Rethinking the Precedent Autonomy, Current Minimal Autonomy, and Current Well-Being in Medical Decisions for Persons with Dementia

Limits of advance directives in decision-making around food and nutrition in patients with dementia

Advance directives are critically important for capable individuals who wish to avoid the burdens of life-prolonging interventions in the advanced stages of dementia. However, this paper will argue that advance directives should have less application to questions about feeding patients during the clinical course of dementia than often has been presumed. The argument will be framed within the debate between Ronald Dworkin and Rebecca Dresser regarding the moral authority of precedent autonomy to determine an individual's future end-of-life care plan. We will use a brief analysis of the positions taken in two important papers that come out of the Dworkin/Dresser debate and a hypothetical patient, John, who will be followed from diagnosis of dementia to death, to show how advance directives should apply to key points in the progression of his disease, particularly in relation to food and nutrition.

Navigating Gender Identity and Dementia in Transgender Older Adults: Ethical Challenges and Patient-Centered Care

OBJECTIVES

As transgender individuals age, they are at risk for neurocognitive disorders which pose not only medical but also bioethical questions. We present a case study of a transgender older adult with dementia who experienced changes in gender identity and explore the bioethical implications of identity over time, including end-of-life care.

METHODS

We reviewed clinical notes and relevant medical history to describe the transition and detransition process and examined ethical frameworks related to autonomy, psychological continuity, and transgender care.

RESULTS

The individual transitioned as a transgender woman in mid-life but detransitioned shortly before being diagnosed with dementia. This case highlighted conflicts between precedent autonomy and current gender identity in the context of neurocognitive decline and end-of-life care.

CONCLUSIONS

The case underscores the complexity of managing gender identity in transgender older adults with dementia, emphasizing the need for personalized and ethically sound care plans.

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

Clinicians should be vigilant about the impact of neurocognitive disorders on gender identity, balancing respect for patients' prior decisions with their current values, and develop personalized end-of-life care plans that honor the evolving identities and preferences of transgender individuals with dementia.