Can the spherical gold standards be used as an alternative to painted gold standards for the computerized detection of lesions using voxel-based classification?

Performance changes due to differences among annotating radiologists for training data in computerized lesion detection

PURPOSE

The quality and bias of annotations by annotators (e.g., radiologists) affect the performance changes in computer-aided detection (CAD) software using machine learning. We hypothesized that the difference in the years of experience in image interpretation among radiologists contributes to annotation variability. In this study, we focused on how the performance of CAD software changes with retraining by incorporating cases annotated by radiologists with varying experience.

METHODS

We used two types of CAD software for lung nodule detection in chest computed tomography images and cerebral aneurysm detection in magnetic resonance angiography images. Twelve radiologists with different years of experience independently annotated the lesions, and the performance changes were investigated by repeating the retraining of the CAD software twice, with the addition of cases annotated by each radiologist. Additionally, we investigated the effects of retraining using integrated annotations from multiple radiologists.

RESULTS

The performance of the CAD software after retraining differed among annotating radiologists. In some cases, the performance was degraded compared to that of the initial software. Retraining using integrated annotations showed different performance trends depending on the target CAD software, notably in cerebral aneurysm detection, where the performance decreased compared to using annotations from a single radiologist.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the performance of the CAD software after retraining varied among the annotating radiologists, no direct correlation with their experience was found. The performance trends differed according to the type of CAD software used when integrated annotations from multiple radiologists were used.

Anomaly detection in chest 18F-FDG PET/CT by Bayesian deep learning

Purpose

To develop an anomaly detection system in PET/CT with the tracer ¹⁸F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) that requires only normal PET/CT images for training and can detect abnormal FDG uptake at any location in the chest region.

Materials and methods

We trained our model based on a Bayesian deep learning framework using 1878 PET/CT scans with no abnormal findings. Our model learns the distribution of standard uptake values in these normal training images and detects out-of-normal uptake regions. We evaluated this model using 34 scans showing focal abnormal FDG uptake in the chest region. This evaluation dataset includes 28 pulmonary and 17 extrapulmonary abnormal FDG uptake foci. We performed per-voxel and per-slice receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analyses and per-lesion free-response receiver operating characteristic analysis.

Results

Our model showed an area under the ROC curve of 0.992 on discriminating abnormal voxels and 0.852 on abnormal slices. Our model detected 41 of 45 (91.1%) of the abnormal FDG uptake foci with 12.8 false positives per scan (FPs/scan), which include 26 of 28 pulmonary and 15 of 17 extrapulmonary abnormalities. The sensitivity at 3.0 FPs/scan was 82.2% (37/45).

Conclusion

Our model trained only with normal PET/CT images successfully detected both pulmonary and extrapulmonary abnormal FDG uptake in the chest region.

Preliminary study of generalized semiautomatic segmentation for 3D voxel labeling of lesions based on deep learning

PURPOSE

The three-dimensional (3D) voxel labeling of lesions requires significant radiologists' effort in the development of computer-aided detection software. To reduce the time required for the 3D voxel labeling, we aimed to develop a generalized semiautomatic segmentation method based on deep learning via a data augmentation-based domain generalization framework. In this study, we investigated whether a generalized semiautomatic segmentation model trained using two types of lesion can segment previously unseen types of lesion.

METHODS

We targeted lung nodules in chest CT images, liver lesions in hepatobiliary-phase images of Gd-EOB-DTPA-enhanced MR imaging, and brain metastases in contrast-enhanced MR images. For each lesion, the 32 × 32 × 32 isotropic volume of interest (VOI) around the center of gravity of the lesion was extracted. The VOI was input into a 3D U-Net model to define the label of the lesion. For each type of target lesion, we compared five types of data augmentation and two types of input data.

RESULTS

For all considered target lesions, the highest dice coefficients among the training patterns were obtained when using a combination of the existing data augmentation-based domain generalization framework and random monochrome inversion and when using the resized VOI as the input image. The dice coefficients were 0.639 ± 0.124 for the lung nodules, 0.660 ± 0.137 for the liver lesions, and 0.727 ± 0.115 for the brain metastases.

CONCLUSIONS

Our generalized semiautomatic segmentation model could label unseen three types of lesion with different contrasts from the surroundings. In addition, the resized VOI as the input image enables the adaptation to the various sizes of lesions even when the size distribution differed between the training set and the test set.

Novel platform for development, training, and validation of computer-assisted detection/diagnosis software

PURPOSE

To build a novel, open-source, purely web-based platform system to address problems in the development and clinical use of computer-assisted detection/diagnosis (CAD) software. The new platform system will replace the existing system for the development and validation of CAD software, Clinical Infrastructure for Radiologic Computation of United Solutions (CIRCUS).

METHODS

In our new system, the two top-level applications visible to users are the web-based image database (CIRCUS DB; database) and the Docker plug-in-based CAD execution platform (CIRCUS CS; clinical server). These applications are built on top of a shared application programming interface server, a three-dimensional image viewer component, and an image repository.

RESULTS

We successfully installed our new system into a Linux server at two clinical sites. A total of 1954 cases were registered in CIRCUS DB. We have been utilizing CIRCUS CS with four Docker-based CAD plug-ins.

CONCLUSIONS

We have successfully built a new version of the CIRCUS system. Our platform was successfully implemented at two clinical sites, and we plan to publish it as an open-source software project.