Effect of Model Selection on Prediction of Periodic Behavior in Gene Regulatory Networks

Hybrid models of genetic networks: Mathematical challenges and biological relevance

We review results concerning dynamics in a class of hybrid ordinary differential equations which incorporates logical control to yield piecewise linear equations. These equations relate qualitative features of the structure of networks to qualitative properties of the dynamics. Because of their simple structure, they have been studied using techniques from discrete mathematics and nonlinear dynamics. Initially developed as a qualitataive description of gene regulatory networks, many generalizations of the basic approach have been developed. In particular, we show how this qualitative approach may be adapted to switching biochemical systems without degradation, illustrated by an example of a motif in which two branches of a pathway may be regulated differently when the thresholds for the two pathways are separated.

Global dynamics for switching systems and their extensions by linear differential equations

Switching systems use piecewise constant nonlinearities to model gene regulatory networks. This choice provides advantages in the analysis of behavior and allows the global description of dynamics in terms of Morse graphs associated to nodes of a parameter graph. The parameter graph captures spatial characteristics of a decomposition of parameter space into domains with identical Morse graphs. However, there are many cellular processes that do not exhibit threshold-like behavior and thus are not well described by a switching system. We consider a class of extensions of switching systems formed by a mixture of switching interactions and chains of variables governed by linear differential equations. We show that the parameter graphs associated to the switching system and any of its extensions are identical. For each parameter graph node, there is an order-preserving map from the Morse graph of the switching system to the Morse graph of any of its extensions. We provide counterexamples that show why possible stronger relationships between the Morse graphs are not valid.

A Modelling Framework for Gene Regulatory Networks Including Transcription and Translation

Qualitative models of gene regulatory networks have generally considered transcription factors to regulate directly the expression of other transcription factors, without any intermediate variables. In fact, gene expression always involves transcription, which produces mRNA molecules, followed by translation, which produces protein molecules, which can then act as transcription factors for other genes (in some cases after post-transcriptional modifications). Suppressing these multiple steps implicitly assumes that the qualitative behaviour does not depend on them. Here we explore a class of expanded models that explicitly includes both transcription and translation, keeping track of both mRNA and protein concentrations. We mainly deal with regulation functions that are steep sigmoids or step functions, as is often done in protein-only models. We find that flow cannot be constrained to switching domains, though there can still be asymptotic approach to singular stationary points (fixed points in the vicinity of switching thresholds). This avoids the thorny issue of singular flow, but leads to somewhat more complicated possibilities for flow between threshold crossings. In the infinitely fast limit of either mRNA or protein rates, we find that solutions converge uniformly to solutions of the corresponding protein-only model on arbitrary finite time intervals. This leaves open the possibility that the limit system (with one type of variable infinitely fast) may have different asymptotic behaviour, and indeed, we find an example in which stability of a fixed point in the protein-only model is lost in the expanded model. Our results thus show that including mRNA as a variable may change the behaviour of solutions.