk factors for implant failure were analyzed.

Methods

All cases of a fractured uncemented modular revision femoral component from one manufacturer until April 2017 were identified and the total number of implants sold until April 2017 was used to calculate the fracture rate. The manufacturer provided data on patient demographics, time to failure, and implant details for all notified fractured devices. Patient- and implant-specific risk factors were evaluated using a logistic regression model with multiple imputations and compared to data from a previously published reference group, where no fractures had been observed. The results of a retrieval analysis of the fractured implants, performed by the manufacturer, were available for evaluation.

Results

There were 113 recorded cases with fracture at the modular junction, resulting in a calculated fracture rate of 0.30% (113/37,600). The fracture rate of the implant without signs of improper use was 0.11% (41/37,600). In 79% (89/113) of cases with a failed implant, either a lateralized (high offset) neck segment, an extralong head, or the combination of both were used. Logistic regression analysis revealed male sex, high body mass index (BMI), straight component design, and small neck segments were significant risk factors for failure. Investigation of the implants (76/113) showed at least one sign of improper use in 72 cases.

Conclusion

Implant failure at the modular junction is associated with patient- and implant-specific risk factors as well as technical errors during implantation. Whenever possible, the use of short and lateralized neck segments should be avoided with this revision system. Implantation instructions and contraindications need to be adhered to and respected. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2020;102-B(5):573–579.

What the Surgeon Can Do to Reduce the Risk of Trunnionosis in Hip Arthroplasty: Recommendations from the Literature

Trunnionosis, defined as wear and corrosion at the head–neck taper connection, is a cause of failure in hip arthroplasty. Trunnionosis is linked to a synergistic combination of factors related to the prosthesis, the patient, and the surgeon. This review presents analytical models that allow for the quantification of the impact of these factors, with the aim of providing practical recommendations to help surgeons minimize the occurrence of this failure mode. A tighter fit reduces micromotion and, consequently, fretting of the taper connection. The paramount parameters controlling the fixation force are the coefficient of friction and the impaction force. The influence of the head diameter, as well as of the diameter and angle of the taper, is comparatively small, but varus alignment of the taper and heads with longer necks are unfavourable under physiologic loads. The trunnion should be rinsed, cleaned, and dried carefully, while avoiding any contamination of the bore—the female counterpart within the head—prior to assembly. Biological debris, and even residual water, might critically reduce the fixation of the taper connection between the head and the neck. The impaction force applied to the components should correspond to at least two strong blows with a 500 g hammer, striking the head with an ad hoc impactor aligned with the axis of the taper. These strong blows should correspond to a minimum impaction force of 4000 N.

Model-Based Roentgen Stereophotogrammetric Analysis to Monitor the Head-Taper Junction in Total Hip Arthroplasty in Vivo-And They Do Move

Model-based Roentgen stereophotogrammetric analysis (RSA) using elementary geometrical shape (EGS) models allows migration measurement of implants without the necessity of additional attached implant markers. The aims of this study were: (i) to assess the possibility of measuring potential head–taper movement in THA in vivo using model-based RSA and (ii) to prove the validity of measured head–taper migration data in vitro and in vivo. From a previous RSA study with a 10 years follow-up, retrospectively for n = 45 patients head–taper migration was calculated as the relative migration between femoral ball head and taper of the femoral stem using model-based RSA. A head–taper migration of 0.026 mm/year can be detected with available RSA technology. In vitro validation showed a total migration of 268 ± 11 µm along the taper axis in a similar range to what has been reported using the RSA method. In vivo, a proof for interchangeable applicability of model-based RSA (EGS) and standard marker-based RSA methods was indicated by a significant deviation within the migration result after 12-month follow-up for all translation measurements, which was significantly correlated to the measured head–taper migration (r from 0.40 to 0.67; p < 0.05). The results identified that model-based RSA (EGS) could be used to detect head–taper migration in vivo and the measured movement could be validated in vitro and in vivo as well. Those findings supported the possibility of applying RSA for helping evaluate the head–taper corrosion related failure (trunnionosis).

Contact conditions for total hip head-neck modular taper junctions with microgrooved stem tapers

Implant failure due to fretting-corrosion of head-neck modular junctions is a rising problem in total hip arthroplasty. Fretting-corrosion initiates when micromotion leads to metal release; however, factors leading to micromotion, such as microgrooves on the stem taper, are not fully understood. The purpose of this study is to describe a finite element analysis technique to determine head-neck contact mechanics and investigate the effect of stem taper microgroove height during head-neck assembly. Two-dimensional axisymmetric finite element models were created. Models were created for a ceramic femoral head and a CoCrMo femoral head against Ti6Al4V stem tapers and compared to available data from prior experiments. Stem taper microgroove height was investigated with a generic 12/14 model. Head-neck assembly was performed to four maximum loads (500 N, 2000 N, 4000 N, 8000 N). For the stem taper coupled with the ceramic head, the number of microgrooves in contact and plastically deformed differed by 2.5 microgrooves (4%) and 6.5 microgrooves (11%), respectively, between the finite element models and experiment. For the stem taper coupled with the CoCrMo head, all microgrooves were in contact after all assembly loads in the finite element model due to an almost identical conical angle between the taper surfaces. In the experiments, all grooves were only in contact for the 8000 N assembly load. Contact area, plastic (permanent) deformation, and contact pressure increased with increasing assembly loads and deeper microgrooves. The described modeling technique can be used to investigate the relationship between implant design factors, allowing for optimal microgroove design within material couples.

Acute trunnion failure of a TMZF alloy stem with large diameter femoral heads

Introduction

Femoral head-neck modularity in total hip arthroplasty (THA) is advantageous but taper corrosion at the trunnion can result in implant failure. We report two cases of acute catastrophic trunnion failure with a TMZF alloy cementless stem.

Methods

Demographic, clinical, radiographic and operative data including implant retrieval was recorded and is presented.

Results

Case 1: A 79 year old farmer presented with sudden onset of hip pain and an inability to weight bear. He underwent a cementless large diameter stemmed metal-on-metal system (MITCH acetabular component, 56mm cobalt chrome head 4.5 lateralised Accolade TMZF, Stryker) nine years previously. He denied symptoms prior to his presentation to the Emergency Department.Case 2: An 86 year old gentleman presented with sudden onset of hip pain and inability to weight bear. He underwent a cementless large diameter stemmed metal-on-poly THA (Trident acetabular component, X3 polyethylene insert, 44mm cobalt chrome head, 4.5 lateralised Accolade TMZF, Stryker)nine years previously. This man had been complaining of mild hip symptoms prior to presentation.

Conclusion

Patients that have received TMZF alloy cementless stems coupled with CoCr alloy heads are at risk of catastrophic trunnion failure. Importantly, background trunnion corrosion may occur silently and present emergently irrespective of surveillance.

Pseudotumors and High-Grade Aseptic Lymphocyte-Dominated Vasculitis-Associated Lesions Around Total Knee Replacements Identified at Aseptic Revision Surgery: Findings of a Large-Scale Histologic Review

BACKGROUND

Aseptic lymphocyte-dominated vasculitis-associated lesion (ALVAL) development (including pseudotumors) secondary to metal debris generation around total hip arthroplasties is a well-recognized histopathologic phenomenon. Emerging data have highlighted a similar potential concern around TKAs although the body-of-knowledge has largely been limited to individual case reports or small retrospective case series. This study sought to establish the prevalence of pseudotumors or high-grade ALVALs seen at the revision of primary TKAs and to establish the correlation between histologic ALVAL grade and patient-reported functional outcome measures.

METHODS

The findings of 321 non-infective (aseptic) patients undergoing unilateral revision knee surgery, at a high-volume tertiary referral center, were reviewed. Each case was independently histologically classified. Complete patient-reported functional outcome measures were available for 134 patients (42%) allowing correlation between functional performance and histopathology results.

RESULTS

Five distinct pseudotumors and a further 18 high-grade ALVALs were histologically identified representing 1.6% and 5.6% of the cohort, respectively. When compared by histologic grade, Oxford Knee Score and Western Ontario and McMaster University's Osteoarthritis Index suggested a high correlation between ALVAL grade and functional knee scores.

CONCLUSION

These findings suggest a prevalence of pseudotumors or high-grade ALVALs at revision TKA surgery of >7%. This unexpectedly high result may contribute insight into the previously under-appreciated significance of metal debris-related local tissue reactions around TKAs. The findings also demonstrate a strong near-linear inverse relationship between patient-reported clinical knee performance and the underlying histologic grade of local tissue reaction. These results have potential management implications for patients with underperforming TKAs and should prompt consideration of an ALVAL secondary to metallosis in the differential diagnosis.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

This is a retrospective cohort study with Level III evidence.

[Total hip arthroplasty in young patients : Bearings and custom-made prostheses]

BACKGROUND

Carefully and correctly implanted components are the prerequisite for the lifespan of a prosthesis. Whether higher levels of activity lead to prior failure of total hip arthroplasty in young patients is controversially discussed. The right choice of bearings is still of great relevance.

BEARINGS

Ceramic-on-ceramic as well as polyethylene-on-ceramic bearings achieve comparable results, although ceramic-on-ceramic bearings should be avoided in patients with high demands on their range of motion. Polyethylene-on-metal bearings also show good clinical results, if corrosion between head and stem is absent. Metal-on-metal bearings lead to adverse systemic effects due to metal wear and should be implanted in individual cases only, e. g. as hip resurfacing. Alternative bearings have to give proof of effectivity first. Custom-made prostheses constitute an option for young patients with special conditions of hip anatomy. Planning and study results of these prostheses are elucidated in this review article.

Influence of flexural rigidity on micromotion at the head-stem taper interface of modular hip prostheses

Fretting corrosion as one reason for failure of modular hip prostheses has been associated with micromotion at the head taper junction. Historically the taper diameter was reduced to improve the range of motion of the hip joint. In combination with other developments, this was accompanied by increased observations of taper fretting, possibly due to the reduced flexural rigidity of smaller tapers. The aim of the study was to investigate how the flexural rigidity of tapers influences the amount of micromotion at the head taper junction. Three different stem and two different taper designs were manufactured. Experimental testing was performed using three different activity levels with peak loads representing walking, stair climbing and stumbling. The relative motion at the head-stem taper was measured in six degrees of freedom. Micromotion was obtained by subtraction of the elastic deformation derived from monoblock and finite element analysis. Less rigid tapers lead to increased micromotion between the head and stem, enlarging the risk of fretting corrosion. The influence of the stem design on micromotion is secondary to taper design. Manufacturers should consider stiffer taper designs to reduce micromotion within the head taper junction.

Impact of stem taper damage on the fracture strength of ceramic heads with adapter sleeves

BACKGROUND

Using a new ceramic head with a titanium adapter sleeve offers the possibility of maintaining a well fixed stem when conducting cup revision of a total hip arthroplasty. The aim of this study is to test the impact of stem taper damage on the fracture strength of sleeved ceramic heads.

METHODS

Pristine zirconia-toughened alumina heads with titanium adapter sleeves (BIOLOX®OPTION System) were tested on damaged Ti-4Al-6V stem tapers in accordance with ISO7206-10. Four distinctive damage types classified as intolerable by the manufacture were investigated, representing various reductions in contact area between the stem taper and sleeve taper as well as damage incurred from previous ceramic head fracture.

FINDINGS

The largest reduction in fracture strength occurred for a loss of contact for the entire length of the stem taper. Nonetheless, the fracture strength in all investigated cases was several times higher than that defined by the FDA standards.

INTERPRETATION

The use of a titanium sleeve recreates a uniform contact situation between the ceramic head and the outer sleeve taper in situations of damaged stem tapers. For the investigated damage types a high fracture strength of the ceramic head was maintained. This study supports the clinical use for sleeved ceramic heads in instances of greater damages of stem tapers than previously defined in order to spare patients from stem removal.

Determination of local micromotion at the stem-neck taper junction of a bi-modular total hip prosthesis design

High rates of clinical complications with bi-modular hip prostheses are attributed to failure of the stem-neck taper junction. Taper wear analyses have shown extensive material loss as a result of corrosion, potentially initiated by micromotion. The purpose of the study was to determine the amount of micromotion at this junction for different loading, assembly and material conditions. Micromotion between the neck adapter (CoCr29Mo6-alloy) and the stem (TiMo12Zr6Fe2-alloy; both Rejuvenate, Stryker) within the taper junction of a bi-modular hip stem were determined by image matching analysis of consecutively recorded images through windows in the stem component. A finite element model was used to determine the micromotion in the taper regions outside the windows and validated with the measured micromotion. With the model, the influence of the load amplitude, assembly force and component materials were then investigated. Determined micromotion (14-79 µm) by far exceeded critical values (5 µm) associated with the onset of fretting corrosion. Increasing assembly forces achieved a significant reduction in micromotion. The numerical model revealed insufficient assembly to cause the neck to perform rocking motions under load, repetitively changing taper contact in combination with gap opening, which facilitates fluid ingress into the junction. Changing the stem material to a stiffer Ti-alloy achieved a reduction of the micromotion of about 30%. This study emphasises the high importance of material selection, assembly force and loading on the susceptibility of bi-modular hip stems to fretting and crevice corrosion. These findings can serve to explain the increased rate of clinically reported problems with this particular prosthesis design.

The Merete BioBall system in hip revision surgery: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Modular hip arthroplasty is widely recognized in hip surgery; nevertheless, despite advances in prosthetic design, the incidence of hip revision surgery is increasing. In these procedures, a modular adapter that engages the femoral stem and the modular femoral head could be useful in order to protect the neck-head junction and restore preoperative biomechanics and soft tissue tension when the femoral or acetabular component should be retained. The Merete™ BioBall™ system (Merete Medical, Berlin, Germany) could fill this need. However the literature regarding this device is sparse, therefore we performed a systematic review to analyze: the indications for its use and clinical results and the causes of second revision and survival in hip revision surgery, mainly focus in complications of its use.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Databases including PubMed and Google Scholar were searched for English-language articles published between 01/01/1999 and 01/04/2017, using search terms related to the system Merete™ BioBall™. Studies that reported the clinical use of the Merete™ BioBall™ system in hip revision surgery were selected. Data related to the indications, characteristics of the implant, clinical results, causes of second revision and survival were gathered.

RESULTS

A total of 14 studies with a level IV evidence were analyzed. Information related to the implant was provided in 194 cases. Isolated acetabular revision was the main indication of implant use (139/194 [71.6%]). The most common combination used was the standard implant (69/110 specified [59.4%]), 3XL length (28/107 specified [26.2%]) with 32mm metal head (58/187 specified [31%]). After a follow-up ranging from 2 to 97 months, there were 16 complications, thirteen (81,2%) were revised, including one neck fracture of the stem (6.25%), two ceramic head fractures (12,5%) and six recurrent dislocations (37,5%). Implant survival was 92.8% at 52.5 months of follow-up in the longest published series. Clinical and functional results were provided in a heterogeneous way.

CONCLUSIONS

There is insufficient evidence to recommend for or contraindicate the use of the Merete™ BioBall™ system. The Isolated acetabular revision was the main indication of implant use. When dislocation is the indication of its use the rate of second revision is high. Some important complications possibly related with the implant design have been reported but as isolated cases. The neck adapter failure or corrosion phenomena have not been reported. Further prospective and controlled trials are needed to assess the use of this type of implant and its survival.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III systematic review of case series.

Head Taper Corrosion Causing Head Bottoming Out and Consecutive Gross Stem Taper Failure in Total Hip Arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Taper corrosion in total hip arthroplasty for bearings with metal heads against polyethylene has developed from an anecdotal observation to a clinical problem. Increased taper wear and even gross taper failure have been reported for one particular design. It is hypothesized that corrosion of the female head taper results in taper widening, allowing the cobalt-chromium head to turn on the stem and wear down the softer titanium alloy by abrasive wear, ultimately causing failure. The purpose of this study is to investigate the time course of this process and the general role of taper dimensions and material in this problem.

METHODS

Retrieved cobalt-chromium alloy heads (n = 30, LFIT; Stryker, Mahwah, NJ) and Ti-12Mo-6Zr-2Fe (TMZF) stems (n = 10, Accolade I; Stryker) were available for analysis. Taper material loss was determined using three-dimensional coordinate measurements and scanning. The pristine tip clearance between head and stem was analytically determined. The influence of taper material and taper size on taper deformation and micromotion was investigated using a finite element model.

RESULTS

Material loss at the head taper increased with time in situ up to a volume of 20.8 mm³ (P < .001). A mean linear material loss above 76 μm at the head taper was analytically confirmed to result in bottoming out, which was observed in 12 heads. The finite element calculations showed significantly larger deformations and micromotions for a small 11/13 TMZF taper combined with a distinctly different micromotion pattern compared to other materials and taper designs.

CONCLUSION

A 11/13 TMZF taper design with 36-mm head diameters bears a higher risk for corrosion than larger tapers made from stiffer materials. Failures of this combination are not restricted to the head sizes included in the recall. Patients with this implant combination should be closely monitored.

A case example and literature review of catastrophic wear before catastrophic failure: identification of trunnionosis and metallosis in metal-on-polyethylene hip arthroplasty prior to frank failure or fracture

Though rare, there are documented failures of femoral prosthesis due to corrosion of the head-neck interface in total hip arthroplasty (THA), a phenomenon known as trunnionosis. This wear can result in metallosis, whereby metal debris scatters the surrounding soft tissues. We present on a 58-year-old female who presented with increase in hip and back pain 10 years following right THA using a metal-on-polyethylene construct with a large femoral head (44 mm). Aspiration withdrew metallic fluid, and intraoperative findings showed corrosion of the head-neck taper with surrounding metallosis and pseudocapsule formation. Despite advances in THA design, corrosion and wear between components still exists and may be cause for failure. We present on both the subtle clinical findings and the recommended workup when suspicion is high for trunnionosis, metallosis, or wear, ideally with identification prior to catastrophic failure such as component dislocation or fracture as previously reported.

What Factors Drive Taper Corrosion?

Adverse local tissue reactions to corrosion products can lead to total hip arthroplasty failure. Although this problem has been well known for more than 25 years, it has seemingly increased in frequency over the recent years. The occurrence of corrosion is multifactorial-depending on implant, patient, and surgeon factors. As of now, there is no "one-size-fits-all" solution to prevent corrosion in total hip arthroplasty devices. Thus, it is imperative to fully understand the exact mechanisms of modular junction corrosion to prevent premature implant failure. This review highlights a few key concepts that need to be explored to minimize the impact of corrosion. The key concepts include (1) the prevention of micromotion, (2) the role of implant alloy metallurgy in the corrosion process, (3) the in vivo generation of a corrosive environment, and (4) potential unanticipated problems.

Profound Trunnion Wear Resulting in Femoral Head-Neck Dissociation in Total Hip Arthroplasty

We describe a case of aseptic failure with profound femoral stem trunnion wear and femoral head dissociation nine years after initial primary total hip arthroplasty (THA) with the Stryker Accolade total hip arthroplasty system. Current guidelines for postoperative care and follow-up after THAs as potential intervention points for early detection of prosthetic joint failure are also reviewed.

Maximizing the fixation strength of modular components by impaction without tissue damage

Objectives

Taper junctions between modular hip arthroplasty femoral heads and stems fail by wear or corrosion which can be caused by relative motion at their interface. Increasing the assembly force can reduce relative motion and corrosion but may also damage surrounding tissues. The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of increasing the impaction energy and the stiffness of the impactor tool on the stability of the taper junction and on the forces transmitted through the patient’s surrounding tissues.

Methods

A commercially available impaction tool was modified to assemble components in the laboratory using impactor tips with varying stiffness at different applied energy levels. Springs were mounted below the modular components to represent the patient. The pull-off force of the head from the stem was measured to assess stability, and the displacement of the springs was measured to assess the force transmitted to the patient’s tissues.

Results

The pull-off force of the head increased as the stiffness of the impactor tip increased but without increasing the force transmitted through the springs (patient). Increasing the impaction energy increased the pull-off force but also increased the force transmitted through the springs.

Conclusions

To limit wear and corrosion, manufacturers should maximize the stiffness of the impactor tool but without damaging the surface of the head. This strategy will maximize the stability of the head on the stem for a given applied energy, without influencing the force transmitted through the patient’s tissues. Current impactor designs already appear to approach this limit. Increasing the applied energy (which is dependent on the mass of the hammer and square of the contact speed) increases the stability of the modular connection but proportionally increases the force transmitted through the patient’s tissues, as well as to the surface of the head, and should be restricted to safe levels.

Cite this article: A. Krull, M. M. Morlock, N. E. Bishop. Maximizing the fixation strength of modular components by impaction without tissue damage. Bone Joint Res 2018;7:196–204. DOI: 10.1302/2046-3758.72.BJR-2017-0078.R2.

Fretting-corrosion at the modular tapers interface: Inspection of standard ASTM F1875-98

Interest in the degradation mechanisms at the modular tapers interfaces has been renewed due to increased reported cases of adverse reactions to metal debris and the appearance of wear and corrosion at the modular tapers interfaces at revision. Over the past two decades, a lot of research has been expended to understand the degradation mechanisms, with two primary implant loading procedures and orientations used consistently across the literature. ASTM F1875-98 is often used as a guide to understand and benchmark the tribocorrosion processes occurring within the modular tapers interface. This article presents a comparison of the two methods outlined in ASTM F1875-98 as well as a critique of the standard considering the current paradigm in pre-clinical assessment of modular tapers.

Compression of the Femoral Vessels by a Pseudotumor after Metal-on-Metal Total Hip Arthroplasty

Here we present a case of pseudotumor following total hip arthroplasty (THA) that resulted in a circulatory disturbance caused by compression of the femoral vasculature. A 63-year-old man presented with pain, swelling, and redness of the left leg 5 years after primary metal-on-metal THA using the AML-Plus stem, Pinnacle® acetabular cup, and 36 mm diameter Ultamet™ metal head system (DePuy Orthopaedics, Warsaw, IN). Enhanced computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging revealed a large cystic lesion extending from the left hip anteriorly to the intrapelvic region and compressing the left femoral vessels. Percutaneous puncture of the lesion yielded a dark red aspirate and the patient was diagnosed to have a pseudotumor causing compression of the femoral vessels. We performed revision surgery to replace the metal head and metal liner with a smaller ceramic head and polyethylene liner without removal of the stem. Corrosion of the head-neck junction was identified intraoperatively with no obvious wear on the bearing surfaces. The left leg swelling and redness improved immediately postoperatively. A large pseudotumor should be kept in mind as a cause of vascular compression with unilateral leg edema in a patient who has undergone metal-on-metal THA.

Ten-Year Cross-Sectional Study of Mechanically Assisted Crevice Corrosion in 1352 Consecutive Patients With Metal-on-Polyethylene Total Hip Arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Mechanically assisted crevice corrosion (MACC) in metal-on-polyethylene total hip arthroplasty (THA) is of concern, but its prevalence, etiology, and natural history are incompletely understood.

METHODS

From January 2003 to December 2012, 1352 consecutive THA surgeries using a titanium stem, cobalt-chromium alloy femoral head, and highly cross-linked polyethylene liner from a single manufacturer were performed. Patients were followed at 1-year and 5-year intervals for surveillance, but also seen earlier if they had symptoms. Any patient with osteolysis >1 cm (n = 3) or unexplained pain (n = 85) underwent examination, radiographs, complete blood count, erythrocyte sedimentation rate, and C-reactive protein, as well as tests for serum cobalt and chromium levels.

RESULTS

Symptomatic MACC was present in 43 of 1352 patients (3.2%). Prevalence of MACC by year of implant ranged from 0% (0 of 61, 2003; 0 of 138, 2005) to 10.5% (17 of 162; 2009). The M/L Taper stem had a greater prevalence (4.9%) of MACC than all other Zimmer (Zimmer, Inc, Warsaw, IN) 12/14 trunnion stem types combined (1.2%; P < .001). Twenty-seven of 43 (62.8%) patients have undergone revision surgery, and 16 of 43 (37.2%) patients have opted for ongoing surveillance. Comparing symptomatic THA patients with and without MACC, no demographic, clinical, or radiographic differences were found. MACC was significantly more common in 0 length femoral heads (compared with both -3.5 mm and +3.5 mm heads).

CONCLUSION

The prevalence of MACC in metal-on-polyethylene hips is higher in this cross-sectional study than previously reported. A significantly higher prevalence was found in patients with M/L Taper style stem and THA performed both in 2009 and also between 2009 and 2012 with this manufacturer.